I live in Salem, but lost sight of this gem after they moved to Pickering Wharf. I was nearby today, so stopped in and ordered a pizza to go and had a glass of wine. The pizza was delicious! It's a bar pie, and the crust was perfectly chewy with that yeasty flavor. Everything is scratch made, and the owner (Jacqui?) and the entire staff is charming. I'm so glad I stopped by on a whim! read more

We enjoyed our experience here. Favorites were the pasta which received rave reviews & the cheesy garlic sticks which were a hit. The steak and cheese also received very positive feedback from my son for its flavor, it did have a lot of grease but it didn't seem to take away from his enjoyment of it. We decided to order a Sicilian style pizza as well since it is out go to pizza style. I really liked the dough, the assortment of cheeses was fine (not my favorite but not bad), and the sauce was probably my least favorite part of it, I'm not sure if it was basil or oregano but that was the main flavor profile from it. We unfortunately did not get to come when the owner was in since she isn't feeling well, but her niece was working really hard to hold down the fort by herself. read more

Amazing Pizza - Sicilian cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

See all

We arrived at 10:59 on a Thursday afternoon and were the first patrons there. Shortly after arriving we had the pleasure of meeting Jackie, the owner and a fantastic host!! Being from a very different place, we were interested to learn some of the history of the area from a life long local. She was funny, she was pleasant, and she is a lovely person. On top of the great company, came great food and the best dark and stormy I've ever had. We got a few slices of the pizzas for the day, and all three were fantastic, with good crust and fresh ingredients- the two most important things about pizza! I was so wrapped up in the experience that I did t take a single picture other than the cookies we snagged on the way out. read more

Amazing Pizza - Chocolate chip cookie - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

The pizza itself was awesome. And, not be corny, dare I say amazing. Flavorful, thin crust, great cheese and sauce. But, alas, it was also obscenely expensive. $9 for a slice of cheese and a can of coke. Also charging 20 cents for a box is a little much. In hindsight, when they asked if I wanted it on a plate or in a box I should've asked if there would a difference in price. I'd pass on this place if I had a do-over option. read more

Amazing Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

While walking around the area looking at all the shops we decided to stop in and try some pizza . After looking at the menu we ended up ordering some onion rings , meatballs and a half pepperoni half Hawaiian pizza. First out was the onion rings which was a good amount and came with a house made bbq sauce and ketchup which were really good , we had asked about a side of ranch and since it was like $2 we passed but the owner came out and ended up giving us a cup of it and was explaining why they charge and it is definitely home made and not just ranch out the bottle. Now the meatballs were so good and the homemade marinara was on point just so good. And now for the pizza it was a good pizza and a good size and the location of the restaurant was right in a small shopping area along the water , they had a good size dining area and nice decor would most likely stop in again to try some other items. read more

See all

Apology accepted, but all the things I complain about you do exactly that, you seem to take bad reviews personally so clearly you know they are true, I came here after a long walk around the whole city, hoping for a nice meal, and kind service, gladly the pizza was alright but the garlic bread was not garlic-ing, and the staff only spoke when it was time to order, and took customers that came in after us before us, I found this disrespectful and honestly ruined my whole day, all I was looking for was a nice experience but got the exact opposite, the service was honestly terrible, they did not even ask if we wanted a drink as I said, they did not even give us the right amount of plants, definitely will not be back here and I do not suggest anyone else does. P.s- i heard your workers talking bad about the pizza they serve. read more

I wish I saved a photo. But I had to dig in after 13 days of not being eat solids... I really was hoping super sub in Beverly but, was not open for Labor Day (deservedly so). I had to have a cheesesteak, my husband an Italian. And believe me, it was top 10 subs I've had in the North Shore. Maybe you think it's just hunger, nope. Husband agreed abd we eat A LOT of subs. Steak bomb, classic Italian. I'm no novice. Worth the praise. PS, Beverly super sub will always of course be a great choice. read more

I can't keep coming here in good faith. It's just too expensive and feels like the quality has gone downhill too. My last two times coming here I have paid $51 for one pizza and Buffalo wings, and then $57 for small pizza, BLT, and Greek salad. $18 for the BLT alone is insane when you realize it doesn't even come with fries. One olive in the salad. And no pita bread or anything. Unfortunately the pizza used to be better too. The last two pizzas I've had, the cheese just slides off when you try and pick up a slice. I would think twice before coming here read more

The place is rightfully named the pizza is amazing! And Jackie's hospitality was outstanding! If you are in the area check it out!

Amazing staff, super friendly. Had my dad take a tour around the place haha. Great food, excellent ambiance. Lighting, music, all good. Reasonably priced. Extremely reasonably priced, actually. 10/10 etc. read more

Amazing Pizza - Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

See all

Local eating during oct. Discovered 20percent tip table of 6, without serving telling us about it. We were 2 people. Plus pizza was 5 dollars more then normal. Talked with owner she said too bad basically. Not good bussiness in my opinion and not fair to those coming. In October to their establishment. There appe they was a hand written sign on their door. Right everyone reads those. Good foorld, good service good things will come please dont take advantage of people tines are tough enough. We tipped that night and then thought about it next day and looked closer at our bill and returned next day to discuss. read more

Nothing went right here. "Amazing" is quite an overstatement. Tables were dirty and unbussed for quite a while. We were told to "sit anywhere", which meant for us to look for a table that was clean. It was an exceptionally long wait for our ordered white pizza. I was unaware that a "white pizza" would mean that said pie would be devoid of spices. No flavor. We were never told about the specials, although we were hounded by our waitress, who turned out to be the owner, about why we didn't seem ecstatic about our experience and the food. Also, no soap in the bathroom. No one came to our table to collect the check; we had to go to the front to the cashier in order to cash out. Done here. There are more than enough better food venues in Salem. read more

I got served some of the worst pizza I've ever had at this place. It was basically like a burned cracker with a little cheese and tomato sauce on it. I got 2 pepperoni slices to go and I was going to eat them on the way home but I ended up stopping after just a few bites because I thought it was terrible. And the fact that they charge $5.50 for a razor thin burned slice of pepperoni is ridiculous. I can't speak about the ambience of the restaurant since I got my order to go but I did think the dining room looked very nice and the girl at the counter who served me was very friendly. It's just that the pizza was terrible and I couldn't even eat it. They need to do better because as of right now, there is nothing Amazing about Amazing Pizza and I won't be back. read more

Amazing Pizza - This is one slice. Although it's good size, it was extremely thin and burned. - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

See all

The pizza is amazing but not the purpose of this review. It's the clam chowder. Spent the week driving from Boston to Bar Harbor and ate some great food during our trip up and down the coast. Stopped by Amazing Pizza for something other than seafood but the owner talked us into a bowl of chowder. It was not only the best of the 9 bowls we ate that week but also the best meal of the week. There should be a line around the corner of this family owned joint everyday. If you are visiting Salam don't make the mistake of passing by this place to eat at the touristy seafood places. read more

Owner/chef Jaqui is probably the most welcoming and kind person of all time. Food was quick and great, service was incredible, and the location is super convenient! read more

We ordered delivery last week. My husband's small meat pizza was tasty, except a few areas of the crust were burnt. My gluten free pizza was not recommendable; it was smaller than a regular "small" pizza, which I have unfortunately experienced with several other pizza establishments. The ham was chopped rather fine and there was very little pineapple. When I went to separate the pieces the toppings slid off. I did not find their pizzas to be "Amazing". Especially where the final bill, including tip, came to $57 and change! read more

Located at the Wharf Shops in Salem, Amazing Pizza is a casual restaurant and bar serving up a variety of thin crust pizzas, calzones, salads, pasta, sandwiches with fries, wings, chicken tenders, fried mozzarella, cookies, and cold drinks in the cooler (Boylan's sodas, bottled waters). The place offers full service dining in and takeout and there is seating up at the bar and table seating in the dining area. The bar offers beer (draft, cans, bottles), wine, and cocktails. They offer online ordering through Toast. I placed an online order recently at Amazing Pizza in Salem. I ordered the Small 12" Sausage Pizza ($15.95 plus tax) and a Bolognese Pasta ($15.95 plus tax), which was ready to go in about 20 minutes. The 12" round pizza was topped with slices of Italian sausage, red sauce, and minimal mozzarella cheese on top of a soft thin light crust. However, the edges of the pizza were burnt and this definitely was not a New Haven pizza. The Bolognese Pasta had plenty of hearty meat sauce over soft cooked linguine. I was able to add more linguine pasta to this dish and quick baked some garlic bread when I got home for a filling meal. Overall, not bad. I would probably return to try one of their sandwiches with fries, but I would skip the pizza. read more

We went to Amazing Pizza tonight. Visiting the area and looking for a great thin crust pizza..... we found it! Cozy welcoming place, attentive service, had two individual sized pizza's that were fabulous. Also had the lemon chicken soup that was superb. Highly recommend, you won't be disappointed! Linda read more

My son and I went on a pizza tour of Salem and this was our favorite. Really good crust, fresh, quality ingredients, and the owner was so passionate about her product.. If 8 could give 4.5, I would. The only caveat was that the pizza had a lot of oregano on it. It was a little strong, and got stronger as the pizza chilled. Still, highly recommended and it will be our go to place, read more

Pizza arrived barely lukewarm but maybe that's on Grubhub. Asked for spaghetti got linguini. Caesar salad was pitiful for the price and forgot anchovies that were paid for. Good meatballs and red sauce but overall more expensive and not much better than your average pizza sub shop. read more

Awesome food - steak bomb sandwich was amazing and our waitress Maddie was so great! We also tried the Sicilian and cheese pizza read more

Amazing Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

The food was okay but the owner was so rude. She referred to herself as a raging bitch multiple times and it would be nice if that self-awareness changed anything about her behavior. She was constantly swearing at both employees and customers and was yelling at employees who were just trying to do their job. The second customers would leave the restaurant she would say rude things about them which, as a customer, made me so uncomfortable. I don't want to speak for any employees but if you ask me, it being in the middle of your busy season is not an excuse for being unkind! read more

The owner was incredibly rude towards her staff and treated them poorly even as they were learning how to do their jobs. The food tastes frozen and the overall ambience is tacky. read more

On 10/17 around 5:30 pm, myself and 4 of my friends decided to have some pizza and drinks at The AmazingPizza. So we stopped in at the bar. We ate and drank and then paid before leaving. I paid last and took out my envelope that I had cash to pay my bill. We left the restaurant and within 15 after leaving I noticed my envelope was not with me. So I went back and asked the bartender if he saw it. He said yes. I said can I have it? My money of $40.00 was still in it. He said no I threw it out, it was empty. I said no my money was still in there. I believe he took the money and then threw out the white envelope. I hope Karma comes back to bite him. YOU HAVE A THIEF WORKING THERE STAY AWAY FROM THIS RESTAURANT WHILE IN SALEM, MASS. read more

This was absolutely the best bar pizza I've had in awhile. Jackie, the owner, was wonderful. She was greeting every guest and making us feel so welcome. It was just so delicious! read more

Food was ok. Service was bad and the prices were absurd and wrong price match from the menu. I am very fed up and annoyed.

Had a really good broccoli and chicken Alfredo. Our server was very kind and was able manage the people coming in super well despite being understaffed. Therefore, despite the lack of staff at that time, it had no big effect on how fast our food came as a result of her diligent work. I recommend the garlic cheese stick and any type of pasta as they make their own and it came out perfectly. read more

Upon arrival, the place is cute and quiet, and one of the only non-busy places around the Salem area. After arriving and waiting to be seated, the owner, Jackie, is yelling at her clearly autistic employee for collecting tips! This almost made us immediately leave. We decided to sit anyways. After ordering our drinks and being one of the two only occupied tables, we hear her continue to yell at the autistic employee, who is clearly trying. Jackie did not think to take her employee into the back room or do this once costumers left, instead she did this in front of everyone. And being of the darker ethnic group she was also saying racial comments that were making me and my company as well as the table next to us very uncomfortable to the point of leaving!! Really sad as from what we understood she was the owner of the establishment. read more

Not only is the pizza amazing but the service is too! It was so convenient to find a park and get seated right away. The food took a little while but it was soooo fresh. Perfect crust!! Great music! read more

Very happy to find out how awesome Amazing Pizza's gluten free pizzas are. We got the parma pizza and loved it so much !

Staff was excellent food came out fast and great menu. 10/10 bread. Bread is made in house and ingredients are fresh! Ranch dressing was phenomenal. Meats are imported from Italy!!!! read more

Amazing Pizza - Sandwiches and fries - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

See all

You know how you go to the North End and expect great Italian food and you have a good time - but .... This is the answer. Someone (the owner) can really cook like your Italian relatives. Don't hesitate to visit this lovely place with great food and kind people. read more

ABSOLUTELY delicious pizza - we had the Parma and it was stellar. The young girl at the bar (who served us) was lovely and doing a great job. The owner was very intense and yelled a lot at the waitress, which was uncomfortable. read more

Many friends raved about Amazing Pizza, so my son and I finally decided to have lunch there today. This restaurant is a lot more than just pizza. My son had the pasta bolognese and I had the chicken parm sub with a side of onion rings. Everything was amazing. Everything is homemade....the bread, pasta, pizza dough, etc. No pre-frozen fries, onion rings, etc. This is a down home restaurant. Had a great conversation with the chef/owner Jacqui. She couldn't have been more accommodating. Highly recommend and looking forward to trying different dishes. read more

Amazing Pizza is worth the walk! It takes just a couple of minutes from the center of downtown to the harbor area, but if you like crisp hot pizza with fresh, quality topping you'll be pleased. The pepperoni is so good and has that authentic sheen when it first comes out of the oven. We also had a HUGE Greek salad covered with tasty feta and briny Katamala olives and home made dressing. read more

The pizza is delicious. We loved the crust. Friendly service and a short walk from our hotel.

The resteraunt was very clean and the service was wonderful. Everyone was so friendly. The pizza was great and so was the chicken Alfredo.

Only two servers working at a restaurant in Salem MA in October... The one older woman was incredibly nasty. Gave us plastic plates. The silver was clearly used and not washed and placed back on our table. Sat for about 30 minutes before someone came to our table. read more

Amazing Pizza - Forks at table - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Massachusetts

I am extremely disturbed by this Establishment. They advertised Dinner Shows...I have been several time and had a wonderful experience...even though the food was rather second rate. This past Friday I received notification that all shows are canceled immediately. I was going ..had tickets and lots of friends coming with me in the next several weeks. This decision on the part of Jackie to end the shows is extremely disappointing. When I inquired as to "why" the shows were canceled...I was told.."Jackie felt the shows were not family friendly". Interesting ...these same shows were acceptable Between Nov and April...They were acceptable over the biggest family time of the year...Christmas! Yet NOW where business is picking up from the tourist trade the shoes...Golden Girls. Judy Garland Tribute shows, Hocus Pocus...are not family friendly?! Clearly Jackie used these talented performers for her own financial gain...and then decided to unceremoniously evict them. The food...sub par...I went...paid $20 to the restaurant...for water...What restaurant doesn't offer Coffee or Tea?? Salad swims in dressing...Meatballs..horrible... Plenty of good restaurants in Salem...Don't waste your money in this establishment which uses people... read more

it started okay. we got seated right away and everything was going smoothly. and then it took a turn for the worse. our waiter came over and fully just stared at us like we were the ones serving him. and we placed our drink order and he still kinda just stood there. we told him we needed a minute and he brought out 2/3 drinks and placed the dinner order. he never brought out the third one we had to get another server. after waiting for 30 minutes and our food still hadn't came out and our original waiter never checked on us. i believe his name was michael who took care of us after fallouh abandoned us and he got our food order actually placed (yes our food order was never placed) and we got our food FINALLY after an hour and a half. we liked this place but we will not be coming back. read more