Cancel

Open app

Search

Benchwarmers

2.0 (3 reviews)

Benchwarmers Photos

Business Info

Recommended Reviews - Benchwarmers

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

O'Bryan's Pub - Cup o Chili

O'Bryan's Pub

4.1(71 reviews)
39.2 mi
•$$

Great service, good food, fair prices. New open g of…read moreOBrians at new location looks much more roomy. Food came out quick. Restrooms could use a tune-up, but they were clean.

I hate writing bad reviews. It sucks the cool right out of me…read more Let's start with positives. Great parking lot. It was very busy but still plenty of parking. My soft drink was cold and wasn't flat We walked in to the restaurant and the waiting area was packed and people who were waiting for open tables as you try and seat yourself. We decided to go sit at the bar to eat. The restaurant is nice. Somewhat clean. Bathroom could have used some tlc We ordered our food, which for me was fish and chips and my friend got a club. BTW I was on the fence between the Reuben and fish chips but the waitress recommended the fish and chips so I went with that and I also ordered a bowl of broccoli cheddar soup. The soup came and I was starving so I dug in and after the first bite was looking for my drink as it was salty as heck. At this point I started having a bad feeling about the food and when my fish and chips showed up my feelings were unfortunately correct. The fish was drenched in oil that was burnt. It was so bad you could smell the burnt oil and even though my plate was full of the oil residue from the fries and fish I tried it. I was totally disgusted and even offered my friend to try it which he did and immediately spit out. I caught the waitress and showed it to her and she immediately apologized even though it had nothing to do with her and she got me a Reuben ordered. Btw the staff was great. The gal tending bar and the waitress who took care of us were great. I also want to add that my friend who ordered the club said it was good. I got the Reuben and again wasn't happy with how it turned out. At which point I asked for check and decided to leave as my stomach was doing hula hoops in disgust. Idk if it was an off day. It is a Sunday around 1pm but I wouldn't recommend it to anyone. Came out to $50 and imho I could have spent it way better. Idk if I will give it another shot, but who knows. Maybe Jersey Mikes would be safer......

Photos
O'Bryan's Pub - Chicken Finger Wrap

Chicken Finger Wrap

O'Bryan's Pub - Back off menu

Back off menu

O'Bryan's Pub - Untitled

See all

Untitled

Shore House Tavern - perch, bacon jalapeno mac

Shore House Tavern

4.5(146 reviews)
14.2 mi
•$$

When in downtown Sandusky, you can't find better food, better service, nor a better vibe than Shore…read moreHouse Tavern. The place radiates friendliness and you truly feel like a regular when you walk in, warmly greeted right away and taken care of the entire duration of your meal. My family had returned after a long day of theme park food and I needed something lite - and their seasonal salad was just what I needed. It was a very generous portion with some of my the sweetest strawberries I've ever had with candied walnuts, feta cheese, and a delicious vinaigrette to go along with it. Skip the theme park dining when you can - or at the very least, supplement it with this delicious cuisine and friendly service.

Our first night in Sandusky landed us in this small tavern right across Lake Erie…read more Very casual vibe and everyone was very accommodating but seemed overwhelmed. For an appetizer, we ordered the wedge salad and the Buffalo Chicken dip. I got the perch dinner for my main course. The kid got a chicken sandwich and my wife got the brisket Mac n cheese. They said that the kitchen was backed up. Honestly, it was totally not an issue. We were just relaxing, watching the game and chilling after a 7 hour drive from NJ. What was an issue was...... appetizers came out exactly the and time as the main courses. WHY????????? It couldn't have taken that long to throw blue cheese, bacon and tomatoes on a chunk of lettuce and pump out the Buffalo Chicken dip and then worry about the main courses later. Now we have to decide, do we want to eat the entrees or even touch the appetizers. That alone always ruins everything. Food was very good. Like I said, people were very nice but you just can't bring everything out at once. Defeats the point of "starting" with something.

Photos
Shore House Tavern - Interior bar area

Interior bar area

Shore House Tavern - Perch basket

Perch basket

Shore House Tavern - Exterior

See all

Exterior

Old Bag of Nails Pub - Fish & Chips

Old Bag of Nails Pub

3.1(103 reviews)
40.4 mi
•$$

Great place that originally was on the North side of Columbus and has now grown to multiple…read morelocations including Mansfield. I had been here originally years ago and the Fish has always been really good, beer has always been cold and the bar is fun and a great place to hang! I was in town to go to the OHSAA Football playoff game and the food was great, drinks were plentiful and the service & setting a lot of fun to spend some time! Get some Suavecito Tequila and everything would be perfect! The Great Lakes Christmas Ale was definitely enjoyed!

I love the ambiance of this place! I've gone two, maybe three, times now for dinner, and it has yet…read moreto be a bad experience. The last time I went I ended up getting in about an hour from closing time (not on purpose!) but even then the service was friendly and fast. I got a beer and fish and chips, since I'd been craving it for a while. It was decent, but not the best I've had. Somewhat bland and heavy on the batter. I do love their shoestring fries, they are super crispy and well-seasoned (and are super yummy with ranch if you like that). I've had their chicken tenders before, and I'd probably order those over the fish. I'd like to come back and try more items on the menu, though! My partner got the mussels and shrimp which are served in a nice spicy sauce (YUM). Overall a good dining experience and I'll definitely be coming back in the future.

Photos
Old Bag of Nails Pub - Fall cocktail list

Fall cocktail list

Old Bag of Nails Pub - Fish & Chips

Fish & Chips

Old Bag of Nails Pub - The patio was a little cold on this Saturday, but the bar was warm & comfortable with plenty of Great Lakes Christmas Ale.

See all

The patio was a little cold on this Saturday, but the bar was warm & comfortable with plenty of Great Lakes Christmas Ale.

Benchwarmers - pubs - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...