Angelina's has some notable upsides and a couple downsides. First, I am not a fan of their standard cheese slice. It seems to have too much "flop" and the dough is not very toothsome or crispy. Overall, the slices tend to be oily too. However, Angelina's makes up for this in other areas. Their chicken and pepperoni rolls are not only huge but delicious. Their empanadas are also fantastic. And their burgers are shockingly great! They always cook the beef to the requested temperature. (I like mine medium rare.) The chicken tenders are also really good. Moreover, some of Angelina's specialty slices, like the chicken piccata and the so-called "Pizza from Mars" are creative, if nothing else. The interior is also clean and inviting and the partners who run this restaurant are super kind. It's a great place in Cold Spring to stop for a quick lunch, or dinner break, but you may want to choose from the menu instead of just grabbing a slice. read more

As promised, posting a 5-star review following the implementation of one of my constructive suggestions (tasteful background music to make it a more relaxing dine-in dinner experience). The food was up to the usual high standard and our waiter was attentive and full of small-town-USA friendly service. 100% sure we'll be back in the near future. read more

3.5 stars. We stopped by here for a late lunch. The place looks clean and the service was great. Our waiter were polite. The margherita pizza that we ordered were just decent but the gluten free pizza here were great! If you happen to live in the area, it's worth trying. read more

Angelina's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cold Spring, New York

We had really satisfying dinner at Angelina's during our recent stay in Cold Spring. It was Monday night and many businesses in town were closed. I found Angelina's through yelp and after reading positive reviews, we walked from our bed and breakfast on main st. We ordered spicy chicken tortilla soup, chicken frances (lemon chicken) which came with a nice portion of pasta (we got angel hair pasta) coated in simple marinara sauce, and hamburger with sweet potato fries. Our order also came with a nice warm basket of house bread and simple salad. Portion was generous and the food was excellent! Especially chicken frances was impressive. Chicken was super tender and moist and the lemon sauce was truly lemony without being too sour. The burger was also fresh with meaty patty and served on kaiser roll(?) instead of typical burger bun. The place is a casual spot with a good amount of indoor sitting area, away from the main street. We actually liked that it was somewhat off the beaten path and not on super touristy main street. Clean, hip decor without being pretentious. Overall, really enjoyed our food here and appreciated friendly service from the staff as well as clean environment. They are doing great job with covid restrictions (social distancing, staff wearing masks and gloves.) The price point is reasonable and we will not hesitate to dine here again next time we are in town! read more

See all

Got a buffalo slice and was disappointed. Had NO flavor what so ever. Great crispy pizza for sure but sauce had zero flavor so i was disappointed. Inside was super cute though and staff was friendly. read more

Good service at this clean neighborhood pizzeria joint. Place is small but they crank out this crispy pizza with great toppings. I also saw other diners eating fried chicken and juicy large hamburgers with fresh tomatoes. read more

My kids are moving to Cold Spring g and my Son-in-Law and I were doing some pre work on the house and needed dinner. I saw that Angelina's had a good looking Sicilian pie, so we ordered one. Cheese only because that is the true barometer of a good pie. Wonderful crust. At least 1.25" thick. I nice sauce and good cheese. A very strong pie for sure. Nice people running the place as well. They show some vegan options which is great so we can feed everyone when we come visit in the future. read more

Pizza is a lil heavy on the cheese n light on the char- which makes it soft with no crunch. Sauce is very good. I'd prefer it baked a lil more but it's not a bad slice at all. For some, it might just be the perfect slice- especially if you like it cheesy n a lil pillowy. Large selection, clean, nice staff- good spot. read more

The food is always good and the owners really care about their customers. They have yummy desserts too!!!

Ask them for a tour of their kitchen before you eat anything there. This place is filthy dirty, using all frozen ingredients, employees/owner don't care for food safety at all, Dept of Health has pages and pages worth of health code violations. read more

Stopped here twice on a motorcycle trip. Pizza was excellent! People were very nice. Iit is a small pizza place.

Best pizza place in the hudson valley, looks like a hole in the wall, but has good pizza. They rotate pizzas every day with a few staples but almost every pie is good, and they do it by the slice so you can try a few. read more

Best local pizza in my opinion. The only one that has a different approach from all the other pizza shops, which are all fine, they just all taste the same. read more

Super friendly service, the waitress was really patient with us and our "animated" 3 month old. M-Th you can get 2 pies for $20. The pizza is pretty good with a decent amount of cheese and tangy sauce. The crust is just right and crispy. read more

Angelina's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Cold Spring, New York

It's a shame for all of us locals who remember the original ANGELINAS pizza This place restaurant is under new owners who now own SANTOROS. Listen the inexpensive cheese coagulates before the slice gets cold. Staff is ran by a bunch of Young people who can care less about quality control. Shame this place used to be a good quick bite. You should consider cutting your prices in half because you don't even mesure up to a $1 slice in NYC read more

Although this is basically a pizza place, they took very good care of me with my gluten free and dairy free needs. They do have a full menu to choose from, even for me. And the staff could not have been nicer. So thank you. And the veggies were great! read more

Angelina's Restaurant & Pizzeria - gluten free shrimp scampi - Pizza Near Me - Cold Spring, New York

See all

Glad I read the reviews and tried this place because the pizza was very good! All fresh ingredients and it makes a big difference in the taste! Service was great too. We had the "Cold Spring Salad" which consists of "crisp apples over mixed greens, fresh cranberries, mandarin, and goat cheese" with Raspberry Vinaigrette dressing and it was so yummy! We couldn't decide on which pizza to get so we got half "Pizza from Mars" (Mascarpone, Truffle Oil, Sun Dried Tomato, Spinach & Mushroom) and half "Sorgente Fredda Pizza" (Grilled Chicken, Broccoli Rabe and Mozzarella). LOVED IT!!!! I love sun dried tomatoes and they were soooooo good! Definitely will be back! read more

Love the pizza, definitely the best anywhere close to Edgewater. The Italian sub and the calzones are really good as well.

Great local spot with pretty good pizza, and always some good beers on tap. If you don't want pizza they have some great salads but my favorite is their Meatball Parmesan, really, really good ! Great place to go with some buddies or with the fam. Very friendly and attentive staff. read more

Best place!! The food is always delicious and fairly priced. It's so nice that they are opened during the stressful time. Thanks for always serving the community! read more

The pizza at Angelina's is fantastic. Creative signature slices like their MARS with truffle oil, sun dried tomatoes, and mushrooms to their Taco slice fully loaded with taco fixings, to their classic standards like bacon chicken ranch and meat lover's. My mouth is watering just thinking about it. They take their specialty slices to the next level. You stumble upon this gem of a lunch or dinner spot in Cold Spring and you are one of the lucky ones. Kamal, the owner, is super friendly, and clearly loves classic rock as the walls are adorned with framed Beatles and Hendrix posters. Staff is nice, attentive, and helpful. This is my favorite pizza in the entire Hudson Valley. Bar none. read more

Unexpected surprise. The place does not look like much from the outside, but if you are in a neighborhood do drop in, you won't be disappointed. Food is freshly prepared. Soup pasta fagiole was outragious! Cesar salad was nice and fresh. Pizza was fine, but not as good as the one Pizzeria Posto in Rhinebeck. Service was friendly. Prices are very reasonable....and they have 2 beers on tap, as well as whine and bottled beer. read more

Fact: I am already self-conscious about my body. Fact: I chose to go to your establishment due to weather. I could have gone elsewhere, but I chose to go local. Fact: One of your employees referred to me as the "one with the girls", meaning my chest. I ask that your employees go to sensitivity and sexual harassment courses. Your employees are not all bad, I just will skip you from now on and not go local. If I could give 0 stars, I would but the other employees don't deserve that. read more

Very disappointed in their takeout food. We have been trying them out for a few weekends over the winter as a result of local comments about the quality and value. Last week my husband and I ordered a few slices of "specialty pizza" and an eggplant hero and the slices came with the wrong toppings and very little toppings for the extra $$. The eggplant hero was so bad we threw it out. Before posting here, I sent the restaurant an email from their site explaining the situation and asking for a refund. No response. Well, no more Angelina's . We have a lot of wonderful choices in our area, Angelina's is not one of them. read more

Best Vegan Pizza Ever!!! - I have had a lot of vegan pizza but this one is my favorite, hands down. We ordered the Grandma pizza. Well of course the pizza itself without cheese is fabulous and I usually order it without cheese when I eat pizza unless vegan is available. The crust was thin but not too thin so it flops. It was crunchy yet not dry. The tomato sauce and spices were delicious. I don't like when the (Vegan) cheese overwhelms the pizza and this did not disappoint. It was the perfect amount , like you would get in Italy. So whether you are lactose intolerant, vegan, or just want to cut out dairy for heath concerns, I highly recommend Angelina's. read more

A very good restaurant and pizzeria located in the Foodtown shopping plaza in Cold Spring. I will admit, I was a little skeptical of this restaurant for the longest time. It doesn't look like much, and my general experiences with pizzerias-in-shopping-complexes haven't always been positive. But given the very positive reviews that Angelina's has long received on Yelp, I swallowed my pride and placed a takeout order here one evening when I didn't feel like cooking. Boy, was it worth it. I walked in on a Thursday - you wouldn't think that the place would be busy on that day, but there were a fair number of people occupying the small number of booths that constitute the dining space at Angelina's. The owner manning the counter was a friendly guy and told me that my order would be ready in 15 minutes. When I returned, my food was ready, waiting and piping hot. The owner made sure I had a takeout menu - I did - and the price for my meal was quite reasonable. I ordered penne ala vodka, and it came with a nice side salad and a very large piece of bread. The penne ala vodka was quite good, and Angelina's indeed lives up to its reputation as a quality place to order some terrific food. The dish was flavorful and there were plenty of leftovers, all of which tasted even better the next day. Angelina's also serves up a variety of tasty, appealing dishes in addition to their highly successful penne ala vodka. This tiny little restaurant smelled great, and the odors of food clung to my coat in a good way after I left the restaurant. Also, the patrons who were there on that Thursday all seemed to be enjoying their meals. An older gentleman was eating a bowl of pasta e fagioli soup that looked scrumptious. Angelina's is definitely worth checking out. Cheaper than some of Cold Spring's more upscale places, Angelina's is a nice place to get a casual, high quality meal at a very low cost. read more

We recently moved back to Cold Spring after several years on the West coast, to find...surprise! ANGELINA'S! I think it's as good as, if not better than, any pizza I've had outside of Brooklyn. For real. Their pasta is good too, although it's a bit steep and sometimes too oily for my tastes. If you go, bring a bottle of wine and kick back in a booth. Or, order to go and write some poetry in the "waiting for take out" book by the register. You can even order from their online interactive menu, it's super easy. My only complaint is that $2.50 per topping is a lot for a family on a budget. It adds up, especially when your wife prefers Spinach-Garlic-Fresh Tomatoes on her pizza, it's over twenty bucks. Can't do that all the time. But when you get that pizza craving... ANGELINA'S!!! read more

Over-rated. Pasta was not homemade, pizza was ok but not special, salad was reasonable price but not special. Coffee was like water. read more

Angelina's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Cold Spring, New York

Finally got the chance to go to Angelina's on my day off. What really brought me in that day was the picture of their garlic knots . When we got there we were greeted by the owner , Kamel and a basket of knots on the house . We love his other two locations Beacon Bread Company & Tito's Taqueria . I ordered a plain slice , to get a feel of the place . Of course it was DELISHHHH. My boyfriend had a BACON EGG & CHESSE SLICE . Thats right , a bacon egg and cheese slice lol. You know I had a bite or two of that. Very yummy . The little one loved her plain slice as well as a beautiful chocolate cupcake that of course she ate all the icing off first. (On the house AGAIN) . Definitely going back for a slice when I'm in cold spring again. read more

On my very first visit to Cold Spring I was taken to Angelina's. That was about four years ago and I've been going back ever since. Ultra clean, friendly and cozy, Angelina's serves up excellent Italian fare at a surprisingly low price for the quality. Also, the pasta portions are huge. If I order their pasta I usually split it with my dining partner and get an appetizer for variety. I recommend Pizza From Mars: Mascarpone cheese, truffle oil, spinach, mushrooms and sun dried tomatoes. Yum. read more

I stopped by Angelina's and had them make me a half margarita and half pineapple pizza and it was excellent. The owner came out and greeted us and he was such a warm and friendly guy. The young girl behind the counter was an absolute pleasure to talk to. The pizza was fantastic. I know people brag about NYC pizza, but Angelina's is not only better...but friendlier. I KNOW I'll be back. read more

Angelina's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Cold Spring, New York

The best Italian restaurant in Westchester. The Service is very good. We love Ray! The seafood pasta is just wonderful! They have the best pizza too! read more

Food is awesome. We got the lunch special. The spicy chicken tortilla soup was amazing, the pizza was above average, and the chicken roll was good. Will definitely come back when I hike around the area. read more

Angelina's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Spicy chicken tortilla (amazing) - Pizza Near Me - Cold Spring, New York

Absolutely outstanding! Visiting from Southern California and found this wonderful gem on Yelp. The food was delicious and only surpassed by the excellent service from Lauren and the friendly staff including the terrific Manager, Robbie. Truly a fantastic dinner and enjoyable total experience. read more

See all

We had such a lovely meal here! Were traveling thru Hudson River Valley and were starving after spending a day touristing. Shared soup, and 2 entrees - everything was delightful. Pasta from Mars is ridiculously rich & good treat. The server was great, and we loved the atmosphere & art - kinda surprising inside for a little mall. If I lived nearby, I'd be there often! read more

Went here for pizza with my husband and Angelina's delivered. The fresh mozzarella and plain slices we're good. The barbecue chicken slice had real barbecue sauce which was a nice surprise. The staff were friendly and the place was very clean. Also, the fact that there is parking is a huge plus give how busy Main Street can get. II would eat here again and try the Pizza from Mars or another pasta dish. read more

We've been eating at Angelina's since 2010 on our way to hike the nearby mountains. We've always enjoy the cool relaxed vibe & the good food here. They have craft beer - doc's cider!!! lagunitas IPA!! and Feltiman's Ginger Beer for minors. Their pizza has paper thin crust which turns crispy when heated. I've eaten eggplants with marinara & basil, mushroom with spinach & cheese, and my bf BBQ chicken and we were very satisfied with the quality of food, the service of friendly & prompt teenage waiter, and the price: 4 pizza & ginger beer rings up to $16. Can't beat it! On a crisp October Sunday afternoon we were in & out in less than 30 min with full stomach & satisfied taste palette. I highly recommend this place to anyone grabbing a quick bite! read more

Came here after doing the popular breakneck ridge hike and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the restaurant. Though Angelina's is ostensibly a Pizzeria, the menu offers plenty of healthy options you can order if you're somehow not in the mood for pizza. I ordered the "Pizza from Mars" and I can't recommend it enough. The combination of the truffle oil, spinach and sun-dried tomatoes work beautifully with the creamy mascarpone cheese. I'm glad I ordered the personal pizza, but you can also get individual slices and try a few more varieties. I must also mention that the interior ambiance of the restaurant is a cut above your standard local pizzerias. Though small, Angelina's makes up for the lack of space by having a quiet, quaint charm accompanied by an eclectic, soothing soundtrack always kept at a comfortable volume. read more

What a surprise! We detoured on our way back to the city and yelped this place as a food stop-over in Coldspring. No regrets here, savory thin crust and quality ingredients ensure that this won't be our last visit. Clean restroom in the back, cool Beatles framed art on the walls, cushioned booth seats, and friendly staff. read more

I had Sorgente Fredda Pizza after 7 hour hike in Breakneck Ridge. I chose this place because this place had the highest Yelp rating in Cold Spring. The pizza was amazing - I was able to taste the sauce, cheese, and all the little ingredients on the pizza. The pizza had a good balance of texture between crust and rest of the pie. In addition, they had some amazing root beer from Sprecher. I've never had it until I was at this place, and I would recommend it to anyone who's a fan of a good root beer. read more