My wife and I recently purchased a mattress from this store, and we want to give a special…read moreshout-out to our sales rep, Brandon Nevarez, for providing an outstanding experience from start to finish. Brandon was open, honest, and patient throughout the entire selection process. He never pressured us to make a purchase and encouraged us to take our time--literally allowing us to lie on each mattress for over 10 minutes, multiple times, until we found what worked best. We spent about 2-3 hours in the store, and not once did we feel rushed. Our first choice was a floor model that was an unbeatable deal. It arrived on time, in perfect condition, but after about three weeks, we realized the mattress just didn't meet our needs. Thanks to the warranty, we returned to the store, and Brandon provided the exact same level of exceptional service during the exchange. He once again walked us through several options, let us test them thoroughly, and made sure we left with a mattress we truly love. We also purchased two pillows during our first visit, and when one started causing neck pain, Brandon helped us exchange it under warranty without any hassle. Overall, Brandon delivered top-tier customer service every step of the way. His professionalism, transparency, and genuine care turned what could have been a stressful process into a great experience. We couldn't be happier with the service we received or the mattress we ultimately chose. Highly recommended!

Been looking for a good mattress for the past few months. I am super picky, because my wife and I…read moreboth sleep on our sides and we never feel good on a lot of the soft mattresses we have tried before. When we went in we had a great conversation with the GM just talking about Colorado. After showing us around we settled on the Telluride pillow top. We didn't feel pressured here, and the GM and staff were laid back and genuine. We will be recommending this place in the future. So far this mattress is a huge improvement to our sleep. Thanks again, and solid service.

We bought a mattress and box spring here in February. I didn't write a review until now because of…read morereasons I'll get into later. Mike, the store manager, was super helpful and friendly when it came to helping us pick out a mattress that fit our budget and needs. We were thinking about returning it for a while because it wasn't quite as comfortable as we expected it to be but eventually decided not to because it was almost paid off and an egg carton topper helps enough. Mike was super helpful when we were thinking about exchanging and even kept the window open for us longer than usual. We're super satisfied with our experience when it comes to Mattress Firm. The reason I didn't write the review until now is because the financing company they work with that doesn't require credit, Progressive Leasing, has been extremely problematic. While Mattress Firm doesn't own Progressive Leasing and they can't control what they do, Mattress Firm does work with them regularly and has a contract with them so I felt like it was important to include. Progressive Leasing has been difficult to work with from the start. We wanted to set up higher payments so we could pay off our account early and initially, they didn't understand what we meant and we had to argue with them about it for a while before it was fixed. We found out about 10 weeks ago, that they were still taking money out of our account after we paid our contract off early. They took roughly $200 from us before we noticed; we weren't looking for that transaction because we were told our contract was paid off. They did refund the money but it took 10 weeks to go through and they're difficult to get a hold of because they close super early even though they're in our time zone. Edit to add: After I posted this review, the refund disappeared from our account, where it had been pending. Unfortunately, we are probably going to have to escalate matters. Again, I understand that Progressive Leasing is not owned or managed by Mattress Firm but they do business together. I highly urge people not to use them.

Great service and education on memory matress. Great price and next day delivery…read more Great selection and layout in the store. Color coded by firmness. Very clean and organized.

We have bought a Washing Machine and Dryer, Microwave, and Dishwasher over the last 9 years. All…read moreSamsung products. Several other top name brands, along with lesser-known brands, and a lot of options to pick from. Absofrekintootly fantastic experience each time. Great service each time. Helped with financing. Great prices. I even bought a part for a different product from the onsite repair department. He was very helpful finding the part for a good price. We are going to buy a Refrigerator this Black Friday from them. 11/20/2025

Recently purchased a washer and dryer combo here. The dryer looked like it was dropped off of a…read moretruck onto its side. It did not work. I've tried to get ahold of someone for 4 days with out any response back. Stay away from this place.

They don't follow Covid restrictions and encourage their customers not to wear mask. I called and…read morespoke with the owner only to be told " ok" no apology or words to express regret.

Don't give them money up front they failed to deliver our couch , we ordered a couch in early…read moreFebruary before Valentine's Day, was told our couch would be delivered by the end of April . Today is June 1,2021 we need some furniture as we have family coming to stay with us shortly. Wife found another couch at lazy boy but we are told the owner will not return our money for the undelivered furniture . And we wait till it shows up I guess do not ship here thanks

Very poor communication! I had placed an online order Monday. I contacted them Wednesday asking how…read morelong it takes for them to ship items. The was no response but shortly after I sent them the email, they issued me a refund. I had sent another email asking if item was out of stock or what was going on. They completely ghosted me. If a store is not able to fulfill online orders. They should not offer an online store or shipping.

Visited this place on a day trip to Greeley, and it was such a treasure!…read more The owners were SO nice and the sweetest! I could explore this place for hours. They also have some "new" items in one section, but I already had found my purchase of a huge, mason jar jug for my fiancé and I to put our collection of matchbooks in. When I'm in the area, I definitely plan on coming back!

We were helped right away. They have a lot to choose from, their website does not do them justice…read more Had our furniture delivered, two man crew, they were fast. We ordered two bedroom sets with mattresses, living room set, and dining room. One guy set up the beds, while the other continued to unload. Great experience!

My sister were shopping for a sofa. Katie help us she was very knowledgeable, personable and so…read morevery helpful. I really hate shopping she made my experience so easy and fun.

Another predatory mattress store. Purchased a mattress a few months ago and it's god awful. We…read morespent about $4k all in because we went for the adjustable base. The kid who sold it to us was nice but he said it was more medium and this thing is plush! And I admit I did try it, but when you're laying on dozens of mattress in one day, it becomes difficult to accurately gauge everything. Here's the real problem.... they try to sell you a mattress protector that costs hundreds of dollars. I don't remember the kid saying this (he probably didn't), but if you don't spend that extra money, you can't return it. So even though we bought our own reputable mattress protector for a fraction of the price online, they simply won't accept it. It's a really lousy way to do business. My back is destroyed. I'm gonna try to make it a year and then put this bed in the guest room. Shame on this place, just go somewhere else without these dumb caveats. There's a million mattress stores in Fort Collins

The absolute best service and experience. My husband and I just bought our first home and needed a…read morebed for the master. Dennis was a great listener and offered his expertise to help with my husbands tossing/turning and scoliosis. He was incredibly patient with us as we tested his recommendations and decide on what we wanted to go for. Delivery day came and the team was so great! They helped us choose a height for the base, made sure to set out moving blankets so they did not scratch the wood floor, and made sure we were happy with the placement. They also brought a new houseplant, bottle of champagn, and card from their staff congratulating us in our new home. Seriously love our new bed and so thankful we stumbled into this store! Could not recommend enough!

There are much better places to buy a mattress, actually there are two places less than a few…read moreblocks from here that will treat you better and give you better selections and options. Speaking from experience!

Uncomfortable Experience in Every Way! I stopped by America's Mattress in Fort Collins hoping to…read morefind a new mattress, but the whole experience left me more uneasy than rested. Jeremiah, the salesperson who "helped" me, was both unhelpful and downright creepy. He hovered too close, made a few off-putting comments, and didn't seem to know much about the products. When I asked simple questions about firmness and warranty, he either gave vague answers or tried to steer the conversation toward unrelated topics. The entire visit felt awkward and uncomfortable, and I ended up leaving without buying anything -- and honestly, I wouldn't go back. If you're shopping for a mattress, I'd recommend going somewhere else where the staff is professional and respectful. This place was neither. -- Condi