It doesn't look like much from the outside, but inside was nicely decorated with Italian pizza decor with Italian crooner music for ambience. Friendly server took our orders and the drinks and food came out timely. Our loaded nachos were good, though the nacho cheese was a bit runny and pooled in the bottom. My grandsons loved their pepperoni calzone and Mac and cheese. My personal pan Meathead pizza was very good; tasty with a nice crisp crust. My wife enjoyed her chicken Tuscany pizza. Both personal pizzas were bigger than expected and very filling. Would definitely stop in again if in the area. read more

See all

Had supreme pizza for 1 and wife had cream of mushroom soup. Both were serviced warn and were very tasty. I had a bloody Mary with plenty of trimmings. Will eat there again soon. read more

We had the fish fry. It was excellent! Our server was so friendly & helpful. Great experience all around!

Nice pizza pub with excellent pizza and good service. I live 20 miles away but will definitely return for some of their excellent pizza

My qualifications: grew up in NJ, went to college in MA, and have spent extensive time in CT. When I moved out here with my boyfriend, we knew we needed to find a pizza place with, at the very least, a competitive pizza. Brickhouse is that place (btw, ask for the pizza well done). As a chicken caesar wrap connoisseur, this one ranks high for me. Service can take a little longer, but the food is always worth it! Our waitress remembers us now :) read more

Best pizza I've ever heard. Staff was really friendly and the restaurant was clean. Service was fast and food was great. Tastes really good.

Excellent Pizza! We had two different kinds of pizza and the cheesy sticks which were all delicious with crispy and yet chewy crust. Friendly service and very clean inside. Highly recommend! read more

Brickhouse Pizza Pub - Pizza Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

See all

amazing food, especially wings and pizza. great service, clean. me and my daughter go there often

Great pizza - the price was a little higher than I'd like but good pie. I ordered online and ordered a large pizza. I ordered pepperoni, sausage on one half, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers and onions on the other. The system seemed to charge me twice for pepperoni and sausage. read more

We were a party of eight out for a Mother's Day lunch. Our meal was done, bill paid (with a substantial tip), and we were enjoying everyone's company when we were asked to leave. We were told that a reservation was coming in and they needed the tables. That may have been true, however there were three tables behind us that could have been pushed together. My guess is they were upset we were no longer a paying customer. I have never been kicked out of a restaurant. I don't care how good the pizza is, I will NEVER go back. read more

Good pizza, many different choices, friendly staff, epic radio, mega comfy booths. Overall, would visit again.

Friendly service willing to accommodate a large group (15+) with no notice, good food and a relaxed atmosphere- definitely stop here again when we're in the area! read more

I'm a pizza lover, so anytime I have a chance to try a pizza spot, I make it happen. I was visiting family members recently and we all decided to come here on a Saturday night to have dinner together. We arrived around 7pm and the restaurant was almost empty. We figured we'd get good service since there wasn't many people inside, but unfortunately, we ended up getting a waitress that rushed us out of there. She was very pushy with wanting to get our orders and we were all halfway through with our meals when she came over twice asking us if we were finished so that she could clean our table off. My guess is that she expected she would get let go for the night once our table was gone. Well, for the fast meal that we had, we started off with Cheese Curds, which were unlike any other cheese curds I've had. The Cheese Curds were about 3 times the size of normal cheese curds and they were a lot crispier. They seemed to be deep fried, which weren't what I was expecting. I prefer cheese curds that are smaller where I can pop them in my mouth instead of having to use a fork and knife. My mother-in-law and I shared the party size pizza, where we got half cheese and half pepperoni. Our waitress was really shocked that we ordered a party size, but why not? It's pizza and no one can call themselves on a diet when eating pizza. The pizza came out hot and fresh. I loved the cheese pizza and liked the pepperoni. The bread was thin, and the cheese and sauce were also good. It's not the best pizza I've had, but for a small town, I thought it was delicious. I also had a bite of the Gyro Pizza and I didn't prefer it at all. I think that the personal pan pizzas have a different bread than the party size pizza, as the personal pizza was not crispy at all. I'd come again! read more

See all

For a local hole in the wall this place is super cute. Pizza quality was great. Crisp crust almost like a corn meal texture. Bartender was busy but kept up. Prices are fair. Shoe string onion rings were to die for. We will be back read more

Have ordered in the past and always got what I ordered, however, for the last 3 weeks they have gotten the order wrong. I ordered a party sized, thin crust pizza, and 12 wings with no sauce. I live a quarter mile away. It took almost an hour to get my food, which was cold, the wings had no breading and looked half done. When my wife called, she was told I asked for no breading, and there was nothing they could do to make it right. They were all out of wings! No apology. No nothing. Horrible customer service. Mediocre food. Threw the wings out. read more

Love their Philly Cheese Steak pizza! They have personal size pizzas with quite a few to choose from. All great food.

This place is great. It was recommended to me by a co-worker, and I am glad I took them up on their suggestion. Huge menu and really good pizzas! I highly recommend anyone in the area to check them out! read more

Looking for a great pizza for about the same price as the big chains? This is a great delivery option. Pizza was warm, fresh and delivered with a smile. It's a great pizza - thin, crispy crust with just the right amount of sauce and toppings. Definitely among the better pizzas I've had delivered during my travels. read more

My husband and I stopped there for dinner. It was very busy with few waitresses working. That's how it is everywhere now though. The food was good nothing to complain about. Prices seemed about right. We ordered the cheese curds and a supreme pizza, both were good. I'd recommend it to others. read more

This place definitely serves up some good stuff. Made two trips there while working in town this week. First was on Wed and we got $0.50 wings. Left stuffed and met a Angel and Devil (it was Halloween) food and staff was so good we made a round 2 today for burgers and a tried the "El Diablo" burger and was burning up for a second there. I would have to vote thumbs up! read more

Brickhouse Pizza Pub - chicken wings, celery, and fries - Pizza Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

Edited below to address owners comments. The kids meals - chicken tenders should NOT have been the highlight of our meal. The pizza was so so - sauce was tough to find, average at best. The fish fry is awful. The baked fish - inedible. The fried was ok, nothing at all to write home about. It looks like the Gorton's fisherman fish filets. Tastes a little better. You get about a teaspoon of tarter sauce, the potato pancakes have zero seasoning. Disappointing. We'd heard good things. Supposedly kids eat free - except they don't. There are all sorts of stipulations. Apparently fish fry is a promotion so no kids meal. I'm pretty sure anything that costs $12 and is subpar shouldn't be seen as a promotion. Now, pizza should include a kids meal, but seeing I ordered fish, still no supposed free kids meal. Which our server did not properly explain. She did explain the fish fry part, so we were all - fine, at least one kids meal included. So we paid over $40 for a really frustrating and crappy meal. We don't go out nearly as often as we'd like now that we have two kids - so it's doubly frustrating to be so disappointed. ----------- Editing to address owners comments - We did clarify - the gentleman, my husband - said, oh, so if we get something other than fish fry then a kid will eat free. She said yes. She did NOT specify that if ANYONE at the table ordered fish at least one wouldn't get it. She said one kids meal per adult. And it doesn't matter even if for some reason we were misunderstood. Regardless of all it's a ridiculous rule - either kids eat free or they don't. It's right up there with their bizarre half price pizza rule and you can take your leftovers home. What the heck is that? Now, back to our issue we didn't even set out to get free kids meals, we saw the sign when we arrived. It's the principle of it all. Either kids eat free all month or they don't. It's that simple. Do NOT Bait & Switch people. Do not lure people in, fill your seats and give them a list of rules on how to get your kids a free meal. It's poor business practice. And the dig about getting more cod? Well um, seeing my other two baked pieces were inedible, I most certainly did order twice more. The filets are tiny. I won't be contacting the owner privately. I do not want a gift card, we will not be returning. read more

Brickhouse Pizza Pub - Except they don't really if you have a fish fry or any other promotional item at the table. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

See all

Great pizza and service! Ordered to go and they had a mishap "over cooking" the pizza- it was actually done perfect to my liking. They offered me a drink on the house while i waited for a new one...looking forward to going back read more

I ordered the Tai pasta. Every bit as delicious as in-house. Delivery was prompt, and very friendly. Thank you!!

We stopped here because sign outside said half price appetizers. We started to order and were told that sign is wrong. That was for Sunday. We didn't change our sign. Too bad for us. We used to go there once a week. Service was great. We used to go on the night Rachel worked. She is long gone and this place has really gone down hill. Tonight I had a Thai pasta. Chicken in pasta was like trying to chew shoe leather I left most of the chicken behind. Decided a dentist visit was not in my future. I mentioned this to my server. Her response was interesting. Sometimes chicken is awful sometimes awesome. You happened to come in when it was bad. Surprising response. Just pay the bill. Take your time. So I paid but that's my last visit to this restaurant read more

Ordered pizza for delivery while staying in Fort Atkinson. Had to get a large to qualify for delivery. Not a biggie. Came on time and was very fresh. Tasty crust - not too thick or thin, bit of a yeast flavor which I like, good sized mushrooms and green peppers - not thin sliced or diced fine (hate that). Lots of cheese. Only critique is that it needed a bit more flavor. Oregano or garlic or something. Wasn't bland, but needed something. Very good though. Menu had lots of other cool untraditional topping options too. read more

Brickhouse Pizza Pub - Supreme pizza with no onions. Tasty! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

I am obsessed with the Diablo burger at this place and order it for myself whenever I can. It's good to find food in a small midwestern town that has flavor and spice! The mac and cheese is also pretty tasty. I love that they do pickup too! Absolutely recommend! read more

Never had a bad meal there and service is very good. Attentive to our needs and special requests. I love their pizza the best but calzone not bad either. read more

As a long haul truck driver, I get to visit a lot of places, and use the local places. I must say that the delivery driver was about 10 minutes early (told 45 minutes) showed up in 35 mins. Was very polite and order was piping hot. (Ordered wings). Wings are large, nothing worst then baby wings ( 1 bite and your done, you know the type). read more

Came back home for a visit, had never been to this place before and was pleasantly surprised. Very nice, warm, cozy interior. Friendly service and our Friday fish fry was delicious. FYI they also brought us bread and a delicious garlic/pepper dipping oil (didn't have to ask as previous reviews commented). Pretty good place for Fort - coming back and trying to eat out has always been an issue especially since old mainstays in town seem to go downhill - hope this place stays around. Food on other patrons' tables looked good would like to try other menu items next time! read more

Brickhouse Pizza Pub - Bread & garlic/chili dipping oil brought to the table. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin

See all

My husband and I eat here all the time and love it. Sometimes the servers are hit and miss but we are never disappointed in our food. The cheesy sticks are our favorite app to get. My husband likes the pizzas and I always get farfell alfredo. The ranch is also our favorite! read more

Been here twice, food is ok, but they never get our order right. It happened again tonight! poor service again!

Worst pizza I've ever had. Hardly any toppings, very little sauce. The cheese almost tasted like a cream sauce. I ordered steak and while I didn't expect sirloin, I wasn't expecting deli meat type steak either. Everything was centered around the middle with very little on the rest of the pizza. Very overpriced. Terrible. I tried them twice and both same results. $18 for a Med pizza I can eat by myself? A friend of mine ordered a pizza even after I told him not to. He had the same result. Worst pizza he'd ever had and very pricey. He said the same for the salad. Guess we will be ordering from somewhere else from now on. read more

I've never been to a place that has so many attractive people working at it. I mean, dimes and mandimes everywhere, and the taller delivery man is such an honorary good guy! The food at this establishment is the equivalent of what Mozart is to music; perfection. read more

Great food & staff! Pizzas are very good and so is the rest of their extensive menu! They accommodated a large group of 15 with short notice. The waitress did a great job with everyone's orders and checked in on us often. Thank you!! read more

Went with a large party and had a little bit of everything. The pizzas were amazing, the fish and chips were great too! Words can't explain how great the boneless wings were though...best boneless wings I've ever had hands down. read more

Nice beer selection, and the dipping oil for the bread was incredible. Could have had a few more Stellas and just eaten the bread all night. The pizza was terrible. Absolutely no flavor at all. Sorry, but I won't be back, despite the awesome bread app. read more

Best Hamburgers, Pizza, and Fish Fry around! Great, friendly staff. Very reasonable prices. Clean restrooms.

Great specialty pizzas as well as great daily deals. A cool environment that is family friendly.

Ordered online. Uber fast. Hot food stayed hot until I got home. Family loved them. Zingy saucy hot tastey wings. We will be back.

has good food but the waitress's aren't that good don't really show emotion and just have a a blank face always when helping you.