A very solid NY style pizza. Not too thin, not too thick, right in the sweet spot. Sauce was tasty and the folks were very friendly. They have lots of dinner and sandwich options also read more

Marlo Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Marlboro, New York

Been going there for a very long time...pizza is excellent and the same exact way everytime..

To far away I'm on the other side of Marlboro but food has always always has been good

Absolutely delicious!!! The staff are always smiling!!! Great family atmosphere! (Super clean too) The best pasta ever!!! Everything on the menu is wonderful! read more

The food is amazing. The pizza is fresh and delicious! I have had their shrimp penne pasta and it was too good. The pizza slices are huge and the pasta portions are big as well and it come with salad and bread which many places do not do. I would definitely stop by at this family owned pizza shop that cooks with integrity and makes food like they're cooking for their own family. 10 stars! read more

oh boy where do I begin. this place holds a special place in my heart. from the savory, cheesy, perfectly cooked pizza to the delicious, well cooked, and incredible taste of famous dishes like the penne vodka and chicken parm. everything about this place is just perfect. the service is incredible; the workers genuinely have passion for the establishment and it shows through their kindness and humility. Marlo's pizzeria, perfection is an understatement. thank you for changing my life read more

We decided to give Marlo a try for takeout since the two other pizzerias we usually frequent in town were both closed. Let's start with the pasta fagiole - this one one of the worst tasting "soups" I've ever tasted. The broth is completely sour and tastes like tomato sauce out of a can. Even canned pasta fagiole is much better! For $20 the mixed seafood linguine was pretty awful - a 1 out of 5 at most. All of the seafood was gummy and overcooked; and again, the same "canned sauce" was used as for the broth mentioned above. The only reason I give this a 1 is that my dog ate some of the shrimp and pasta. The pizza was mediocre with very little toppings. Plus it was a gummy rubbery pancake when we brought it home, fresh out of their oven. We needed to cook it for another 10-12 min for 350 to crisp it up. From their oven to ours!! We are consumers and paid a fair amount of money for quality food so there's no reason we need to bring it home and need to doctor it. The leftover soup and seafood linguine is still in my fridge. Nobody feels like having it and I don't feel like spending time on it to make it better. The other 2 pizzerias we frequent are very similar in price and their food is always delicious with huge portions, fresh seafood and crispy pizza. You would expect comparable quality. We are very disappointed in Marlo, considering it was for our daughter's 3rd birthday party. Next time competition is closed, we rather make frozen pizza and spaghetti with Ragu from the pantry! read more

We order from here all the time. Never any problems. Food is delicious. Love Love Love the Pizza. The Caesar salad is the only place to order it from around here read more

I was a bit skeptical at first about what to expect but I am impressed! $16 for Penne ala vodka with chicken, comes with bread and a salad. Good portion, great taste. The girls at the counter were super nice too. Definitely recommend. read more

Marlo Pizzeria - Penne Ala Vodka with chicken! - Pizza Near Me - Marlboro, New York

This is our fourth and last try. We always did take out. Pizza is just ok, they put very little of additional toppings you pay extra for, still have to put it in the oven bc it's too soft on the bottom every time. Seafood spaghetti is a disaster, very thick sauce just like opening the can of tomato paste, definitely using frozen seafood and not to mention the bean soup- total disgrace. So sour you can't swallow it. They put so much disproportionate amount of saggy pasta. 80% of the soup is pasta not beans. We only went there because the competition was closed but from now on - no way!!! Please owners of the place, do us a favor, sample the food from other local pizzerias and then you'll find out what people are talking about! Ruined our food portion of birthday! read more

BEST PIZZA I'VE EVER HAD! I've been a huge fan of Marlo's Pizzeria for 10 years now. They are by far the best pizzeria in the area. We've had plenty of different items but my all time favorite is their Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza. Everything is always so fresh and amazing and the people are always very nice. Great people, great food. Don't forget to add garlic knots to your order, they are never a let down! read more

Worst customer service ever. I waited at the counter and they ignored me... eventually when I got someone's attention, they were rude and they cut me off while I was placing my order several times. As if this wasn't enough, the pizza tasted bland and the sauce was like ketchup. Considering how many options their is in Marlboro, I would pass on Marlo's. read more

Chicken Scarpariello, my favorite dish ever, unfortunately when I opened up my dish, it was two thin chicken "tenders" (not even cutlets) and maybe 3 slices of sausage for $17.95. Don't get me wrong it tasted amazing, but when you need to have another dinner 3 hours later.....Just sayin...... read more

Their food is consistently the best!I have ordered party trays of chicken parm and eggplant parm and everyone raves how delicious. The chicken is plump and moist and the eggplant isn't fried and greasy like most places. Excellent! read more

This place is amazing, I order from here at least once a week, the margarita pizza is the best I've ever had!

Wow never had pizza with so little sauce, wow never had pizza with so little sauce. So they won't let me post until I say more, well I have nothing more to say. read more

Middle of lunch time and the joint is deserted. Ordered two pepperoni slices. They are very large, hot and greasy... just the way I like my pizza. Five stars for the pizza. Not much in the way of decor or ambience. They could use s serious update. Looks clean but very worn and tired looking. Very weak customer service. I was served quickly, but silently. read more

Ordered pizza and ziti. Both made us sick. Taste was bland as well. Sorry, but won't be back.

I think those previous negative reviews were bogus competitors or people being jerks. This is a nice family owned business and the food is awesome. Not crowded because it does almost 100% take out. This location is tough and many restaurants go oob next door but this one is great food and good service! Support your local business people read more

We're lucky to have so many great places to eat in Marlborough....and this is one of them! Excellent thin-crust pizza! Tastes fantastic...definitely give this little shop of pizza a try! Fil read more

Great pizza, great chicken parm, too. I've tried other places in Marlboro and Highland and Marlo's is by far the best. The Buffalo Chicken pizza with blue cheese sauce on the side is amazing. read more

Consistently great meals and pizza. Food is much better than you'd assume just looking at the place. Dinners can reach the quality of that of a fancy restaurant, but you can go in a shirt and jeans (and it is most definitely a shirt and jeans kind of place). Go more than a few times and the folks who run it will know what you're going to order before you even sit down (personal experience). Recommended if you're in the area and don't want to spend too much money. If you're going for pizza, go for a pie, not slices - slices can sit out pretty long. read more

Fantastic. Just ordered first time from them and food is delicious and arrived piping hot. Job well done. I will be ordering from you again. Thank you! read more

I ordered pizza with in 15 minutes was there to pick it up ice cold terrible I think they sold me old pizza they had at the counter. Also there wings where the worst I ever had. read more

Had dinner this week, ordered the Chicken Francese, which was very fresh, tender, a little bit too much lemon for my taste, but still delicious. It came with a large garden salad, nicely done, side of pasta, and bread. Overall a great experience, will be back to try more dishes. read more

Only giving it a four because pizza is not my fav from here but their food is consistent and fresh. The wings are always perfect, just the right amount of crisp. The chicken fingers with fries is a great deal for kids $7. Can't go wrong. They know what they're doing here. read more

MMMMM...Veal Francese is sooo good. Everything is consistently fresh and taste superb.