2 cons and one is only personal preference: delivery was over an hour (peak hours on a Thursday,…read morethere's only so much they can do,) and no garlic crust. The sauce is sweet. The pizza is thin. The garlic bread is fluffy and the sauce that comes with it is also a fresh tomatoey delight. It is not overly oily! (Look at the pizza box in my pictures!) Throw some hot honey on this pie, it is perfect. Almost perfect... just a bit of garlic crust would make this unstoppable. :) Will absolutely be ordering again! Well worth the delivery wait, or go pick it up. Either way, you will be happy.

One of the most delicious pizzas I've ever had, loved it!…read moreRich, flavorful sauce and that cheese.. WOW!..Absolutely amazing taste. Great price, too.

First of all the pizza is very cheesy and delicious, the tomato sauce is authentic and also the…read morecrust is delicious This was my first time trying this place and I would certainly recommend it, not only is the food delicious but the prices are amazing! I got 2 slices and a drink for 6.00 plus tax, and they have specials every Wednesday. Not only is the food and prices amazing but also the service is outstanding, the service is friendly and they make you feel welcomed. I arrived 2 minutes to closing and the guy made me a whole pie with a smile. You wouldn't get that anywhere. The ambience is updated and it's a very nice and comfy ambiance. I would definitely recommend it if you pass by Tom's River.

Delicious pizza but also hot and cold subs, salads and wraps. Great made to order take out or a few…read moresmall sit down places. Honest, hard working owners and reasonable prices.

I have been to Slice House Toms River several times. I really like it. This pizzeria on 37 has…read moreenough room for casual eat in after counter ordering. SH does a large takeout and delivery business as well as the store ordering. Parking is easy out front. The place is clean and service is good. It is a bustling place at times with young people running the front. The pizzeria boasts many, many selections of by the slice as well as a menu of pies to order whole. Lots of add ins and drinks both bottled and fountain style. The pizza is tasty. It is served hot. I especially like a cheese pie but found their specialty pies like the cheesesteak & chicken parm pizza delicious also. The cheesesteak in particular tastes like a breakfast pizza due to its cheese, cheesesteak that is seasoned like sausage and it's white cheese sans sauce. It would be over the top great with sautéed onions, mushrooms and green peppers on it. The chicken parm with red sauce and chunks of chicken with yummy cheese is also tasty. They have salads, Stromboli, sandwiches, garlic knots etc to add on. I really like the entree Caesar salad. The dressing is good and the lettuce is fresh. It comes with toasty bread. I will continue to frequent this quintessential Toms River pizzeria as it checks all the boxes

Finally a place to grab a good slice while you wait, and wait for your loved one to be discharged…read morefrom Community Medical. Plain slice is meh BUT the Sicilian is delicious and the hot honey pepperoni is no joke, deliciously hot! Staff is friendly and knowledgeable about their wide selection of slices. So take the short drive and grab a slice while you wait for that discharge order!

Just ordered mozzarella sticks and a chicken parm sub ... mozzarella sticks are over cooked, and…read morethe sub is cold. I walked into the place to order and i live less than 2 mins away. NO reason for the food to be cold. First time trying the place and will be my last. Ill stick with Capri

My first time trying this pizza and honestly it's one of the best slices I've had in a long time…read morebeing that the tomato sauce is homemade you can tell that has a light sweet taste the tomato sauce absolutely absolutely 100% recommend to anybody

Absolutely the BEST local pizzeria! They always have a great selection of fresh pizza slices ready…read moreto go -- the Big Mac slice is hands-down my favorite. The chopped salad is also incredible, especially with their homemade vinaigrette, which is packed with flavor. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. There's a small amount of high-top seating inside if you want to dine in, but it's also perfect for a quick takeout stop. Highly recommend giving them a try!

Ridiculously good pizza and garlic knots!…read more Stopped here to pick up pies for a family gathering. Staff was super friendly on the phone during ordering and in person for pickup. Super attentive too. They have a parking lot and a cute outdoor setup as well. The pizza is delicious, sauce is perfectly sweet and savory. The crust was delectable. Nice amount of cheese. Really no complaints. I regret not getting more garlic knots, they're fried and garlicky and perfect. Don't skip the garlic knots if you come here!

Sals is our go-to place for pizza, Italian, & sandwiches. They did a great job catering a big party…read morelast summer as well. Good food, friendly service, & reasonable prices. This last time we ordered bbq chicken pizza via delivery. It came fast, was hot & looked perfect. The pizza is so large you can only eat one slice! It was a little salty for my taste, but still pretty good.

My new favorite pizzeria down the shore!! I ordered over the weekend, and everything was delicious!…read moreThe penne vodka with angel hair, chicken Marsala, soup and mozzarella sticks were awesome! They even gave us free zeppolis!! (We did pick up before they closed) Can't wait to be back down to order again!

The steak was really good, but the short rib was the standout for me. It was incredibly tender,…read moreflavorful, and cooked perfectly. I also loved the asparagus that came with it. Overall, the meal was a great value, well prepared, and very enjoyable. Definitely enjoyed everything :) Nice random stop I made, glad I found them

The spinach and artichoke dip bowl was half-full. More than enough pita slices for dipping, however…read morethis shareable appetizer wasn't. Manager said it was portion controlled. Eight year customer won't be back.

We got take out here for the first time and was very pleased. Got the meatball sandwich and it was…read moreclose to perfection. My husband really enjoyed the hot honey buffalo chicken wrap. We did not try the pizzas, but they have a lot of great sounding ones

Ordered delivery via dd. It was just ok, sandwich bread was really good on the chicken parm, but…read morethe chicken was stringy. Caesar salad was nothing extraordinary.

Being Italian, grew up on good cheese and gravy. I find that the first Gen Italians make the best…read more Pascual and Emily owner/operator make the best Pizzas. They are also able to make 2 types of Fradiablo sauce pizza with while being the cheapest around at $12.00 on Wednesdays for a large Pie. Before the pandmeic the special used to be $7.00. The curst is good too. I order double cut and well done.

In town visiting family and with so many pizza places in the bayville area I always try to find the…read morenext best one when I'm in town and trying this place for the first time I went with their garlic pizza and talk about fresh garlic..wow....for me it was just the right amount of cheese and the crust & sauce were really good.....a very solid choice for pizza.