Cancel

Open app

Search

Amy's Hallmark Shop

5.0 (1 review)
Open 10:00 am - 8:00 pm

Services - Amy's Hallmark Shop

Cards and stationery

Gift shops

Amy's Hallmark Shop Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Amy's Hallmark Shop

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Joe C.
1
61
224

8 years ago

Great place. The nicest people work here and they always have an excellent selection of cards and ornaments.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Amy's Hallmark Shop

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Cards & Stationery 8,100 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

East Meets West

East Meets West

4.5
(11 reviews)
$

The store was a feast for the eyes and the senses. Beautiful clothing, interesting objects, and a…read morekind, patient salesperson. I enjoyed walking around the store, and I purchased a gorgeous wraparound colorful skirt. I will visit again soon!

I use to love visiting this place and I sort of still do, only because this store has so many…read moremetaphysical items for spiritual needs. But once again I have an issue with entitled Staten Island white girls who act like they are above serving Latino men. You know, Latin men also have a right to shop at the mall! The gate keeping attitude some of these employees have is shocking. Upon visiting this location yesterday one of the employees, happened to be a caucasian young girl who knew nothing about archangels and sigils. Everytime I'd ask her a question she seemed disgusted and like I was inconveniencing her. I ended up speaking with a young man who assisted me with purchasing dragon's blood incense and he was pleasant during the interaction. I despise Gen Z and their attitude. I don't owe these lil white girls in Staten Island anything. It's not good enough to have a job. Being able to have proper communication with the public is extremely important but to do so you need to put your egos and biases aside, especially in a metaphysical store, where a smorgasbord of spiritual items are provided for various practices. If the female employee is reading this, get over yourself! Your bigotry shines and it's unpleasant in this day and age. Look around you, girl, businesses are shutdown from left to right and workers are losing their jobs. But I guess you don't care, since you think your special. This is another business I will sadly not be visiting. Thank goodness for online shopping, am I right?!

Gift Man

Gift Man

4.3
(52 reviews)
$$

They threaten you if you complain ! Magdalena the owner will threaten police for any problem…read moreapparently. Buyer BEWARE These people lie to your face and in their responses and the service in this place is just plain terrible then if you complain they want to involve police just like any other discriminatory party. Then they edit their comments to erase their mention of cops it's just ridiculous Their shirts are overpriced for their cheap fabric and the selection is no better than anywhere else Be careful if you're a POC (other than Asian) or LGBT cause they really don't seem comfortable and will watch you like a hawk. The workers don't even know how to tell if a bill is real or not they accuse you of it being fake tho just to decline you If you need souvenirs from Brooklyn go elsewhere Support the botanical garden or museum but this place is not the place to go if you're looking for good service, a good selection, or value for your hard earned dollars. You can walk them through the checks on it and they still don't believe you they are clearly off I haven't used any defamatory language or disrespect. I walked her through the checks, showed her the real bill and then she agreed it was indeed fake. Before I had decided her disrespect was not tolerable. The shop was acting in a way that is disrespectful and the staff needs training on what a bill looks like. Further who would counterfeit a 10$ bill ? No one that's who. This place is just trying to cover its tracks after being caught being rude. Now they're threatening to involve police for a real bill these people have nothing better to do than to discriminate indiscriminately. I've posted the exact bill. As I said before, I showed them each parameter of the bill and now they're saying I'm false. They're lying. They're now threatening me. Yes I took the bill after I showed her it was fake and decided I didn't want the magnet and pin for less than 10$. The video footage will show my taking it from her hand in my frustration, saying this was incredibly rude, and walking out. There was nothing sketchy on my end at all They saw my bill and decided it was fake. This business now threatens police action when they're the ones in the wrong. Magdalena should be ashamed of herself for this ridiculousness. Let's involve the police if you want ! They'll have the exact bill the review in the photos. These people are deranged and liars. Avoid them! Send the security footage ! It shows how I walked you through how the bill was real before you accepted it ! The only reason I walked out with my REAL bill is because you accused me of something you can't even verify !

I am visiting brooklyn and so happy to have found this shop with so many different types of…read moresouvenirs and trinkets, some of which are so delightful and humorous. I spent quite a while browsing through everything and ended up buying quite a wide range of things. They stickers they sell are super cute!

Amy's Hallmark Shop - stationery - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...