Fresh make pizzas and good subs and really good tasteful Italian pastas yum also there salad are delicious to that there nice employees provide a well good service. I absolutely recommend this place for a good day even on a nice cold or warm day. read more

Our service was okay, but when the food came out it didn't look right. Now my family is facing food poisoning. MAKE SURE YOUR MEAT/ CHEESESTEAKS ARE COOKED!! will not go back. read more

THE BEST place to get food in Selinsgrove. I've been here countless times and still haven't found something I didn't like on the menu. Service is always good and the food is consistent. I couldn't recommend enough. read more

The food was delicious and our server Tori was very pleasant and helpful! The Christmas decorations throughout the seating area made our stay much more enjoyable read more

This place always has great food and it's always fresh and hot! The service is very good. It's a smaller restaurant so the dining room isn't huge but it's still nice. They have overhead music playing at a nice level and they have a TV with captions. The dining room has plenty of natural sunlight coming through their windows. They have a small parking lot in the front and then a bigger one in the back. read more

Disappointing visit. Close to an for my pick up pizza this evening. There was certainly a lot of fun going on in the kitchen area. It was not that busy and I expressed my displeasure as I have had better experiences at this location in the past. Not tonight. I reported my concerns, but they fell on deaf ears. Shop/Buy local only goes so far and should work both ways. I am not joking, but I have had surprisingly better service at the Selinsgrove Dominos. And their hand tossed pizza has come a long way. read more

I always go for the Linguine with Red Sauce and Meatballs whether I come for eat-in or takeout and it's never steered me wrong. Absolutely delicious, and you're hearing that from a true Italian. My boyfriend got their Calzone with ham and cheese inside and that dipped in the marinara was also very yummy. A medium size would have been more than enough for two! Lucky he's got a big appetite. I also enjoy their Caesar dressing, though I always get it on a house salad. Only complaint there is that their tomatoes always have an odd taste to them, so I eat around 'em. They have a cute little dining area and you can seat yourself once you come inside. From there, a server will bring you a menu and bread. Our waitress was polite and friendly, though a good deal inattentive despite the small number of customers at the time. She took a bit of time to realize when our waters were empty or to reassure us about the food but she was very nice. Overall it was a relaxing atmosphere with very good Italian food. I'll surely be back again soon. read more

See all

Usually the food is great from here- specifically pasta- great portions. however we were very let down with the cheesesteaks and gluten free pizza. Little meat on the sandwiches, gluten free crust was so dry, but salads were redeeming! Def better place for pasta than anything else. read more

Amato's Pizza - a piece of meat wrapped in foil - Pizza Near Me - Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania

Not fancy, but the pizza and pasta are consistently good. It's always a bit chilly in the dining room in the winter.

You become familiar with the taste of desperation when living in Central Pennsylvania. It sounds tragic, but it feels true. This is the better side of despair*, but it's got to be placed in perspective. Given your options around the area, Amato's is likely the highest-quality pizza you will find. And at that, it's decent. If you presented a slice from here to me in any other geographic location, I would have to pass unless I were hopelessly lost and desperately hungry on a residential street. Should you discover yourself pulling into the parking lot, make sure it's not a Monday. It won't be open (see, you should hate Mondays). When it is open, the pizza is fresh, the service is standard, the taste will tide you over until you escape this town. Their "subs" are your basic sandwich. Nothing I'd write home about. *de·spair noun \di-sper\ 1. utter loss of hope. 2. utter loss or absence of a proper slice of pizza within a hundred-mile radius. Source: Puja-Merriam-Webster Dictionary read more

The negative reviews on this place are an absolute joke. The pizza is always amazing yet the calzones are my favorite. The only gripe I could possibly think people would have is they use a sweeter sauce then some places. But if that is not an issue there are none. read more

Ay! It's GOOD Red and Black Tablecloth Italian, you know what I mean! No arrabbiata, but you want good red sauce . . . you can tell the chef how much you love garlic. People who move to Iowa dream about good basic places like this. read more

Considering how much we spent, your staff could have at least pretended to be friendly. Won't be back and suggest others go somewhere else. There are a lot more small businesses in the area we can spend our money at and I am sure they will appreciate it. read more

My family and I came here to eat before my daughters chorus concert. Multiple tables came in after us and got served before us. The food took about an hour and a half to get and we still never got it. Our server kept making excuses about the wait and said there were a lot of to go orders and they were taking care of them. The final straw was when a table the same size as ours came in 30 minutes after us and got their food. We got up and left. After an hour and a half. No food. Servers just making excuses. We will not be back. read more

The food at this establishment is hit and miss. Sometimes you actually get what you order and it tastes good. Sometimes you get what the waitress feels like bringing and a nasty attitude to go along with it. The only consistent thing they offer is disappointment, so good luck. read more

So the food around here sucks. It's all fast food and fake pizza and Dunkin' Donuts. Thank goodness for Amato's where the food is fresh, the pizza tastes closer to NY/NJ pizza than anywhere else around here and the service is friendly. read more

Had lunch here today for the first time in a couple of years. My memory of this place has always been positive - an independent pizza and sub shop. Nothing fancy, just simple fresh food. Today's lunch was in line with those memories. I had a Stromboli and it was delicious! The bread was very fresh and light and the mix of meat, vegetables, and cheese was perfect. Flavored were nicely balanced and the meal was filling but not heavy. read more

It really can be hit or miss. I definitely had to try this out a few times to find my favorite items. The salads I am never crazy about. The hot subs are all worth ordering- especially meatball- and the pizza is good too. I wouldn't rave about it to anyone, but it's a Decent spot in the area where you can usually go with a group of people and not have a long wait to be seated. read more

Couldn't have been more disappointed in our last visit, ordered a medium steak special stromboli with extra cheese... And there was hardly any cheese in it, ask the waitress if it was indeed extra, and made it clear that I was not happy, she said she'd ask the cook and came back and said yes it was extra cheese. They didn't seem to care at all that I was an unhappy customer. So with that being said, I will not be returning. The stromboli wasn't even that good, steak wasn't chopped up well..and a medium for $17.50.... Get Oip xpress supreme stromboli, you will not be disappointed! read more

We ate there last weekend . There is 6 of us but the sever brings 4 plates. We ordered bread sticks as a app they came out with the pizza . So that was just pointless . After bringing are second pizza out we get 2 moor plates . So one pizza was a little cold and every had to wait a good amount of time so we could eat as a Family . They did not even apologize or let us speak with a manager or owner . read more

decent pie - nothing to write home about. Definitely better then chains pies. Price was a little high $15 for a large Pep and cheese.

Not that great! Pizza is fresh, pasta dishes pass over. Eggplant was frozen and reheated, perfect inexpensive college joint.

This place is in a college town where there aren't many options to go out to a non-chain, non-fast food restaurant. Service is quick and friendly. I haven't had pizza from them, but I have had their pasta and was underwhelmed. It was okay, but nothing I couldn't have made at home. I did however really like their homemade bread and cold subs. The bread is delicious! I stopped by a few times just to get a few of their small loafs (~ 6 inch) for me to make my own sandwiches at home. Their meats and cheeses were fresh and packed on there. read more

Went there tonight, ordered at 5:15 PM., table of 7. There were 4 tables that came in after us with at least 6 people and they were served and ate and were leaving and we still didn't have our order. When we asked the server what was taking so long, she said there were a lot of to go orders...seriously?! We had a school concert to go to and had to leave at 6:30 pm and we still didn't have our order...unaccecptable! read more

The calzones and the boneless wings were good. The service could have been better. You seat yourself, which is fine, but we ordered the wings as an appetizer and they didn't come out until our meal did. That is the only complaint really. read more

Nice clean restaurant. Waitstaff is usually very friendly. The menu has awesome pasta selection to choose from. The pizza is some of the best pizza your gonna eat in this area! read more

This is a good place, but unfortunately it isn't up to the quality, customer service, or consistency of the Northumberland location.

okay food, pizza not the best but better than mall pizza. dinners priced a bit high for what you get. Salads are just lettuce.