Today was my first time car shopping, and I initially trusted the dealer when he said nothing was…read morewrong apart from the sound button not working. Took it in to the mechanic my family trusts just to be safe and thank god I did because there was ALOT of $$$ problems with it :(( leaking transmission, missing antenna, radio not working, air conditioning not getting cold enough, leaking sealant, just to name a few. My family thinks I've dodged a bullet, and it sounds like the mechanic was very through when they went through with it. It took about 2 hours and ran me about $200~ but saved me what would've been thousands in damages. The man at his desk (Larry) who I believe was the one who did the maintenance check was very nice to us even though we were almost half an hour late to our appointment initially, I was extremely apologetic and he didn't seem to mind at all.(again, very sorry about that) They even spoke to my family and recommended a dealership for us to try (didn't seem like a money grab, wasn't on a business card they wrote it on the back of a blank piece of paper in pen) so hopefully my car hunting goes better....

I had been having my car serviced here few times, I always happy after my service visits. The…read morestaffs are very professional and friendly. I also preferred few of my customers and families to have their car fixed here , all of them are happy with what they got. 100% satisfaction. Will continue supporting.

I've taken my car to Nakoma for more than 25 years, and have built up my trust in Dan over that…read moretime. He's fair and honest and does good work...all I could really ask for in a mechanic.

My parents have been bringing their cars here for many years. Fast courteous and knowledgeable…read moreservice at fair prices.

We had our jeep inspected by Eagan who were so helpful & honest after our mechanic retired. We…read moreread many on-line reviews being so POSITIVE that was our SAME EXPERIENCE with Eagan Automotive. Being disabled & on limited income we needed someone to inspect the Jeep to know if it was safe to drive. Honesty is critical for vehicles when you are traveling on highways with your loved ones. We bought 5 vehicles during my marriage at 1 dealership where we experienced being lied to learning that dealership was telling us our jeep needed a new part that a second opinion told us that was not true. My neighbor told us of their mechanic being honest & not overcharging shared people were driving from other States to have him work on their vehicle. We learned their mechanic quit working for this same dealership but he was at their Madison Dealership shared with us he ethically & morally quit because this dealership owner was charging customers for repairs they did not need to keep money coming in to pay his payroll expenses validated our experience at this owner's second site scared us. He retired that we were looking for a new mechanic that Eagan's Automotive provided us with EXCELLENT SERVICE & were HONEST..... which we read on-line I am giving them my review as the REPAIRMAN you need to go for repairs. They are very busy as a result. BRAVO EAGAN AUTOMOTIVE CREW for being HONEST REPAIRMEN as vehicles must be SAFE on highways with our family member's SAFETY being your #1 priority.

Great service and friendly, knowledgeable staff. Reasonable prices. Our durango had a rattle/click…read morenoise. We took it to Eagan for an inspeciton and found the driveshaft joint loose/worn out. Eagan removed & replaced the part and had the car back to us the following day. Apparently this prevelant design flaw on the dodge durango that hasn't been approved for recall.

Stopped by for a quick oil change and it was done within 30 minutes and I was only charged $30 for…read morea regular oil change! Such a great deal. I do have to say it did take a bit of waiting before a tech came out to assist me at the desk but nonetheless, will come back again!

great people, very knowledgeable and incredibly reasonable pricing! I would definitely come back if…read moreneeded!

Matt and Paul helped to squeeze me in after I got a flat tire in the middle of a trip! They were…read moreexcellent at accomodating me on short notice.

Disappointing Experience -- We Won't Be Returning-…read more This is a long one, but I feel it is important to share our experience. We were previous customers of Wrench's before the change in ownership, so when our vehicle needed work, we initially felt comfortable returning to a shop we had trusted in the past. Unfortunately, this experience was very different. We dropped our vehicle off overnight for an inspection and some needed work, including an issue with the trunk that would not fully open. The following day, we received a call informing us that the back windshield had spontaneously shattered while the vehicle was at their shop. We were told it was a huge mess and that they didn't know what had happened. We understand that unexpected things can happen. What became concerning was how the situation was handled. When we asked about security footage, we were initially told that there was footage. When we asked whether it showed our vehicle, we were then told that it only showed people coming and going. We were also told that additional footage existed but that someone would have to go through the entire day's footage to find anything. Our expectation was fairly simple: we hoped the shop would take responsibility for the broken window, replace it, and we would continue with the other work we had planned, including purchasing new tires from them. We also asked whether they had the neighboring body shop take a look at the trunk issue per their recommendation. Instead, the conversation became a back-and-forth about who would pay for the window. We were initially told the neighboring body shop was too busy, then that they wouldn't do it, and eventually that no one would be willing to install the glass. At this point, we were out of town and had a vehicle sitting at their property with a large missing window. After approximately a week and a half of back-and-forth, they finally agreed to have the glass replaced, but initially would not pay for it. After further discussion, they agreed to pay half, which was our suggestion. However, they did not provide us with a quote or keep us updated on the process.We repeatedly had to reach out ourselves asking basic questions: Had they found someone to install the glass? Was it being done? When would the vehicle be ready? Eventually, we were told our vehicle was finished--without any prior communication that the work had been completed. We were also told we should bring cash or a check because there would be a $30 credit card processing fee. When we asked how much we owed, they couldn't tell us the total. At that point, I did some research of my own. I called the first two auto glass companies that came up in a Google search, explained our situation, and both quoted us approximately $300-$400 for the replacement and said the installation would not be a problem. Wrench's ultimately chose a company in Illinois and the glass cost nearly $800. We were then presented with a bill of nearly $600 for the glass and an inspection fee. We were particularly frustrated by the inspection charge because the window broke while the vehicle was in their possession during the inspection, and we had no explanation for how or why it happened. After additional discussion, my husband was eventually able to get the inspection fee removed. The final cost to us was $388.03. What was most disappointing throughout this entire experience was the lack of communication, accountability, and customer service. At no point did we feel that there was genuine concern about what had happened to our vehicle or the inconvenience this caused us. Other than the initial "we're sorry, we don't know what happened" phone call, there was no meaningful apology or effort to make the situation right. We also never received the invoice we requested for the glass replacement, so we were left without documentation showing exactly what we were charged for. As people who have worked in small business, we understand that unexpected situations happen. What matters is how a business handles them. We would have been much more understanding if the situation had been handled with transparency, communication, and good customer service. We even intended to continue doing business with them and purchase new tires. Instead, this experience cost them not only our future business, but also our recommendation to friends and family. After nearly two weeks of having to repeatedly communicate, negotiate, and follow up just to get our vehicle back, we ultimately paid $388.03 and received our vehicle back in essentially the same condition it was in when we dropped it off, aside from the replacement of a window that broke while it was in their possession. Unfortunately, based on this experience, we will not be returning to Wrench's and cannot recommend them.

Our mechanic retired that we needed a TRUSTWORTHY HONEST REPAIRMAN & FOUND IT AT MIKE'S AUTO REPAIR…read morehere in Sun Prairie WI. He gave an extensive report & photos showing our 1999 JEEP could not be on the road anymore as I was going through a divorce having medical bills I was forced to keep my jeep functioning but sadly the WI SALT RUSTED the underside frame. Mike then helped inspect a VAN we were considering from a private owner to ensure it was a good safe vehicle for the price/milage vs price having more knowledge & experience than we do as previously I bought vehicles from dealerships but being disabled on fixed income I can't be stranded nor had money for any surprised repairs. This was so helpful to us to make sure we invested our money into a used van that will meet our needs for $6600. He gave us knowledge to handle this transaction with the title & checked so we were not scammed as we experienced looking for a used vehicle on CRAIGSLIST....that seller was lying that we caught them scared us because we are struggling it is SAD to almost be harmed that MIKE'S ASSISTANCE took away so much stress that is priceless when disabled, poor & suffering other issues. We gave a TIP he did not want to accept but we insisted telling him to buy lunch for his staff or give them each a $20 bill as I said his kindness helped us so much that he /staff needed a little treat. He is NOW OUR PERMANENT REPAIRMAN. We are suffering by Attorneys committing crimes to avoid liability that we have suffered deeply where Mike was an EARTH ANGEL SHOWING US HUMAN KINDNESS still exists. We moved to Sun Prairie after our trauma & always hearing wonderful things about Sun Prairie citizens.....has been 100% accurate being a BEAUTIFUL COMMUNITY.

This place is amazing! We went here today for a pre-purchase inspection of a vehicle we are…read moreconsidering purchasing. Mike was incredibly helpful, knowledgeable and kind. He took the time to carefully inspect the entire car, helping us not only to pinpoint possible problems down the road, but also to better understand the vehicle's history. You can tell he really enjoys what he does for a living. He also appreciates and treats his customers well! I would definitely recommend him to anyone with auto repair needs.

I've been taking my cars here for years after my neighbor said "he'd trust these guys with his…read morelife". Don't expect frilly greetings, hugs, customer satisfaction surveys or espresso in a decorative lounge. If you have parts preferences tell them before they start the work. I always ask and beg them to "fix everything you touch" but they always reply "don't fix what's not broke". Can't know if it's the right path but maybe it saves a lot of money. I've spent a ton there but never got sold blinker fluid or similar scams. Wait times can extend to a week sometimes. They'll give a ride nearby if you're not a jerk.

I hesitate to write this again because I'm concerned they've gotten so busy it can be hard to get…read morein, but they deserve it. They've been my mechanics for years. Lots of repairs, some small, some big. They've never hosed me, not once. Just the opposite, when stuff didn't need to be done, they told me and let me make the decision. These guys are real mechanics, its a working shop. If you want a slick shiny repair shop go somewhere else. If all you care about is that your vehicle is fixed right at a fair price, this is a place for you.

The kindest and most knowledgeable staff and owners in the area. Highly recommended. Best local…read moreauto shop in sun prairie.

Never going back here again. I brought my Kia Soul+ in for a tune-up, oil change, and transmission…read moreflush. The plugs and wires which I specifically asked for were not done, not sure if any of it was done. I did LOSE about 4 miles to the gallon after service, and there is increased hesitancy in acceleration now. I brought in my own oil/filter, AMS, which in every other vehicle I've owned, has INCREASED mileage by 2-3mpg. I don't know what these people got going on, but they certainly do not deserve the high rating they have. Take your vehicle elsewhere.