Lisa was personable and after asking for recommendations of places to eat besides Brothers, she wrote them down. Great service for sure. We were also lucky to have their Thursday special of large specialty pizza $22. The House pizza was our choice as most like supreme. I got the 10" House gf cauliflower crust and it was amazing. If this was near SE Tampa; our fav place would be here!! Quaint place. Next trip we will be back. read more

Pizza was great in size and quality as well. Very punctual service to boot. Did a takeout order and was packaged well for the trip to the house. read more

Pizza with a thin crust (with toppings twice as deep as the crust ) sold by the slice as a lunch special. WOW!! This pizza has toppings thar make the flavor and not the crush. And the flavor is not bland- or shy. The House pizza had ground beef, pepperoni, sausage, onion, peppers, mushrooms and real mozzeronie cheese- the kind that breaks into long strings. Spices which give hints of identity and does not overcome everything else. Great pizza! Tea was not strong. Small inside eating area- 8 booths and 5 tables. Very clean with few frills. Service was quick, attentive and made lunch special. I really appreciate being offered a to-go drink. Would certainly come back- I would love to try the caesar salad. read more

Brother's Pizza - Dinning area - Pizza Near Me - Crystal River, Florida

See all

Ordered food for delivery on their website. Was called by them that they were out of one item. Ok with substitution. Then the delivery. An uber driver delivered food. No silverware, missing the substitute item. Any the instructions on the order were completely disregarded. A phone call to them and I was told they don't control silverware and would just refund the missing item. Zero caring about messing up the order. read more

So I went to a family members house and they ordered some wings and salads prior to me getting there and me just being greedy I asked if I can taste ... lol and oh my the Wings were sooooooo good !!! I took the rest of their wings Great flavor and apparently it's their go to place. Next time I'm in the area I'll be getting my own plate. You can order wraps, wings, subs finger foods ( appetizers ), and pizzas ! read more

Brother's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crystal River, Florida

See all

Very good pizza and service was great! Very reasonably priced !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Delicious pizza! Thin crust and perfectly done!!! Fast service. Shop local! Tip: Order from their site rather than 3rd party and save.

We were really hungry after being out om the water kayaking all day and decided to try Brothers Pizza. So glad we choose this pizza spot, the pizza was done quickly and tasted great! We ordered the Farmers Market and a pepperoni pizza. Both were tasty. Prices are really decent as well. read more

Haven't written a new review in 6 years, time just flys by.This is our go to place for subs, pizza, roll ups, salad etc. Always cheerfully greeted upon walking in, booths on one side, tables on the other side. You might have to wait for a seat 5 min but things go pretty quickly. They do a tremendous carrying out business. Few tables outside with full service. The waitstaff are always very friendly and offer you great service. We ordered a small Caesar salad, big enough for 2 to share, dressing on it is delicious. Along with it we ordered a medium House Delux cooked well done, it was cooked perfect to our liking. Just delish and we had leftovers for breakfast. Prices are reasonable for what they give you, and that is your monies worth!! Favorite place with the locals! Give them a try, you are missing the boat if you don't, you have been warned!! Debbie PS, they also have a Happy Hour 2/1 til 7:00 PM, just keeps getting better! LOL read more

See all

Overall excellent service and delicious food , they also have a point system so you can save Money

amazing pizza. I highly recommend the white pizza, with pepperoni, and pineapples. They're pasta is great there too.

Hands down, best pizza in Crystal River! My favorite is the Brother's Veggie Pizza, I'm not sure what it is, I've never had a pizza quite like it but it is the best pizza I've ever had! Great place for pizza when you don't feel like cooking. read more

Humm, Pizza Joint had a 3 hour wait (that good!) and we were hungry and didn't want to wait. We looked online and the reviews looked good for Brother's so gonna give it a try. Called in and placed the order. I asked for Italian sausage, thin crust. The girl taking the order hesitated for a sec. I told her, like the picture on their website, the BIG chunks. She put me on hold for a sec, came back and said okay. Picked up the pizza, see attached photo of their website showing Italian sausage, and what we got. One big greasy mess. Had to eat it with a fork. We would have taken it back if didn't drive so far and not hungry. We threw half of it out. Silly me, thinking it would look like the picture (not). Next time, will wait for Pizza Joint or no pizza at all. read more

Brother's Pizza - Italian Sausage - Pizza Near Me - Crystal River, Florida

See all

I was just coming back on Yelp to get Brothers phone number to order delivery when I saw a couple of bad reviews. I just had to finally write mine and I'm sorry it took me so long. First, we moved to Crystal River in February and we've come to Brothers about once or twice a month since then. We've mostly had pizza and garlic knots, but the soups have been amazing also and that's not something you hear from pizza joints very often! Last time I tried a sandwich and was very pleased - great bread and lots of sauce so that was fantastic as well! The pizza crust is always crunchy, maybe not as much when it's delivered but I would much rather it be a real authentic crust than a cardboard crust that stays hard for hours BECAUSE it tastes like cardboard and has the consistency of cardboard. If that's what people are complaining about - then go order Dominos! As for cheddar cheese - Yelp reviews are for quality. Not for you to trash the company because they have a cheese you don't particularly like...just write that they HAVE that in your review so others know and can request to delete it if they so choose - but why give one star because YOU don't like cheddar cheese on pizza?? Was the staff courteous? Was the restaurant clean? Fast delivery or plenty of places to park? These are reasons to mark a lower score - but their recipe??? That's just mean. Brothers is fast, courteous, clean, and I think their food is super yummy! :-D read more

Brother's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crystal River, Florida

If you like papa johns this is the one for you. Let them know to leave your pizza in the oven a few extra minutes would make it a lot better. Sincerely Long Island Guy. read more

Burnt up chicken parm- the solution, a credit for another one on another day. No seasoning in pizza, crust or garlic knots. Very disappointing. If you like bland, burnt and disappointment. This is your spot. ​ read more

See all

Love their pizza! also love that they sell it by the slice very hard to find anywhere anymore!

Just recently moved to Citrus County and have been looking for a "go to " pizza place. I've tried 5 different restaurants and so far, Brothers Pizza is the best around. Fast, plenty of cheese and toppings, and tastes great!!! read more

Got a pizza and " a fully loaded large Italian sub". The sub is awful. It's toasted with greasy meat and cheese, no vegetables or oil and vinegar. Doesn't everyone know a fully loaded Italian is with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and peppers with dressing, AND ALWAYS SERVED COLD.​ read more

Bad pre-cooked front counter pizza - very dry & old. They tried to reheat an old pizza they sell at front counter

We stopped in today and had buffalo chicken pizza, veggie pizza, garlic knots, french fries and blackened shrimp Alfredo pasta and it was all phenomenal! The staff was friendly and attentive and it was continuously busy the whole time we were there. We look forward to going back again! read more

Not too bad. They were really busy so when they lost our order, I guess I will give them a pass. They did offer us free garlic knots. For a local Pizza place, it fit the bill. Not the best I've had, but not bad either. read more

See all

Great food, great prices, great service. Check, check, check. Will be back. Nuthin fancy. Strip mall restaurant that was as good as I heard from our new neighbors. read more

Brother's Pizza - Veggie with sausage added. Yummmmm - Pizza Near Me - Crystal River, Florida

Love the spinach/mushroom pizza best around. My husband enjoys the cheese pizza! Just wish they wouldn't expect a tip that's why I take out! read more

Great pizza, thinner crust. We prefer the cheese or pepperoni. It's always ready pretty quickly.

Being from up north its hard to find good pie, but this is pretty Good pizza for this area. I always get extra cheese and its so good

Brought out of town family here for a late lunch. The pizza, salads and wraps were so delicious! We will definitely be back again and again! read more

They are now open on Sunday. Amazing options for pizza love the pesto as a base option. Update YELP you've got them closed on Sunday.

We have been going to Brother's every week for 11 years. Food is wonderful and the staff is great, with one exception. An employee, Ed, was incredibly rude to us recently. We have never been treated so rudely in a restaurant - ever. Not sure we will be going back there as long as he is employed there. read more

Salad is amazing staff not so much!!! We went on a Friday. Very rude... maybe hire nicer people.

Excellent pizza. They have a huge pizza and it's not cheap but it's worth every penny. This is my favorite place to eat Italian in this area. read more

It's pizza it was slightly above average but I'm a food snob . Service was good worth the money but I wasn't blown away

Takeout food is great. I've had spaghetti and meatballs, calzones, sausage pizza, side order of meatballs. They have good blue cheese dressing for salads. I keep going back to try new things. read more

The food was amazing, the pizza was perfect. Service was amazing, felt very welcome to the restaurant. Will definitely come back when in town again. read more

My first extremely positive impression of the restaurant came when we walked in the door to find only one table large enough to seat our group of seven, and it was occupied. Without anyone saying a word the group of four at the table hopped up and offered it to us. Everyone from staff to the clientele were extremely friendly and loved to chat. The pizza was delicious too. The crust was a perfect chewy crust with an excellent sauce. Quantity wise you will not be disappointed. My in-laws ordered a small plus a salad for the two of them and had leftovers. The medium (easily a large elsewhere) we ordered would easily be a large elsewhere. The salad and medium pizza we ordered fed us, our 4 year old, and our 2 year old with plenty of pizza left over to send home with my wife's parents. Since my wife's parents now live nearby I expect we will be dropping in at Brother's for more delicious pizza and friendly people whenever we come to visit. read more

What a disappointment! Every time I order a grinder they are the worst! I don't know why I tried again. The veal parm had one little slice of veal on the grinder. Plus the veal was burnt to a crisp! Look at the pics! This is the worst grinder I ever had! I'll never try there sandwiches again. Rocos next door is sooo much better! read more

See all

So... I just got my Brother's pizza order delivered through Doordash, I definitely went to the comment section about my order and added specific ingredients for my sandwich . I would like to proudly thank Brother's pizza for exceeding my expectations. Thanks again Tommy low cash read more

Waste of Money! ....Greasy noodles, canned sauce, Meatballs & Sausage were Sysco items. Nothing homemade or fresh. Food was cold and served with day old over garlicky breadsticks. Service was so-so, they started cleaning around us and trying to shut down early. If you're from the East-coast you'll think this place is a joke. If you expect a real Italian place, this isn't it. read more

I ordered the spinach and white sauce pizza and added black olives and mushrooms! It was excellent!! Excellent dine in experience as well! Great food and great prices! read more

Ordered 2 large thin crust pizzas the other night. They were so delicious! Perfect crust and piping hot, even after I picked up and got home. Family really liked the meat pizza! A bit pricy but much better then franchise pizza places. read more