My husband & I came across a video of Calogero's on YouTube a couple of months ago and we had to come try out their pizza! Drove about 45 mins and it was 100% worth it! We tried their pizza, vodka pasta, arancini and garlic knots! Everything was 10/10. Owner was super friendly and made it a very personable experience even with my crazy kids running around! Also Coming from a Sicilian family loved all the decor! Will definitely be back along with some more of the family! read more

This is for delivery service only. Please, please, please do not get delivery here. I could tell if it was served in the restaurant it would have been very good. You can always tell by the crust. But delivered this was lower than room temperature - ice cold. I doubt they deliver or use a service that delivers with insulated carriers. I was a bit put off by the overdone burntness of the garlic knots but another photo of them here looks the same, so I guess that's normal. read more

This is an amazing little pizza place! We love pizza and are always looking for the next best place--well, we found it. The owner is a super-friendly guy and the quality of the pizza is outstanding. We tried the Salsiccia, garlic knots, and a cannoli. The garlic knots were unbelievable- the dough was amazing and had the right blend of oil and garlic. I could have made a meal out of them. The pizza was equally impressive- the right balance of quality ingredients. It even tasted good the next day when we reheated it. Cannolis had pistachios on one end and chocolate chips on the other--perfection. You can tell that they care about their food and we will definitely be back. read more

DELIVERY REVIEW: Do not EVER order delivery. Your pizza is guaranteed to be cold. They use door dash and the drivers take forever. If the restaurant is going to continue to use door dash they'd be better off to not even offer delivery. read more

Real people real food real passion and love going into every bite. Love seeing places like this and meeting the owners

Love this place. Quick, authentic pies. Good prices. The dude who works there is always nice. Just wish they were open more.

Great Neapolitan Pizza and friendly staff. Sal has a true passion for old world Italian pizza, breads and more. Highly recommend you stop by and give them a try!!! They also have a wood fired pizza trailer and catering as well. read more

You can taste the quality ingredients and the love put into the pizza in the first bite. This little pizza shop in a rather inconspicuous strip mall blew away all expectations. The inside of the shop is beautifully designed with an amazing mural. You can see them baking the pizzas just behind the counter. The fresh sourdough crust is amazing, as are the garlic knots. Kind staff, great food, amazing ingredients; what more could you ask? read more

We tried a salad, bruschetta,pizza, tiramisu. Everything was delicious. The owner and staff were welcoming and friendly. Small "homey" space-, felt like eating at nonna's kitchen table. If you are in the area, it is a must try! read more

Best real Italian wood oven pizza in Naperville. Family owned restaurant super friendly owner. Their hot honey adds the best touch to the pepperoni pizza. Pasta so fresh and delicious. Will definitely be back! Our favorite new pizza restaurant for sure read more

Calogero's - Nutella calzone - Pizza Near Me - Naperville , Illinois

Very good pizza, we've been ordering for a while now and here I am writing a review to recognize this restaurant and their pizza as one of very good that we had over the years. read more

I love this place! Owners are very friendly and you can tell they take pride and joy in what they do. Rainbow cookies are the best thing I have ever tasted! I really love that new seasonal items pop up on the menu too. Love the pepperoni with hot honey and the pizza bianca. All delicious and no guilt given the quality of ingredients are high - organic, locally sourced or imported from Italy. read more

Delicious panini with prosciutto and mortadella ! You must try it ! The sour dough bread is best I ever had. Thanks so much for your authentic Italian food read more

Picked up two pies. Real wood fire, you could smell the smoke in the parking lot. More New York than Napoli. Will be going back for sure.

Fantastic pizza and knots! The sourdough is divine. I highly recommend trying this place if you appreciate unique food and authentic charm with flavors that exceed your expectations. Bravo! read more

Really great. The Neapolitan pizza is the best around. Also got the sourdough and the focaccia ( get on the mailing list ) . Really fresh and authentic. read more

Walked into this place with a friend by accident glad we did they have such delicious pizza and dough. Treated us so nicely and they have a great back story and why they wanted to bring quality bread to everyone. Last part that surprised me was they broke bread with us one they where saving they wanted us to try it and they opened it up to do so. Great atmosphere, amazing food, and they care about what you eat. I don't leave reviews often. read more

Coming from an Italian... this is authentic Italian food! Very good!! We will definitely be back.

I heard great things about this place and wanted to see if it lived up to the hype! Let's just say I couldn't attach pictures because we were to busy eating the pizza! Delicious Delicious Delicious! It is a small spot so if you have anything larger then a party of 4 you may just want to do carry out. But don't let that discourage you, if you love delicious brick oven pizza, this is the spot! read more

A gem for REAL traditional Italian cooking. Fresh pasta's and amazing Dolce! A taste of Italia right here in the Ville!! Definitely go here!!! read more

Authentic wood-fired pizza - absolutely fantastic. The sausage was really amazing. One tip: Pizzas come in just one size, and they are fairly small compared to less authentic pizzeria standards (1 pizza feeds 1-2). So plan ahead accordingly if you're ordering for a big family like ours. This is a great addition to Naperville. read more

Absolutely amazing pizza and probably the best in Naperville. We ordered the margarita, funghi, and Nutella calzone and we were blown away. Highly, highly recommend! read more

Coming from a fellow first generation Italian, I can tell you with certainty that Calogero's has quality and authentic Southern Italian pizza! Their ingredients are incredibly fresh and delicious! read more

Delicious. Pizza was great. Crust fantastic. Also had the penne a la vodka which was very tasty. Nice little place. Wanted to go to a local wood fire pizza place and Calogero's did not let us down. Talked to the owner & his daughter. He's legit Sicilian & it shows in the pizza. We'll be back. read more

Quick and great service every time. The quality of food is amazing and taste is as well, you can't go wrong with Calogero's read more

Calogero's - El charro - Pizza Near Me - Naperville , Illinois

Absolutely phenomenal food!! We've been to parties catered by Calogero's and their service and food was outstanding!!! read more

See all

I have traveled all over the United States in my military career and as a native of Brooklyn NY, pizza is extremely hard to impress me with .. until I went to Calogero's .. not only was the hospitality, the family history inside of the restaurant mesmerizing.... But the Pizza.... OOOOMYGOODNESS! .. it brought NYC PIZZA back to my taste buds!! By far the BEST Pizza I have tasted in years! I will surely be returning in my travels!! And I recommend to anyone reading this.. you have to try this Pizza! Bravo Zulu Calogero's!! read more

Calogero's - I waited for months to see and taste this amazing Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Naperville , Illinois

We've been to Calogero's a number of times and have never been disappointed in the food or service. Ownership is awesome, ingredients are fresh and flavorful. This time we ordered bruschetta with our pizza( one pepperoni one sausage) and everything was fantastic especially the bruschetta! What treat! We'll be back again and again! read more

Wonderful owner, truly handmade italian pizza. Such a wonderful atmosphere and was a wonderful experience. The owner was making the pizzas and was so kind. You can see his dough starter and how clean he keeps everything and everything being handmade. read more

Authentic Scicillian pasta and pizza in a small but "chill" location. BYOB allows patron to pair food with Chianti or Super Tuscan.

Amazingly delicious pizzas. My husband had the pepperoni and I had the BBQ chicken. Crust was perfect mixture of chewy and crispy. Enough seating for 10 in the dining room - but it was empty on a Thursday evening, and it shouldn't be! read more

See all

Delicios Old World Italian Pizza - Great hospitality and service!!!

This place is awesome! Pizza is great wood burning oven. If you like the wood burning true Italian style pizza then check this place out. read more

Calogero's catered my birthday party this weekend and did an awesome job! Their wood burning pizza oven, pasta and salad were a hit! The food was great and we will definitely work with them again. Thanks, Calogero's!!! read more

By far the best pizza in Naperville! The ingredients are incredibly fresh. Service is outstanding! Great restaurant!!

Great wood fired pizza! Very fresh ingredients. I ordered it for a party and it was a hit .

The pizza is very good and as authentic as it gets. Good quality dough and ingredients- nice little gem in Naperville.

My Wife and Son went to Europe this past summer to visit Family, and kept telling me that there isn't any pizza places back home that can make it like they had back in the "Old Country"... I remembered seeing this big wood fired oven while waiting in line for the DMV, and mentioned that we should maybe give Calogero's a try... That day changed their view on pizza in Naperville, now they want to get pizza every day of the week, AND we are patiently waiting to see if we can get bread there on a weekly basis.... Thursday can't come quick enough!!!!! read more