The service was friendly and fast. The place was very clean. My son ordered the club sandwich and…read morefries with a chili dog and said that all of it was tasty and plentiful. The chocolate malt was delicious! I ordered a burger with onion rings and it was good. The onion rings were fried to perfection and I had way more than I could eat! The fried mushrooms were also delicious and crispy. Yes, I recommend this staple if ever in New Iberia!

Very good food homemade atmosphere relaxing large portions waitress polite,kiss da cookread more

Slop small portions, serving leftovers food,I had bring food back 3x.the workers got attuide not…read moremy fault u don't like your job

Very good home cooked meals. Love the food and everyone is so nice. They can cook. Price is very…read morereasonable too. You will love it too.

Visiting Louisiana and had never had boudin or cracklin before. Delicious! And the meat selection…read moreis phenomenal! Staff is pleasant and quick service!

You have to try Chicken Cracklings! You will never forget them! Everything else is awesome too…read moreBoudin Balls, Boudin roll ups, hamburgers!

If you're in the area, Castalano's is a must! Please note their hours & the lunch rush. The…read morerestaurant is small & you may not be able to get a table. My favorite dish is the eggplant parmesan. The Sunday gravy served over crispy eggplant and angel hair pasta is a treat for your tastebuds. The sauce is a dark red, sweeter spaghetti sauce. Other recommendations include the Mardi Gras burger, tropical salad, adult grilled cheese, and all the desserts. We have ordered sandwich/wrap trays for family celebrations. The trays definitely add more pizazz than a basic sandwich tray.

Definitely a place one should frequent. Delicious food. Very good serving sizes. Ambiance is very…read moreinviting. The BEST waitresses around!!!

Gross. Inedible. Brown lettuce and bad meat. Wet bread. Pre-made and stuck in the frig for days and…read moredays. Go somewhere else, anywhere else.

Passing through and stopped for for quick gas fill up and food. I was a little apprehensive with…read moregetting food from a connivence store, but was looking for something with a little more local flavor than McDonalds; this was the only close option that would be quick and easy. Got the Po-Boy, with fries. Food is very fresh, cooked to order, and the staff was very friendly. The sandwich was awesome and would certainly chose it again.

Today I ordered their shrimp poboy and fries, the ingredients are always fresh and I like the soft…read morefrench bread they use. Great place to stop for a quick bite.

Great deli inside the Exxon station. The deli has several…read morePo-boy and burger options as well as pizza. They have a variety of cold pre-made sandwiches and Po-boys. During the weekday, they have other pre-prepared options. They do have a few picnic tables outside if you need to eat there, but they are out in the sun. Glad to find this place.

The food was absolutely fantastic -- rich in flavor and clearly crafted with care. Unfortunately,…read morethe service fell far short of expectations. We waited over an hour for our meals, after a 20-minute delay just to have our order taken. During that time, we watched multiple tables that were seated at least 30 minutes after us receive -- and finish -- the very same dishes we had ordered. By the time our food finally arrived, the restaurant was nearly empty. To make matters worse, the $20 fried gator po'boy initially arrived cold and rubbery, and had to be sent back. Thankfully, when it was remade, it was everything it should have been: hot, crispy on the outside, tender and juicy within, and bursting with flavor -- easily the highlight of the meal. Adding to the frustration, our appetizer, which had been ordered with our drinks, wasn't brought out until we were nearly done eating. That said, if you're fortunate enough to receive your food hot and in a timely manner, the kitchen clearly has the potential to impress. I might consider giving the place one more try for the food alone -- but given the poor service, it's unlikely. Hence, the one-star review.

We ate here in July, and it was good. Would stop in again for a quick bite. Lots of smiling,…read morefriendly faces, and fast service!

The best food ever the roast beef n gravy to die for. Been going here for years and never…read moredisappointed.

Glad we found this business on Yelp. We stopped on our road trip passing through on I10 and glad we…read moremade the detour. Took about 10 mins off the highway. We had the shrimp poboy and fries- which we split between two people and were plenty full. They have Cajun seasoning, hot sauce and plenty of napkins on the tables. You can eat indoor or outdoor. Plenty of drink selections!! The place is clean and you can even watch the fryers through a window. We had a poboy in New Orleans a few weeks before and it was no comparison to the one we had at Old Tyme--filled with large shrimp and plenty of them. We would detour here again. It is not a grocery store anymore...but a darn good place to eat. Lots of college vibes for the local university as well. Nice bathrooms that have funny decorations for him and her.