Michael Anthony's is one of the very few restaurants near where we live that offers delivery from their restaurant not using delivery services like Door Dash or Grub Hub. This helps to save a little money and is super convenient if you're not feeling well or just want to relax and rest without cooking and cleaning up. We opted to share Michael Anthony's large Stromboli. Made with their homemade pizza dough it's stuffed with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green bell peppers and onions plus cheese. Very tasty and satisfying. Served with a side of their homemade marinara sauce. Their sauce is very,very good. Not bitter or too sweet - it compliments their strombolis and calzones very well. We also opted this time for a cup of their daily soup choice : Pasta fagiole. Loaded with beans and vegetables in a delicious broth - it was a excellent addition to our meal. My husband who is very particular about his food was very happy with their soup. A very satisfying and filling delivery meal that cost us a total of $33.21 including a delivery fee plus a driver tip for the convenience. It's great to know we have the option of delivery in our area. We will continue to use their delivery service plus eat at their restaurant when we want good quality Italian cooking. read more

See all

Fist time visit to Michael Anthony. I found the restaurant to be very clean, staff was good. Ordered the garlic knots with extra garlic came out perfect. We got a large pizza with onion and 1/2 mushroom. Great crust, sauce was ok not great but still good. I give Michael Anthony a 7 out of 10. I can't wait to go back and try the pasta dishes they looked good. read more

See all

Just ordered the grandma pie, which is special with fresh basil The only pizza I ordered in my town read more

Best Pizza in Homosassa Fl. so far . Delivery too. Friendly people too. Don't miss out on the good Pizza. Oh did I forget to mention , the Pizza is Great. read more

Delicious food, went out of their way to serve me bread even though supplies were at The time difficult (post Milton & Helene) and delivery was was and efficient! It made me feel so much better to eat a good meal. Helped block out All the devastation around me! read more

Michael Anthony's Pizza - Baked Ziti, bread and salad - Pizza Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

We always get the garlic meatball pizza and it is excellent! Get it slightly well done if you like a more rich flavor to your cheese and crust. read more

Some of the best pizza I've ever had also had the fried calamari and pasta Bolognese so delicious read more

Michael Anthony's Pizza - Is fried calamod and pasta Bolognese out of this world - Pizza Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

See all

Great veal with very large portions. My wife sweats by the Marina Sauce. Wonderfully simple salads with very good dressing

Food was great. The philly steak with onions,peppers, and marinara. The meatball parmagiana was hot and large. They cut both sandwiches in half which is nice because we got a second meal out of them. The only d aw back was their onion rings are not hand breaded so we didn't try them. And we love homemade rings. A place worth stopping at even if you're just driving through. The employees are friendly and efficient. read more

Ordered delivery was told within an hour and it was an hour and half later to get it. Pizza was cold and burnt. This happened before and we said we would never order again, but we gave it another chance and it happened again. will never order from here again. When I called I was placed on hold and never got an answer. The delivery person was super apologetic. still shouldn't have been placed on hold to get no answer at all and got burnt, cold pizza! read more

From PA and excited to find a cheesesteak made the PA way with sauce! Plus every time my adult kids visit from NC, it's their arrival request...hot honey pizza and chicken bacon ranch pizza! Thanks for helping us fill our cravings and being our go to pizza restaurant! read more

Over an hour wait on delivery. Would not of cared if it was good however the fries were greasy and cold! The chicken Philly the bread was stale and chicken was like cardboard texture and taste. read more

Burnt cardboard crust, no flavor. Worst pizza I've ever had. Veggies soggy and mush. Paper stuck to every bad bite. Super disappointed.

Located in a Publix strip plaza in Homosassa Springs, it does not look like much when you come inside but the food speaks volumes...very casual and they do take out and delivery..we have tried many things here and have never been disappointed..as soon as you walk in the smell of fresh Italian herbs will consume you...tonight we had a Sicilian Pizza cooked Crispy per my request and he nailed it..do not like it really doughy...it was delicious, they use good Cheese here too and that is so important..also served at our table was a Philly Cheese Steak which we have been to many places and the one they serve here beats them all..we had Jennifer take care of us and she was sweet as can be and took very good care of us..we know we come here or when driving through we can get a good meal or delicious Pizza.. read more

See all

Great food great cheap lunch specials $8 for a sandwich drink and fries or onion rings Chicken parm pizza is the best ever Chicken cutlet salad is perfect read more

Food is out of this world. Service good . Reminds me of New York pizza restaurant. Food is always served hot. Prices are fair.

I Love their food and service. Ambiance is good but not amazing. They have really delicious Italian Wedding soup and warm bread and butter brought to the table. The thin crust personal pizza with cauliflower crust is really good as well. I ask for lightly cooked so it's not too done. The chicken or veal Marsala is Amazing and I always have leftovers to take home. Nummy!! read more

We ordered a pizza and calamari. You can tell the calamari had a homemade breading on it. It wasn't thick, but seasoned perfectly! The pizza....soggy! While ur was loaded either way toppings, I think it was too much for a thin crust pizza. Half of our pizza had almost a completely chopped onion on it! I think we'll head back over to Moschellos! We weren't impressed read more

We always have a great experience! We normally use take out / delivery & they are on point each time!

All they needed to do was toast my sub . Then it's our fault. They are plenty of other options in the area. This place sucks

We went there for dinner tonight & it was delicious! I had penne pasta with 2 meatballs! My wife had shrimp parmigiana! My son had Stromboli! We also had disco fries & onion rings as appetizers! So much food & we bought home leftovers! Our waitress was great !she was the only waitress working on the customers!def they need help! Also we got a pepperoni pizza to go for my other son! So convenient by our house & definitely we will be back ! read more

See all

Chicken piccata was great. Will definitely return This was a take out order will enjoy leftovers for lunch read more

I ordered a pizza today. They told me they couldn't deliver to my house that was eight minutes away so that's fine so I ordered the pizza and picked it up. I got there and open the pizza and it was burnt barely any cheese barely any toppings am I said it looks burnt she said sorry and that was it so if you like burnt pizza with sorry shitty customer service this is the place to go over priced burnt pizza read more

Good sauce makes good pie. Their sauce is very good. Order takeout pies "topless", no top on the box. Makes for a much crispier crust, just like what you get when dining in-house. read more

I'm a NY Italian American. Super picky about pizza. Michael Anthony's is great by even NY standards. The crust is the best I've ever had. Very light, thin and crisp. The sauce is perfect and the cheese is top quality. It actually melts and us oh so stringy. If you love NY style pizza, this is the place for you. read more

food was amazing but the woman with the green hair was extremely rude to me. barely even acknowledged me while proceeding to be kind to other customers. read more

I felt like a hog that had just been slopped. I called in an order that said an hour or less. It was a simple order a veggie sub and a dozen wings. I called them back twice after an hour and twenty minutes and they didn't really care just said you're order is on the way. We got the order one hour and 45 min later. It was slop the sub was so soggy and the wings were cold. The sub was not edible just a ball of wet bread. The wings were ok but there hard to mess up. That will be our last order to this place. read more

Michael Anthony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

See all

Good food and awesome service. I had eggplant almost like a Stromboli... it was delicious. My husband had a Stromboli and love it. Not too much dough. Need a water filter for the water. The ambiance okay... the ceiling tiles really need replaced. Other than that, we will definitely be back as the food was delicious! read more

Pizza was excellent. The fettuccine Alfredo not so great. We took one bite and discarded it. Not sure if it went stale or rushed to make as we ordered before closing. Enjoy the pizza. read more

It is the Best Pizza. Period. Monday-Friday when Michael makes it. Done deal- just sayin'

Love the white pie. Great place for pizza. It really was a delicious pie and we will be back. read more

Michael Anthony's Pizza - White pizza with mushrooms and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

The Burgers are out of this world. Chicken cutlet salads are fresh..with cutlet hand breaded and crispy!

it sucked! Never again. And here's your warning! If you have read this don't complain if you order from them. Don't order anything hot and don't complain because it won't matter! Again fair warning. Called and complained about our order this evening and they said "thank you". lol, really. How about how can we make it right or keep you as a customer. Nope, nothing! read more

Very slow service. They only had one server in the entire place so I can't fault her for being slow. Pizza was the greasiest I have ever eaten. I had to put napkins on top of the pie to sop up all the grease. This place is a one and done stop for me. Garlic knots had tons of raw garlic on top so they were not very good either. read more

My husband and I have been going to Michael Anthony's for several years. We normally go on Monday evenings for dinner. The wait staff that we have on Mondays and try and get the same girl taven who is such a sweetheart. The food is wonderful and the owner Michael is awesome. We can't recommend him highly enough. read more

Micheal Anthony's attitude is for the landfill I waited 45 minutes and then my order was going to start over $25 I'm telling everyone they are no good read more

Had the works pizza minus peppers. They ran out of mushrooms :( it was delishhh. Pizza was perfectly crispy & their marinera sauce is so good! Garlic rolls were yum but wished garlic was cooked it was pretty raw. Friendly staff & fast service. read more

Michael Anthony's Pizza - The works minus peppers :) they ran out of mushrooms :( Delicious. Friendly staff! - Pizza Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

This was delivered along with a cheesesteak sandwich with a slice of cheese on half, not even melted. Also a personal pizza that had no cheese and just the toppings in the center. I called and asked if they changed chefs and they said no. I asked to speak to the manager and I heard the girl yelling several times "who wants to play manager" then just heard laughing and giggling. Beeb going here for 10 years and this has sadly gone down hill. BTW, that is supposed to be angel hair pasta with roasted garlic not burnt and bitter garlic. Will Never go back read more

Michael Anthony's Pizza - Burnt Garlic - Pizza Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

We just started going here for pizza because Crystal river is lacking in that area. So far we have had good service and the pizzas are pretty darn good. Place is nice and quiet even when they are busy. We haven't taken advantage of the BYOB yet. Tonight we may even try something besides their pizza. I think that this place could make a great Detroit style pizza.. It's the square deep dish with the crust that goes up the sides and the sauce is layered onto the top with the cheese on the sides and burned to a crisp.. read more

Great for a quick lunch! The prices and service are excellent, too. You can't go wrong with the pizza lunch specials and a bowl of soup.