I love this little dockside restaurant!!! It has a great view, great service and great food!! The pizza was so flavorful and had that perfect amount of "chew" to it. My salad was fresh and tasty as well. I'd come back any day! read more

Black Sheep - Pizza and Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

We eat here almost every time we come to Beaufort. The pizza is delicious and made with high-quality ingredients. Sometimes the service is excellent and other times it can be a little slow. Overall, we enjoy the food and would definitely recommend you give it a try. read more

See all

I wish I could give this restaurant 3.5 stars so I went up instead of down bc it was more positive than negative. A group of us camped for the weekend at cape lookout and my boyfriend and I stumbled upon this adorable water town. We checked the yelp reviews and menus and settled on black sheep. We were greeted and seated immediately. Not overly friendly but not rude. No smiles. Just, how many without looking up. Inside or out? We chose outside for the view even though we have had been water view all weekend. Waters were brought promptly. We ordered the crab dip as an appetizer. That came out in less than 10 minutes. Here's where the lower stars come in. Presentation was beautiful but the food was extremely bland. He ordered this sandwich with thick floppy bacon and pimento cheese. Again, presented beautifully and excited for the first bite... disappointed again. Bread was soft, bacon soft, with very little flavor. I ordered the wenny pizza. Crust was perfect and the pizza was beautiful. I ended up covering it with red peppers and Parmesan to liven it up as much as I could. 3/3 we're bland. Inside is a very cool, eclectic restaurant. It ran efficiently but nobody was overtly friendly. Nobody was smiling or acknowledging even. Walking into the bathroom, I even almost got trampled by a server not caring she was cutting me off walking. Bathroom was behind a huge photo of a man's face. read more

See all

A fun evening with pizza and draft beer! Popular waterfront spot with a great vibe and pleasant service. Look forward to returning. Indoor seating and pet-friendly outdoor seating availabe. read more

This is a fun casual restaurant on Beaufort's waterfront boardwalk area. They serve an interesting variety of 12" thin crust pizzas which make 6 slices and were perfect for the two of us. They carry an interesting variety of local beers on tap which I enjoyed. The service was friendly and attentive even though it was busy with large family groups. We had pizza, salads and my beer and it cost half of what a fancier restaurant was the night before. We would revisit again when here. read more

When you imagine a restaurant that can successfully appeal to all audiences, this place hits it on the head. The bar room is great for adults and the outdoor dining is great for families. Regardless of where you sit, be prepared for a bright, cheery atmosphere with great views of the bay. The food is delicious as well. read more

Black Sheep - Mediterranean Platter and happy fingers - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

Our first visit to Beaufort. What a nice town. We started with lunch at Black Sheep. The atmosphere was ok and the service was welcoming. We ordered a Caesar Salad, Pimento Cheese Dip, and a Sausage & Pepper Pizza. Everything was good but not outstanding. It was an interesting take on pimento cheese but the "ciabatta" was really just pizza crust which overlapped a bit too much with the pizza. I liked the flavors in the pizza toppings but the crust was pretty ordinary. A good meal though. read more

See all

My family and I all work in the food business - we LOVE great food- great food is very, very important to us. That being said, truly great food is unfortunately quite hard to find- especially in tourist destinations like The Outer Banks. I have come to rely on Yelp to help steer us in the right direction in any city we're visiting. I saw Black Sheep rated fairly high- the menu looked interesting and the atmosphere/ location, well the Beaufort Waterfront is tough to beat. So we ventured over there this evening after a few hours at the beach. We were seated quickly outside (just as we were hoping) - the hostess and our server were quite warm and welcoming. We had two of the specials, one of which was a Watermelon Gazpacho - DANG...we all wished we had ordered a bowl with a to-go vat for home! We had several sandwiches (the Cuban and Beaufort Cheesesteak) as well as the Tomato Pie. Everything on our plates was very obviously made with love and care. There was not a single "throw-away" component. The Pickled Golden Beats, the Potato Salad, the homemade Focaccia, the House-Cured Pork - etc....everything was given thought and made with excellence. There were 5 of us picky food snobs in our party- we all tasted every component on each others plates and we all walked away thoroughly impressed and amazed at what great eats we had just experienced. Thank you for putting such love and thought and heart into your food - it matched at beauty of your location and gave us a truly memorable evening as a family / we left thoroughly blessed and thankful that we dined at Black Sheep this evening! read more

Cuban sandwich very good , pepperoni pizza with caramelized onions very good and wife had the golden beet salad very good with fresh shrimp. read more

Black Sheep - Pepperoni pizza and golden beet salad - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

My family and I are staying about 30 minutes outside of Beaufort but had a craving for pizza and this place didn't disappoint. The pizza was thin and crispy and perfectly cooked. We ordered one cheese and one pepperoni pizza and devoured them. My wife had a beet salad as well and it was also quite tasty. Our server Mikayla was pleasant and attentive! We are in the area for two weeks and I'm hoping we can make it back for more great eats! read more

Black Sheep - Pizza time! - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

Pizza was delicious, great crust! Yummy Caesar salad, next time I'd order it without the anchovies. read more

Black Sheep - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

We ordered several pizzas for the table and they were all good, spirts were also nice. We had to listen to a screaming child and I would still give it a good review! read more

Enjoyed the thin crust pizza. Wait staff was incredibly attentive. Nice vibe. If it had been a little warmer, we would have loved to sit on the deck and enjoy the amazing water view. We will be back! read more

The bad thing is they are Busy during spring and summer hours and hard to find a parking spot. The good side is Theres shops to check out on the streets while waiting and a nice waterfront seating area to hang out around while waiting. The menus outside, you have to scan the QR code to read the menu online. Kinda inconvenient for some people. We got pizza rolls, mac and cheese and a pizza. The foods really good and has a homemade taste. The pizza rolls are really tasty and kid friendly. The marinara sauce is kinda tangy but not hot. The mac and cheese is light tasting and good as well! Also kid friendly. The pizza we received is about 12 inches around. It was light on the sauce and thin. Not a deep dish kinda pizza but a thin crust style. The bacon is good and thin. The sausage is kinda sweet tasting. Over all the pizza was kinda sweet and salty tasting. Not bad. Not what I was expecting from a pizza though. I would come back here again. Id plan ahead to wait 30 mins due to traffic, parking and people. Thats the down side for sure and reason for 4 stars. The view is super nice on the porch though. Boats, water and sometimes horses. ^_^. Very nice view. read more

See all

AMAZING food and service. We will be back. We loved the atmosphere too. We sat outside near the water! read more

Black Sheep - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

See all

Pizza was super tasty & had a fun atmosphere. Food was fast and ready. The view of the water was breathtaking.

Black Sheep is absolutely wonderful. Great outdoor dining option with a spectacular waterfront view in beautiful Beaufort. Service was wonderful and the pizza was spectacular! Nice kids meal selection as well. This was our first time at Black Sheep but we will definitely be back. read more

Brick oven pizza at its best! We took a drive looking for a place to stop for dinner. We drove by several places, decided to park, walk and commit to a place. We landed on the Black Sheep and SO glad we did! We sat outside on the water (it was dark so we couldn't see much but it was a beautiful evening so we couldn't resist. Our waitress was amazing - she explained everything and we heard her doing to same to the tables around us. They have a full bar and also serve NC craft beers on tap. I had the pepperoni pizza and my husband went with the pulled pork pizza. Both were SO good that we didn't want to stop eating - although we forced ourselves so we'd be able to enjoy the next day. Their prices are very reasonable, too! HIGHLY recommend!!! read more

See all

Perfect location on the water. Pizzas were AMAZING! Painkillers nice and cold. Service attentive and quick. Watch the water, have some scrumptious food, enjoy a cocktail, ORDER THE PIZZA! Any of them. read more

Food is always amazing, service is great, and the location is perfect for a day of shopping and enjoying sightseeing on the town.

Are you serious? 1/2 capacity = 30 min wait. Charcuterie plate 30 min wait. I realize the pandemic has hurt us all but we watched food roll out of the kitchen. Then it showed up sweaty and hot. At least cut your charcuterie meats please read more

Black Sheep - UNC hopped prosciutto - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

Crostini was fantastic. The charcuterie board was good. The boys had pizza and pizza rolls, both were good. The wait staff was friendly. Again, the crostini was fantastic! read more

This is my third review as I've now become a regular at Black Sheep, visiting at least once a month. I love this place and it keeps getting better. From delicious food and drinks every day to their wine and cheese events, we always enjoy a night at the Black Sheep. Highly recommend the pizzas, the beet salad and the Mediterranean platter. The staff is great too!! Updating my review after another visit. We went on a holiday weekend and sat at the bar. Rinks were top notch-best Dark and Stormy in Beaufort. We ordered the Wenny pizza and the flavors were perfect. Really delicious. It was also served fairly quickly. Great service. From my first review: First the good stuff...the location of this restaurant is perfect. Waterfront with both outdoor seating and an indoor bar that faces the water. They also have a nice list of cocktails so it's a good spot for a drink. Now the reason for only 2 stars (would be 2.5 if Yelp allowed half stars). They have a limited menu and I'm pescatarian, so my options were small right out of the gate. But then they were out of three of the items I tried to order. Bad planning on a holiday weekend. We ended up having to finish our drinks and go elsewhere for dinner. I'll update the review if we have a different experience in the future because I really want to like this place. read more

See all

First of all the pizza was a home run like a five out five. But if I'm ever here again; I will just get the pizza and go! Our waitress was very unprofessional and rude. After she took our order, she only came back to our table once. I had to ask someone else for napkins, a box, and the check, after I waited for 20 minutes. So the restaurant service NOT the pizza get the score. Get the pizza to go and forgettabout the rest!!! read more

Black Sheep - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

Black Sheep has good food, and an entertaining outdoor seating area. Great pizza, good salad, soup, as well as other tasty dishes. read more

Black Sheep - Soup - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

See all

First visit. Great selection of sandwiches. I had the Cuban. It was wonderful. I could probably order two or three other sandwiches off of their menu and be equally as happy. read more

Like others, my review does not reflect the food but the service. We had drinks and the Mediterranean platter. The food was good, and the drinks were fine (one was sweet but that's the chance you take). We ordered 1 pizza - Sausage and pepper. We were not in a rush and we had told the waiter (Thomas) this but we waited over 1 hour for a pizza that never came! We asked one of the servers to check on our pizza and our waiter, Thomas, told us the at kitchen was "slammed" and he was sorry for the wait. Wait, wait, wait and watched others get served and still no pizza. Finally we had enough and asked for our check and the manager. Blah, blah, blah with excuses. We did get our pizza with the check and were comped the pizza but an hour for a pizza that took 3 minutes to cook was rediculus. We are local and have eaten here before and will again. The food is good, and the pizzas are really good. We have never had this experience before so GET THE SERVICE RIGHT!!!! read more

Pizza was charred. Very little toppings Expected more after reading reviews Artisan Pizzas read more

The food was great! The service left something to be desired. We loved sitting outside but felt rushed out despite the fact that there were open tables read more

Excellent spot on Beaufort waterfront to eat and superb pizza ! We eat there every time we go to Beaufort for sure.... Love there different soups and especially the gazpacho (sp)....cold soup. Give it a try and you will not be disappointed! read more

See all

Good pizza, gluten free and vegan options, fantastic pita. Service is good, sitting outside our inside is pleasant and 80s tunes playing for fun. read more

REAL Italian pizza in a southern beach town??? Check out the pics; this place is foodie central. Most places with superb view of the water and sunset are mediocre; this place is a real Italian style farm-to-table pizza place with fresh local shrimp and seafood featured in their daily and regular menus. The owner told me they import their meats from spain and their flour from italy, with veggies pickled in house and sourced locally. We enjoyed the lunch so much we returned for a late dinner. For lunch we had a daily special, watermelon gazpacho with avocado- it was refreshingly crisp, a bit spicy and really showed off the local tomatoes. We also had a roasted and pickled beet salad with a very fresh spicy arugula fennel mix and light cheese in vinaigrette. They served it to us as a split entree. This would be a perfect hot day repast, or hangover cure. For dinner we had the local nc shrimp pizza and the mixed charcuterie plate. Our plate featured Speck, prochutto and serranno ham and sopasadas, derby sage, ginger apricot stilton, manchego, olives and red pepper medly, with toasted baguette slices. The shrimp was just perfectly cooked, not rubbery like one might expect, so you can taste the sweetness of the shrimp. But wow that thin Italian style pizza dough, a bit buttery and tasted, very light with a very soft chew, was as authentic as the pizzas I've had in italy. I really liked the complex and high quality chatucerie plate. That would be a great group snack or instant picnic for a boat excursion to shackleford banks. Fantastic place! read more

See all

I got the pizza bites and omg they were to die for! Highly recommended! Their pizza was so good will be returning

Very good food. Friendly staff, dog friendly right on the water. Solid meal and overall good experience. read more

Black Sheep - Patio seating. - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

This place was amazing we had a party of 8 so it took a while but well worth the wait. Fresh brick oven pizza. The mozzarella sticks were the best we ever had. One of our folks has a Cuban and loved it. Highly recommend read more

The location and views here are top notch but I didn't get pictures of that because I was more concerned with the delicious food that had just been placed in front of me!! I got the Santorini pizza (cheese, prosciutto, spinach, and tomato), and it was so yummy. The crust thin and fresh. I highly recommend! A friend of mine ordered the Black Sheep BPT sandwich (bacon, pimento cheese, and fried green tomato). I didn't hear a word from her for the whole meal other than to say how amazing it was (so I may have to try that next). I also suggest the Dark and Stormy and the Painkiller from their cocktail menu. We will be back for sure!! read more

Black Sheep - Santorini Pizza (spinach, tomato, prosciutto, cheese) SO yummy!! - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

See all

It was a beautiful unseasonably warm Thursday afternoon and a few places were closed as it's off season and I was so happy to learn this one was open! We opted for the beautiful waterfront seating as we had our dogs with us. We sat down and I followed the instructions on the table to open my camera on my phone to take a photo of a QR code and it pulled up the menu. No app needed. Very cool! There were multiple daily specials and the menu is updated daily to show - which is another reason I thought the QR scanning was so convenient and cool! My husband and I had the tomato pizza and my oh my it was delicious! Perfectly baked and seasoned- with a couple different kinds of cheeses. Our waitress (Maread- I'm sure I botched the spelling- sorry!) was super informative, attentive and friendly. We engaged in conversations about our shared loved of dogs which I always love. We would come back for sure- one of the more welcoming and efficient places we dined at on our trip to the crystal coast. read more

See all

Amazing!! I loved the pepper and sausage pizza. We were visiting Nc staying in Morehead, I got this pizza and the frozen painkiller. They were so good we came back before our trip was over. Honestly I'm craving this pizza while typing this... read more

Finally was able to get back here and try their pizza, and really glad we did. We are still a little reluctant to do indoor dining, so we decided to pick up a couple of pies and have a picnic. The online ordering was a breeze, and they were kind enough to drop it off at our car, so that covid experience was top notch. The pizzas were delicious and prepared exactly the way we ordered them. Try this place, you'll like it! read more

Black Sheep is the best casual restaurant in Beaufort. The view from the patio is great and we're always seated quickly. The food is delicious, especially the crab dip and the selection of desserts. The service here is fantastic and our most recent waitress Megan was very friendly and helpful. Can't wait to visit again! read more

Black Sheep - Dims Good Crab Dip - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina