So we arrived a few minutes early and were promptly seated. Menu's were dropped without a wine list. We noticed nine outdoor tables and only one waitress. She was nice when she greeted us. We ordered appetizers and the food for our children to come out the same time. We waited thirty minutes for wine and had to grab another waiter to bring out our drinks. The waiter asked if we want it on ice. Of course we want it chilled, it's white. We are an hour in at this point the appetizers are served, no kids orders. The calamari and clams were tasty, so I ordered another basket of semolina bread to soak it up. I might as well baked it myself. Kids meals are served. My youngest orders an additional sauce. Ten minutes, fifteen minutes, the waiter comes out to the table and delivers a side of sauce. My son has been finished with his plate for a while now. Our main's are served. Plates on table, do you think they would offer salt, pepper, grated cheese? Nope. I had to grab another waiter for condiments. An hour fifteen into our meal then the waitress returns for a water refill. I'm glad the view was nice and people around us were having a good time. The restaurant was clearly understaffed for the night. I counted several tables around us nursing cocktails for over an hour and half patiently anticipating their dinner to be served. Food was typical New City Italian. Next time, I'll take the family to Piermont or Nyack. read more

Cute cozy place with the best Alfredo sauce dishes the chicken is so soft and tender and great cocktails too.

Came here on a Saturday night after researching on Yelp around New City area. The reviews and pics was enough for me to try this spot out. I didn't make reservations but the host allowed us sit at the bar until a table opened up. The place isn't huge but can sit a good amount of people without feeling cramped. Bar is located in the back across the bathroom. When we got the table, they served complimentary salad and warm bread with side of seasoned olive oil which was great. Started off with fresh mozzarella ($11.99) which was nice and refreshing. For my main, I got the rigatoni bolognese ($17.99) which was solid. Overall good experience and I would highly recommend this place if you are in the mood for Italian food. - great service - outdoor dining available - street parking - make reservations read more

See all

Always enjoy my dining experience. A good side salad and a large portion that I often take home 1/2.

Good food and service. Nice local restaurant that is consistent. Nice cocktails too. Gets a bit crowded as it is not too big so go on an off time or make a reservation. read more

Excellent always consistent and reasonable prices.staff is very courteous and efficient. This is a gem of a small place. Reservations a must. Salad and bread with dipping oil the best around. We have been going here for years and it never ever disappoints. read more

We love this place. Yes it gets crowded so yes it takes a bit of time to get served. That's because the food is amazing. Relax. Enjoy the bread. And dipping sauce. The veal piccata is worth the wait. read more

Food was excellent. The warm bread to start. Nice tossed that comes with the meal is the perfect size. Triple parmigiana (shrimp chicken eggplant) fills all my needs. Will definitely return soon. read more

Always a solid dinner with reasonable prices. Food always made fresh waitstaff great. read more

See all

The shrimp scampi was outstanding! I got it to go! Now I have to fill up space to make sure I hit 85 characters so what do you call a guy with no arms and no legs and a pile of leaves Russell read more

my husband and i have been coming here for several years and we've never had a bad meal or experience. i see some of the older reviews that mention slow service and a too-long menu with dishes that don't seem to go together and that was true in the past. however the menu has been simplified to classic italian dishes and the service speed has improved. don't judge this tiny little restaurant from the outside without trying it but definitely make a reservation as it books up quickly on the weekends. the martinis here are huge and delicious. they have specials every night which add to their already stellar menu. they serve complimentary salad before the main course which is a nice touch. we frequent this place every few weeks because we enjoy it so much. if you've never been you should absolutely give it a try! read more

See all

Love how cute this place is! Martinis were amazing and the fettuccine Alfredo was outstanding

We were told there was a 40 minute wait but since we wanted an inside seat, we were able to find a seat inside. Luckily! The place was jamming. All the staff members were still pleasant and all working as a team. My margarita drink was strong. Both entrees were authentic Italian dishes , great portions; and great prices. The tiramisu and cappuccinos was real and delectable! We left wowed by the experience here and the delicious food. Believe the five star reviews! read more

Alfredo’s Restaurant - Italian Near Me - New City, New York

The food is varied and delicious. The wine list is varied and mixed drinks are generous. A truly great restaurant

Went here on Friday night because of all the great reviews. We ordered the fried calamari for an appetizer, rigatoni bolognese , eggplant rollatini and fettuccine Alfredo. The place was packed, but our order was taken in a reasonable amount of time and the waitress was pleasant. The bread was warm and delicious, crispy on the outside and soft inside. The olive oil was tasty. The fried calamari came out and had more fried peppers in it than calamari. The sauce was tasteless and sweet. Our dinners took a long time to come out and we never received the salad that everyone spoke of. The fettuccini were dry, the bolognese was loaded with meat and peppers, but the pasta and sauce were just okay. The eggplant rollatini was average. For the amount of servers present, we had to flag them down a few times to fill our water glasses. This was a disappointment after all the previous great reviews. read more

It's been a while since I could get back to Alfredo's and I'm glad I did. The owner aLso Chef and his staff accommodated six of us, each of us ordered something different..exceptional meal were the responses from each. The waiters were attentive, friendly and hospitable! Highly recommended! read more

Always a favorite of ours, went recently, had to wait about 10-15 minutes past our reservation time which was no big deal to us but received 2 appetizers no charge! Amazing! And delicious! The food is consistently delicious, generous family style salad and fresh Italian bread. Veal was tender and flavorful, chicken Francais always a fav, was outstanding. Generous portions and great veggies you can sub for the pasta. Just be sure to make reservations they get busy! read more

My husband and I were in the mood for authentic Italian food so of course I used Yelp to help me find the best near by restaurant. Alfredo's showed on my list. I read the reviews and decided to try it out. I was wowed!!!!! The food was so fresh and tasty...lobster ravioli for my husband and rigatoni bolognese for me---WOW! The ravioli had so much lobster and so flavorful. My Rigatoni was delicious, sweet taste and so fresh. I also had the crabmeat bisque, which was also delicious with so much crab meat. I usually take pictures but the food was so good, my husband and I devoured it! The service was superb, the drinks delicious and ample parking. I highly recommend trying Alfredo's out for a nice, fulfilling dinner at a reasonable costs. read more

Food was very good, took my order to go. I will have a sit down meal next time. Will definitely be back.

I just left there and I am very upset. My friends and I go there frequently however we won't be going back. We each had drinks a meal dessert and coffee. When we got the bill we were charged for salad. When we got our salad that always comes with the meal it was skimpy. So we asked for more. We received more. When the bill came we were charged for it. We questioned it. The manager came over and was a bit aggressive. We asked to speak to the owner and he went I. My husbands face and said "you will only speak to me". We thought he was going to punch him !!! It wasn't the money it was just the way it was handled. Yelling in front of an entire restaurant. We won't be going there again!! read more

Hidden gem. If you're looking for a solid meal to impress a food snob, this is the place. Laid back cozy vibe but high quality perfectly executed dishes. Waitstaff was great, personable and friendly. It's quiet, no music blaring. Impressed by everything we had: Calamari, Crab Bisque, Carbonara, Steak-Lobster-Shrimp, Lamb Chops, Tiramisu, Cheesecake. We'll be back frequently. read more

See all

Horrible. Went there for dinner , ordered fried calamari , it was overcooked like tough rubber bands . The salad was very skimpy, my dinner was bland and I didn't even bother finishing it . I left there disappointed and still hungry . This place is definitely a waste of money and absolutely the worst Italian food I have ever had! read more

Excellent food, consistent quality, great service. I have gone to Alfredo for many years and have never been disappointed in any of my choices. Try it once, you will go back! read more

Make a reservation as this place gets busy. I had the filet mignon: Food is AMAZING with FRESH vegetables, great cut of meat perfectly cooked, creamy potatoes!!! I am SUPER picky, but this place has an amazing kitchen staff!! Superb food!! Service was great, place is very clean; outside patio looks like a great place to relax in warmer weather. Prices are RIDICULOUS!!! I paid $20 for an (easily) $36 meal!!! Beers were also cheap!! I love Peroni, and they serve Peroni in an actual Peroni glass!!! Just a wonderful dining experience!! No doubt I will be back!!! read more

Tonight, May 23rd, 2021 was the first time I ate at a restaurant since the start of the pandemic. This was also my first time at this restaurant. My family was seated outside at a comfortable table. All of the servers were wearing masks. Seating between tables was spaced appropriately. A short time after being seated, the waiter brought a basket of hot semolina bread that was served with a seasoned olive oil dipping sauce. This was delicious. A house mixed green salad was included, with ample tomatoes, cucumber, and red cabbage and was perfectly dressed with a light Italian vinaigrette. I chose a special - - - shrimp and scallops fra diavolo. The shellfish was cooked perfectly, soft and tender with a very fresh taste. The tomato sauce was spiced to perfection, not over seasoned as many restaurants do and balanced between acidic and sweet. It was a great time out after a long time in! I'll return to this restaurant frequently. read more

It's been a while since I could get back to Alfredo's restaurant in New City, and I'm happy I did. The staff were very courteous and attentive. Our party of 6 each ordered a different meal and we all thoroughly enjoyed their selection. I highly recommend trying out Alfredos in New City. read more

Absolutely love this place. Cozy, yet festive atmosphere. Food and drinks top notch.They know what the hell they are doing here.

I moved to Rockland county last year and have been struggling to find a good authentic Italian restaurant. ALFREDOS IS IT!!! I was blown away by how delicious and flavorful all their dinners are. Veal Milanese is to die for and chicken scarpariello is amazing! This will be my go to Italian restaurant forever! read more

From the great drinks to the delicious food and the friendly staff, Alfredo's is a New City staple that never disappoints. The stuffed veal chop was the best I've ever had. Tortellini carbonara w chicken is so good. The toughest thing is deciding what to order because the specials are always so good. The servings are big and the prices are reasonable. Have a martini or 3. read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE nothing to say except exceptional service, exceptional food, and would come back/ recommend this place in a heart beat. Genuine italian food amazing!!! read more

This is my first time here at this restaurant. The food was amazing and the service was on point. Very intimate and warm atmosphere. We had the filet and lobster which were cooked to perfection. Thank you so much, it made our anniversary even more special. read more

This spot is one of our favorites. I make a reservation here for birthday, valentines day, anniversary etc. The atmosphere is cozy and comfortable small and cute to dine in. The service is impeccable every sing time we go. Food is served fast and absolutely amazing. By far the best chicken franchise in Rockland county. my boyfriend does the eggplant parmigiana and claims that is the best you can get in Rockland county. Overall this place hits every necessity on the dot. Great service, amazing high quality Italian food, great wine, good location ( especially in the summer with outdoor dining) Its a family owned restaurant by a mother and her son and they really do a wonderful job. read more

This place blew my mind! The quality of the food here was crazy good and it was super cheap...I couldn't believe it! We had the chicken alfredo, veal oscar, sausage with vodka sauce, the frachise trio, and the tilapia franchise. All were sinfully good...as we all sampled off each other's plates. I didn't give it a five star for two reasons... even though the food should be six stars!!! 1. We dined al fresco...surrounded by strip malls (it is New City after all) on a main road that is riddled with construction projects, pot holes, and orange barrels. However the construction chic ambiance paired with my glass of chianti and excellent food, made for a very surreal dining experience. 2. They also need more staff. Our waitress was very nice but they were definitely short staffed. So don't expect to get in and out quick. Be patient though as it is definitely worth the wait! Can't wait to come back...but with friends...not good for a date read more

Alfredo's is one of our favorite restaurants because of its consistently excellent food, relaxing atmosphere, and good service. We consider ourselves lucky that it is only minutes from our home and extremely convenient for us to enjoy on a regular basis. If you haven't yet tried this neighborhood gem, you are in for a treat. At Alfredo's, your mouth starts watering moments after sitting down when you are treated to warm thinly sliced Italian bread and a dish of uniquely and deliciously seasoned dipping oil. The bread is perfectly warmed so that it is crisp on the outside and still soft on the inside, and then wrapped in a napkin so it stays that way. Every meal starts with and includes a large garden salad served family style. Here again Alfredo has thought of details that make a difference, from the lettuce and cucumbers that are always crisp, tomatoes that are red year-round, and chilled glass salad plates. It seems simple, but too often these small details are overlooked by others. Not by Alfredo. It would be easy to fill up on bread and salad, but then there would be no room for the appetizers and the main course. Alfredo's menu offers a wonderful selection of Italian specialties, both traditional and unique. Entrées are prepared with sauces that are light, perfectly seasoned, and never overpowering. If you can't decide whether to have chicken, veal, or seafood, there are several combination choices on the regular menu in addition to the daily specials. Over the years, and with a concerted effort to not repeatedly stick with our favorite menu items, we have tried most items on Alfredo's menu. Everything we have tried has been delicious. Alfredo's is one of the few restaurants where we know we can order the veal because it is always thin and tender. And the pasta is always perfectly al dente. This is especially appreciated because the dinner portions are hearty and we invariably have leftovers that we will be reheating to enjoy our meal a second time, particularly if we are treating ourselves to one of Alfredo's tasty dessert options. If you are looking for a consistently outstanding meal made with fresh ingredients for a great value, we highly recommend Alfredo's. You won't be disappointed! read more

What an incredible place to eat. Great bang for the buck. The food was fantastic. The service second to none. Make sure to make reservations though. It gets busy!!!!! read more

Honestly had a horrible experience with my waitress she was completely unprofessional and made very sneaky remarks to my significant other. It left a bad taste in my mouth as I was sitting right next to him as well as his grandmother and aunt. The food was alright but the menu leaves you overwhelmed as there are many many options to choose from. I would say the service was fine but possibly only because she was interested in who she was serving. Get it together, never witnessed anything more disrespectful. Heard good this about this place so I was disappointed to have such a horrible waitress. read more

Alfredo's is the definition of average. Went here with a party of 5 for the holidays and everything we ordered was just okay. The dishes we ordered ranged from veal to pasta. The veal entree was absolutely tiny. The veal serving was not filling whatsoever. My frutte de mar pasta was actually quite good, but the pasta was bland. Some perks were the appetizers. The stuffed mushrooms were yummy and the calamari was also tasty, but when is fried calamari bland, am I right? Something that really turned me off was the sprite I ordered. I don't know what it was, but it was foul. I had to send it back and just opted for a water, weird. Anyways, I would just go to Ella's next door for similar options and better food. read more

After a hiatus of a few years, we decided to retry Alfredo's a few months ago and were pleased to find it back to it's former glory. A rather extensive menu and very tasty plus, very good specials. Not very large inside so on a weekend reservations are a must. Outdoor dining in the nice weather so that makes things easier and they are also dog friendly which is a major plus. read more

Really nice outdoor seating in summer. Good food. nice family style salad in the beginning

We have been fans of Alfredos for years, all the food there is spectacular, and to date we have never been disappointed with the food nor the service. The staff are very nice and friendly considering its location . You cannot go wrong with going there nor take out. read more