I'm going to admit right off the bat that I was so pleasantly surprised. We've been to Benchwarmers before and just thought it was ok. The service can be a bit slow overall, but not terribly so. I love the sports murals on the walls. This time I got the bone in wings because it was $1 per wing night. I got mostly drums and they were big. The breading was SO crispy and the chicken was juicy. It was honestly the best cooked plate of wings I've had in awhile. I got Parmesan garlic and teriyaki (I was sharing with kids who don't like spicy). The Parmesan garlic was not bad but not really to my taste. It was a bit vinegar-y(sour). The teriyaki was good but sweeter than I expected. I'm looking forward to trying more flavors. I also got a BLT salad also. It was a good size salad, good overall but I didn't like how tiny the bacon was, it's mostly a personal texture preference for that. read more

Benchwarmer's Grille - BLT salad - New American Near Me - Portage, Indiana

See all

Order from this place bc I was told their pretzel pizza is really good. I did a take out order with the pizza, mozzerella sticks, & their garlic cheese bread. The mozzerella sticks were alright. You can't go wrong with garlic cheese bread. The pizza? ITS OVER HALF CRUST. The tiny pizza part was actually good tasting. But the fact that they sold a pizza like this is just ridiculous. I should have checked it before I left since the place was 30 mins from home. The lady at the counter was nice and the place has a nice big spacious inside. Only recommendation I can make if you do order from here is to check your pizza before you leave. Especially if you want to order the pretzel pizza. read more

Benchwarmer's Grille - Pretzel Pizza - New American Near Me - Portage, Indiana

Grand slam burger was very good. Thick crispy bacon, big crispy onion ring and a toasted brioche bun. The patty was large and flavorful. The fries were crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. Service was great. We also got a pizza with ground sausage. The crust was a little dense, sauce is sweet than tangy, the cheese was nicely browned on the top. read more

Benchwarmer's Grille - Grand Slam - New American Near Me - Portage, Indiana

See all

I don't come here often, but this was the place to go after a long day lol I stopped in about two weeks ago with the bestie for a quick dinner. There were a few groups of people there . The vibe is generally the same, super warm and friendly . They had a 2$ drink special going. I don't remember the name of the it but it was made with tequila, Sprite and some grenadine I believe ... it was delicious. My server Brandy W. was incredibly polite and lovely . I ordered the Fried Green Tomato BLT and my friend ordered the shrimp alfredo. For starters we had the fried pickles which never disappoint. I couldn't decide between fries (I love their fries ) and tots and they let me order both with no up charge (I appreciated that) everything was piping hot and brought out in a timely manner. Our server did wonderful coming to check on us but not hovering . There wasn't a rush to be done quickly and I enjoyed just taking my time to conversate and laugh. I really appreciate how nice things have been each time I've visited. I didn't grab a pic of my friends food because she TUCKED in quickly lol I don't blame her lol. The BLT had fried green tomatoes of course, bacon , lettuce and pimento cheese.. yes you heard me right .. it was DELIGHTFUL! My total came out to 39.55. Thank you guys so much! I'm sure I'll be stopping in again at some point! read more

Benchwarmer's Grille - New American Near Me - Portage, Indiana

I used to be a regular here. My last experience ruined that when I pulled something long & stringy out of my burger

Decided to try this place since it was new and really close to our home. We were greeted quickly by a friendly young lady. My husband ordered the fried green tomatoes do an appetizer. Not my thing really. They give you quite a bit though, with a side of ranch. Sadly, it's not the "good" ranch. If you are a real ranch fan like me, you'll know what I mean. Unfortunately, the croutons were awful. They tasted like they were fried in oil that wasn't hot enough and just completely absorbed all the oil. I actually had to spit it out! I ordered the side salad and battered chicken sandwich. I know I should've ordered a grilled item since this place literally has grill in its name, but I wasn't in the mood for that. My husband ordered the shrimp. read more

Benchwarmer's Grille - New American Near Me - Portage, Indiana

Great food, great people, reasonably priced! Food was hot and cooked exactly how we ordered. Staff were fantastic. Will definitely be visiting again. read more

They were out of several things I wanted...Yuengling, Blue Moon, tater tots, blue cheese but the server was friendly and apologetic. Will I come back? Yes. The food was good....especially the pulled pork Mac and cheese. read more

Traveling to a friends lake house near Willard, we were stopping for gas, and dropped in for some food. The burger was cooked to a perfect medium rare, the tomatoes were fresh, and my wife's grilled chicken was flavorful, and not over cooked - hard dislike for over cooked, well anything.... It was a pleasant surprise, and when we head that way again, we will Def stop for a bite! read more

Average burger joint, nothing to knock your socks off, but not to stop us from dining again.

We had the grand slam burger and I'm telling you that it's the best burger I've had in a very long time, maybe ever. I wish I would have taken a pic of it but I dig in without thinking of a review pic. It was our first time at benchwarmers but it won't be my last. My problem is trying other options after that burger I hope they keep that chef, compliments to him/her read more

Deeply unsettling chi here. My wife says they have spirits inhabiting the walls. I not disbelieve her as she was once the shaman of our clan. She speaks to the walls and the dogs as well. We have divorced. I recommend the Hawaiin burger. read more

We went for lunch. I had the Philly Beefsteak which was very good. My husband had the Fiery Hot Burger which was good but messy. My favorite thing was the French fries. Crispy on the outside and creamy on the inside. No need for ketchup just good fries. You must go to Benchwarmer's Grille. Remember to get the fries. Portage location. read more

Great new restaurant in Portage. They must have a lot of their, new restaurant, bugs worked out. Food was great and the service was also. Try it, I liked it. read more

We just discovered the jewel today. Fantastic food. Great service. Killer ambiance. If you're looking for a great casual dining spot in LaPorte, give this place a try! read more

Great find! Syd did a great job guiding us through the menu and we were all able to find something great while listening to some great music! read more

Had the chicken Cesar salad. It's a huge salad could work for two. It is so fresh and awesome I would recommend it.

Great place for the whole family. They have a great variety of food to choose from. The people who work there are down to earth. The pizza is really good. read more

They have the BEST fried mushrooms ever! I would return for sure to try other items on the menu.

Had Italian beef with baked beans. Buns were very fresh sandwich was good. Beans tasted like a familiar brand you can buy in a can which was fine. read more

Food was average. Burger was the typical frozen patty. I did not like the fries because they are coated. The atmosphere was not good. A big open place. A small bar in the back. The murals on the walls were nicely done. read more

We came in on a Saturday afternoon with a group of 10 softball players plus their parents. The servers were quick, friendly and efficient and got us in and out without losing their minds. read more

Just utterly awful. I went last Monday while I was in town to visit family. I was the only person sitting at the beer, and it still took ten minutes just to be asked for my drink order. I then waited a full hour and a half before my food arrived - and not only was their pulled pork the most pathetic excuse for a pulled pork that I've ever seen, it was missing the fries. I got the boneless wings I ordered, but they will hard as rocks and barely edible. I finished my food, and waited another 20 minutes to get the check. At no point did anyone ask how anything was. No questions if my drink was good, if the food was good, or correct. Not my server, not the bartender, and not the cashier. I had to ask and they told me they were short staffed from people calling off. Apparently the management does nothing to prevent that and passes the buck to their customers. A tremendously awful experience and I will not be coming back on future trips to NW Indiana. Consolation prize: during the 90 minute wait of my food, a gentleman sat at the bar near me and asked how it was. I informed him of the terrible service and we chatted for a minute as he recommended some good local places. After a few minutes he still hadn't been served and he walked out. read more

The food was horrible. Service was good, our waitress was very helpful. They were out of pizza and pasta. The chicken was salty, vegetables soggy, and fries cold read more

We have been to benchwarmers several times! We have enjoyed carry out and dine in. Great food and service!

I tried Benchwarmer for the first time tonight with my wife. It was as the youths say "Bussin". Trinity took care of us and she was adamant I try the blue cheese, I am very picky when it comes to blue cheese so I was initially hesitant. Man am I glad I trusted her; it was phenomenal. I would return for the blue cheese and Trinity's hospitality alone! read more

Delicious food, friendly servers. The best mozzarella sticks I've ever had! Can't wait to go back!

We have dined here at least four times so far. The food has always been delicious and we were stuffed when we left. Have to try the pizza next time. read more

On an old-friends reunion tour, we trusted online reviews to select Benchwarmers. The food was very good, the beer was cold, and the recommendations from Ashley were spot on. As a former bowling alley associate now graduate to the limelight of client experience, Ashley should be trusted to point out the gastronomic highlights. Trust those online reviews... they were right about this place. read more

I tried the new restaurant on a Wednesday, middle of the week and it wasn't too busy. The boneless wings my other family ordered were fine but I ordered the shrimp dinner(at a much higher cost) and it was gross! They were soggy and they tasted like someone had put malt vinegar on them which I can't stand. $12 bucks wasted and still have to find something to eat. Just nasty..... restaurants are going to have trouble staying afloat if you can't serve decent food for what your charging. read more