I just went back and tried to delete my old (a little cranky) review of Chicago Pizza. In hindsight, it was basically about one former staff member rather than the restaurant itself. That person has been gone for a while now, and no, it had nothing to do with me! Since Don and Jessica took over as the new owners, the transformation has been nothing short of miraculous. I actually feel a little bittersweet writing such a positive review because I'm genuinely worried I'll show up one day and have to sit on the roof to get a table. But credit where it's due--these two have turned this place into something really special. The food was always fantastic, and they're still tweaking things because "excellent" apparently wasn't good enough for them. The staff is warm and amazing, the vibe is genuinely friendly, and the interior now feels so cozy and inviting that I could easily be guilty of lingering way too long (and honestly, they wouldn't mind). The TV setup alone deserves its own award--it's like they figured out the perfect answer to "How many screens is too many?" and the answer is simply "More." What I'm looking forward to is the day some actual Chicago natives walk in and give their honest verdict. That'll be the ultimate test. If they look around, take a bite, and nod in approval, we'll know Don and Jessica didn't just renovate the place... they truly honored the Chicago spirit. This spot has become the closest thing Cape Coral has to a Cheers-style hangout. (Yes, I know Cheers was in Boston, but if Don and Jessica keep this up, I wouldn't be surprised if someone starts yelling "Norm!" when I walk through the door.) Not sure if that's flattering or a little concerning, but I'll take it. This place is a rock-solid 5 stars. And if bonus stars existed for rapid improvements, I'd need an entirely new rating scale. Highly recommend! read more

Chicago Pizza in Cape Coral is a home run! The interior renovation looks fantastic--modern, clean, and welcoming. The food was absolutely outstanding from start to finish. Great flavors, generous portions, and excellent service. If I had to rate it on a scale of 1-10, I'd give it a 12! Definitely worth a visit if you're looking for great pizza and a fun dining experience in Cape Coral. #CapeCoral #ChicagoPizza #SupportLocal #CapeCoralDining #BrokerJoeApproved read more

See all

We heard they have a new owner not sure for how long, didn't care for their pizza a couple years back. We got the Chicago thin crust & it was great, their sausage & beef is from Fontanini Italian Meats & you can definitely tell the difference at places if it is not from an authentic Chgo meat company. They have coke fountain drinks that are very good (a lot of restaurants have terrible soft drinks because they don't calibrate them like they should). We also had the Chicago nuggets which is basically garlic bread pieces soaked in butter with a cold red sauce to dip in. Server was excellent, we'll be back! read more

See all

We were looking for a Chicago Bears bar with good food in Cape Coral. Google AI search failed us, and we stumbled upon this delicious tasty pizza joint with a bar. We got a Chicago tavern style pizza, and it's actually BETTER than a few great spots in Chicago! They also have pan pizza which I will have to get next week. They were very busy, but once we were seated, the food came out pretty quick (expect to wait longer for pan). The wings were great as well! read more

See all

So glad to have found a true Chicago pizza restaurant in SW Florida!! The inside is very inviting and locals could be found at the bar. Decor of Chicago sports memorabilia to include the 85 Chicago Bears! We had the garlic knots appetizer, delish. Then we got both the traditional thin crust as well as the deep dish pizzas. My friend and I ate the thin crust which was absolutely delicious! Dad had the deep dish as said it was very good. Can't wait to try their Italian beef and Chicago style dogs next time!! This is our go to for pizza when we are not back in Illinois! read more

Chicago Pizza - Bottom is the large deep dish sausage and top is traditional thin crust sausage and vegetables. - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

When we heard that Chicago Pizza had new owners, we knew we had to check it out--and we weren't disappointed! We were greeted by a genuinely friendly bartender who clearly loved her job. The subtly renovated restaurant was cleaner than we'd ever seen it, and all three of us immediately noticed the completely refreshed atmosphere. The local hometown gathering place was BACK, and the excitement was visible on every face in the room. Unbeknownst to me, I was sitting next to the new owner, Don. He was extremely welcoming. Once a patron himself, Don understands exactly what this bar means to locals and snowbirds alike. He's making a real effort to restore that authentic Chicago spirit--even if he's from Ohio! He truly gets it. The three of us shared a large, thin-crust double pepperoni and cheese pizza. It was delicious, though the pepperonis were tucked under the cheese, so they weren't as crispy as I prefer. Surprisingly, the bartender mentioned she likes hers with the pepperoni on top and suggested we try it that way next time. It's nice to see they're happy to accommodate personal preferences--a refreshing change from the previous owner, who never allowed any modifications. To top it off, my husband ordered an espresso martini--his ultimate test. It was good, though he's not a fan of Baileys in his martini. Impressively, the bartender remembered his preference and said she'd stock what he needed for his next visit. All I can say is--CHICAGO PIZZA is BACK! Thank you for bringing our beloved local pizza joint back to life. I'm confident it will be even better than ever! read more

I am age fan of Chicago thin / Tavern style pizza. We were told this place named for the dish was good. We ordered medium thin crust with sausage. Asked for well done and sadly it was not. But the crust wasn't very thin, the sauce was good, and the volume was perfect, too much cheese and not enough cook. When we got there it was busy, maybe an off night. read more

Visiting from VA, ordered delivery and have had authentic deep dish Chicago style pizza before. What we received looks and tastes like something you would buy at a gas station. Overpriced, overcooked, poor quality ingredients, no taste and cardboard crust. One star for looking edible. read more

Love the pizza, however very disapointed in the beef sandwich, overpriced and very small. For a few dollars more you can have a pizza. Highest price for a beef sandwich around for the size read more

The pizza is fantastic and the service is excellent. My favorite pizza is the Chicago without the onion. Delicious

The ChiTown Tots Are Great! We have been fans of this pizza place for a few years and typically order the Antipasti Plate Salad or Side Salads with our large pizza, but tonight we tried the ChiTown Tots appetizer ($10.00) just because it sounded good. Our server did tell us that it is very popular and we would enjoy it. So the plan was that we would have the Tots as an appetizer, then the pizza would come out as our meal. Not sure what happened tonight, but the pizza was out fast and the Tots were still in the oven, hence the lower rating for service tonight. As for the Tots - OUTSTANDING. The long porcelain 'boat' was loaded with crispy fried or baked tater tots, topped with Italian beef, giardiniera and topped with melted mozzarella cheese. This dish clearly spent some time in the oven as it was super hot and kept the tots hot from start to finish. My wife and split this and had just a little of our pizza. A great dinner once again at Chicago Pizza. read more

Chicago Pizza - ChiTown Tots Appetizer - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Average at best. If it's Chicago pizza it's on the low end of edible. Restaurant is old and everyone was there for the 50% off but guess what....seasons here so they lowered it to 25%. Regulars weren't happy. Would not entertain this place again. I'm from Chicago so I know pizza!! read more

Service: No greeter at the host station, sat at the bar for 10 minutes before my order was taken finally taken. Pizza took 25 minutes. s Worst pizza ever: Ordered the 12" Chicago White Pizza with mushrooms $17 for the pie, $2.50 for the 7 slices of canned mushrooms.... Pizza was over done, hard toasted, burn in spots with tough, flavorless, burnt crust, Their products don't show much care about quality control, proper preparation. Cardboard comes to mind. Even the grocery store frozen pizzas are better and school pizza are better than what they served up. $20 for 2 bites and then into the trash. read more

My favorite pizza in SWFL. Always good and consistent. Maybe I'm just lucky, but I've never had a bad pizza from here. A couple of times it could have used an extra minute in the oven, but overall, great pizza consistently. read more

Chicago Pizza - Thin crust with double sausage - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

This is the closest thing to home that I have found, the only thing missing is the Chicago service and warmth. This review is solely on the pizza. A friend recommended we try this spot and she helped me find a gem. The place is nice and open, it feels like an older Chicago restaurant, lots of Chicago memorabilia, but it does feel outdated. The staff was meh, not mean, but nothing amazing. We came here on a Sunday expecting to watch a bears game but we were shocked that they didn't have it playing and when asked they had no idea, it didn't make sense if you're establishment that is focused on all things Chicago. Regardless we got the tavern style, thin pizza and we loved it. Closest thing to home, I almost teared up when I saw the square slices. I heard the Italian beef is great, will try next time. read more

Chicago Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Food is fantastic! Staff is wonderful! Especially Kennedy!! Always look forward to discount pizza night on Tuesday. Keep up the good work.

Nice local hangout for chicago dogs, good pizza and beer. We love their Italian beef full dunk sandwiches. read more

Chicago Pizza - Chicago Deep Dish Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

I can never count on the pizza being made the same way each time I order it. Don't know if it's the transient nature of employees or what but it's delicious when someone takes the time to make it well otherwise it's a tossup and I don't mean the dough read more

Looking for some authentic Chicago style food. Yelp helped us find this place, arrived just after opening on Sunday morning, we had the place to ourselves for about 30 minutes, the service was off to a slow start so it gave me chance to absorb the good ole' days of the Chicago sports area when the city was full of exciting sports achievements, the decor was left behind in the late 80, early 90's sad the decorations had not kept up with the Cubs world series win, that in itself is an historical achievement. Ordered a tavern style cheese pizza, which was okay but not something I would have to come back for. Two Chicago style hot dogs and an Italian sub sandwich, the hot dogs were ok but not worth 8.50 each and the Italian sub was a little light on the meat portions. Again, definitely not making an extra trip for the food or to see the latest sports memorabilia or should I say the lack there of. read more

Some of the best pizza anywhere! We always have it when we are in Cape Coral. I am unashamed fan of deep dish...and they have the best!

watch out for many hidden fees when ordering to be delivered. will never order out from chicago pizza again read more

Chicago Pizza - My bill - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Chicago pizza was always a staple when I would visit my father in Cape Coral. However, with the changes that were made as far as the ingredients, I'll opt to order Little Cesar's. You can tell the drastic changes that have been made by new ownership. The dough tastes like that of a frozen pizza, the sauce is bland and the ingredients are sub par. Unfortunately, Chicago Pizza no longer produces "Chicago Pizza" and is more like any other pizza place trying to emulate it on a budget. read more

Hmmmmm. First and second visits were amazing with excellent pizza and the very best gold nuggets (garlic bread) you have ever had the pleasure of tasting. We tried to take guests for a third visit. The restaurant closes at 8PM on Mondays and we would arrive at 7:30 so we called to make sure it was okay. After the AI phone service said it was enough time, the guy who answered the phone was either high or half asleep. He made it clear that he was not interested in having any additional customers. We elected to try a new pizza place closer to home. The gold nuggets might make me overlook the poor experience, but we will have to be driving by and be hungry. We will no longer make the 35 minute drive. read more

Good service. Friendly staff. However we were disappointed in the pizza. The thin crust pizza is like a flatbread. They definitely have changed the recipe. Nowhere as good as it used to be. Unfortunate. read more

Used to be my favorite for delivery, last week I threw half of a $30 pizza in the trash, after waiting an hour and 20 minutes for it to arrive. The pizza tasted like it had been sitting out for an hour. Crust was crunchy and, and burnt pieces of cheese were on bottom of pizza. Having to order via a text, I can adapt to, but miss speaking with a human. read more

Stopped in for a "Chicago Italian Beef" sandwich, expecting an Italian roll, loaded with beef, and dipped in au jus. What I got was pre-packaged beef, dry, on a bun you would see in the bread section of the grocery store. I'm guessing they placed the dry beef in a dry bun, then put it in the oven to heat it up. Not even close to an Italian beef sandwich, what a disappointment. read more

This is our third visit to Chicago Pizza and yes we order pizza. We sit at the bar and enjoy a couple of drinks. The service is always good and the pizza is fantastic. Reminds me of back home. Nothing gets better than that. read more

My brother took me to lunch couple weeks ago on my birthday. I'm not big fan of thin crust pizza anywhere else but here. It is the best I've had by a mile. I even received a complimentary cannoli that was very nice touch We sat at the bar and our service was great! The bartender was on top of everything offering us another drink before ever having to ask. The prices are decent, in line with the quality read more

The employees here are super friendly and nice. The vibe is one of a neighborhood bar, and no one is a stranger. In fact I witnessed a birthday cake being presented to a patron at the bar. Then everyone sang happy birthday to him. How cool! And, if you're a Chicago Bears fan, you'll find Bear memorabilia adorning the walls. I ordered a 12 inch (small) cheese, and meatballs deep dish pizza ($20.00). To drink I had a Mich Ultra draft ($4.00). "Bryce" was my server and he did a great job - friendly, courteous, prompt, and hard working. It only took about 15 minutes for my pizza to arrive. The pizza was good. The sauce was good, and the cheese was very good. However, I was a little disappointed in the crust. It was dry (IMO) and I had difficulty cutting it with my knife - embarrassingly "launching" a small piece off my plate and table. But, no one was hit, so no foul, no harm, ha! I will definitely return to try their thin crust pizza and one of their famous Chicago Dogs, and Italian Beefs. There's a reason why they've won Cape Coral's Best Pizza, Beef, & Dogs six years running 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, & 2021. Make sure you check them out. read more

See all

I ordered a sandwich at 1230. when I arrived at 1250, there was not 1 employee there to serve me. an employee poked his head out after a few minutes telling me he was on the phone....it couldn't have been taking an order as they have an AI assistant answering their phone. after waiting a few minutes and seeing no one in site, I left. Bad business practice!!! read more

Pizza delivery was late and pizza cold when we received it. Driver said the establishment was packed and he waited 30 mins just to pick it up. read more

Amazingly good food and even better service I'm a Chicagoan and have been coming to SW Florida since I was young....I have NEVER been able to find good pizza down here...until today Their thin crust (which they SHOULD market as Tavern Style, the REAL Chicago style pizza...if you know ANYTHING about actual Chicago pizza ‍) was absolutely incredible ...I ordered mine with three toppings and extra sauce/crispy....unbelievably good , and the sausage has fennel seeds as it should If you are from Chicago and are looking for legit pizza from back home...this is as close as you're going to get I also ordered a Polish with fries, equally as well presented, fries were hand cut, et al Service was also absolutely top notch and took care of a solo customer grabbing some post happy hour food to Uber home with perfectly.... I honestly could not be happier with my first experience at this place ... good job read more

Chicago Pizza - Small Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

We ordered a thin crust cheese and a Chicago style meat which is what the receipt attached to the box said. It was supposed to have bacon, sausage, ham, & pepperoni. We received a thin crust cheese and a Chicago style pizza with a bunch of vegetables on it. I wasn't driving all the way back and waiting another half hour. When I think of a Chicago style pie this isn't it. What they're serving is just a thick crust pan pizza. The thin crust pizza was good. The pizza was OK but again not what I ordered and not what I was expecting. I probably wouldn't purchase from there again. read more

Chicago Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Ordered italian beef and pepperoni/sausage pizza. The beef was excellent and the pizza was delicious. Nice place, good service, reminds me of the many taverns I frequented in Chicago many years ago. Bears paraphernalia everywhere!! Enjoy. read more

Sorry lunch was not good very sparse and confusing this place usually a staple but disappointed with the lunch. If you are serving 1/2 a sub should tell the customer and load up the 1/2 sub I just don't leaving hungry my 1/2 sub was mostly the bread and VERY small. Would not recommend. read more

Never again. Companion and I stopped in for the lunch special. The menu said spaghetti and meatballs (plural) I had expected two. Meal included side salad which was acceptable and garlic bread which was good. All I got was spaghetti with sauce and not a meatball at all. I had to call the waitress back and ask if meatballs come with the bowl of spaghetti. She returned to kitchen and brought one meatball back. The dish was average at best. Companion had the lunch special 8" pizza with three toppings. It didn't look like any pizza I've ever seen. She ate about half of it and it was so bad she couldn't finish it. The waitress was also the bar maid. She wasn't rude but from her attitude she obviously didn't want be serving the booths. We both felt like we were bothering her. The place has the atmosphere of dive bar but certainly plenty of dive bars put out some tasty meals but not here. It isn't even worth a second chance, I'll never return. read more

Love their sausage & mushroom thin crust- had it today & was served by the lovely & efficient Brooke. Her attention to details was right on & her pleasant smile was-enjoyed. read more

This is a must stop okace for me and the family when we visit. Being from Chicago, it's nice to walk in and see all the Chicago sports memorabilia. We first went the other day but when we got there they said they were not serving food because they had no customers so released some of they staff. So we can the next day. Just a heads up if they close at 9 assume the kitchen closes one hour prior to that . We didn't know that and basically had 10 minutes to get 6 people to okace an order - wish they would have said something when we were first seated. The pizza is good and thin- nice and crunchy crust. The wings were decent and the fried raviolis were good - the house sale that accompany a tour meal looked plentiful and tasty . In my group we had a pizza - cheese raviolis and meat lasagne. I would recommend stopping again just would have an earlier meal Their lunch and happy hour specials looked good as well read more

See all

Over the years, Chicago Pizza has been hit or miss. I'm happy to say this evening, everything was fantastic. Our server was nice, attentive, and made sure or drinks were never empty. Forgot to grab a pic of loaded tots, but they were pretty good. Not great, I wouldn't get them again when they have much better appetizer options like their Chicago Nuggets but I also wasn't upset we got them, either. The pizza was just about perfect. We got the deep dish with sausage. And while it's not traditional "Chicago style" deep dish, it tasted great and the balance of toppings, sauce and crust was executed flawlessly. I can't say every experience here is this great, but hopefully this is the norm and not the exception from now on. read more

Chicago Pizza - Deep Dish Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Great, great place for classic Chicago food and pizza. Lots of snowbird Bears/Cubs fans hangout