Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza
    Open Open 24 hours

    Casey's Pizza Restaurant Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 357 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Nancy's Pizza Litchfield - $32.00 large specialty "Uncle Tony's" Pizza.

    Nancy's Pizza Litchfield

    4.1(107 reviews)
    26.8 mi
    $$

    Service was great and food came out quick. A great casual feel no fuss, has a great bar area. The…read morefood was delicious - surprisingly enjoyed the salad too!

    Although we have eaten there before, it's been a few years and this review focuses on the takeout…read morequality and experience. I like this place enough that we get it 2-3 times a year even though we live about an hour away (driving 2 hours out of your way with no other errands or stops along the route is a lot for pizza). It's clean, just off the highway, and attached to a hotel. Every time we go I think of all of the restaurants attached to hotels that I have had when traveling for work and how few of them were even in the same approximate quality realm as this place. The wait staff have always been pleasant and competent with a couple of stand out great experiences. But the food - the bone in wings are good. They are normal sized, not steroid franken-chicken. There are several sauce options, but we like the traditional buffalo. Salad is good. Like the wings, it is solid. The pizza is why we go. We get the Chicago style although the thin crust is decent, too. The sausage and pepperoni are balanced, the vegetables delicious, the crust and tomatoes very nice, and best of all the cheese is mozzarella and old school. Nothing tastes plasticky and frankenfood. It reminds me of restaurants 25 years ago. Highly recommend, even if it's a long drive.

    Photos
    Nancy's Pizza Litchfield - Deep dish cheese pizza

    Deep dish cheese pizza

    Nancy's Pizza Litchfield - Half eaten stuffed pizza

    Half eaten stuffed pizza

    Nancy's Pizza Litchfield - My husband's first slice literally had zero Italian sausage on it so I was feeling blessed with this on my $32 pizza ‍

    See all

    My husband's first slice literally had zero Italian sausage on it so I was feeling blessed with this on my $32 pizza ‍

    Joe’s Pizza and Pasta

    Joe’s Pizza and Pasta

    3.4(39 reviews)
    6.6 mi

    Joe's Pizza, really doesn't get the recognition that it deserves. I'm guilty myself, not thinking…read moreabout them when I go to order carry-out or delivery. After my flavorful Italian Sausage and Jalapeños pizza today, I will call Joe before a national chain. It was National Mom and Pop Business Day and my local Joe's posted a picture of their owners on Facebook and it prompted me to order. So I got on their website and ordered my favorite, Sausage & Jalapeño Small Thin Crust Pizza. When I order pizza from any pizza joint, I always add special instructions. I am not a fan of "square" cut and request mine to be cut "pie", the traditional way to serve pizza. My Italian Sausage was spicy, the sauce had zing to it and there was plenty of jalapeños. The jalapeños even had some crunch to them, which tells me, they were fresh. Then of course, the mozzarella cheese was plentiful on top of everything. The website was user friendly and when I arrived, the young ladies working the front counter were friendly and polite. Good pizza and friendly service will have me ordering pick-up again. Sure I can have them deliver, but I don't mind the short drive to pick it up myself. Support your local mom and pop businesses.

    Everything looked and tasted burned. This was a $40+ door dash today…read more My first time in this restaurant over a year ago was also burned. At that time service was ok. But food was not good. Btw. DoorDash only offered a total of $10 refund.

    Photos
    Joe’s Pizza and Pasta
    Joe’s Pizza and Pasta
    Joe’s Pizza and Pasta - Entrance & Drive-Thru

    See all

    Entrance & Drive-Thru

    Sage House - Tater Tots

    Sage House

    3.2(9 reviews)
    10.4 mi
    $$

    I knew I was in for a treat when one of the other customers seated at the bar looked at me and…read moresaid, "You're not from around here. Are, you?" I wanted a new experience for lunch, so I ventured out to Bunker Hill to see what I could find. I remembered Sage House from when I ate at a restaurant across the street, so I went to see what they had to offer. It was your typical bar/diner grub and a good selection of pizzas. Being a fan of chicken wings, I ordered 6 pieces with a side of tater tots. I liked that they offered both breaded and naked wings. I choose naked and bourbon as my sauce. I'm a stickler for my drums and flats being the same number and SH made me happy. The wings were meaty and juicy and the sauce was sweet and flavorful. There was a lot of sauce, so I am glad the waitress placed a full container of napkins next to me. The tater tots were good and crispy. No need for ketchup, I rolled mine around in the bourbon sauce under my wings. The service was hospitable. My server and another employee checked with me frequently as I enjoyed my wings, tots and draft beer. They had a full bar, but I went with one of the beer offerings. If you ordered a mixed cocktail, I'd make it a simple one. I didn't get the feeling they specialized in classic or fancy cocktails. I ended up chatting with the other customer while he waited for his carry-out. I guess his earlier statement/question, was his ice breaker. I now know more about him, than I really need to know.

    their pork tenderloin sandwich was fantastic and all for $10. Service was great and the bartenders…read moreeven kept up with getting bum rushed by 50+ people walking in all at the same time.

    Photos
    Sage House - Plastic Glasses Behind the Bar

    Plastic Glasses Behind the Bar

    Sage House - Bourbon Naked Wings (6)

    Bourbon Naked Wings (6)

    Sage House - Menu 1

    See all

    Menu 1

    Decaro's - Wings

    Decaro's

    4.3(67 reviews)
    10.3 mi
    $$

    Decaro's is a wonderful surprise. We initially intended to eat at another restaurant in the area…read morebut it was closed for the day. Decaro's became a hastily decided Plan B. We had no expectations but we were hungry. What a wonderful Plan B this turned out to be. It was mid-afternoon so the place was relatively quiet, in a pleasant way.Everything was clean and the dining room looked inviting. We seated ourselves and the waitress quickly came to take our order for drinks and food. She suggested the day's special, a personal pizza with two toppings, side salad, and a drink. It sounded great was was a real bargain so we both went with it. The wife ordered a simple cheese pizza and I ordered mine with sausage and mushrooms. In very short order, our salads were presented and they were delicious. The lettuce and vegetables were all very fresh, not the sad looking stuff you frequently see at other restaurants mid winter. Even the croutons were delicious, light and with just the right amount of crispness. Next came our pizzas piping hot. We both loved them .They came on a thin cracker type crust, my favorite, sauce was sparingly applied but tasty, and the Italian sausage on my pizza had wonderful flavor with just a light kick to it. My wife truly enjoyed her cheese pizza as well. We'll definitely be coming back. I'm tempted to try their Italian beef sandwich next time. It was highly recommended by the staff.

    So, my food was VERY tasty, but that's about it. Service was lousy. Really had trouble getting…read moreour server to wait on us and to flag her down once we did order. The ambiance is lacking. Just not a very nice place, seemed pretty run down. Definitely not a favorite of mine.

    Photos
    Decaro's - Decor

    Decor

    Decaro's - Sausage and mushroom personal pizza

    Sausage and mushroom personal pizza

    Decaro's - Dining area

    See all

    Dining area

    Napoli Bros - Arugula pizza

    Napoli Bros

    4.3(220 reviews)
    34.9 mi
    $$

    I took my family to Napoli Bros for my mother's birthday dinner. Perfect place for a date night or…read morenight out with friends or family. I had been a few times in the past but it was my family's first time. I don't drink alcohol and they have a great mocktail section! I got the NOPE-rol Spritz, it was delicious! My family and I split the white truffle fries and ciabatta as appetizers and they all got pasta dishes that they loved. I got a pizza (the Arugula) and unfortunately I feel as though I ordered wrong (which was my own fault), I didn't really care for it. When you took a bite it was like all the toppings fell off on the first bite. I think they cut the pizza before putting the toppings on which just made it harder to eat. I think the best part of the night was the service. We had Grace as our waitress (she was training another girl, but unfortunately I don't remember her name). They did a fabulous job - Grace did a wonderful job training her! It felt like we were at one of the more elevated Napoli's like Napoli III. They were so attentive and gave us great suggestions. Get that woman a raise! Well done, ladies!

    If you have been to other Napoli locations, some things will feel familiar and some things will be…read morenew. The food will be very familiar from the perspective that everything we had was excellent. We started with calamari, and to our surprise there were also a small group of onion straws on the plate. It was served with 2 sauces (one marinara and one aioli - both were excellent). Don't skip the fried lemons, they are an added treat. We then moved on to the Napoli salad, it is as described on the menu...crisp, and appropriately dressed. Then we had the special pizza of the evening, it was a black garlic base (not strong) with mushrooms and burrata on top - delicious. We also happen to be sitting next to the area with the pizza oven - a must see if you are there. We did sit inside, but outdoor seating was available. What might not be so familiar, but I thought was great, was a more casual atmosphere, and decor, I would classify is as upscale casual. Our server was very pleasant, the only thing that surprised me was the time in between courses seemed a bit longer than expected, but that gave my friends and I a chance to catch up. Overall, a very enjoyable experience and I will be back!

    Photos
    Napoli Bros
    Napoli Bros - Vodka Al forno-- delicious

    Vodka Al forno-- delicious

    Napoli Bros - Ciabatta bread with Herb Butter

    See all

    Ciabatta bread with Herb Butter

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...