I had seen on social media that Bagel Bazaar was making Knicks colored bagels for the finals and I was excited get my hands on some. First, I called ahead to make sure they weren't sold out. Carmen was super helpful and she reserved the last 4 bagels for me! I drove over and sure enough, the bagels were waiting for me. Carmen also told me that a new batch of Knicks bagels was going to be ready in 3 minutes, so I waited and bought a dozen. While the bagels were finishing their last few minutes of baking, I shared the Knicks fan love and gave the staff some Knicks friendship bracelets to spread the Knicks joy! They loved it, and I loved my bagels! Thanks Bagel Bazaar for all your help. The bagels also tasted mighty good and they're huge and puffy/fluffy! GO KNICKS! I opted to take my order to-go, but there are plenty of tabels to enjoy your food inside. The only negative was that the bagels were $3 each. Understandable because they take more effort to prepare. How many times have the Knicks been in the NBA Finals? So I went for it. read more

See all

I'm so glad I stopped coming here since my last review. I can't believe people would even give this place more than 1 star review. Knicks bagels or golden bagels lol. The Fact is this place is disgusting. Staff which are mostly Mexican women provide the worst service and quality of food is horrible. They speak nasty about customers any given time amongst each other or to themselves, will overcharge if you are not aware, and overall service and food is pure mierda! read more

Bagel Bazaar - Englishtown Rd - Turkey sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Monroe Township, New Jersey

The staff that works here are the absolute worse. Stopped by today and had five ladies working there... every single one of them, rude, ignored customers and rolled their eyes constantly. I was speaking to another customer and she mentioned this is how it is all the time. I did a pick up order, stood in the pick up area for 10 minutes. No one was there to help. I went to the main cashier and told her I wanted to pickup my order. She mumbled something and walked away. When I said, excuse me, I didn't hear you, she ignores me. Went to someone else they told me to go to the pick up line, I told her I was there for 10 minutes and no one helped me, she tells me to go back. Waited like a fool for another 10 minutes, I went home and realized that they messed up my order. Going forward I'll just go to another bagel shop close to home. read more

I like their bagels and have a great variety or sandwiches and spreads. I would give it a 5 but their staff is not always the friendliest.

This store has a wonderful range of products. The problem is that the help either does not understand English or does not pay attention to orders. The other day I asked for egg salad on an egg bagel with lettuce and tomato. The woman did gave me egg salad on an egg bagel BUT it had NO lettuce or tomato! read more

They literally charged my 92 year old mother to cut her bagels! They know a huge piece of their business is elderly and they are really pushing the envelope by charging to cut a bag of bagels for these people to make it easier for them......SHAME read more

got breakfast here the other day. I got the bacon egg and cheese and also a bagel with butter. Both were pretty good, decent quality and tasted great. read more

Bagel Bazaar - Englishtown Rd - Bagel with Butter - Bagels Near Me - Monroe Township, New Jersey

See all

This place is pretty good. Not a true authentic NY Jewish bagel but still quality. Good service and the same prices as competitors.

This used to be my bagel spot. But every time I go, they mess up my order. Whether it's missing an item, or the wrong thing completely, or different from what i ordered, there's just always an issue. But this weekend was the LAST straw. the food was completely burnt and inedible. to knowingly serve absolute shit to a customer and try to hide it thinking the customer won't notice, is the worst kind of customer service. won't be returning, and that sucks bc i used to love them. read more

Bagel Bazaar - Englishtown Rd - Burnt Steak Egg & Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Monroe Township, New Jersey

They have GF bagels. They are always undercooked. No matter how times I ask them to wipe the knife and put paper down to slice it, they never remember. My last visit finished me here. I ordered a gf bagel with cream cheese. Besides cutting on crumb filled counter they put butter. I told them it was supposed to cream cheese and please put it on the paper. She actually scraped the butter off , put the butter back in the container and tried to put cream cheese back on top of the butter. When I told her to please give me a new bagel, she grabbed a stale day old instead a fresh on from the back. At this point I just paid took one bite of the stale bagel and threw it away. NEVER AGAIN! read more

I ordered 2 bagels with butter. The cashier said they put cream cheese on instead. How the F can you get confused ?? After waiting 10 minutes to receive the wrong bagels, I was asked if i wanted to wait again for new ones. Being in a rush AND after i just left a 18% tip, i said no, i will throw them in the garbage. She said ok, lol. Never offered to refund my money. I lost money & time today but never again. Instead of coming here on a regular basis, I will boycott and never return. F ing ridiculous. Thus, if you don't want to waste your time & money, definitely go elsewhere. read more

Decent local bagel store. Many coupons available in the local mail/Val paks for the 4 free bagels with a dozen purchase. The whitefish salad is excellent, on the other hand the veggie cream cheese is a pathetic representation of veggie cream cheese, hardly any vegetables.....step up and make your own for heavens sake. Saturday morning at 830am....out of plain bagels...seriously? The bagels themselves are solid, especially if you request well done bagels. The store is clean and has tables and chairs inside and out. There is a grill for egg sandwiches, bacon etc. read more

Bagel Bazaar - Englishtown Rd - Bagels Near Me - Monroe Township, New Jersey

Be sure to check your receipt, overcharging. Hire at least one person that understands English.

The best tasting toasted corn muffin I have had!!! Definitely will be going back soon for another.

Terrible terrible order has never been right - wrong type of bagel, wrong ingredients in the bagel, tasteless, poor quality ingredients. never ordering from here again - much better bagel places in the area. tried to give this place so many chances but it was just becoming a waste of money and calories. read more

I knew when I saw "Taylor Ham" instead of pork roll that I should have ordered something else, but I tried it anyway because they give you options for the type of bagel, cheese and egg you want. The sandwich itself was bland; the bagel, the "taylor ham", the egg. I also ordered a crumb cake with my order and received a brownie instead, which was not a huge deal but kinda disappointed in the whole thing. read more

Bagels are bland. Asked for a bacen, egg and cheese with salt, pepper, ketchup. Cheese wasn't melted. Drop of ketchup.

Went here for breakfast yesterday because Manalapan Luncheonette was packed. Although most employees were friendly. The food was not as accommodating. Wife an I each got a bagel breakfast sandwich. Both of our bagels were stale. The egg was dry, overcooked and the oil was slightly burnt it was cooked it. Wife's bacon was undercooked and my sausage was bland. When our order was ready the lady called our number. As I was getting up to get it (don't always move as fast as I used too, she called the number again (about 3 seconds after the first time). As I approached she called our number again with disgust in her voice (again 3 seconds after the last time). I responded that I was here. She seemed disturbed that I took 9 seconds to get there, gave me a disapproving look, made some comment under her breath and walked away. If you enjoy good food and service, go elsewhere. Your not going to find it here. As a note. When looking at the menu it showed the pound pice of white and yellow American cheese being the same price but if you order the white American cheese sandwich you pay $.50+ cents more than yellow. Why is this? If it's the same price per pound, why does it cost more for white? These are small things but make you wonder where else they're deceiving you. read more

Bagel Bazar makes nice bagels with a good crunch on the exterior. The salads are good. The nova is good, but you should request that it be sliced thin. The gyro sandwich is surprisingly tasty and they have an assortment of quality lunch items. read more

Bagel Bazaar - Englishtown Rd - Bagel all the way - Bagels Near Me - Monroe Township, New Jersey

I'm starting this review with just 4 stars to begin with because the wait time was ridiculous. There were people before me who waited over a half an hour before their food came out & mine took exactly 24 minutes.... it was a simple egg & cheese sandwich! The problem is the lack of organization in this place & the griddle is SO TINY (as u can see in the picture) THEY NEED A BIGGER GRIDDLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! How do they expect to serve so many people with that MINUSCULE thing?!?! The lines were huge so they should be expecting this kind of thing & get their act together ! I took another star away because my bagel was burnt & I saw my sandwich sitting on the side READY while I stood there & no one told me it was mine. They were all disorganized & in a craze. I'm NOT taking another star away because it was actually really good besides the fact that it was burnt. It was great quality but it just took TOO MUCH TIME!!!!! The eggs were cooked perfectly & the bagel was a classic jersey bagel! I actually took 6 bagels home & I can't wait to try those... this time- without a crowd of angry people waiting for their food....... read more

Bagel Bazaar - Englishtown Rd - Bagels Near Me - Monroe Township, New Jersey

See all

the absolute worst place. the food here is often old and stale and they dont cook the eggs properly. the staff here is also rude and will ignore you. why would anyone go here? there is no customer appreciation. read more

This place is disgusting women cooking my omelette didn't have gloves she basically threw everything with her hands into the omelette. The omelette looked like a disaster. Really careless filthy unprofessional place do not go here waste of money and time. Go to Tommy's or grandpas bagels much better and cleaner. read more

Worst place to have delivery from. Not only did they miss the 3 eggs requested on my sandwich; the 20oz ice coffee that was order was barely 10oz. Don't waste your money. read more

Don't waste your time and money. Unprofessional and rude stuff. Food could be better. Stay away from the place and find another bagel store. read more

I really like the food here, but getting your order in can be a struggle. The ladies behind the counter who serve you are hard working and friendly but English isn't their first language and it's a struggle for them to understand what you are ordering. Even when I try to slowly enunciate and speak my order, I find that I have to repeat it because they misunderstood. With that said, there are electronic kiosks that you can place your order in. This is the best Bagal Bazaar in town and bagel shop for that matter. They have the best bagels and unique varieties of spreads to choose from. They also make very good sandwiches and breakfast items on the grill. Just check your bag before you leave to see if you got what you wanted. read more

See all

great bagels and service. Best breakfast sandwich around. It is also the cheapest since everyone raised their prices but they didn't over here. read more

Mo was a terrific help in arranging 2 deliveries. One was a lox platter- it looked great and had an abundant amount of lox and spreads. My cousin lives close to Bagel Bazaar and loved the gift - it was delicious! The 2nd platter was a salmon dinner to another cousin at a further NJ location. Mo took time in preparing an attractive and delicious meal and despite the distance, made the delivery on time. Mo gave me updates on the delivery status of both gifts and pictures so I knew what was going to arrive. My cousins were touched by our generosity and the tasty treats and I owe it all to Mo at Bagel Bazaar. Go for good food and great service or order for prompt and reliable deliveries. Thank you Mo!!! read more

This was really good. The plain bagel had a nice outside crunch, but was light on the inside. Bagels were nice and big. Tuna was non-offending, and BEC had good tasting bacon. Everything I ordered was exactly what it was supposed to be. If I had 1 complaint it would be not enough everything seasoning on the everything bagel, but that is being super picky. Glad I found this place. read more

This is a great place. I ordered through door dash $50 worth of bagels and salads (seafood, egg and whitefish) and a coffee and the guy didnt bring my coffee. So i called the store and Harmatta brought me the coffee and also some cookies to make up for it. Excellent customer service! read more

The absolute worst 6 dollar BEC I've ever had in my life. I don't know why everything is so greasy. Even the coffee tastes greasy.

So this review is for their catering business, which we utilized for my son's 1st bday party... If you need sandwich platters, wraps, salads for a large group of people, don't even bother looking around, call Bagel Bazaar, ask for Paul, and let him take care of the rest- you will not be disappointed. We had about 30 people and there was an ample amount of food, with plenty of options and everything was darn tasty. We went with wraps as it was the best option and you must get the tuna included in whatever you order. Opt for the macaroni salad, which I liked a lot because it had a very good mayo taste- often times, delis either skimp on the mayo, over do it or use the wrong kind altogether. Whatever Bagel Bazaar does to theirs, I like it, and their potato salad was good too. I think I changed the headcount on the order 2-3 times, due to predicted bad weather, and each time, Paul was more than accommodating. They do offer delivery, just not on Sundays but with 4 area locations, you can probably find one close by to pick up from. read more

Food is always good but it's filthy. Posted some photos because I never noticed until today. Took forever to get food and there's no customer service. With the amount of business this place has I would expect a cleaner more friendly establishment read more

Bagel Bazaar - Englishtown Rd - Bagels Near Me - Monroe Township, New Jersey

Never again. I ordered a pork roll an cheese on a roll. When I got home, I got a pork roll egg and cheese on a bagel. It was not the end of the world, but the bagel was completely under cooked and gooey and the outside of the bagel was very greasy. Also, it wasn't even busy. I can understand messing up orders when it's busy, but there was only 3 other people in the store and like 8 employees. read more

The person at the cashier called me fat ("gordito") in Spanish to her co-worker. Most likeky she was assuming that since I'm white I wouldn't understand. I told her that I know what that means and she just gave me a blank stare and walked into the back area without saying a word to me. So, if you're looking to taste the sensation of being discriminated against in two separate ways, come to Bagel Bazaar! You can find over sixteen combinations of insults based on your ethnicity, body type, and how many items you have ordered. Bagel Bazaar - you may not eat the food, but you sure will lose your appetite. read more

I'm so glad I discovered this place! The bagels and sandwiches are fresh and delicious. There's usually a wait during breakfast and lunch peak hours however I never seem to have a problem and don't usually wait longer than 5 minutes. I will definitely be back! Love bagel bazaar! read more

The most poorly run establishment. Woman who takes orders doesn't speak English. If they get too busy they won't answer their phones. There are plenty of other bagel places in the area. Don't waste your time here! And your order is always delivered incorrectly. Also no delivery on Saturdays. read more

Ever since Pablo left this place has gone downhill. They are slow and can't get a simple order right.

I love Bagel Bazaar! My boyfriend lives up the street and we always come here for breakfast on the weekends (sometimes during the week if we're feeling gluttonous :P). I think this place used to have different owners a few years ago, and it has vastly improved since it became Bagel Bazaar. There is always a really nice woman there who I believe is the owner or manager - she's the happiest person ever! The bagels are good and they have a wide variety of options. If you come after noon, they are typically out of the more popular kinds. Their Egg and Egg Everything bagels are my absolute favorite! Solid coffee, you can make your own hot or iced. Lots of flavors to choose from, including seasonal ones. For me, cream cheese can make or break a bagel and they have the formula down. Most of the employees are young girls, and they are all very polite and I've never had a problem with the service. They get really into the holidays with decor which I think is a nice touch! I'm currently eating an Egg Everything with Cream Cheese and bacon ~ to die for! read more

They don't know how to make a CLUB SANDWICH. These are even on their menu. They called my wife back to ask what a CLUB SANDWICH was after she placed our order. Are you kidding me? The attitude of one of their employees was the worst I have ever dealt with in a long time! When I arrived to pick up my order, it still wasn't done (3 sandwiches) after 25 minutes. The "CLUB" sandwich was simply a sandwich, nothing more. I could understand if they didn't offer it. If it was not on their menu. Or even if the employee who made it simply said "Sorry I'm new to the CLUB sandwich. Instead, I got the worst attitude I have ever dealt with. The guy who made the sandwich simply ignored me and did not respond! I thought that John Quinones from What would you do? was going to come running out..... NEVER HAPPENED. I plan on NEVER going back there. We used to get breakfast bagels there all the time....NO MORE! The excuse from another employer was "He had a bad night"! REALLY? Ask your employees to all make a triple Decker club just like on your menu. If they don't know how, FIRE THEM and find someone that does. Deeply Disappointed.... read more

Used to be my go to place for a bagel egg sandwich but the last few times they've screwed up my order. I don't know if it's the language barrier (employees barely speak English) or just plain incompetency. It's not like they were busy when I ordered. Oh well, adios to this place! (Maybe they can understand that!) read more