This is our absolute favorite new pizza place!! Recommended by our friend and neighbor! What makes it even more special is the mutual appreciation :) thank you Amici's for the sweet note that we noticed grabbing the last slice before getting rid of the box!! read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

Pizza was amazing and crispy and tasted like old authentic pizza not from a fast food place

Wow, the crust reminded me of Boston pizza. Sauce was great and the atmosphere was comfortable. Friendly staff was refreshing! We'll be back! read more

Amici's food and staff makes you feel like family. For quick and hot pizza delivery use their online ordering. Food never disappoints! We are so happy Amici's is part of our neighborhood choices for great dining options. read more

Ok so I'm Italian and very picky about my pizza. The crust isn't too thick or thin, the cheese is layered just right, and the sauce!! Oh my the sauce has such great flavors it might as well be made by my grandmother. The staff that works there really makes me feel like I'm eating with my family. Ana is so personable and sweet to everyone that walks in the door she is a great addition to the amicis family. Oh and best meatball Parms in coconut creek :-) read more

Stopped for a quick bite. I ordered 2 slices of pizza, which were nice sized and very good. They also have sandwiches and salads. read more

See all

Great food & great service! Pizza was so delicious! Our waitress was Taylor and she was amazing, very on top of things & so sweet :) Would definitely recommend & will be back soon! read more

Best pizza in town. Hands down. Not only the pizza but the staff is friendly, pure, and wholesome I come here every Friday and the staff excites me just as much as the pizza. The pizza has a perfect crust and flavor with a perfectly crafted mild crunch, the sauce isn't too sweet or tangy, it's just right and the cheese and toppings are always the perfect portion. read more

Always ordered from here, because their food was always delicious. The last time we ordered pizza I was a little disappointed because it was a little greasier, and the cheese was a little chewy than it was normally. But I decided to give them a second chance and order for them tonight. I was so appalled by my treatment from the manager or at least she said she was the manager. I called to order and placed an order and then called five minutes later because I saw on their menu that there was a special and was told that I couldn't change my order to the special because they already made my food. when I asked how they made my food so quickly, I was told that they are slow. So now I know why they are slow because the manager has no customer service skills whatsoever. She even said I was breaking up when I asked to cancel my order altogether. I worked in the restaurant business as a manager for 9 years and I always try to treat this who do with respect because I understand the hard job that it is. I'm sorry she was having a bad day. I'm not sure when I'll be ordering from here again if ever. There are plenty of pizza joints around here. read more

This is the definition of hole-in-the-wall! The wings are to die for! The pizza is amazing! Everything about this place is spectacular! Oh and that chick Ana is pretty amazing too! read more

Seriously one of our favorite place to hangout with our family ! They treat you like family! My kids love their penne and brocoli... I love their unique decoration and their kitchen open concept... did I mention the pizza of course but the tiramisu... it's simply delicious read more

The best! Comfortable environment, friendly staff, killer wings, awesome pizza! Everything I've tried is delicious!

I tried their Sausage and Pepper Parm Hoagie and it was one ofnthe best I have ever eaten. It is a Wonderful Local Family owned Italian Restaurants where the Owner, Craig, comes out snd talks with you and his Daughter is very kind and attentive to making sure that your good is prepared just as your requested. I convinced my Wife to have dinner there this past Saturday Evening and their Antipasto Salad was very good no skimping on the generous portions of good quality Italian Salami, Cappicola and Han and their Pizza was Excellent with just the right juiciness, flavor and crispy crust. I highly recommend Amici's as one of the best friendly family owned Local Italian Restaurants in North Broward County, Florida. The Food, the Service and the Prices are all Excellent. read more

My wife and I were in town for a few days. We found this place on Google with good reviews. Not being ones to fancy the corporate type of establishments, we decided to give it a try. Boy are we glad we did!! The food was incredible, prices very reasonable, and Craig, one of the owners, treated us like we were family. Not to sound like a snob, or know- it-all, but I've been to every US state, and many, many cities, and have had pizza all over this great nation, (I think I was Italian in a former life), yes even in NYC, LA, and Chicago. This place is better than all the rest. It's a tiny little place, but neat, clean, and the food is second to none. I give it my highest recommendation. Rob M, MD & Susan read more

I love Amici's Pizza on Hillsboro and Lyons. I order weekly takeout or I stop at lunch for a slice. Give it a try. You won't be disappointed. read more

This place is a gem ! I live in boca and bypass all the pizzerias in boca and head to amici's in coconut creek on a regular basis . The pizza is the best I have ever had ... even better than the pizza I had growing up in nyc! My son and I had the pleasure of eating at amici's tonight and the very friendly and personable owner came to our table to see how our meal was . How often does that happen ?? Everyone is so friendly and the service is excellent. They have a very comprehensive menu other than pizza. read more

Love their pizza, especially the Monday special for $9.99. Can't beat feeding your family of 3 for $20 with tip. The staff is super nice and friendly. read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Large mushroom pizza. - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

Ehhh.... Sandwich was good but the pasta and clam sauce was bad. All canned clams and they throw in 1 shell so you think it's all fresh. The delivery was a mess. Everything squashed and leaking. read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Need better delivery procedures. - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

I'm changing my review because the last time I came here I'm 100% sure they had already baked pizzas just sitting on racks that they would pop into the oven to heat up. I placed and order for pickup so there's no excuse for this. I know a reheated pizza when I see one. The cheese was tough and rubbery. My first visit here was good and I remember the pizza being fresh but I like consistency and don't want to roll the dice on getting a fresh pizza or not. There's another place nearby that's amazing so I'll be going there instead. read more

Pizza is very tasty. However, the service was very disappointing. First, the pickup order for a one topping pizza was said to be ready in 20-30 minutes. I was there in 20 minutes and after paying, I waited 5 minutes before the pizza chef put my already-made pizza, that was sitting on a shelf with a bunch of already-made pizzas, in the oven to be heated up. Then, the website and menu show a price of $13.99 for a large pie, but they charged me $14.99. While I was waiting, since i had time to stand there in the empty restaurant for 5 minutes before they put my pie back in for reheating, I asked about the price. They said the changes went up but it's not reflected on the menu yet. Usually I would expect a restaurant or business to honor the advertised price when confronted about it. They didn't offer or suggest anything. Then, the charge for an entire topping was applied when we had the topping on half the pie. I know it's nitpicking, and I would order from here again, but I was disappointed because I expected much more from a local business. I did not push for any discount or deduction, so I cannot say they refused to honor it. But still, that should have been routine. Never had anything but pizza. Pizza is tasty. Great sauce. read more

I saw Amici's ad in one of those coupon ad pages and the fact it had high ratings on here plus it was a 7min drive for pick up I decided to give it a shot. I was debating between their Grilled Vegetable (zucchini mushroom eggplant onion) l or their margharita, both thincrusts. I asked to put fresh mozerella on the veggie one but it was $2 extra so I passed and chose the margharita. A small for 15.99 is pricey, for me at least, however because I am picky with my thincrusts I trusted that I'd be paying for quality. I must say I love the flavor of their pizza, the sauce, the cheese, just the right amount on basil, the taste of their dough and crust was delicious as well. However, I found the crust to be hard to chew. I got some nice crunchy parts but then the rest,such as the bottom, was not enjoyable to munch on. I've had thincrusts where they're able to balance between some crunchy parts and softer dough bottom. The small had 6 pieces, I ate half and got full. I also took out a Tiramisu, and unfortunately that only gets 3 stars. It has a strong liqueur taste, many might like that, but what really bothered me was the texture. Too much bready lady finger then the cream was too liquid. I'd like to think I'm a bit of tiramisu snob and know what a good one is. I like the marscapone to be thicker/fluffier and the whole dessert to have more coffee flavor. Because this place is so close, I would definitely come back and dine in with my bf and try out other items on their menu. Overall Amici's has one of the most flavorful thincrusts I've had in the area and recommend that others try this place out!! read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Tiramisu for 5.25: the bready lady finger texture and liqueur taste were overpowering, marscapone was runny - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

See all

I've come here for pick up twice - it's in a convenient location and easy to grab on a Friday night. Their margherita is where it's at - good mozzarella and lots of basil. Their crust is fresh and hand tossed in house so it has that good , random quality I love in pizzas where they aren't perfect circles. It's the place you don't leave the crust ends at. Their bread sticks were too tough and I wouldn't order them again - this place is all about the pizza. The normal pizza we ordered with black olives tasted amazingly like sbarros pizza in the mall with better crust. The cheese and sauce were amazingly reminiscent of Sbarro. I think the margherita is what I'll stick with. read more

Folks, be serious. This is a take out pizza place. They are not staffed for sit down meals. It's take away with option to stay. Service was brutal even though it was counter staff only. Pizza was fair, but not worth a second trip. Ratio of sauce to cheese is way off. Dough was ok, but, as many Yelpers noted, cheese pizza is pre made, toppings added and then it's reheated. House salad and garlic bread were unremarkable. If you want take out consider this in your rotation. Yelpers of FL you've let me down! read more

The Izzy is the best. We love the pizza from here. The service is good as well. Of course it's also great to take to go.

I've been getting delivery from here for years and it never disappoints. It's your classic pizza that has more quality than the mainstream delivery places. All the other dishes are great too: chicken parm, salad, garlic bread, calzones, etc. This is my favorite delivery pizza place. read more

What a great surprise this place was. We ended up there because the wait at duffy's was too long and I'm I glad that happened. We had the rice ball and it was outstanding also the marinara that comes to dip it in was as good. My fiancée ordered the mussels which are an appetizer as her entree and it was a very decent portion of some of the best mussels we ever had. I ordered the chicken smoked Gouda portobello panini and wow the flavors in that panini was amazing I could not stop eating it. We are glad we found this place since we live nearby and we will definitely be back next time we want Italian. read more

Tried this place a few months ago and waited TWO hours for delivery. We decided to try it again tonight... definitely a mistake! Order has taken over an hour.. going on two AGAIN. On a Wednesday night? The pizza isn't that good for delivery to take this long. Will not be back!! Fair warning to all! read more

My favorite local Italian restaurant. Everything tastes homemade, service is always friendly, delivery is always prompt, and the app is simple to use. read more

Great pizza made by nice people! Try the whole wheat crust pizza. They make the finest rice balls. Nice wine selection for a pizzeria. I say pizzeria, but Amici's is a cut above the average pizza joint. Try it and you'll be sold! Free Wi-Fi! The code is the store phone number... read more

First time i come for my mom recommendation and food is amazing place is very nice italian style prices is very comfortable with high quality food read more

I grew up in Brooklyn with a neighborhood pizza parlor that served you slices from a window open to the sidewalk. Big, cheesy, thin and crispy slices. To me, of course, they made the best pizza in the world. In fact, almost all "sidewalk" pizza that I've had in New York was fabulous! Fast forward to Florida and after living here 30 years, I've only encountered 3 pizza joints that were a fair match to the NY pizza I grew up with. This place is one of them! It's not fancy and, like most places in NY, seating is limited and service is mostly confined to counter. But you can get one slice without having to buy a whole pizza to find out for yourself if you like it or not. The slices are large with just the right amount of sauce and lots of cheese. The crust is thin and crispy without their having to be told to make it so. This place knows how to make pizza a la New York! The first bit I had I closed my eyes and was transported back to my childhood. Naturally I ordered a couple of large to go. If you've ever eaten a NY pizza and want one while here in in Florida, this is the place! I'm glad I don't live so close to them that they'd deliver to me because I'd be eating those at least once a week if not more! It's worth the drive no matter where you live! Truly epic pizza! read more

We decided to try Amici's one night on a whim. They delivered and were close to our house. OMG. All can say is WOW!! We are pizza fanatics and not easily pleased. This is by far the best pizza we've had in the Palm Beach, Broward County area. From the excellent crust to the exceptional sauce. Not to mention that Taylor who answered the phone was the most pleasant person to deal with. She made me feel like she really wanted our business!!! read more

I'll keep it short awesome chicken Parmesan and service was great. Defiantly can't wait to go back. read more

Amici's Pizza Cafe - Italian Near Me - Coconut Creek, Florida

My wife and I love to pick up the cheese pizzas from here, which rank among the best we've ever had. The restaurant is kept clean inside, and the staff is always very friendly - I don't know the owners, but it seems to be a family-owned place, with all the positives that brings. If you're looking for an alternative to a big-chain pizza, definitely give this place a try. You may find a new favorite! read more

Their pasta is amazing! My boyfriend and I love the pasta (which we saw on one menu online but can't find it anywhere else) with a cream sauce, chicken, broccoli and mushrooms. We don't eat Italian very often, but when we do, we eat Amicis. Their pizza is a thinner crust which I'm not typically a fan of but the flavor of their pizza is really good. Goes great with the pasta. I've also had their sandwiches, which of course are very flavorful. I've done take out and delivery. read more

Hands down best pizza in Florida. I had the pepperoni and sausage it was cooked perfectly the crust was amazing and it was well done. Great job I am impressed the only downside is its 12 miles away from home read more

If you are looking for some top notch pizza, Amici's does not disappoint. And trust me I know good pizza. I come from a Sicilian family with a pizza brick oven in our backyard where we make fresh pizza all the time. I decided on a basic pepperoni pizza. I am a huge fan of a pizza with a crispy dough. Amici's Pizza has just the right amount of crisp to it and it folds perfectly to eat it. Not to mention our waitress was super sweet and very attentive to our table. The staff was super friendly and provided excellent service. Hands down the best pizza i have ever found in south Florida. Definitely will be returning for more of their amazing food!! read more

Pizza is good, but good luck on delivery. The delivery guy couldn't find our office. Then he called and asked me to come outside. Really? He wasn't outside. When he got here, he couldn't figure out how to make change. No fork, soup, or napkins included. Really? When I called them, she said she doesn't send forks, spoons or napkins unless requested. You will be eating your spaghetti with your fingers. Drinking your soup. Make sure you ask for napkins, unless you want to wipe your mouth on your sleeve. read more

Had an amazing lunch here at Amici's. Great lunch specials, reasonably priced ! Highly recommend their pizza read more

Yummy local pizza place. Pizza is very good but a little pricey. Looking for something different? Try their buffalo chicken pizza. Has a little spice to it along with great flavor. read more