Good food, friendly staff, but be prepared to WAIT A LONG TIME!!!!!! I would come here all the time…read moreand for every meal if they were faster. My whole meal for a family of three took 2 hours...

To be honest, I never had the highest hopes for this diner the second I walked in. The first thing…read moreI noticed was how cramped the interior was. There was barely enough space to walk. The second thing that I want to mention is the long wait times. I ordered a cheeseburger and fries, which took at least an hour to be finished. The food itself wasn't the best and was not worth the wait. Lastly, the floors of the diner were sticky, and the restaurant appeared to be dirty. It wasn't appalling, but it wasn't clean either. Either way, I don't recommend going to this diner.

Always a must when u get up up this way they do have food awesome place Def a kool place for a…read morebike ride destination

The reviews were spot on! We were on our way home from Lake adventure and passing through Bucyrus…read more Omg this is a must stop! Best barbecue in Ohio!! We were in Dallas several weeks ago and this place matches it! We shared Bama wings. I don't know what sauce is on that but it's scrumptious. Wings fell off the bone!! We inhaled them. Both of us ordered baby back ribs. Supremely tender! Baked beans, potato salad and sweet potato fries were solid! We have a whole meal to take home! Full bellies and giant smiles --- we are fans from here on out

This restaurant has Good food and good service. I always get a couple meals out of my entree.read more

Was very cute ! If you have a child that loves trains they would love the place. The food and…read moreservice were very good!

The food was decent but the service wasn't great. The condition of the restaurant is also not great.read more

Service is great, the pies are phenomenal but the food is just ok. We only tried the liver & onions…read more(frankly the worst I've ever had) and the meatloaf though. The meatloaf and all the sides were very good just not fantastic. The pies however, especially the Kentucky derby are worth 5 stars.

This restaurant is amazing! "Never" a bad meal! All made homemade & the pies are phenomenal &…read more"homemade!" If you go in to eat & don't get filled then you're not a big eater cuz you get very generous portions! Y'all better hurry & try if you haven't cuz they'll not be there much longer cuz Tracy is selling his lil gold mine! And for all you who like walleye you need to go for the "all you can eat" cuz it's the bestest you'll ever eat! It's not that thick dipped breading, it's a crispy breading that only Tracy can prepare to perfection! AUCE walleye is the bomb! Well, I hope you all won't delay cuz when he's gone all the goodness he prepares will be gone as well! I've eaten at other restaurants & none compared to the delishisness of this one! I'm saddened to hear they're selling! :( Good luck Tracy in the new door you'll be opening & the door of all the deliciousness you serve will be gone!! It's a sad goodbye to Carlyle's in Marion, Ohio!

Service started off rough. It took about 30 minutes before we were helped, which felt excessive. I…read moreunderstand that it was busy, but the initial wait definitely set a negative tone. Our waitress also forgot my water at first, which added to the slow start. That said, the food redeemed the visit. I ordered the buffalo chicken mac and cheese, and it was genuinely excellent. The flavor balance was strong, creamy and cheesy with a solid buffalo kick. The portion size was satisfying. The ambience was nice and felt like a classic diner. Even though it was busy, the lively atmosphere actually made the place feel welcoming and energetic rather than chaotic. The full dining room gave it that authentic diner experience. Overall, I would rate it 3 out of 5 stars. The long wait impacted the experience, but the food and atmosphere were strong enough that I would consider giving it another chance during a less busy time.

I found a hair in my food. The serverdid not have hair pulled up in a ponytail it was definitely…read morehers...blonde hair. The cook had black and it was pullled up into s ponytail. The server's hair was past her shoulders and blonde. From my experience as a retired server, I know that if your hair touches your shoulders, it is to be pulled up. Very disappointing. I was hoping for "hairless" food. If it happens again, I will address the server and the health department.

Do you like to gamble? Well going here is a gamble....... Will the cook show up today? Will the…read morewaitress have to make the food and serve to everyone in the joint? Will they actually make the food as described in the menu? Will they be open????

This place was amazing the service is great they definitely have top 5 hash brown and they are even…read morebetter with the ketchup and they ice tea is amazing would have added a picture but already finished all my food and they prices are not bad and this diner is open 24 hours every day of the week

We were waited on so fast that I thought I must have looked real hungry. I mean real hungry…read more Our stop was at 11:30 and could choose breakfast or lunch items. My choice isn't everyone's but I like Liver and Onions while my spouse doesn't do I like to order it out and this seemed to be a great place to try it. I was not disappointed! Small town vibe and great food with friendly smiles sure made our travel day a lot better. I would taken a picture of the homemade potato salad but it disappeared really fast. Sherrill our server was an Angel in disguise. We highly recommend stopping here whether you are hungry or just need to have an uplifting smile in your day.

Had one of my best breakfasts ever at the Corner Inn. I had some sort of dish where the eggs,…read moreeggs and meat was all mixed together. I got the large size and took most of it home. I was still eating it three mornings later!

The outside looks like something from a 70s sitcom set…read more. The inside is dated, but I love the vibe! It was packed on a Saturday at 10:30 in the morning. But they move fast! We were sat in under two minutes, and had our food in less than 10. This place runs like a well-oiled machine. Some of the waitresses here had to be at least 60 to 70 years old, and it looked like they came with the building. I'm not saying that as a bad thing. Is it really a good diner if at least one of the waitress's hands don't shake a little as she sits down your plate? The portions are enormous... The pancakes are the size of a plate. We watched the food come out and everything looks really good. Our waitress was fast and friendly, can't ask for anything better. It was one of the best experiences I've had in a long time.p

We recently stopped here after randomly coming across this place while passing through on our way…read moredown south for some breakfast. WHAT A DIAMOND IN THE ROUGH! I HIGHLY recommend stopping in. It has a nice old school diner / down home feel. Definitely a place the locals frequent. Everyone was very polite & kind. The food was AWESOME! "Herbie's Mess" really hit the spot with me... paired with some Rye toast that made my belly VERY happy! My GF got the tater tot skillet which she very much enjoyed. The service was quick and the prices surely won't break the bank. Support small & local businesses! A+ We look forward to coming back as it's only about an hour and a half from home.