I got a chance to sample a slice of their white pizza at the Jersey Eats NJ Pizza Festival. The slice was the first one I had and yet it is still one of the most memorable for me. The crust was crispy yet soft and unbelievable - no flop! The pizza was savory and had the perfect dollops of ricotta. The cheese wasn't slopping off, everything stayed together nicely. It even had a unique crust that had "everything but the bagel" seasoning encrusted on top. I normally don't go for a white pizza but seeing this at first glance I just felt gravitated to try it and I'm glad I did! This is a great family operated pizzeria. The family is super kind and proud of their business which I took away in the few moments I interacted with them at the festival. I wish them all the best and hope to stop by for some more of their pizza if I'm ever in the area! I recommend you try them! read more

Amici Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey

I'm honestly flabbergasted how this place has any slightly good reviews. It is absolutely awful. I was hoping to find a neighborhood red sauce take out place, but this was AWFUL. I think the folks in NJ who have never lived anywhere else..just have nothing to compare this place to. I mean the roads, the parks, the infrastructure, the amenities, the beaches, the water, the roads (deserves a second mention) , the shopping, the culture, the EVERYTHInG including restaurants is so very inferior to the other suburbs. Yikes! The eggplant parm was unbreaded, uncooked, unflavored, un sauced --simply gross. The calzone was so full of cheap cheese we were gagging,. Thanks Amici for not changing my opinion of this shthole state. ZERO stars read more

Had a great experience with Amici's. I had a small event to cater and someone had recommended I check out Amici's. The ownership was great and easy to work with. The full catering trays of penne vodka, baked ziti, chicken tenders, garlic knots, and mozzarella sticks were full and plentiful, and the food was great! read more

Service food & atmosphere are all excellent! Such a nice family business. Owners work hard to make their customers happy & the chef is always trying new recipes. read more

See all

3.5 stars Salads are good and so are the appetizers (garlic knots and wings). The pizza was fine. It wasn't the best, but definitely not the worst I've ever had. Everything is well priced and the portions are a good size. The people who work there (who I think own it) are nice. read more

Everything was very good..we had our delivered..it came very fast and packaged well. I would definitely recommend them

I rarely give out 5 stars, but I'll have to make an exception here! Amici is run by the family that used to run Umberto's in Fair Haven, which is dearly missed. We ordered from them for years and I loved going in whenever I come home. I'm glad to see them back in the pizza game even if it's a bit further We ordered a large plain, large pepperoni, a ham calzone, and garlic knots. All were fantastic as usual. I ate until I hated myself from eating too much. You don't have to do that, but it's hard to find good pizza in the Midwest! Unfortunately I forgot to take pictures but there's plenty of them on their Instagram so just check there! read more

I had to go to Atlantic highlands for some work and decided to stop by for lunch at amici's off of Route 36 and gotta say this place was great. Not only was the cashier/counter lady very nice and attentive but the pizza was great too. I got a plain slice and maugherita slice and both were fantastic along with a fountain Pepsi. I'll definitely be coming back here again soon read more

I would give this place 10 stars if I could! The food is sooooo good. We order from here at least 4 times a month! The owners are so kind and friendly as well as the delivery drivers. I look forward to every time we order! Keep it up, Amici! We LOVE your food and service! read more

I called today to order food. The person that answered the phone answered with: "Amici's please hold" and she put me in hold. I called when I did to get a head start on a pizza so I could get there and not have too long of a wait. Over 15 minutes later I pulled in to the parking lot and went inside. There were people in the restaurant but it wasn't by any means a mad house. I told the person behind the counter that I have been on hold for over 15 minutes. She smiled and said "I have been too busy to get to the phone... I'm the only one here doing this". She was not the only person behind the counter. This is not the first time this has happened to me trying to order food from Amici. The food is good but the people working there don't seem to care much about customer service. This could be a booming business but they need to get the front of their house in order. read more

Just had a great chicken parm dinner. Sauce was fresh and amazing They just put together a spa menu if healthy meals designed with the help of Eastpointe Fitbess. This sounds great read more

Ordered buffalo wings and a large pizza and it came on time and it tasted amazing the wings and pretty friggin good!

I was eager to try the new pizzeria. The place looks great looks like they can grow into nicely. I ordered a half anchovie half plain. The crust is thin which is good and the sauce and cheese was good. My wife even complimented on that. Only critique was even though cheese was good there was too much and not enough sauce. Like anchovie but pieces were large overkill. Lastly and importantly the crust, not much flavor. Hopefully, they can consider and make changes. If so they have a steady customer. I wish them luck. Good luck! read more

We were really excited to try this place. They renovated the space beautifully, have a friendly staff and a nice menu! Sadly the bread for our sandwiches was horrible (everything inside was excellent though). The pizza was way over done and my two kids who will eat anything pizza related refused more after reluctantly eating one slice because they said it wasn't good. The crust just not ideal, and not enough cheese for such thick crust. Really bummed because we love the location and so many things about it. Hoping they consider making a bread/dough change. Best of luck to them! read more

Salad cost extra with entrees, sauce and meatballs just ok, bread wasn't that tasty. We gave this place a try but I wasn't that impressed.

I regularly get a plain Sicilian pie which I truly enjoy, as does my family. For holidays, I have ordered a half tray lasagna with meat sauce, which is also excellent. Their salads are also well done. Food has always been first rate. read more

Just picked up sausage pizza and a chicken parm sub(hoagie) both were excellent and tasty. Plenty of sausage on the pizza and a gargantuan amount of chicken on the sub. New favorite place. read more

I tried a slice today and found the pizza dough was light and thin which I like. The taste however was not there. The sauce had a sweetness to it and there was no taste over all.. It was like eating thin crust dough. read more

Horrible. An Italian restaraunt with no pasta??!! Ended up ordering sandwiches. Was told 45-50 minutes. Did not arrive for 1 hour and 20 minutes and missing one of the sandwiches. read more