Holy moly this is the real for fish sandwiches here in Bermuda. It is in a neighborhood but it is worth the effort. The bread was so soft and the fish was unbelievably delicious. There were plenty of smiles when my husband ordered the sandwich. You will order what you want on your sandwich and then take it to go. We ate ours on a beautiful beach down the road. read more

Ordered: Fish Sandwich (~$15): fried fish, tartar sauce, coleslaw on raisin bread Small Fries (~$3) Barritt's Ginger Beer (~$2) Aya's take: A few things to know about Bermuda: 1) the fish sandwich is a menu staple and Art Mel's has one of the highest rated ones, 2) the prices are equal in Bermudan or US dollars, and 3) they really don't use Yelp there (only ~10 businesses have a Yelp page!). This is my favorite Fish Sandwich I had during my whole trip. The fried fish was super fresh and light, the coleslaw and tartar sauce added some freshness and creaminess to the sandwich, and the raisin bread was soft and somehow the sweetness of it worked so well. It's massive so I highly recommend getting only one to share among 2 people. We washed it down with some Barritt's Ginger Beer which was delicious, sweet, and found all throughout the island. Definitely add this to your Bermuda itinerary! Cash only. read more

See all

Sometime ago, the owner (may God rest his soul) switched to an imported Swai fish. I remember that as a teen, I saw the boxes in the back of his car. Since this time, time and time again, I have hoped upon hope that they would at least use imported wahoo or something of higher quality (if they are unable to secure local fish). Nevertheless, nothing changes. It is a shame because they have a great batter and great sides. Hoping for change. read more

Believe the hype- best fish sandwich we've ever had, hands down. Order it the popular way, even if it sounds a little strange to you.. on raisin bread with tartar sauce and coleslaw. We walked all the way from the ferry stop in Hamilton, about half an hour on a very hot day, and it was worth it! It's in a local neighborhood, not much else going on in the area and nowhere to sit down in the restaurant itself, only to go... So grab a fish sandwich... One is definitely enough for two people, it's huge, and then go for a walk and eat it and enjoy! The service was friendly, too. Cash only, FYI! Just go! I will dream of this sandwich. read more

We were in Bermuda for a fish sandwich crawl. We love the version available on island; fresh fish, tasty sauce served on raisin bread. It's heaven. Everyone recommends Art Mel's. It took awhile to find it but we did. It's in a local neighborhood on the north shore. We ordered one fish sandwich and a side of extra fish for added protein. Take out orders were flying out of the little storefront but our food came and we headed to Shelley Bay Park to eat. When we opened the sandwich, it fell apart a bit as the bread was not toasted. The sauce wasn't to our liking. We prefer a tarter sauce type. I took a bite of the fish and it was super salty and spicy which normally would have been ok but the fish was tough. My partner ate half and I passed. Later, in our flat, we ate more of the fish and both commented that it tasted like KFC and wondered, was it pre battered commercial frozen fish? We will never know. Out of the 4 sandwiches we tried on our trip, it was the biggest by far if that's important. read more

Art Mel's Spicy And Dicy - Burgers Near Me - Bermuda, California