Based on other Yelp ratings, reviews and pictures, we decided to give Baked a try. We are very glad we did! This is a smaller sit-down Chicago inspired restaurant. It is comfortable and casual. They have several TVs and a Chicago flag on the wall. Our server, Brianne, was great. She answered all of our questions, was friendly and efficient. We ordered a 14" Chicago Deep dish pizza (the main reason we came) with meatballs and extra cheese. It was very flavorful, the crust was soft and firm with a buttery taste. We could have used more meatballs, but I won't deduct a star for that. The pizza was topped with fresh-tasting crushed tomatoes. We also ordered a 16" thin crust pizza with Pepperoni, extra cheese and 1/2 green olives. It also was quite good. The crust was crispy, but not tough and the toppings tasted great. Baked has some good deals to know about. 50% off beer, wine and most appetizers 4-6 daily. Kids 11 and under eat free Sunday's from 11:30-6 (one adult for two children, so four free with two adults). If you want to score big, order the daily pizza special, drinks and bring your kids on a Sunday between 4-6! These deals are on right now (April 2026) so ask before you order, as they may not be forever. We will be back! In the meantime, we have enough left overs for three meals (lol). read more

See all

This place was recommended to me by a guy from Chicago and said it was like going to Chicago and suggested I try it. I am so glad I did. The Italian sausage was imported from Chicago and the Italian beef was amazing with the au jus on the side. It was amazing. I then tried the Sears tower thin crust pizza that was made with fresh dough and house made sauce. Great service and had some great 80's music playing. Don't wait, run to this place if you're in the area. read more

Baked - Italian sausage and Italian beef sandwich with goodies on top - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

I am a pizza snob, I like places that think outside the box for sure. I like variety. Two very different pizzas which were both very good. Not quite 5 star but almost. One of the better thin crust around SWFL and the Pan was unique in the area, both were good. We will go back, not regularly, but we will go back. read more

Baked - Thin crust - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

If I could give this place 10 stars I would! My family and I were hungry and it was 20 minutes til closing time, after being turned away by another pizza place around the corner because it was almost closing time we stopped in here. They were so welcoming even and didn't mind serving us at the midnight hour. Not to mention the service was excellent, food was amazing, and it was better than the Chicago pizza that I had when I actually visited Chicago. We will definitely be back! read more

Found this place online and I waited all day for Chicago hotdog. I flew in and went straight there from the hotel. Will never come back. I asked the waitress if they have a pizza puff and I got nothing but attitude. Hotdog was cold and the bread was stale. Took one Biden threw it away. read more

Brought a real Chicagoan here. We both agreed that the food and the staff were excellent. Great flavors in our fried ravioli, Meatball Parm sub and Deep Dish sausage w/ mushroom pie. Julia and staff were friendly and gave great service. Will be back! read more

Baked - Meatball sub w/mozzarella. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

We had an amazing server, Julie. She knew the menu and how to make our experience the bes! she let us know the best tasting deep dish pizzas would take tome and made sure our family was happy and eating in the meantime. The food was great and the service was better! read more

Tried Baked for the first time today and we will be returning! I read the good reviews and wanted to try it for myself. They had some nice March Madness specials which made it a good value. The deep dish pizza was spectacular. We love UNO's and this is the first local pizza that can compete. The sauce was fresh and tasty and sausage was delicious. My husband got the Chicago dogs and is a fan. The star of the show was our server, Julia. She was the perfect mix of friendly, knowledgable and professional. I'd go back just to see her. Run, don't walk to Baked for your next meal- I know we will! read more

Baked - Large deep dish sausage and green pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

My guilty pleasure in Fort Myers. I was hoping they still offered their lunch special that featured a personal size 1 topping pizza with a small salad but unfortunately it's not offered anymore. I was really craving their pizza but since I was by myself I knew I'd have tons of leftovers. I got 3 additional meals from the leftovers and it tasted just as good as it did in the restaurant. read more

The food from Chicago Baked was like a taste of home for my mom from the Chicago area. The Chicago style dog and Chicago combo sub were both traditional and can't be eaten with one hand. The cheddar cheese bites appetizer was plenty for our table of three, crisp on the outside and perfect on the inside. If you're lucky enough, maybe Miss Mary will be behind the line to crumble chicken around their delicious caprice salad! read more

See all

I'm working for four days in Fort Myers and I felt like pizza, so I went online and wrote, pizza near me and it sent me to a few places but the nearest one was Baked Pizza Company. They serve Chicago style deep dish pizza, thin crust and other things. I was confused with the menu so I then met Alicia who's a cook there and she suggested that I order their specialty the deep dish pizza. Alicia was very friendly and professional. The pizza was really good, there was pepperoni, sausage, olives, onions etc... It's a great place to enjoy a good meal! read more

Baked - Chicago style deep dish pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Excellent pizza and hotdogs and other Chicago favorites ! You can eat in or have the food delivered!

Wife and I popped in for supper on a yelp recommend. Brie was our server she was great very inviting local vibe but all welcome. Got the wrigley field deep dish. Wife says some of the best ever and I agree. Baked deep dish 1" thick or better cheese on crust then sauce and toppings baked slow together.on top of. If you've never had try it you won't be disappointed. Having leftovers tonight just as good Great yelp find again read more

pay attention to pizza in the oven so it does nor over cook. Thin crust requires extra care read more

Baked - Over cooked thin crust pizza. While our pizza was in the oven the pizza guy was outside. The crust is hard as rock! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

First time here we live in the Cape & have no good Chicago restaurants! We had the Italian beef (a close Portillos runner up!) and a Buckingham Fountain deep dish pizza. Both were very good & we'll be back to try more, had leftover pizza to take home! read more

See all

Who like Chicago style Hot Dogs? I love Chicago Style Hot Dogs and you can get them here. Everything Chicago is here from hot dogs, sandwiches, pizza etc. you have got to check them out. The hot dogs are made with Vienna hot dogs. They come with the wonderful sport peppers on a fluffy poppy seed bun. I love that classic Chicago dog style. The meal comes with delicious hot fries included. The dog actually pops with flavor. My hubby and I had been here for pizza when it was Buddy Z's. So glad only the name was changed. I added a side salad to my meal for my hubby and I to share. He decided on build your own hot dog which came with fries as well. However. He got everything except sport peppers and he really enjoyed his meal too. This place is perfect to come and enjoy great Chicago food at a reasonable price. read more

See all

Top notch Italian Beef Sandwich! Tender, hot and cheesy! A must try for the local crowd or the hardcore Chicago snow bird. You will not be disappointed. read more

Baked - Italian Beef with with cheese! Very juicy and delicious. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

The best Chicago deep dish pizza. We love getting a fresh pie and a frozen to go home. They always have great specials and their service and staff is amazing. Thank you for making fresh dough and homemade sauce- we see you and thank you- it makes the difference. read more

After many disappointments with restaurants claiming to serve Chicago style deep dish I found a genuine one! Great sauce and loads of cheese. We will be back!! read more

Was Buddyz and they have a location in the Chicago area. There are probably a couple deep dish pizza places we prefer more in Chicago, but when you are 1000 miles from Chicago and craving pizza, Baked deep dish definitely hits the spot. Many others say they do Chicago deep dish, but this is about as good as you will find. read more

Pizza looked amazing but am I wrong to order something else that's on THIER menu? I don't think so but I was served the worst chicken parmigiana entree ever and was told by the server that they are known for pizza! So I said if you can't deliver the same quality on another menu item, Don't Put It On The Menu. Good grief! The chicken parmigiana entree was a patty... yes, a patty like one of those compressed meat burger blobs. OMG the worst. read more

This is an absolute must!!! It is The Best Pizza I've ever had and I have had 40/50 states.the service is incredible and I can't say enough! The appearance and the taste!!! Even the smell when you into this restaurant is just memorizing.... Yum I definitely recommend this place to anyone coming to SWF read more

Craving a Chicago deep dish, didn't know there was a Chicago pizzeria a couple miles from my house. Ordered one to go today and I could not be happier!!! The staff was very polite, pizza was ready in 30 minutes as promised, and the crust was perfect!! Reminds me of when I was a kid and we would go to UNO's and write our name on the wall. I will be back soon!!!!!!!!! read more

Best pizza I've had in Fort Myers! Love the Chicago style deep dish Deep dish Chicago style pizza, like UNO's . Loved it going back soon! read more

Great pizza! Great sports atmosphere and the service was wonderful. I recommend this place for su read more

Baked - Chicago style pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

I am mad I did not go sooner! The service was wonderful and the food was delicious. We ordered salads and penne with meat sauce. To go we ordered a frozen pep. We loved it-thank you! read more

We went yesterday for a Chicago style pizza. Pizza was delicious. Kendra M was our server. She was wonderful. She took great care of us and was really a sweet young lady. We will be back and ask for Kendra! read more

The Chicago beef sandwich with mozzarella cheese is absolutely the best sandwich I have ever eaten. The rolll is absolutely stuffed with beef and a nice layer of mozzarella cheese is laid on the top of the sandwich. I've never been a fan of Chicago beef sandwiches until one day I decided to try it at this location and its utterly to die for. Now I stop here every time I am in the area for lunch. read more

The pizza was delicious and the service we received was amazing, she did an outstanding job. Definitely I will be back. I ordered a thin crust with beef and extra cheese, plus fries. My girlfriend and I love it, no greasy pizza and the ingredients were good. I am a Pizza lover and I can tell they use good and quality ingredients. read more

The BEST Chicago deep dish pizza outside of Chicago. Italian beef sandwich is also very good. My Chicago relatives love it all, we're all repeat customers now. Authentic and delicious. The owner is a great guy and true Chicago native. Good service, clean establishment. Never disappoints! read more

Food was so good! Pizza tasted just how it was supposed to. Best pizza I've had in Florida! Service was good, staff was friendly. Definitely will be back again to try other items in their menu! read more

Baked - Sears Tower and pepperoni and sausage deep dish pizza! It was so good! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

I believe this restaurant used to be Buddyz but is now Chicago baked pizza. Same address on Forum boulevard. Seated promptly. Restaurant was clean. Waitresses were friendly. The food was good but the kitchen doesn't understand that a thin crust pie and a deep dish pie take different times to bake. The deep dish arrived as my companions were finishing the thin crust pizza and they had completed eating salads before they got their pizza. The food when it arrived, was pretty good. Soft drinks, two salads, and two pizzas cost $60 plus tips. Don't get to Fort Myers very often but we probably won't go here again. read more

Been there twice now, both times for an Italian Beef, both times excellent. Those with me got pizza and loved it as well. Hot real fries, not something breaded and artificially crisped. Decent prices. read more

Excellent pizza! Original from Chicago, and our search is finally over. You will definitely see us again.

Great pizza, best in Fort Myers. Love the deep dish with the sauce on the top. On the weekends buyone get the second half off. Yum!

Definitely a great place to visit!! Staff was friendly & the pizza was absolutely delicious. We will be back.

Genuinely so annoyed. Im visiting my grandparents down in fort Myers and decided to get some pizza. We ordered at at around 4:45 for and in-store pickup. I show up with my two elderly grandparents. We show up at around 4:40 and go in to get our order- there is a family of three and they say they are packed. I admit people were most likely ordering on line but they said about 20 times that they were behind and swamped. The workers were rude-extremely passive aggressive and inconsiderate. The one worker told the costumers to be quiet and to be patient and kept making comments. She would run back and forth and not finish the task at hand, it was extremely clear that they could not handle stress (even the minuscule amount that they had). After waiting for about 35 minutes- the worker asked us what our name was and said that she remembered taking the order but she heard the name wrong and did not care that she put the name wrong, and she did not remember the name she put it under. I could not believe the lady had said that. We proceeded to wait another 25 minutes and they brought out a COLD PIZZA. Then didnt have any clue how to check us out. I honestly hope this pizza tastes good other wise i just wasted my time and money on a restaurant with rude employees and awful customer service. read more