Joe is the most knowledgeable, pleasant, patient and honest jeweler around! I came in yesterday to have repaired an older beloved necklace, but when he really examined it, there were several more parts that were cracked and would need rebuilding. It was going to be an expensive repair, which I had not anticipated. He made a suggestion to take all the diamonds out and scrap the rest of the necklace, which has significant gold weight, so I did just that! I picked out a diamond eternity band that I've had my eye at Argyle for about two years and with the high price of gold, I got the new ring in trade plus cash too! I went back again today, after he took out all the diamonds, and he spent nearly an hour with me to make 2 perfectly matching stacking diamond eternity bands to go on either side of the ring that I purchased the day before. And even though he has a very active business to run, we sat and chatted for several more minutes about our daughters and similar circumstances. A very pleasant experience. I can't wait to get my new rings! read more

Their work is top notch! I had them repair a prong in my wedding ring. They were very nice and took their time explaining the process they would use to repair my ring. They also assured me that my ring would be safe, and used an active anti theft system during the day as well as at night. I will definitely use them again! read more

Couldn't recommend more! Have bought several pieces here and have always had a great experience. Recently went in looking to sell some gold, staff is very knowledgeable and offer some of the fairest and honest prices around. I've tried various jewelers closer to home and have not had the same experience elsewhere totally worth the trip. Owners are also a pleasure to work with, I've never felt pressured but rather met with honesty and transparency in both selling and buying. 10/10 would recommend read more

Whether a new purchase or a repair they do 100%. All of their items are well made and stunning.

Very Happy with my 4 transactions at Argyle Jewelers! I needed to raise cash by selling our family Sterling Silver utensils & serving platters. Joseph was friendly, professional, & Honest. The price that I was given for my silver was at least 15% higher than the four other Jewelers and buy & sell shops that I researched! I highly recommend Argyle Jewelers, and I wish to Thank Joseph for helping me out and working with me to accomplish my goal. read more

This jewelry store is amazing. Joe, the owner is like no other. I've been in and out many times. (I'm lucky I haven't been thrown out yet). He's done some custom work for me like melting some of my mom's gold from her jewelry that I could not use but didn't want to part with. He melted the jewelry and made a free formed nugget for me and now I'm ready to distribute this gold nugget to my granddaughters. He's making pendants. His staff by the way is superb. read more

Amazing work done on replacing a bracelet band. Also had watch bands replaced in the past ... truly fine workmanship read more

i had the misfortune to start the New Year losing the diamond from my engagement ring. Needless to say, I was extremely upset. My husband was determined to get me a new diamond or whole new ring. A friend suggested Argyle Jewelers. My husband met with Michelle who was extremely sympathetic to our situation and set out to help in any way she could. She and Joe showed my husband many different options including a beautiful 3 stone ring. At no time did Michell pressure us into making a choice and spent a great deal of time with us trying to make us happy. She was friendly and made us feel welcome from the time we entered the store. We selected the 3 stone ring. It's beautiful beyond my expectations and I couldn't be happier. We would definitely do business with Argyle again. Don't hesitate to shop at Argyle. You'll be happy if you do! read more

Argyle Jewelers - My wedding band after being cleaned and my beautiful 3 stone ring - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

Argyle worked with me over a period of several months to create the dream engagement ring for my fiancee at a price that was within my budget. She wears it every day, and we recently went back to have them make our wedding bands. I won't go anywhere else for expensive jewelry like this, as they did a fantastic job and have earned my trust. read more

Argyle Jewelers - 2 carat Marquise cut diamond engagement ring created by Argyle Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

Took my chain to get shortened in length and job well done for a fair price and all work done on premise, very nice story and friendly helpful staff! Keep up the good work! read more

Choosing Argyle to make my girlfriend's engagement ring turned out to be a no brainer. I chose them based on the reviews and was not let down. I showed Joe some pictures of what I wanted and he made it a reality and at a price that i thought was very fair. He also managed to get it done quickly (without sacrificing quality) so that I had it in time to take on vacation to propose. It's an absolutely beautiful ring and she loves it!! read more

Argyle Jewelers - Joe made this gorgeous engagement ring that my boyfriend gave to me. Of course i said yes! - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

Writing on behalf of my parents, as they don't have Yelp! Our family has been loyal customers of Argyle, particularly Joe and his incredible staff, for over 20 years. We keep coming back time after time because of their ultimate attention to detail and genuine concern for their customers' happiness. We have never been disappointed in any purchase whatsoever. This is definitely the place to go for the ultimate experience! read more

So my husband decided to surprise me and have my chain fixed at Argyle Jewelers in Babylon. It had been broken for about 6-7 months. It broke a few months after I purchased it due to a new puppy. He asked the jeweler to fix the clasp . They were supposed to text my husband with status updates and let him know when he would be able to pick it up. After 5 days, my husband called to find out what the status was for a simple fix and the lady responded that the chain is complete and they are now waiting for it to be polished. Once polishing was complete they would text him so he could pick it up. He received text and picked up the chain and dropped it off at my job and left. I put the necklace on and realized the chain color was not white gold anymore, it was yellow. I called both my husband and the store to let him know we have to go back to talk to someone because the rhodium was polished off the chain . Now this chain cost 16.82 to be fixed, no big deal. We go back and tell the lady "hey we called about this chain being over polished". She got the owner, and let me tell you!! I have never been spoken to by anyone the way this man spoke to us. He was the most unprofessional, disrespectful business owner I have ever encountered. I don't know if he thought he was going to intimidate me by yelling, swearing and raising his voice at me with nothing but anger I. His entire demeanor. He then proceeds to swear on his kids (as if that was going to change the fact that the chain was over polished and everything would just disappear and I would walk away), that he didn't polish the chain. He told me he only polished the tiny clasp and left the rest of the chain as is. So I asked, "do you not clean the jewelry for your customers when you give back the finished product?" This must have really infuriated him as proceeded to slam his hand on his glass counter, screaming and yelling at me (in front of customers mind you. Again, how unprofessional). This was his reaction because I asked what was polished and what wasn't . He then told me that this is normal from wear on the chain and when I pointed out that the clip is the same color as the charm, how is that possible, the wife comes over and tells me she told my husband they would be different color which is not true . She also kept saying that my chain was antique. To redip the chain is was a 65.00 at cost to the consumer (about $20 to merchant before markup). The way this man spoke to me and my husband was absolutely disgusting as if I was trying to get something from him, telling me to trust him and that he swears on his kids. I told him to trust me, why would I lie about my chain being yellow. I have no problem getting the chain redipped for the 65.00 . It's a lousy $65. I would never go to or refer anyone to deal with this business . As we were walking out, he all of a sudden had a "come to Jesus moment" and decided that he would redip the chain at no cost to us. At this point I said no thank you and we walked out. The owner told me to write customer reviews and told us put whatever we feel like on Facebook and anywhere else we want, he's been a jeweler for 35 years so it don't matter. I normally do not write reviews because I do not like to harm one's business, however, people spend a lot of money on jewelry and to be put down, talked to as if you are insignifican shows he isn't interested in local business with the community. For an$20-$25 dip (his cost), he took the route of rudeness and complete unprofessionalism. What goes around comes around!! God doesn't like ugly. All over a few lousy dollars. read more

Argyle jewelers is the best! Joe, Tina, and staff are very knowledgeable and friendly. Their new store is beautiful. We have bought many pieces from them including my engagement ring and our wedding bands. Joe knew exactly what type of ring to pair with my stunning one-of-a-kind engagement ring. Besides the fine jewelry they also sell Pandora and LeStage. If you want a local jeweler who is knowledgable and honest Joe is your guy! You can't compare them to a chain jewelry store like kay. They really are exquisite! read more

This place is down the block from me so I figured I'd give them a try when my girlfriend's birthday came up. She is very difficult to shop for, and the salesperson Tina gave me a ton of recommendations. She explained their return policy in case my girlfriend didn't like the piece and sure enough, I had to return it. No problem, full refund, extremely friendly staff. This place has mostly high end jewelry and they recently got rid of their pandora stuff. They do however have a few really nice affordable pieces and the staff is super helpful. I recommend this place to other clueless guys that haven't quite mastered reading their girlfriend's minds yet. read more

My husband and I highly recommend Argyle Jewelers! Joe is absolutely great to work with and his custom work is fantastic! He took my husbands grandmothers engagement ring and wedding band and turned them into such beautiful vintage modern pieces for me. They are stunning and we are so glad to have a family heirloom that we can continue to pass down for generations. We were also able to purchase wedding gifts for each other there because they have such a large and beautiful selection. If you are looking for a jeweler that provides excellent customer service, custom and quality work, large selection, and stunning jewelry, you will not be let down. We are so glad we chose to work with Argyle Jewelers throughout our wedding! Definitely stress free and not let down! We will certainly be back for future pieces! The staff is wonderful to work with and Joe takes pride in his work. Argyle jewelers will exceeded your expectations! read more

See all

the watchband we bought 2 months ago broke so I went with my husband to get another one the salesperson did not consider a refund or discount. the new band cost $10 more than the first one. when I asked for a receipt I was told receipts are not given for watchbands. I insisted and was given one. on leaving we were waiting to be buzzed out. when I asked to be buzzed out the salesperson spoke rudely. this was an extremely unpleasant experience read more

Stopped into Argyle Jewelers after researching places with positive reviews for jewelry repair. My boyfriend recently proposed to me with his mother's sapphire and diamond ring. It needed to be resized and cleaned up a bit and after reading so many positive reviews, I thought I'd give Argyle a try. I'm so happy that I did!!!! I called ahead of time to make sure that I didn't need an appointment to for resizing. Unfortunately, due to horrible traffic, I ended up arriving 10 minutes before closing on Mother's Day weekend. They still saw me and met with me. They consulted sizing, re-plating, and were so hospitable. They didn't rush me out the door at all! My ring was done 1.5 business days later and it didn't even look like the same ring!!! I was amazed! They told me that the re-plating would make it look different but when I picked it up I was stunned!!!! I'm over the moon with their work and so happy that I chose them! I will definitely be back and will recommend them to everyone I know! Thank you! read more

Argyle Jewelers - Stunning!!! Doesn't even look like the same ring!!!! Thank you! :) - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

Surprise, surprise. I am a bit of a klutz. Sometimes I fall down stairs, sometimes I step on things I shouldn't, and occasionally, my wild Italian "explaining hands" get caught in my necklaces as I speak. In fact, such a thing has happened twice in the past year. Argyle jewelers has fixed my jewelry with no funny questions asked (though I assume I would get a chuckle) and no nonsense. They're pretty speedy as well. We've also gotten watches sized and a few other small repairs done for a fair price. The store is safe, clean and the jewlery that is sold behind the counter is not over the top in looks. I haven't purchased anything however I would consider it as their selection is classy, not gaudy. Thanks for remedying my enthusiastic, spazzy mistakes with my expensive jewelry Argyle. read more

Special thankyou to Joe and Michelle at Argyle Jewelers for creating a special ring for my wife .They exceeded my expectations in designing a beautiful diamond ring .Thank you Michelle for the extra effort to have the ring completed on time. read more

I stopped here on a Friday afternoon with my girlfriend because they are a local shop that sells Pandora bracelets & charms. They honor Pandora promotions too which is awesome. I bought a bracelet and charm for my sister and I bought myself an extra charm, my girlfriend gave me a little money because she got the leather bracelet that came free with the promotion. I love their pandora selection, the clerk was pretty nice, she told us the store would clean our bracelets for free if we came in (which is what most Pandora retailers do). There were a few minor dislikes even though I would come here again which is why I'm giving four stars instead of five. My first dislike was the bracelet packaging. I'm not sure if they had the Pandora pouches that the regular retailers have but they packaged my sister's bracelet in a small box. So I had to tell my sister that if she went to buy more charms to make sure she got herself a pouch. My second dislike was that even though the clerk we dealt with was pretty nice she did ask me when I was due and I'm not pregnant. I get this question a lot from many people and I'm sorry even if I was pregnant this question is unacceptable. A woman can be pregnant, just fat, have stomach issues or worse case have a tumor so asking if she's pregnant and when she's due is insensitive. I don't think the clerk we dealt with meant any harm, my girlfriend had her son with her so she probably just assumed I wasn't far behind on the pregnancy band wagon but it's just not a nice question to ask. Usually I don't go back to a business after they ask me that but I will make an exception because this jewelry store is local and I did like them for the most part. read more

Joe and Tina are the husband and wife who own Argyle Jewelers...they are friendly, trustworthy and very accommodating to their customer's needs. I have had several custom pieces made there...really beautiful. They are there to help with repairs whenever you need them. This is the only jeweler I would ever go to. read more

I'm obsessed with them now. I first went in there in December of 2019 for a Christmas gift for my mother in law. I bought her gold earrings which she wears all the time now. I also inquired about having my engagement ring (purchased in 3/2012) fixed because it was missing a diamond. I decided to wait until after the holidays. Then my bday came around 7/5 so I decided to purchase a pair of earrings. Joann was was so helpful and she showed me all the earrings that they had available for my budget and I also had my rings fixed. My rings look like they are brand now!!! I'm so obsessed with their helpfulness, their workmanship and their collection. Thank you again for your help! Can't wait to go back and purchase more jewelry for myself lol read more

Argyle Jewelers - My "brand new" engagement and wedding ring that they fixed and polished - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

I can't say enough how amazing my recent experience of buying an engagement ring from Joe was. I went in person on a Saturday and talked with Joe about the style I was looking for - I showed him some pictures (oval diamond, rose gold band) and discussed my budget which he respected and stayed within it. He was able to come back with 2 diamonds (one nearly flawless and another just slightly bigger but with some discoloration) I went with the smaller, nearly flawless diamond and he built the setting from scratch (4 "2-prongs compared to 6 single-prongs) and the ring was built much quicker than expected! I proposed this past Friday and my fiance absolutely loves the ring. Thanks again Joe! We will be in for our wedding bands and other jewelery needs! -Ryan Devlin read more

Argyle Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

My boyfriend (fiancé now) purchased the ring from Michelle. He said she was extremely friendly and patient with him and made the whole experience super easy! He used a stone from my grandmothers ring and she showed him a bunch of settings it could work with and didn't pressure him at all. When it came time to get it sized, Michelle helped us yet again. They had it done the same day!! (And I didn't even need to ask!) Such a great experience! read more

Argyle Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

Brought a chain in because the locking link broke. 5 minutes and $5 later I was out the door. Friendly staff and great customer service. read more

This is a trustworthy jewelry business. I have left my diamond ring for repairs and would not hesitate to leave Anything. Their jewelry selection is wonderful from expensive to Brands like Pandora. I have patronized them for many years read more

I recently went to Argyle Jewelers to get a battery changed on my watch. I was helped by the manager Michelle. She was so welcoming and kind, a real gentle spirit. As I was waiting for the battery to be changed, I was looking around and saw a beautiful men's gold chain necklace, that I really liked. Michelle helped me with that as well and was so accommodating and sweet and made the whole buying process a pleasant experience. I also had the privilege to meet Joe the owner, who is a true gentleman. I will definitely be back there for all my jewelry needs. I highly recommend this business to everyone. read more

Words can not truly express my gratitude nor come close to my level of satisfaction with my new engagement ring. Joe took the time to listen to what I was looking for , searched for it, gave me several choices, after which he created an absolute masterpiece from a 25 year old diamond I had sitting in an old broken setting ,to a gorgeous double halo piece of art!!! It is stunning! I feel like a Queen and thankful I asked for his help....he searched...gave me options, made adjustments where needed...and voila....I was shocked and stunned at the beauty of this piece....thank you , thank you.....to Joe and Argyle Jewelers!!! Highly recommend....I honestly felt like my happiness and satisfaction truly mattered to him...very genuine experience.... read more

Argyle Jewelers - Beyond love!!! There is nothing more gratifying then having a jeweler genuinely want to satisfy and boy did Joe deliver!!! - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

Very friendly local jewler. The service is excellent and fast. Its always tough as a guy to go jewlery shopping. They are happy to offer fair, honest advice. You dont feel like you are being sold on anything. They did an amazing job cleaning my watch and bringing it back to life. Ill be going there for anything i need in the future. All of the other positive reviews are completely true. They are "as advertised." read more

Went to Argyle Jewelers looking for ideas for an engagement ring, and walked out with one. The Service I received was beyond fantastic. Way superior than any of the places I went to in smithhaven mall. I was immediately greeted at the door, and asked if I needed any help. I was with a friend who knew someone who worked there so, we asked for them. I was presented with tons of different ring styles most of which I have never heard of. I was also given the option of picking a style from a 1000 page book, and it would be sent to the store. Good thing I brought help! I probably looked at what felt like every ring in the store. In the end I decided on a beautiful ring, which if you were wondering the now Fiance loved as well. This store also has any other type of jewelery you may e looking for. When I am looking for wedding bands this will be the first place I go to. read more

I got my 20 yr old white gold bracelet the fixed buffed and polished at argyle Jewelers...couldn't be happier....you would be surprised what a little "tune-up" could do fora piece of old jewelery...very happy...thanks Argyle Jewelers!! read more

If you are looking for an engagement ring or any jewelry Argyle Jewelers is the best! Joe (owner) is extremely knowledgeable, fair in pricing and has a wide selection. He can custom make any ring you like. And I do not mean pick a diamond and a setting a put them together. They can actually custom create your exact ring! I have a halo setting and wanted the border around main diamond to be wider & he was able to create that for me. Do not wast your time in the diamond district in NYC, as I did initially. All the merchants get their diamonds from the same source and it is not always quality. ALSO, Argyle Jewelers is a 3 minute walk from the LIRR Babylon train station and 15 minute drive from the Deer Park Outlets. Make a fun day out of it! Brigid & Chris Richichi read more

Does phenomenal work, really made me a piece that I truly like. Excellent staff and great customer service. If your looking for custom work or repairs i highly recommend. read more

Argyle Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

I needed my engagement ring resized but 1) I didn't have much time to get it done, and 2) I didn't want to permanently damage the ring. Argyle Jewelers was so amazingly accommodating and knowledgable, I couldn't have asked for a better experience. They ended up placing little balls on the inside of the ring instead of actually cutting out metal from the ring, and they got it done in an hour! My work schedule isn't all that flexible, and I'd never be able to drop off and pick up the ring during their normal business hours. So since they open at 10AM on Wednesdays, and I needed to leave for work by noon, they made sure to help me out! They also informed me that cutting metal out from the ring would make my ring more prone to losing diamonds from the band, so they suggested a different way to resize my ring and for that I am eternally grateful! They're a small mom-and-pop shop that's been there for 20+ years, and it seems like they've built quite a great reputation around town. Don't be alarmed when you have to ring a doorbell to get in or out of the shop. It's a secure place, and I love that especially since I had to leave my beloved ring there for an hour! read more

If I could give them more stars I would! Joe, who owns the business, could not have been more helpful, knowledgable and patient. I had done a fair amount of research on diamonds and engagement rings prior to coming in and was given a real education on diamonds once they were in front of us. We sat with several selections and after letting me tell him what I thought of each, Joe walked me through the pros and cons of each. I felt 100% comfortable spending a large amount of money with Joe and know that I got a very fair deal with exceptional service. read more

I went to Argyle after my engagement ring was stolen. It had been a custom design, created 30 years ago, and I wanted the new ring to closely resemble the original. I had no good photos of it and could find no similar rings online to show him what I wanted it to look like. Joe worked with me through several iterations until I ended up with a wonderful replacement that captures the look of my first ring with an updated flair. I couldn't be happier with it. read more

I went to see Joe a week before Christmas to purchase an engagement ring. He took the time to sit down with me and find the exact ring I was looking for. His kindness and determination to make his customers happy goes above and beyond. The ring came out amazing I couldn't be any happier. Needless to say my girlfriend was even more excited. Argyle Jewelers is the best thank you read more

Argyle Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

I was referred here by a friend as I was looking to reset my engagement ring. I met with Michelle and she showed me various beautiful options that would compliment my wedding band. After discussing it further, Michelle suggested keeping my original setting and simply adding a piece to enhance it. This wasn't even an option that I would have considered but I trusted her professional opinion and experience. Joe walked me through the changes that were needed and reassured me it would turn out great and it sure did. I picked up my ring recently and couldn't be happier. My ring came out gorgeous. Joe's work was exceptional. Such a small addition made a huge impact. I thank Joe, Michelle and the rest of his team for a wonderful and trust worthy experience. I highly recommend Argyle Jewelers whether you're looking for something new or enhancing a current piece in your collection. read more

Argyle Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Babylon, New York

This has been our go to jewelry store for years. They provide great quality jewelry at fair prices. The customer service from Joe (the owner) and his staff is always excellent!! read more