Absolutely delicious baked goods. No need to travel 45 minutes to that place out east. The Dutch Apple pie is to die for. Their website indicates that they carry strawberry rhubarb as a special order but it doesn't appear they carry it in the store on a regular basis. I will try to order it ahead next time, but there's a chance it's a seasonal item and may not be available. We'll find out. I haven't tried the deli but everything in the cases looks really fresh and delicious . I'm looking forward to trying it the next time I'm there. The workers in the store and at the check out were extremely helpful. I highly recommend Buttercup's Dairy Farm! read more

I'm very disappointed lately. three times I have asked for certain deli meat. and instead I received the cheaper store brand. not realizing it until I get home and unpack my bags. on top of that. the younger men / high schoolers they look like , always rush it. for example I asked for super think salami. it takes. little longer to cut yes .. . but no one likes extra thick deli meat. They always pack it up, don't show it to you. etc. again, you get home and wind up throwing the meat out again. I used to really love buying my groceries here. it's a locally owned business I wanted to continually support. I stop buy every saturday and one night the week. I can no longer do so. read more

First off we really like this store anyway but this week we catered a holiday party and decided to order a 4' hero and it was the best party hero I've ever had. Awesome. Forget the other places and consider them next time. read more

Buttercup's Dairy Store - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

AWESOME store! Very convenient and FRESH food. Cashier Chris was very helpful and polite. Will definitely come back again!

Love shopping here! They have a great variety of prepared foods, delicious breads, cookies, pies and full service deli too! Also precut deli meats if you're on the run! read more

Love this place. It's like a miniature supermarket. Great baked goods and a little bit of everything. Read some of the negative comments. Nothing but picky shit. read more

So anyone ever ordered a GROSS 3FT HERO?? WELL .. THIS IS THE PLACE TO GET ONE!! We ordered a chicken hero for a party and the bread crumbs were white and the chicken was not sliced. It was just the cutlet placed on the hero and the chicken was hard . Yeah ... try wrapping your lips around that. We called and we were told the chicken is cooked elsewhere and they just make the sandwich. Ya think you could mention that on your flyer??? This place is not where you buy a hero, unless you like to choke on day old dry chicken and pay for it... read more

just a quick note to tout the pies here. i was close to home & suddenly felt the need to buy a pie... too lazy to drive to Tilda's or Benkerts and too cheap..i say NFW to supermarket pie- I'm right near Buttercup... i go in, in two minutes I find the last Apple Pie on the shelf... not my favorite- it's got crumbs & white sugar on top--I still buy it. takes 10 seconds to check out... wow, why was the bill so cheap? this can't be good.. i get home...best freakin' pie I've had in years...the price ? $7.99...WTF !! would've been at least $20 at a bakery. Buttercup forever... read more

I've shopped here for convenience vs. overpriced items. Today was enough for me. I was the only one in line at the deli counter, with 6 people behind the counter, 2 backs turned to me, and the rest ignored me. I patiently waited until I was done watching what was going on. I say loudly, excuse me. A young girl turns around, gives me a look (I bothered her), and walks away without a word. Eventually, she comes back and asks "what do you need." I tell her just 2 deli items. When she was done, she returned, asked "is that all you need." I replied yes, and she dropped my items on the counter, eyes rolled, and walked away. But wait, there's more. I purchased several produce items, which I washed thoroughly before using, all covered in ants! How does this place stay in business? Absolutely disgusting. However, I will say that the people at the registers, during multiple shifts, are always very pleasant. read more

Super fresh...... Very convenient..... Staff is extremely helpful..... Quality is excellent and they have been around a long time. Support local read more

If you purchase any of their prepared food, be mindful of the sell-by date. Today I found expired meat. Ugh!

000000000000000000 You see I went in there and boy did some shopping and spent like $70 and then I had to bring some items back very shortly after and they would not let me return anything so I will never go there again. I don't recommend it to anybody and I recommend people to stop shopping there because of that. read more

I have lived in this area for nearly 20 years and only just started going here. This is sort of like your old fashioned local grocery store. Yes a little small and can get crowded but you will never go wrong here. Quality food and fair prices. Sorry I didn't patronize Buttercups sooner, what was I thinking? Don't make the same mistake I did, check it out you won't be disappointed. read more

The owners are so cheap. I ordered ham and asked to have it shredded, they charge an extra 1.25 to shred it! Give me a break, what does it take the kid an extra 20 seconds? Oh and they messed up my order also, putting everything on rolls instead of hero's which I ordered and he wrote down.... $26 for 3 crummy sandwiches with an absolute minimal amount of meat... pathetic. read more

=Buttercup's Dairy Store I've been going for years but today is my last visit. I had my 6 pound service dog with me on a blanket in the wagon. I went to the deli counter, I was stared at then the short lady whispers something to the young man who tells me the dog can not be in the store. I say he can because he's a service animal. As he is taking care of my order the short woman is now whispering to another employee I'm assuming it's about my 6 pound non shedding non barking service dog when someone comes behind me and tells me the dog can't be in here. I said he's a service dog and the young man told me and he's wearing a tag, they walk away. Then from behind the counter to my left another lady tells me how he can't be here. I again said many people told me and he's a service dog, with a blank stare as if she never heard of a service dog just keeps staring at me. Yup you guessed it now there is a tall woman next to the woman who is still staring and tells me the dog can't be here. Well I started to talk loud. 5 people have told me and I keep saying he's a service dog, must every employee make me feel uncomfortable, I get louder and emotional, I have anxiety and medical PTSD which I should not have to tell you. The response I got from tall woman is they did nothing wrong. I said do i have to wear a hat saying service dog next time but sadly there will be no next time. As I waited to pay the woman in front of me said I heard what had happened to you and I'm so sorry. I started to cry, again anxiety and medical PTSD that I don't share with the public makes me nervous when I'm out. Thank you buttercup dairy for a horrible experience. And now I will spread the word are how you make disabled people feel. Food is everywhere and nobody needs to spend their money there . wonderbar deli is pretty close, hallack ave. Discrimination and you can get sued With reading other reviews I see you have discriminated before. read more

Best local store . Everything is fresh . A absolute staple in my neighborhood . Customer service is excellent and cashiers are always friendly and always offer to pack up for you . Highly recommend this store ! read more

The wrap barely had meat, was not worth it. Didn't come with pickles or side salad. I asked for a lettuce wrap, they didn't have that either. read more

Buttercup's Dairy Store - Not worth it, no meat, more lettuce, tomato, and wrap than anything. - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

They have the most amazing food here! I've been going here for the past 20 years with my husband and we now bring our kids here and the food only seems to get better every year! Thank you guys, keep up the great work! read more

Wish the manager was more friendly. Has been rude to customers and employees on many occasions.

I love this little store! They have a great selection of food to go. I especially love their sandwiches and pies. I have been picking lunch up here for the past few weekends and usually opt for a sandwich with chocolate pudding. read more

I must be missing something was not impressed.lousy bread and overpriced.very cluttered.did not buy anything to eat because nothing appealed to me. read more

Just spoke to a young girl on the phone who was really not nice or helpful at all... I was trying to get a grilled vegetable platter for Sunday among other food items .. they make a grilled vegetable hero but apparently cannot put grilled veggies on a platter instead of a hero.. because according to her they just don't do that... sorry you lost my order.. read more

Just ordered 3 sandwiches, 2 with mayo, 1 with mustard. All 3 have mayo. Ham and cheese. I slice of cheese. Rolls were stale. $27 for what??? read more

Let me start by saying this review is SOLELY based on what my expectations were, not on actual products/customer service, etc. I've passed this place MANY times and have never gone inside until just the other day. I for some reason thought it would be more like a farm stand but it was more like a convenience store. They had basic necessities as well as items like milk, eggs, cereal, deli counter and some bread/baked goods. The store appeared clean. I didn't have any interactions with employees but from my observations they seemed friendly! read more

My father who has an issue with his eyes tearing went into Buttercup today. He had to pull his mask down a little to help wipe away the issue because he was having a hard time reading. The manager came over to him asking him to put his mask up. My father tried to explain what was going on that the manager didn't hear him out. Then told him to put his "F*cking mask on"!! Really is this how we are going to talk to the older people. Will no longer shop at this place. Would rather drive out of the way then be in a place that won't hear a customers issue out and try and help them out. read more

Doesn't look like much but I think it's a great deli and small grocery. Their sandwiches are always winners. The rice pudding is a must have. So yummy! I have been going here since I was little and will continue. There are closer deli's but I prefer Buttercup. read more

Buttercup's Dairy Store - Might not look like much but it is - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

Awesome store!! Been going there for 35 years. The produce is good, the Deli has nice stuff that's all fresh. They make great pies & baked goods. Also they have pre-made sandwiches, salads, entrees & fresh meats. Everything is reasonably priced & the staff is very nice!! read more

Small store, but it has a fair selection. Staff polite and helpful. Minus a star for the closed deli department. You have to phone in an order for baloney ahead of your visit? PLEASE! There are always a bunch of guys behind the counter anyhow. Have one pull those "closed" signs off the deli counter, and start slicing some ham for customers! He's there on the clock anyhow. Why loose deli sales? read more

This place actually was taking orders for MEMORIAL DAY up until today. I by chance called to add to my order and was told they decided to close on Memorial Day. No phone call . What the hell would have happened on Monday when I went to pick up all my food? I spoke to the owner and voiced my frustration. He literally hung up on me. WOW!! Aweful customer service. Be aware this is how much they care.very RUDE read more

AWFUL SERVICE!! I placed an order for heroes for Memorial Day, I confirmed that they were open and they said yes. Placed an entire order and gave my deposit, called the next day to add on, they said they are closed , I said to OWNER when were you planning on calling and letting me know???? I would have came down that day to pick up and you would have been closed. OWNER was a total bastard and HUNG UP ON ME! I called right back and a lady answered and suprise! He's ""not available " .... owner was a true asshole!!!! I always used to go , NEVER again will I step book in there or recommend this awful place..... 0 stars is what I would truly give it read more

its a small grocery store with all the basics and a deli counter. prices were very cheap. came here for their home made pies and i was not disappointed, probably the best dutch apple pie ive ever had!!! the only bad part is when its busy it is very small and hard to walk around but i will definitely come back read more

Buttercup's Dairy Store - dutch apple pie - Bakeries Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

Not the nicest employees and the place is kinda dirty. Could really use a good scrub down and new employees.

I am unable to leave me house so I tried to place and order from the deli department and a couple of grocery items so I could have it all picked up at once by someone. I spoke to who I was told was a manager and she told me that they could do that because they are rang up separate departments and they could do grocery items. I try and support mom and pop stores but I guess they don't need my support for the little extra things. I guess I need to go to the big stores since they will help with it. read more

This is the perfect place to go if you need a few things & don't want to wait an hour on line at the supermarket. It has everything you need. I've been living in the Port Jeff area for almost 10yrs & I've passed Buttercup so many times, but never gone in. From the outside, it looks like a red barn. Inside, it's a convenience store with a deli, milk, ice cream, fruits & veggies, baked goods & toiletries. I read the other reviews & have heard people raving about their pies. It was my Dad's birthday, so I decided to stop in & pick up a pie. They had quite a few to choose from, including more than one kind of Apple Pie, Cherry Pie, Blueberry Pie, and Carrot Cake (all baked fresh), both small and large. I bought the large Dutch Apple Pie, (with crumb topping & apple filling). It was a good 14" (if I had to guess) and it was $8.99. It was delicious! Not too sweet, just the right amount of everything. The staff was very helpful & quick. I was in & out in under 10 minutes, which is unheard of, for a Sunday. I would definitely recommend & return. read more

See all

I read the other reviews and was excited to try their apple pie. It was good, needs more apple filling though. The Dutch Apple pie was sold out. I'll update my review when I try that one too. It's small inside and the line was long in the deli section. read more

I love this place, it's a clean, no nonsense, family run operation with excellent prices and super fresh cold cuts and goods based on the huge and quick turnover. Good on site bakery goods and treats, a vast assortment of grocery items and a healthy sized sandwich made to order any time. This place rocks! read more

They make great pies for the holiday seasons. Polite, neighborly and service with a smile. A staple in the community m

7/17/21 my wife and I had entered the store with our service dog. Hea in training but wasn't acting out. A manager told us he wasn't acting good and we needed to leave. The manager dropped something and almost hit the dog so he backed up with his tail between his legs. We had a loud disagreement with this kid and they threatened us with the cops cause we refused to leave with our registered service animal. This was discrimination at its finest. I even showed the manager and the head guy his ID and they still had us leave read more

Great sandwiches and salads here! Love their mac and potato salad. I always order my Heroes from here when I have an party at my house! They're just awesome! Plus it's a quick stop for milk and cold cuts. read more

This place is the greatest little deli ever! The cold cuts are always so fresh and salads delicious. They even have a pre cut section that they stock a few times s day for on the go people like myself! They carry everything from hamburgers to vegetables all sorts of drinks cakes ice cream etc. this is our go to place and the catering is also fantastic! The daily lunch specials are also delicious and greatly priced. I recommend them highly!! read more