Great store, cool to see the confectionery behind the glass too. A good selection of American candy…read moreand homemade things they produce themselves. The ambience is great, with the taffy bins resembling a small row boat! Service is great, there's also a 10% off discount for the first order when signing up for the rewards. Generally prices are reasonable too. Pretty funny they have the same store within 500 ish feet of each other. I'd go twice!

Fun candy store experience. There was quite a bit of variety to choose from, which makes it fun for…read moreeveryone. We ended up getting a taffy assortment to try, and the kid family members we were with opted for gummy sharks and sea creatures, and some gummy pizzas. I saw some people ahead of us getting frozen lemonades, which looked good. If my friend were with me, I know she would have gotten the chocolate covered gummy bears, which can be hard to come by. There's a little freezer with chocolate covered frozen bananas- in dark and milk chocolate varieties. It was the first time I had a dark chocolate covered frozen banana. It was awesome!

Amazing. So unique. Boston Pride. Definitely worthy to visit this place. Nice staff. Very friendly…read moreand I felt very comfortable shopping there.

I cannot even begin to tell you how unbelievable the fudge is from here!!…read moreI have been in search for a perfect penuche fudge for quite sometime. It is thee most delicious I have ever had. Other places I tried don't even come close!!!! Texture, freshness and unbelievable flavor - I have completed my search. I also bought another flavor to broaden my horizons and that was as equally delicious (chocolate kahlua). I actually am trying to figure out when I can actually get back there to purchase a larger amount. Not good - but soooo ridiculously good! Wonderful friendly staff - the whole experience is like a little bit of heaven!!! My new addiction -just sayn!! Jeanne A

Must stop for all! Candy is wonderful, fresh, lots of choices priced fairly and the gift options…read moreare fun and varied. Need a post card, a whatnot' the friendly staff is front and center. And they wrap for free.

RUDE EMPLOYEES!!! I asked to throw something in their trashcan so I could shop around with my…read morechildren, the old woman who works there went on a tangent about how employees aren't even allowed to use the trash there...I told her I'd take my business elsewhere, she then slammed the door behind me and my 2 children.

Mehhhh. Very cute store. Very friendly people, but the candy is subpar. The white almond bark is…read moregood, but the others just aren't worth the calories.

Picked up some small items as gifts. Fudge and chocolates tasted great! The service was fantastic…read moreas well.

What a selection! I was greeted when I entered by a woman who hand dipping carmallows…read more I picked out several items. All were delicious. I tried a few unique pieces such as dark chocolate cranberry pecan turtle and a blondie (chocolates dipped penuche ). Also a caramel filled non parrell. I'll be back.

Turtle Alley Chocolates are SO SO good. It's worth the drive and also worth ordering online to ship…read moreto someone as a gift! I live 50 minutes away and will take the ride just to grab my cashew clusters and drive back home. They're that good. I've gifted a box of their turtle clusters for my mom's birthday, Mother's Day, Christmas, and Valentines. Truly it's the perfect gift if you're on the hunt for good quality chocolate. Everything is made in-house and it tastes oh so good. They've also got fudge, Carmel, chocolate, candy, and more. There's so much to choose from in this cute store!

I was in here yesterday to pick up a friend & myself some mild chocolate nonpareils. I was sooooooo…read moredisappointed to see the increase in prices on their bagged candies & nuts and the contents being less than how much they use to fill the bags up with the product. I get that most everything has gone up in price but to give less and charge more is outrageous and I don't agree with it. I saw lots of things I wanted to buy & bring back home (Vegas) to share with my co-worker's but I just didn't want to pay the price for 1/2 the amount. It's definitely a great store to go in and look @ all their products, even stuff from your childhood. I'm sure out of towners have no problem spending the amount that Yummies is charging too so I'll save it for them!! Iol I did have to get some fudge as I saw they had my favorite which is penuchi without nuts & it was delicious!! This is a better deal because the price is based on weight, so no skimping there!! This is a must store to stop in if you have a sweet tooth and you're in town or close by!! They do have some souvenirs you can buy and a bunch of non-editable gifts. I did see the cutest stuffed lobster animal & wanted to buy it until I saw the price. Great selection of t-shirts too! Enjoy & have fun!

Whenever we're in Kittery, we always stop in Yummies to pick up some treats…read more This store has pretty much any candy you can think of, from salt water taffy, to fudge, to old time favorites that you haven't seen in years, it's truly a candy lover's delight. If you ever find yourself in the Kittery, ME area, you must stop in.

We stop by every time we're in town. This charming little candy shop is small but always bustling,…read morefilled with a huge variety of sweets. One of the coolest parts is their display of centuries-old candies they recovered. It's a neat bit of history because they're the oldest candy company in America. My favorite is the Bog Turtles, their Massachusetts take on classic turtles with dried cranberries, available in both milk and dark chocolate. They also have tons of adorable tourist souvenirs, like chocolate witches. I can never leave without grabbing a packet of Gibraltars, their signature snappy candy that melts in your mouth. The mint flavor is my go-to, but they have lemon too. If there's a line, it's worth the wait. It moves pretty quickly and the folks behind the counter are really nice.

I went in several times before Christmas for gifts for my kid's teachers and family members. Their…read morestaff is so friendly and knowledgeable. They answered all of my questions and helped with suggestions. Their selection was large and I was able to get everything I needed. They had premade boxes of chocolates and also offer gift wrapping. Their prices are per pound so you can get things in your budget. I found street parking and although their store seems small on the outside, you will not be disappointed when you stop in!

A great mix of local products and specialty products that are hard to find. The deck on the back…read morealso had an amazing view of the harbor.

Rude employees!! I made a purchase and the 2 employees continued their conversation, never…read moreacknowledged me or said a word. No greeting, no thank you, nothing. Really regret buying anything there. Won't make that mistake again.

This is a very nice candy store and the workers were friendly and exceptionally helpful…read more I was looking for some take home gifts, and after a quick Yelp search PennyCandys came up. They are located in a small-ish strip mall, and parking (private lot) was right outside. They have a variety of interesting sodas, candy, in-house chocolates, and fudge. My son got some Freeze dried skittles (is this an East coast thing?) and we bought some chocolates, pre-packaged fudge, and old-timey candy. Prices were very fair and the fudge (Valley fudge and candy) that I bought was delightful (peppermint!). I am not from the area, but I would revisit the next time I'm in town.

Great place to spend penny candy right next door to Methuen family restaurant . Old fashion as it…read morecan be

can never have enough candy. Yum…read more Service is awesome. when they were setting up to move I was devastated. Once I found out that they opened into another facility I was so Overjoyed. No One can take their place

I was very much looking forward to visiting because the reviews were so good. I was not impressed…read more. The candy bar was stale. The m&m's did not taste like real m&m's. The gummies tasted like chemicals.