The best bagels not just in Sioux Falls, that we've ever had! We've gone twice in the last week and Erica was working while we went and her service is too notch and she's super personable. And makes the best pumpkin spice latte around the experience we had made our day read more

Bagel Boy never lets me down! They have consistently provided excellent bagels and bagel sandwiches, and the staff is always friendly. If you're looking for a local breakfast or lunch option, I can't recommend Bagel Boy enough! read more

Ordered 2 bagels, and was asked to pull ahead so I did. I have been asked to pull ahead before so I pulled into the same area I did before. Waited a half hour and no one ever brought my food out. Went inside and they said they thought I had left?? I was especially frustrated with the guy who took my order and saw my car and still somehow thought I had left when my car was exactly in their line of sight???? Will not be returning, the common sense in this store is absurd. read more

The 1st thing I noticed when I walked in was a young man with longer hair. His hair was not pulled back and he did not have a hat or hair net on. It was hanging in his eyes and he kept having to flip his head to get it out of his face. It turned me off a little as I was nervous I would find hair in my bagel. They also forgot to put cheese on my husbands bagel sandwich. Other than that it was okay read more

Went to Bagel Boy for lunch after Church. Everyone else must have had the same idea, because the line was to the door. We didn't have to wait to long since they were staffed to handle it. As we looked for a table to sit at, the open tables we found were dirty. This would have been a 5 star review had we found a clean table. I like how they take your name when you order, then they will call out your name when your food is ready. The food was great! 4 of us were all happy with our food. And it can be tough to make an 8 and 13 year old happy at a restaurant. This was an overall great lunch experience, as it is each time we go! If you like bagels, soups and sandwiches it is a great place to eat. The employees there are all super friendly. read more

Great bagel joint with a great selection. The staff is always friendly too. This place is a go to when I want a fast and quick breakfast.

On a recent Sunday morning I, along with two other people were at this Bagel Boy location. There weren't many people in the place. We didn't step up to the counter right away. We were trying to decide what we wanted. We stepped up and not one person acknowledged us. Everyone was working, with their heads down, my friend cleared her throat, nothing. Finally my friend said we wanted to order. One of the workers finally acknowledged her. She ordered, the next person ordered, and off to work the person went. She completely ignored me. I stood there a little dumbfounded. No one else stepped up to take my order. I had to ask to have order taken, not once but TWICE. To top it off, she acted annoyed that I wanted to order. No apologies. I do have to say I like their bagels. But service is HORRIBLE! Based on this, this is why I am only giving one star. read more

Easily the BEST bagel I've ever had. The atmosphere is great and the prices are fantastic! Whenever I know I'm coming through Sioux Falls I make sure to make a stop here! It's essential! Would highly recommend! read more

Best bagel shop around! Make sure you get an everything bagel with sausage and cheese! Or the cinnamon bagel not toasted. It's melts into stickiness if you toast it. I could eat here every morning. It's really crowded on the weekends so expect quite s line. Coffees pretty good too. There's enough tables to eat inside or take it to go. read more

Loved their breakfast bagels with choice of cheese, sauce and vegetables. I had the 9-grain, which included flax seed and chia seed - delicious. Just as good as the big names in Minneapolis, but right here in Sioux Falls! Busy place Saturday morning, but if you like bagels and a great cup of coffee, you'll want to stop here! read more

Salmon bagel was very good but I was a little bit shock by the bagel size. It was smaller than expected... other than that great place!

We love to stop at the bagel boy and almost always order a Karen Special on an everything bagel. The Karen Special is peanut butter bacon and pickles and sounds less than spectacular. However, it is the most amazing breakfast that you can buy for less than $3! Their coffee is great and they have a wide variety of blends. read more

Bagel Boy - Karen Special on Everything Bagel - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

I want to have this place suceed but they keep on missing the mark. How difficult is it to make a smoked salmon with cream cheese? There is no consistancy with orders and those who prepare them. I have found some of the sandwich bagels to be overflowing with 'fixings' while others in the same bag have scraps. I want this place to work...but so far, I have yet to see it be worthwhile. read more

It's as if they forgot to bake the bagels. I ordered 2 sesame, 1 everything and 1 garlic. My first clue should have been that they were all very anemic looking--no brown, crispy crust on the outside-- but I hadn't had a bagel in awhile so was looking forward to a good bagel. So, toasting an underbaked bagel the outside is like chewing on plastic. Definitely wasn't worth the several minutes I waited in line. Go visit a bagel shop in NY to see what real bagels are like. read more

We decided to go here at about one pm on a Sunday, friend is a fan of the bagel sandwiches. We arrive and no one says anything to us at first. We look over the menu for about five minutes before being stepping further down the line at the counter while were finally asked if we've been helped, so no real greeting. We ordered two breakfast bagel sandwiches to go, waited for about 5 minutes. Took the bagels home and discovered we didn't get any eggs on either of them. Tried to call the store to try to figure out what happened, twice, no one answered either time? Ate some sub-par egg-less breakfast bagels and didn't quite feel satisfied afterward. Not sure I'll be going back to this location.. read more

I love this restaurant! These ladies Our wonderful! Thank you so much for doing such a great job in making people's lunch dinner any kind of social occasion that much better! Thank you thank you thank you! read more

No. Don't go here. The food was disgusting, and nobody wore masks! The person at the counter was very rude and told me to screw myself when I took over 2 minutes to order. The manager just shrugged and walked away. One of the employees was looking my 8 year old up and down in such a disgusting way. Never going here again. read more

Love Bagel Boy, best fast food around. I wish their franchise would come north so I wouldn't have to drive over 100 miles to enjoy them. Beats all other fast foods out of the park. read more

The setup is unique. The staff was extremely helpful with it being my first time there. All the staff was really nice. They made a unique coffee for my husband and it was really good! The sandwich was also really good. I wasn't a huge fan of the pretzel bagel because it was crazy salty but I will definitely be going back! Thanks for being so nice staff! read more

I've been having breakfast and lunch at Bagel Boy on 26th Street for over 10 years and my latest trip there was just as great as always. I came in with a friend for 5 different sandwiches to go. The staff was patient with us. We were out the door in 5 minutes and enjoyed a tasty lunch. Thanks Bagel Boy! read more

When I want fresh tasty bagels....I go to Bagel Boy. When I NEED a fresh, hot Philly steak bagel sandwich....I go to Bagel Boy. When I want to treat my friends or family to a dozen bagels with some delicious whipped cream cheese varieties....I go to the grocery store? HELL NAH! I GO TO BAGEL BOY!!! read more

Bow down to the 605 bagel! Best place to get lunch on a budget in Sioux Falls. Do not skip the monster cookie.

I typically go through the drive up in the morning and while I understand they don't have a speaker the service is always slow and typically people are rude. This morning I went and my coffee was this flimsy cup (something was obviously wrong with it so why would they use it???) and the lid wasn't on so I got half of it all over myself and the interior of my car. I distinctly heard the girl at the window say you didn't get the lid on AGAIN, so it's happened more than once this morning and can personally say, it's happened to me before at least twice. Terrible, terrible service. read more

This really shouldn't have surprised me. I decided to give Bagel Boy another chance because I really do (or did) enjoy their bagels. This morning I showed up around 7am and got my bagel. Everything was made and I paid for my bagel with my credit card. The lady asked if I would like a receipt. I said yes of course and stuck it directly in my pocket. The bagel tasted old and stale. Nothing fresh like they use to make. Later that day at work I reached into my pocket and found the receipt. Little did I know they over charged me by two dollars. Frustrated I called to complain about the service and to get my money back. The lady told me that it would take 5 to 7 business days to get the two dollars back on my credit card. They said they would make it up to me by giving me a free bagel. How is it free if they already have my two dollars? Please think twice before eating or purchasing anything from this place. One day and another phone call the manager did give me a 10 dollar gift card. Makes me feel a bit better. read more

It's been a year since we were in South Dakota. In Canada now, heading north as far as the road goes. Just said to my husband, "remember those bagels in Sioux Falls".... We will be back! read more

Favorite place for breakfast and coffee! They have a ton of choices from breakfast bagels to lunch time bagels. The coffee is great too! The staff is friendly and food is made fast and fresh! read more

One of my all time favorite places to eat! I live in Texas now and wish there was a Bagel Boy here. I'm able to visit Sioux Falls once a year and come here every time. The best is the Turkey Club with muenster cheese on a garlic bagel. I dream of this delicious sandwich for 364 days a year. read more

This is my first yelp review. Ever. The bagels and coffee are your average run of the mill stuff. I'm writing this review on the fact that I will never go back again. I have been to bagel boy a total of two times since I've moved to Sioux Falls from California. 2/2 times I have been verbally abused by some angry older lady who hates her job. I have never had someone be so RUDE to me EVER!!!! read more

Ordered my bagel with four others in my group, mine never came. Found out mine went out the drive thru. Two employees apologized , said they would remake it and gave me a cookie. Ate the cookie, and my replacement bagel never came either. Went up to check, they NEVER made it. Guess they lost my business. Too bad read more

As a native of NYC I'm not embarrassed to say I'm a bagel snob. So, take that into account when considering my 4-star rating. I've lived in the Midwest for over 20 years now and am constantly looking for something that closely resembles a true NY bagel. Before visiting Sioux Falls, I hadn't found it. Bagel Boy has nailed it though! The crust is right, the inside is right, and the seasonings are spot on and plentiful. Why not 5 stars? Well, they're just a little bit smaller than they should be to be a perfect New York bagel. If they aren't being held up against that standard though, these are 5 star all the way. I wish I lived closer to Sioux Falls, or Bagel Boy would open a shop in the Twin Cities! read more

I always make it a point to go to bagel boy while I am in town, and they always do a great job. After waiting in line to try Einstein's, we decided to head over here instead. With a line of over 15 people on a Sunday morning, it only took about 10 minutes to get my order and extra bagels. Also the bagels that I took were fresh and moist. I will definitely be returning on my next trip. read more