Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Bentley's Pet Stuff

    4.4 (5 reviews)
    Open 10:00 am - 6:00 pm
    Updated over 3 months ago

    Bentley's Pet Stuff Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Bentley's Pet Stuff

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Andy K.
    185
    560
    3068

    9 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Bentley's Pet Stuff

    You might also consider

    What's In The Bowl Pet Shop

    What's In The Bowl Pet Shop

    3.9
    (11 reviews)

    This place is sooo much more than just a pet shop. The owners really truly care about the health…read moreand happiness of your beloved fur baby. They are educators as well, and I have learned so much from the owner Amy about how best to take care of my dog. They are like family and they like seeing our animals as much as we do. It's so refreshing to see business owners be motivated by their love of animals instead of just money. You cannot go wrong with this place. It's a win win situation for human and animal alike .

    BUYER BEWARE! On…read more12/17/20 I purchased from "Whats In The Bowl Pet Shop" 15401 West National Ave. New Berlin WI. a "Huggle Hounds leather Bunny & Duck pack, #30794 under the name "Natural's." The price was $11.99 At the time of purchase I informed the sales person of my dog's breed, and age. I also mentioned that I wanted a "toy" that would be tuff, strong and most of all safe for her to play with. I was directed by the sales person to the afore mentioned toy. With her assurance that it would be perfect for my dog, thereby I purchased it for her. It must be stated that the reason I shopped at this "Premium Price Pet Store" is the perception that they are selling only "pet friendly" products and not the random, off shore products found at the larger chain stores. Unfortunately, in my case, that is only an illusion. Within less then 10 minutes my 10 month old Caviler had ripped a hole in the toy, had the Jute Fiber stuffing pulled out and the plastic squeaky insert in her mouth, which I had to pry from mouth to keep her from choking on! If I had not noticed this I have no doubt she would have been in serious trouble. I have NEVER seen a dog toy come apart so quickly! Yes. I know, there is a disclaimer on the back of the package that this is not a "toy." If not a toy, what is it, a wall hanging? I took the product back to the Pet Store, along with my receipt the next day. What occurred then only added insult to injury. I explained to the women behind the counter (owner?) what had happened. In what can only be described as an arrogant and insulting manner I was left with the impression that it was my fault for buying this item, and my dogs for putting it into her mouth! OMG! Whereby she informed me it was not their responsibility that I purchased this product! AT THE VERY LEAST; she should have said "I am very sorry this happened, can I give you a full refund, or help you pick out a more durable replacement?" That's called marketing 101 or "customer service." Which the "Whats In My Bowl Pet Shop," seems to have no knowledge of? I will take my business elsewhere, and encourage everyone I know to do the same. I am posting this review in hopes of keeping anyone else from making this kind of purchase and having more dire outcomes with their beloved pet.

    Happy Tails Pet Supplies

    Happy Tails Pet Supplies

    5.0
    (2 reviews)

    This place is fantastic. The owners, Ken and Tiffany, strive to make shopping there as convenient…read moreand positive as possible. They have an incentive plan so that once you reach a certain number of points you get a rewards card to use in the store. They will special order food for you and answer any questions you have about pet food or products, and they pride themselves on doing research about their products, to ensure quality. In addition, they have hired (always) the best staff. Each staff member has their own knowledge set and will also answer questions. They also are wonderful about retaining customers' names for that added personal touch. Their staff is intelligent, polite, kind, and helpful. I am so grateful to have this business in Hales Corners. They are only a half mile or so from the freeway exit and just south of Grange.

    Just as great as the Franklin location, and their rewards program is linked so you can still earn…read morepoints on purchases! Franklin is closer to me but the Hales Corners is also super convenient for me. Happy Tails is located in the strip mall adjacent to Festival Food on Hwy 100. Plenty of parking and close to the Dollar Tree if you need to pop in there as well (who doesn't!) for some items. The store is very clean and well organized. Toys, treats, food, grooming supplies and more. Prices are clearly marked on everything as well as the bulk treat bins. The staff are quite knowledgeable and takes time to listen and answer questions to the best of their ability. I'd definitely recommend to anyone. They carry high quality brands at competitive prices.

    Pet Supplies Plus Brookfield

    Pet Supplies Plus Brookfield

    4.4
    (29 reviews)

    First time here. We have a new cat, Stu. Stu is a young male who loves to play just as much as he…read moreloves to eat and sleep. I have found that many other pet suppliers have a pretty dismal selection of cat toys, while offering plenty for dogs. Since I was in the neighborhood, I decided to stop in and check this place out. They have a lot to choose from. I don't know if they carry every type of cat food, but the selection was far more extensive than I expected. On this visit, though, I was mostly interested in toys. I found exactly what I was looking for. In fact, they had four different versions of tunnels for Stu to crawl through. I ended up buying one with a very unique design. Definitely a place I would stop by again.

    I love coming to this location and have pretty consistently for the past several years now (since…read more2019). The staff is helpful and friendly, plus they are very nice to my quiet and well-behaved pups as they sit in the cart with me while I shop if they are with me. I enjoy shopping at this location. It is clean, well-stocked, easy to navigate, and I often find great deals. They also have rewards programs on certain styles of food and such. I typically order online for pick up when something is needed in a pinch. The process is a breeze and the staff is always very communicative if something I selected has sold out (only a handful of times over the years where online inventory during a peek sale hasn't caught up to in person purchases so not bad, IMO). Nothing but great experiences!

    Bentley's Pet Stuff - petstore - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...