Tried the Penne Vodka pizza slice from Sal's Pizzeria in Fishkill in between meetings my mom and I had and wow... I was skeptical at first because I'm very picky when it comes to pizza, but this slice was absolutely delicious. The crust was crisp, the vodka sauce had great flavor, and the penne on top made it such a fun and satisfying twist on a classic slice. Definitely exceeded my expectations and I'd order it again! Our waitress was really sweet and attentive. The restaurant was had a nice rustic vibe. read more

Close to lunch time; hot soup seemed the best bet at 28° and gusty. Tried the chicken noodle soup, it hit the spot. There's table service, the dining room has a pleasant ambience, there's more than just pizza here. When the weather is nice, you can eat al fresco at one of the many tables. More than sufficient free parking. read more

See all

My wife and I were in town (from South Carolina) for my brother's retirement. Sal's was close to our hotel so we stopped in for a NY style pizza. I was a little skeptical at first when the pizza arrived because the crust seemed a little thick for true NY style pizza. But...it was delicious! The crust was light and crispy. The (sliced) meatballs were some of the best I've ever tasted. I will go back for a meatball sub just to get some more of those delicious meatballs. Our hostess/server Nicole S. was great! Give that girl a raise! I highly recommend Sal's!' read more

Sal's Pizza & Pasta - Half cheese/half sliced meatballs. - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

ordered 2 pepperoni slices was charged for 3. I picked up my slices and the pepperoni fell off right away. they just took two plain slices and threw pepperoni on them and they clearly didnt leave it long enough to let the pepperoni bake on to the pizza. never going there again read more

What a spot! My go to when looking to treat my family. Remember when pizza was affordable....? Them days are over but I can't fault Sal's for the prices - they are on par for the area. What's important is the food is top notch. Whether sitting in the dining area, hanging at the bar, or just grabbing to go, you'll not be disappointed. The ambiance is super chill and the staff is over the top friendly. I've never seen a grumpy face in there which is really refreshing. And guess what!?! They deliver on time every time. Gotta give credit where credit is due - I've been frequenting this place for years and there is a reason why! But OH, I miss the day of a dollar slice.... Lost a star due to my general disdain of pizza price inflation. Sorry Sal's! It ain't your fault! FJB read more

Sal's Pizza & Pasta - LG plain - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

We haven't been here in a long time, now I understand why, they are not the best.. they are big slices that's for sure. I've had better. But also I've had worse. The hostess is very sweet. read more

most delicious eggplant parmigiana I've ever eaten! Their red sauce is perfect - texture, seasoning, consistency, and there was lots of "pulley" mozzarella cheese throughout . It was a large portion and couldn't finish all of it but brought the leftovers home. (which were just as delicious warmed up two days later!) The owner, who was our server was absolutely lovely and showed such kindness and patience to our table of "seniors" with some of us having health issues that she happily and compassionately accommodated. We will most definitely go back read more

Best pizza in the area. Take out, delivery, or dine in are all fantastic. Plenty of seating for dine in and the service is great. Would highly recommend. read more

Lots of food at a reasonable price. When you walk in, they tell you to seat yourself. That being said , a lot of the tables were dirty or had crumbs. After we found a clean table and sat down, there was nothing but positives that kept occurring. They serve warm bread as an appetizer and keep bringing out more. They accommodated my dairy allergy by helping me customize a pasta dish which came with a salad. At first, I was disappointed because the pasta dish looked small but the bowl was deep so the portions were actually quite large. The presentation wasn't exactly the prettiest but once you get past that the food is really quite good. read more

Sal's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

Sal's is more a 3.5 stars as they do a pretty good job overall, our meal was solid especially the Antipasto, it was extremely well done. The pizza with the toppings we ordered was good, just not exceptional but by no means was it below average, we just happen to frequent some very good pizza houses in our area and elsewhere. Still the quality is good, the service was above average, the waitstaff was very friendly and accommodating. Wouldn't hesitate to return, if I were looking for a quick in-and-out at a reasonable price. read more

Sal's Pizza & Pasta - Cheese pizza, with peppers, mushrooms and onions - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

This place is my favorite place to go when I'm in town. Everything was piping hot and ready to go when I picked it up.

This review is based solely on there wings. The pizza here is decent. Ordered 2 orders of wings to be delivered. Expensive for 8 wings per order. I opened them up and was immediately upset. I probably should have called back at this point and demanded that they bring new orders but I was working and don't have time so I ate what I could. They are what you call nickel wings. Definitely not worth it at that amount and price. Not only were they nickel wings but they were so over cooked that they were inedible. Out of the two orders I was able to eat only 12 of them. They were by far the worst wings I have ever had in my life and I eat wings a lot. It was so disappointing. See the pictures for yourself. One of the wings in the order was literally just bone. I hate giving bad review but this couldn't go ignored. Never order wings here. read more

See all

The food is amazing! I got the rigatoni a la vodka and the garlic knots! The pizza and bread is also great. The service was nice too.

Wish I could give 0 starts and a refund. Where do I begin? I ordered and had the worst 2 salads I ever paid for. How much you may ask.... Oh $24 plus. One was a Cobb Salad and the other was a regular garden salad. Horrible.... Also got 2 small cups of soda that were over $4. One would think if the ingredients listed on each salad then that's what you would get. Massive amounts of black and green olives were piled on the bottom. (I purposely chose the salads based on what's listed). The vegetables were just carelessly thrown in there. Look at the pictures. No care, or effort was put into the food. Avocado was not ripe and hard! After the chicken was put on the top of the salad that I saw through a doorway, both were sitting above an open garbage can with the back door to the restaurant open. Flies, bacteria etc. you get my drift. read more

Very unhappy with them. Have ordered in the past via phone and food was good, and large portions. Thought I would save time and order from their website this time, BIG mistake! Food was OK, BUT smaller portions and did not receive the salad that normally comes with a dinner. When I called and asked about it, I was told that when you order online you do not get a salad with the meal. Also, they would not give me a receipt! Last time we will order from there. read more

I think they put the Love in this pie. I've never ordered pizza from Sals Before. I very nearly ordered from Dominos moments earlier; before realizing their absurd topping prices and delivery charge of which the driver receives 0. I just can't get behind a $32Dominos Pizza delivered .9 mi. Thankfully I tapped Sals listing and saw a very tasty looking pie. I called Sals, they were friendly and quickly took my order (a 5 topping Sals special pizza) $19 and change! I held my breath a bit (so to speak) as one does when anticipating the quality of a pizza you've never tried. It was delivered to a hotel, no plates or napkins for a hotel delivery was a little disappointing, I hadn't asked for them but thought perhaps they assume folks in hotels may not be traveling with plates and cutlery. In any case, my goodness the pizza certainly was delicious. Wether you eat this pie off a plate or a hotel washcloth, it's absolutely and incredible pie esp at the value. The crust was perfect, not soggy, not soft, not burnt, proper. Fellow travelers, just letting ya know... The pie we received is proper to say the least. Ask for Napkins n plates if you need them and support your neighborhood pizza shop. read more

Sal's Pizza & Pasta - A delightful crust. - Pizza Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Great place to eat ! Pizza is great , service warm and friendly. Just had an amazing Meatball parmigiana sub from Sal's yesterday! You must try this place ! read more

The owner and staff are very friendly. Servers are really attentive and pleasant. I like the chicken parm wedge with vodka sauce instead of the regular sauce and they always accommodate my request. The extra large pizza is a great value and feeds a lot of people. They also have a really good Italian combo and the specialty slices are really really awesome. I enjoy every single visit to Sal's and I will continue to support this local business at both Fishkill and the beacon location. Thank you for always making me feel welcomed and taking the time to engage your customers in Pleasant conversation and great service. Sincerely ... Gene Trifilo read more

Sadly the quality of the food has taken a turn for the worst. Honey, who shrunk the sandwiches The chicken was cut thin and over breaded , camouflaged in a little sauce and cheese. Moving on read more

Food was not bad and enjoyed the outdoor seating in the Fishkill Village. Was served good sized portions and had leftovers for the dog and self read more

Daughter picked up pizza last night (small with chicken) and when she brought it in and I opened the box, I was appalled! There was sauce all over the top of the pizza - ON TOP of the cheese and chicken. That might not have been so disgusting IF they'd put it back in the oven to warm and thicken the sauce, but they didn't. It's like they forgot to put the sauce on before the cheese and topping and added it later thinking nobody would notice. It was Ragu right out of the jar! On top of that, crust was consistency of frozen pizza!! More like eating the box than a good piece of pizza! We each managed to eat 1 piece before throwing the rest in the trash - $20 from this month's social security check wasted! I used to work in a pizzeria - a 5 star pizzeria in Albany and that would have become food for the staff there! That plus the shitty attitude from the kid I spoke to makes this our 1st and last pizza from Sal's! read more

Delicious! We just had take out from Sals and we've dined in there before as well and ordered pizza multiple times. This is our go to Italian restaurant. The special margarita pizza is always delicious. Tonight I had Sal's special veal which was amazing! We're excited to order again soon!! read more

I called for pricing and eventually was going to buy instead the guy said our pricing is on the website.. that type of answer looses you a customer read more

Went there tonight for take out. When I got home to eat the pasta was bad. A wast of 40.00. Won't be back

Drove from Poughkeepsie to Fishkill to get their pizza so good We ordered the Sals special and they don't skimp on the toppings

I will never go to Sal's again. The delivery driver is apparently incapable of reading the number next to my door and gave the order to my neighbor. Then the manager said she would call back (which was a half hour later) and was defensive and rude for THEIR mistake. Guess what Sal's? I ordered from you guys all the time, but there's too many places to put up with rude service. Keep it. The female manager should be fired. read more

Consistently good food! Sal's II in Fishkill is our go-to place for pizza which says a lot because they don't deliver to where we are in Beacon so we have to pick it up.* A family favorite is their Chicken Marsala Pizza but we also love their salads and sandwiches. They also have the largest variety of ready to heat slices than anywhere else in the area. Tonight's garlic knots were spot-on, the plain pizza had the perfect ratio of sauce to cheese and yes, the afore mentioned Chicken Marsala pie was the star of the show. *While they do have a location in Beacon that can deliver to us, for whatever the reason it's just not the same. read more

Ugh...pizza was delivered cold....barely any cheese and crust like cardboard...so dissapointed. I had pizza here once and could have sworn it was good. Ordered the zeppoles and their were barely any in the box, no powder and ice cold. Can ANYONE recommend a great Brooklyn style pizzeria around Fishkill or Beacon? And NOT Antonellas....thanks! read more

My husband and I stopped by for dinner last night, not knowing what to expect. When we came in, we were greeted with beautiful music, being played by a young man playing the piano. I had eggplant Parmesan and my husband had veal franchese. Both of our dinners were delicious and huge! We will definitely be back! read more

Everything was really good. The young lady waiting on me and my two dining partners was very gracious and friendly. The fresh pizza the we ordered was very tasty and came out of the oven with a very crispy crust and nice and brown on the bottom. They didn't serve beer/wine, but they allowed us to BYOB/W, which was cool. The vegetable pizza is one of my favorites in the area. It's LOADED with veggies that are pre-sauteed/seasoned and chopped up very finely before being baked on top of the pie. Sals is definitely improving this past year in ambiance, having remodeled the bathrooms, dining area and installing a beautiful patio area just outside. read more

I was there last night and had mussels clams shrimpSquid in a light white wine Marinara sauce it was absolutely delicious I recommend this place highly read more

I get takeout from here often. Tonight I ate in. Simple order. A slice with pepperoni and mushroom and a glass of wine. Pizza cold. Mushrooms raw. Wine turned. Big mistakes read more

I would not recommend Sal's Pizza II to anyone. The way they treat customers is horrible. The pizza is ok but the attitude of the staff is so horrible that anything good I could say has been completely thrown out the window. I would not tell my worst enemy to eat from this establishment. read more

Pizza was excellent. Service was fine, not friendly but not rude. But the fresh pie is fire.

I've been dedicated to Sal's for over 10 years, but over the last 6-8 months it's really dropped off, pizza that's been over cooked and burned, tonight we got dinners delivered, it was cold, asked for same sauce on the pasta as the chicken(not red sauce) never happened, pasta was hard and uncooked, salad dressing spilled all over, fresh tomato and Mozzarella was all melted. Definitely going to explore other options, I understand everyone has a bad day but cold food, and no instructions followed is horrible. read more

Pizza is good, but they don't seem to understand how to heat up a slice to go, hate to pay $4.00 a slice, and have it cold and mushy. Huge disappointment. I usually just pick up a slice and heat it at home, so didn't realize how challenged they were to deal with a hot slice. How had can it be??? read more

Only the delivery boy earns the stars on this one. I called in the order and wanted to pay with my card over the phone. I told the girl to let me know when she was ready and she said she was and I told her not to write it down. I again said let me know when you're ready and she said she was so I gave her my card number and asked her how much it was and she told me to hang on, that she had to go get the ticket. SERIOUSLY?!!!!!! When she got back on the phone I said to her that I told her not to write it down and she said not to worry, that they don't kept the paper. If I get bogus charges on my card I'll know exactly who to turn to. And we didn't like the pizza. Not because of what she pulled, but it really wasn't very good. And the maranara sauce for the mozzarella sticks was really soupy and didn't cling to the sticks. Never going back. read more

I tried them yesterday,(pizza) it was like eating cardboard and ketchup. They also don't have Sicilian pie. I tried them because my normal place was closed for a private party. Also I had a drink at the bar while waiting and it was horrible. Go else where. Save your money or buy frozen. read more

Been looking to try other pizza places in the area, so we stopped in here before going shopping. I remember another pizzeria in this location from many years ago and it was nice to see that they've updated the decor. The place looks new and beautiful and has a nice outdoor seating area. I wasn't looking for a big lunch, so I had the chicken noodle soup and a plain slice. My husband got a nice pasta dish. Everything was delicious, from the salad to the soup, to the bread, to the pizza. Our waitress was also very sweet and attentive, and the best part was the price. $28 for two people! I'm a HUGE fan and will definitely be back! It's not easy to find good, affordable food anymore, so I love them! read more

This place used to be my favorite pizza spot, but has worked it's way to the bottom of the barrel for me. The last few visits I've encountered a few of the female employees to be rude and I don't know how other to put this....lost. they just looked spaced out. This time, I stood at the counter for a good 10 minutes before they took my order to eat in, but they ended up boxing it up as a to go order. No biggie, I reminded them I was eating in, & they gave me an attitude about it. Then as I sat there and ate, everyone in the dining area could here the 2 girls that work behind the counter making fun and complaining about previous customers and people that were calling. I find it unprofessional to b**** about customers in front of your customers. Get it together Sals. read more