I was craving a breakfast bagel and saw that this spot was the closest to me so I gave it a try. I ordered a toasted everything bagel with lox cream cheese. It was delicious! Bagel was fresh and fluffy and the cream cheese spread was generous and tasty. The French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese was my second choice if I decided to go sweet, so maybe I'll try that next time now that I know this spot is yummy! *Located in a strip mall with lots of parking! read more

Everything Bagels And Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Marlboro, New Jersey

See all

Great little bagel spot! Bagels are great, as well as their fresh spreads. Service is always quick and the staff is friendly. Highly recommend! read more

TLDR: inconsistent preparation of bagels makes for a bad experience... don't come for breakfast, come for their hot lunch sandwiches. Came here on a Sunday around 10AM and ordered 3 bagels with cream cheese and 1 hot bagel. The breakfast bagels themselves were all inconsistent. One of the bagels had a generous amount of cream cheese while the other two had barely any... are we sure that these are jersey bagels?? The sausage, egg and cheese with a hashbrown was almost $10.... Seems a bit absurd for how thin the bagel was. Service was quick, but probably to their own detriment as an inconsistent product is being sold. read more

See all

Big red sign above store that says Bagels/ everything bagel and more. Like who could miss it right? The taxi driver couldnt find it because his GPS didnt take him to the door! Ha. They had a variety of bagels, muffins and drinks, with a seated area to dine in. They take credit cards and there is a % fee for use. I found this out after the server asked the workers as she did not know. We met a few customers there from the Taekwondo place a few stores down. They were pleased to allow me to take and place a picture. They noted that the sabom was really good and suggested we stop by and meet him after our breakfast. We did walk over to find the door locked and hours open at 1pm. This noted the review is about the bagel store. The workers were pleasant enough. I could not comment on the other items as I had a blueberry muffin toasted as I had requested and my friend had a scrambled egg on white bread. While we were there they were installing a new TV on the wall. That's nice. read more

See all

This place was great. Nice crunch on the bagels, light and fluffy on the inside. Huge smears of cream cheese. Loved the BEC, tuna was tasty. I even got a solid Italian sub here (the Old Bridge Sandwich). Just super happy with everything I ordered. I told my wife about it and ordered again that weekend so she could check it out too. read more

When your daughters are in travel softball you spend A LOT of time eating at quick bite places, countless Wawas, McDonalds, and casual fast food. Enter todays softball game in Holmdel, add a hungry dad, mom and 2 kids that you told a hundred times to eat before we left Tuckerton and we pull into the first shopping center and hit "Everything Bagel,". It's NJ, there a lots of bagel shops and most are soli eats. This one stuck out because the staff was just so damn nice and our sandwiches were GREAT! BLT with plenty of bacon, egg and cheese cooked perfectly and the bagel were awesome. Love it when even when busy, a counter person engages, in this case with my girls wishing them luck in their games and offering a free sandwich if they won. we lost, but pretty sure they would have given C a free sandwich anyway. Service speaks volumes. great spot to hit if your in the area. read more

Congratulations! This cafe just opened recently and I had to try it out and I'm glad I did !! Friendly and attentive staff, large assortment of bagels and spreads, as well as an assortment of cold and hot sandwiches to order. I ordered the everything bagel ($8.98) which was fresh and tasty. Large portion of lox, cream cheese, capers and onions on a everything bagel. Yum ! I also tried their French toast bagel($6.99) fries eggs bacon and white American cheese I. A French toast bagel. Also very tasty ! I can wait to come back. Posted hours are : Monday- Saturday 6 am- 3 pm Sunday 6 am - 1 pm read more

See all

This is plain and simple the best bagel store in New Jersey. Trust me, I have been to tons of them, Brooklyn, Staten Island and New Jersey. This rival ls all of my Brooklyn favorites and the Egg bagel might be the best I've ever had. Plus the staff is great. And I love a bagel store with some TVs :) Nice touch guys. read more

This "bagel" shop is a disguise for an amazing take out or dine in. The bagel and bread is always fresh...sandwich combos are outta control...doesn't skimp on the meat or the fixings. At the end of the day...doesn't disappoint. read more

Everything Bagels And Cafe - The Seabright....1/2 of a full hero...amazing. - Bagels Near Me - Marlboro, New Jersey

9.00 for a pork roll egg and cheese on a hard roll. Ok not offended by price but 2 pieces of pork roll is a bit chinsy

Best bagels in the area by far. I'm from NYC and used to getting good bagels. Moved to NJ and hadnt found any place that was close to comparable until I was recommended this place and most say they are top notch bagels that are like having my normal ny bagels again read more

Gave me the wrong order. I asked for 4x everything and I got 4x plain. Also, I've never seen a pathetic egg & cheese bagel in my life. The even the everything and cream cheese we received was lack luster. Never going back again. read more

Everything Bagels And Cafe - They put 1 egg on an egg & cheese bagel costing $4.24. They should be embarrassed. - Bagels Near Me - Marlboro, New Jersey

See all

My mom and I are constantly in search of a good bagel place and we've finally found it. The service is amazing and the bagels are so fluffy! We even drive 20 minutes to go get it! Highly recommend read more

Everything Bagels And Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Marlboro, New Jersey

This place bakes its own bagels and italian heroes, and the breakfast and lunch sandwiches made with those fresh baked goods are amazing. They are very clean, have tables to sit at, and are always able to get food out without a long wait. This place beats the local bagel shops and is strong competition for the local hoagie and sub shops. For a couple dollars more than quick check this place isnt too bad on price. The only downside are 1.it is hidden away in the back of the lot (so keep your eyes peeled) and 2. there are no baby seats (but there is room to bring a stroller if you have a baby). One day I will remember to take a photo but I usually dive in too fast without thinking. read more

I just stopped into this new bagel shop for the first time, the staff was extremely friendly & all the pastries, bagels and salads looked fresh and delicious. I asked the ingredients in the eggplant salad they had on display and was offered a sample of it which was delicious so I ordered a container for my sister, who is dairy and gluten free. I got the French toast bagel for myself which was perfectly baked with a light crunch. I'll definitely be back. Welcome to the area! read more

Everything Bagels And Cafe - French toast bagel - Bagels Near Me - Marlboro, New Jersey

You're not gonna find a bagel Store anywhere in the area that is as warm and inviting as Everything bagel and Cafe. They have the best selection of kettle bagels and you will not get a better tasting bagel. anywhere in the area then what you can get at Everything Bagel Cafe. Services impeccable, food is incredible. The owners are on premises every day to ensure their customers are satisfied. You will not be disappointed. read more

If you're in Matawan area (an area almost completely devoid of good food yet packed with places to eat), go here for the bagels. This place has the best bagels in town. If you're looking for Pork Roll, as I am every morning, hungover and in dire need of PEC, look elsewhere. Very skimpy on the pork roll. Very skimpy read more

Best bagel with butter ever. Could not recommend more, the everything bagel has the best flavor I've ever had. Has like a pinch of pretzel salt and it's amazing. read more

Terrible service, they could learn some basic manners. The bagels they served were pathetic. Probably a decent bagel place outside of NJ. Save your time and go somewhere else. Seems like they're rationing there food when they serve it to you. I even left a tip and the server couldn't even say thank you. read more

The best service and the best bagels. You get treated like family here. I recommend to everyone I know.

I used to travel all the way to Hot Bagel in Oakhurst for a good bagel. After this place opened I haven't even thought about making the drive. Everything Bagel literally makes the best bagels in central New Jersey! It's a real bagel not a roll with a whole, the outside is a bit crisp and the inside is fluffy and delicious. You won't be disappointed read more

We had been waiting for this bagel store to open and it was well worth the wait! The food was delicious, staff extremely friendly and it had a very nice atmosphere. This is definitely more than a bagel store with their selection of baked goods and prepared foods. My wife absolutely loved the eggplant tower and kids loved their chocolate croissant pretzel. We will definitely be going back! read more

got a christmas bagel this morning and got a warm welcoming hello from everyone!! the bagel was so cute and i loved it. one of the best bagels i've ever had . read more

Anyone who talks bad about this place is a typical spoiled brat! These people are the friendliest and most accommodating whenever I go in- morning to evening! The staff is always working hard and smiling through morning rushes. Honestly, if you're writing this place a one star review, the only thing that should be checked is your impossible central jersey standards :) thanks! Love everything bagels!!! read more

Consistently excellent bagels and other baked goods. Very friendly and attentive service. Reasonable prices. The people who work here work hard and seem to really appreciate the business that comes in. Highly recommended! read more

The cafe is clean and the staff is very nice. Our food was fresh and delicious. We will definitely come back!