B is for Bella's Pizza I was between 4 & 5 stars, more of 4.5 stars. But rounding down only because it's not outstanding pizza, but is very good and better is at a cheap price point. A group of us were going up to Rochester in April 2024 for an unofficial wedding, love ceremony for the total solar eclipse. On our way, we ate a late lunch here. They sell pizza by the slice. And the prices were surprisingly reasonable. We had some sticker shock coming from the more expensive Maryland-Washington DC area. The staff was very nice too. The pizza was solid, not quite top notch pizza, but was above average for this cheap pizza. I got 2 slices: mushroom & chicken. The chicken were large chunks put on top. Both slices were delicious. There was some talk about stopping here again on the way back 3 days later, but we ended up eating dinner in Williamsport, which will be a 2-star review when I get to the letter J in this alphabet series. If I'm ever in Selinsgrove, I'd try to come back to this place for sure for the reasonably priced & delicious pizza. read more

Bella's Pizza - Delicious at a cheap price...yes please! - Pizza Near Me - Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania

This is a wonderful little pizza place in the 'old town' part of Selinagrove. Servings are huge--a large anything is for sharing, as are many if the other items. Side salad comes on an huge plate, stacked with veggies, generous dressing, and half a loaf of bread with butter. We tried the veggie Stromboli, which despite its large size, was devoured completely. Great balance of fresh vegetables, gooey cheese and crisp crust. read more

Bella's Pizza - Vegetable Stromboli (with a couple pieces already eaten) - Pizza Near Me - Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania

The Pizzas and Salads are delicious and reasonably priced. I also like their evening hours and it is located downtown.

Everytime I order food from here I am never disappointed. One of the best non-chain pizza places in the area! The pizza is always incredible, the garlic knots are super flavorful and the mozzarella sticks have the cheese pull you're looking for in a good mozzarella stick. 10/10 would highly recommend!! read more

I see the mixed reviews and struggle to completely get the angst. As far as I can tell this pie is as good as any I've had while visiting Susquehanna. Pizza, broad brushing, in central PA is different than near Philly. Generally sweeter sauce and floppy dough. Bella was really good. Crispy tomato-y and tasty. read more

I don't normally give negative reviews but must say that on 2 occasions, I ordered pizza and it smelled like sanitizer and tasted off, I called to let them know and they said a manager would call back but no call ever received. My husband thought the same thing. Tonight we picked up a stromboli, my very first bite was embedded with a long piece of hair cooked right into the cheese. Gross! I think after 3 attempts with Bella's, I'm moving on. read more

Good location and good subs and pizza but not great but if anyone is looking for a really good Buffalo Chicken sub try another place they don't put as much Buffalo sauce on. There foods are tasty, if anyone wants to know how long and how much they will not tell you until until they deliver or pick up don't know about pick up, otherwise service is not as much bright than you may think. Anyway you all decide I do recommend. read more

Bella's is a hidden GEM! If you know pizza, you will be pleasantly surprised.. asked for our crust extra crispy and they understood the assignment. Service was quick and friendly! Stumbled upon this place on accident and WILL be back read more

homie vibes in there. dusty lamp :/ pizza (italian hand thing) confused on disposal of dishes good for college kids who want a cheap snack! read more

Great pizza!! Not floppy and nice and fresh and hot. Also, the garlic knots were great! Nice and garlicky and the perfect amount of parmesan on top. The lunch special was a great deal as well, 2 slices for 2.99 Also, we ate it so fast we couldn't even get pictures. read more

Bella's is a super casual pizza joint right in the heart of downtown. Ironically, it's next to ANOTHER pizza joint (OIP), but I always found myself preferring Bella's. I've been quite a few times so here's a review of what I've had. Garlic Knots -- absolutely amazing; go for it! Wings -- not bad, but a little too soft; have bordered on mushy when ordered through takeout Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza -- delicious and addicting but SUPER oily, always gives me a bit of a stomachache Plain pizza -- you can't go wrong, very good Buffalo Chicken Pizza -- yummy but absolutely smothered in sauce; sometimes they add the ranch without asking and sometimes they don't (hint: you want the ranch) You order at the counter and they bring the food to you. Despite their flaws, I love Bella's and they always have some booths or chairs to slunker down in inside. I've also never felt rushed while eating there with a friend, which is mighty appreciated. read more

Bella's Pizza - Chicken Bacon Ranch slices and Buffalo Chicken slices. - Pizza Near Me - Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania

See all

Nice place, helpful service, but the reason you go to a pizza place is mainly for the pizza and this pizza is so/so at best, doubtful to return read more

Overpriced dreck! Decided to give Bella's a try. The world's most expensive "Sicilian" pizza ever. Better pie at Little Cesar's and I am not kidding. Bella's uses cheap ingredients so the dough tastes like Wonder Bread. read more

Just some of the best pizza in town! Always look forward to going! The GF pizza was cooked perfectly and was so happy they had gluten free options! Thanks Bellas! read more

Picked up two slices of pizza from ínside theiDelicious cheese steak through the garden. Could have been a little bit more meat but it was not on the skimpy side. read more

I have been reviewing pizza restaurants for the majority of my life, and I can say that Bella's pizza is absolutely the best bang for your buck. Not only is the pizza amazing but the people that work there are what make the store what it is. I'm so grateful for having a quality pizza restaurant in Selinsgrove. Thanks Bella's! read more

We just had subs at Bella's. I had a tuna sub which was good except the lettuce could have been a little fresher. Otherwise the staff were friendly and the bread was great. We will probably go there again. We were just passing through town. read more

*called to complain about hair in my food and they laughed and hung up* Great food if you like finding HAIR IN YOIR FOOD. Trust me, I get it, it happens but this a common occurrence and it's really disappointing. I have ordered twice and they both had hair in the food. During these hard times I want to support local businesses but not enough that want hair in my food! Bella's please work on this!!!! read more

They were on the phone when I entered, but as soon as I came in they apologized. I only waited about 5 minutes, and the employee on the phone profusely apologized again. They were very kind and upon returning home, they gave me an extra SLICE!!! I'm assuming just because I had to wait a moment (which was totally fine!). Wether or not it was an accident, I was very pleased! read more

Cafeteria pizza would be better honestly. It was cardboard with a little sauce and cheap cheese. The decor is dated but what really matters is that is pizza is not good. It's not expensive so if you want cheap cardboard this is your place. The people who work there are very nice. read more

The doe goes in the oven and comes out pizza. There's this place next door and they pizza too. Their pizza looks like pacman when you eat just one slice read more

Bella's Pizza - a man with a smile on his face - Pizza Near Me - Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania

Absolutely love Bella's pizza! We get take out once a week and they never disappoint.

For the most part, I have always enjoyed the food at Bella Pizza. However, Tuesday evening we ordered a large cheesesteak calzone. We specifically asked to have ricotta added to our calzone. We were staying in a hotel because we had a tragic death in our family and have it delivered as we were exhausted from the trip. When my husband called Dallas to tell them that we were very disappointed in the calzone as it had no ricotta cheese in it, the man on the phone named won told my husband that there was no problem and that it would be replaced for nothing if we came back in. Last evening we had our grandson with us and decided to take him to Bellas. W we ordered a large pepperoni pizza and 20 wings which was a deal they had on their menu for 2399. When my husband went to pay he questioned this so-called refund. One walked away from the register and have another guy handled the transaction. He had already run the card and said he was sorry but he already finish the transaction and there was nothing he could do. Needless to say we were very upset with this. But, due to the fact that our grandson who is six years old was with us, nothing was confronted by us. The jerk, Juan, decided to give us a WHOPPING $3.75!! The calzone was almost $15!! Our order was a large pepperoni pizza and the 20 wings deal on the menu for $23.99. He told my husband that it was a typographical error on the menu and said that that deal had gone up to $29.99. First of all, we are not responsible for the airs on their menu and we should have gotten the price of $23.99. Long story short, our bill was $27.79. I was livid but kept my mouth shut so as to spare our grandson. The pizza was great but the chicken wings absolutely sucked! They were not for us and they tasted as though they were left over from earlier and they microwave them. They through the wings on a plate and poured sauce over them. Really? Never again will I order anything but pizza or a hoagie from Bellas pizza. And to be honest with you, we may never ever order anything again from there. Buyers beware! Save your money and go to Amato's for the best pizza in the area!!!!! read more

This place was okay. We didn't get pizza though. My husband got a cheesesteak, which was cook on pizza dough shaped like a roll. I order a cheesesteak panini, which had a similar bread as my husband's steak, just flatter. read more