Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Burgatory - McCandless

    3.7 (289 reviews)
    Closed • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Updated 1 month ago

    Waitlist - Burgatory - McCandless

    Waitlist closed

    The restaurant is not taking waitlist parties right now

    Burgatory - McCandless Reservations

    Order Burgatory - McCandless Takeout or Delivery

    Burgatory - McCandless Photos

    BURGATORY - MCCANDLESS ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Trendy
    Casual
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    More like Burgatory - McCandless

    Recommended Reviews - Burgatory - McCandless

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Larissa G.

    I stopped in here recently after spending my morning kayaking at North Park. I'm a Burgatory fan in general, but I have to say: coming here after a relaxing morning on the water just made the meal even better. So this Burgatory fan likes to mix things up from visit to visit. Sometimes I make a custom burger, but during this visit I just ordered right off the menu and got a Cha Cha Chicken burger. It was very good! Chicken with everything bagel seasoning, tomatoes and avocado, bacon, and a delicious sauce on a pretzel bun? What's not to like? I also ordered a cold brew mocktail; and while the cold brew/vanilla/caramel combo wasn't exactly the best to pair with the burger, it WAS the caffeinated boost I needed after kayaking. And it was super refreshing to sip while waiting for the main course. So it basically became a dessert beverage. I loved their outdoor seating area too - they had unzipped its plastic coverings so that a nice breeze was rolling through that section of Burgatory. And given that it's spring, it's the perfect time of year to enjoy the seasonal temperatures. Top off the delightful space and delicious food with the great service from the staff, and it all made for a pretty perfect lunch. I'd definitely swing by this Burgatory again!

    Morty's Steakhouse Burger
    Menghai T.

    I got the Morty steakhouse burger. Burger cooked to a perfect pink temperature. The patty had a nice pepper crust and tasted delicious. The fried onions were a good topping on the burger which also paired welled with the grilled onions. A very thick and solid burger. The chips were house made and tasted good. The salted Carmel milkshake was good, the pretzel bits in the shake made it taste unique. Burger was $16 and shake was $7. Overall a solid burger joint to go to. Food: 7.7 Staff/service: 7 Overall: 7.5/10

    Caramel Pretzel Shake
    Corinne K.

    We had a great time visiting this location. The shake was amazing as always and burger was great. The wait wasn't too long for a table. The service was standard. It was a bit cold in the restaurant!

    Nicely stacked chairs
    Stacey B.

    We've been here many times over the years. Sadly, the experience has been going downhill each time. We walked in around 7PM and were seated in the patio area. The hostess stand had three staff but only one even acknowledged us and ended up having to crawl over the other host blocking her from getting out of the stand to seat us. Our waitress was great. We were slow to figure out what we wanted and she was very patient. We each placed custom burger orders using the selection slips. My burger arrived over cooked without any pink and was missing lettuce and onions. The fries were hot and very dry and not crisp. How do you goof up the condiments when it's written on paper right in front of you? So we had very little greeting and so so food for our $80 Burgatory dinner (with two beers each) when the Manager tells staff start to noisily stacking every metal chair and cleaning tables all around us all the while talking to these waiters/waitresses in a condescending manner. It was a little disconcerting. I said to the Manager when he was clearing a table near us, "It's almost like we aren't even here trying to enjoy our dinner." I was clearly ticked off. He tells me to take my time and they aren't pushing us out. I replied, "Are you kidding me?" He obviously was not understanding how loud and obnoxious it was to have all of this going on around us trying to enjoy our meals. Clue phone, it's for you. Don't seat people here if you're going to do this. It was pretty ridiculous. The bottom line is that you can't charge premium prices and give people a half assed meal and subpar treatment and expect them to come back.

    Chocolate covered pretzel shake

    See all

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jon C.
    0
    11
    0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Excellent food and service every time that I have been here. Normally get the Crab Shack or Meat Your Maker. Both are amazing.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 8 of 8

    Burgatory - McCandless Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Burgatory - McCandless

    You might also consider

    Dough Daddy Brewery

    Dough Daddy Brewery

    3.7(47 reviews)
    6.6 mi

    Full disclosure, i attended a birthday party here. We were in the outdoor area which is nice…read morebecause there is cover and it is behind the building and not along the roadway. I never could understand why people eat outside in downtown places where cars drive by them 5 feet away. The beers were OK, nothing really special but OK. They have a little bar outside so getting a refill was quick and easy. The don't serve any kind of hard spirits. My wife isn't a beer drinker so one of the bartenders at the inside bar mixed her up a drink with seltzer and something else(tea) which she found to be quite tasty, so i tipped her generously for having the ambition to please a customer. Where they fell down IMO was their pizza. It just wasn't very good. We had several versions of their Sicilian to choose from. The cheese was generous, but the crust was doughy and heavy, the sauce was flavorless, and the toppings were very stingy. A big piece of Sicilian pizza with 3 slices of pepperoni is not good. I checked out their menu and was stunned at the prices they are getting for those pizzas. WAY overpriced. Of course i didn't have to pay for them since it was a party, but knowing what their pizza is like i would never go back there and pay those prices. The wings were just OK, pretty mediocre. Parking is a joke. No where near enough spots for the size of the place. Overall it was just OK, i would not return. There are better places for the same or less money.

    I had to try the hot dogs because I am doing a hot dog tour. It was a big hot dog!! I got the Rocco…read moreand my bestie got the buster. We both enjoyed them!! I will say I wish the bun was smaller, it is just too much bread. The onion rings were great. The sugar pretzel was good could use a little more seasoning on it though.

    Photos
    Dough Daddy Brewery
    Dough Daddy Brewery
    Dough Daddy Brewery - Bar/ inside Area

    See all

    Bar/ inside Area

    Cinderlands Taproom -  Wexford - Cinderlands Patio and Cindis Hard Mt Tea

    Cinderlands Taproom - Wexford

    4.1(22 reviews)
    4.3 mi

    Made an impromptu stop into this satellite brewery pub on Saturday and were very pleased…read more We sat at the bar and had a great chat with Paul who was minding the bar. He allowed us to sample a few beers and made suggestions to help us choose. There were a few hazy options as well as a black IPA. There is food onsite, which is supplied by sandwich shop Long Story short. The menu includes soft pretzel, pizza and a quesadilla. We had the quesadilla which was filled with tasty seasoned shredded beef. Also had the pretzel which came with mustard but surprisingly not beer cheese! The atmosphere was friendly and relaxed. There is a nice outdoor space that we will check out when it gets a bit warmer. Glad we found this place and look forward to visiting again soon!

    Came here with friends on a Friday night and happily surprised it wasn't packed. It was also vinyl…read morenight so people were able to play their favorite records they brought or select from their collection. They also have 2 tvs around the room, giving you the ability to watch sports. This made for a super comfortable atmosphere to relax and enjoy time together. Their menu at this location is a bit limited, especially if you want something on draft. Their stout beers and IPAs are all on tap but lagers are only available in can and only 4 options. I ordered the Lil Cinder out of the can, which was a wonderfully cheap $3. It's one of my favorites at their other location and was happy it had a consistent smooth and refreshing taste out of the can too. I would have liked some more beer options, like sour or wheat beers, but understand it's only the taproom.

    Photos
    Cinderlands Taproom -  Wexford - Cinderlands Patio for Dog Days

    Cinderlands Patio for Dog Days

    Cinderlands Taproom -  Wexford - Interior

    Interior

    Cinderlands Taproom -  Wexford

    See all

    Wheelfish - 1/2 Chicken 1/2 lb. Brisket Sweet potato fries Corn bread

    Wheelfish

    4.3(262 reviews)
    2.6 mi
    •$$

    Bbq sauce is so good. Dinner comes with all 3 sauces so I could mix and match. I really liked the…read morespicy one and the Texas style sauce. Brisket was a bit fatty but so tender. Fries are so good. Kielbasa was amazing 3i wanted more. Sausage was ok. The beans were a bit watery -so more sauce then beans. I felt I should have ordered corn muffins as a side instead to sosk up all the goodness. Got one of the drink specials and it was also good. A band was playing that night so tables were full and we sat at the bar because we wanted to listen to the music instead of sitting outside. Lots of parking too.

    Wheelfish is a casual BBQ restaurant that serves dinner, on some days lunch, and catering. The menu…read morelists appetizers (e.g., spicy cheese curds and chicken wings), a couple salads, sandwiches, tacos, several meats, sides (e.g., slaw, sweet-potato fries, corn muffin, and potato salad), and drinks. Trivia and live music are sometimes available for entertainment. In the past few years, my husband and I have eaten at Wheelfish a few times. For our meals, the hostess and waitress promptly and politely served us. Here are my reviews for the foods: Pretzel bites - 4.5 stars - This appetizer was a large size. We really liked the flavor of the pretzels and the honey-mustard dip. We thought that the cheese dip was OK. Pulled-pork nachos - 5 stars - This appetizer of nachos was huge! Many tortilla chips were topped with gooey cheese, pulled pork, jalapeños, sour cream, and pico de gallo. Fried deviled eggs - 4 stars - The egg white was breaded and fried. It contained a yolk filling and was topped with a spicy jalapeño. We prefer traditional deviled eggs, but these ones tasted good. Mix-and-match soft tacos - 4.5 stars - The pulled-pork taco contained pulled pork and vegetable toppings that were very flavorful. For the brisket taco, I enjoyed the flavor of the brisket and toppings, but the juices made the tortilla soggy and caused it to fall apart. Shrimp tacos - 4.5 stars - These were on sale on a Thursday. The shrimp were breaded, and the toppings of napa slaw, mango salsa, and chipotle aioli tasted very good. Meat entrees - 4.5 stars - My husband liked the smoked chicken the most (5 stars), and he described it as being "delicious." We also ate ribs (4.5 stars), kielbasa (4 stars), brisket (5 stars), salmon (4 stars, needs more seasoning), and pulled pork (4.5 stars). Macaroni and cheese - 5 stars - My husband said that this macaroni was the cheesiest thing that he has ever eaten. He described it as "delicious." I ate some of the macaroni, and I agree that it was extremely cheesy. French fries - 5 stars - These fries were perfectly crispy and salty. Grilled vegetables - 4.5 stars - I wanted to make my meals more nutritious, so I chose a side of grilled vegetables, which are seasonal and included peppers, corn, squash, and zucchini. This mix of veggies had a very good flavor. Side salad - 4 stars - This salad contained a lettuce mix, some tomatoes, some pickled onions, and my choice of dressing. It was fresh but was slightly plain. Pork 'n beans - 3 stars - My husband ordered this side. He ate only a small amount of the beans and sauce, and he thought that they tasted just OK. For drinks, we had iced tea, diet Pepsi, and water. The waitresses brought refills.

    Photos
    Wheelfish - View from back of bar

    View from back of bar

    Wheelfish - Brisket, Ribs and Salmon

    Brisket, Ribs and Salmon

    Wheelfish - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    North Park Lounge - Strawberry Chicken Salad

    North Park Lounge

    3.6(254 reviews)
    0.3 mi
    •$$

    This was such a wonderful experience! We were seated immediately, despite it being a pretty busy…read morenight. Our server was friendly and thorough throughout the time we were there, and he did a great job ensuring certain things came out allergen friendly! This restaurant offers bar seating and a decent amount of tables within the restaurant. I ordered a burger and it was delicious! It was absolutely massive, which I appreciated because I happily enjoyed the leftovers the following day! The gluten free bun was really yummy as well! Burger was cooked perfectly, seasoned well, and very juicy! The side salad was wonderful too! I also ordered a ginger beer, which was super delicious! Just all around, this was such a great experience and I'm excited to go back again!

    So Mother's Day they're offering a brunch. Last year's was fantastic. This year they are asking you…read moreto pay ahead of time. But it's not unfundable. So what happens if there's a car accident? If there's traffic and you can't make it and you did leave enough time? What if somebody got sick and everybody has to cancel? What if the worst happens? So my day that we honor our mothers, if any of the above happen, you're out of more than $100 if there's 3 (approximately) of you? What if you're less one or two people? Are they charged? I guess it's a way to make money for the next big event at the Gibsonia location Come on give people a break. At least Disney only charges $10 per person, but you have to cancel within 24 hours to avoid that fee. Rating is based on surcharging the customers

    Photos
    North Park Lounge - Inside

    Inside

    North Park Lounge - Burgers

    Burgers

    North Park Lounge - Vegan Breakfast Wrap

    See all

    Vegan Breakfast Wrap

    Burgatory - McCandless - burgers - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...