Little Italy has quietly become my go-to pizza spot, and I don't see that changing anytime soon…read more I've been to a lot of pizza places, but something about Little Italy in Groveport just hits different. The sauce is what gets me every time -- thick, deep red, and rich in a way that actually tastes like it was made with care. There's a subtle kick of spice in there that keeps it interesting without overwhelming anything else on the pie. The crust has that perfect balance of chew and crunch. Not crackerlike, not doughy -- just right. And the cheese? They're not skimping. You get a solid, generous layer that pulls and stretches the way pizza cheese is supposed to. It's the kind of place that earns repeat visits not because it's trendy, but because the food is just consistently good. If you're anywhere near Groveport and haven't tried it yet, fix that.

It's clean, new and they market well…read more Meatball sub deserves the 3 stars only because of the bread. Mid meatballs, watery spaghetti sauce. The young staff tries their best. Avery, the owner, seems to have completely lost touch with reality. Don't drive out of your way.

I have not had Flyers Pizza in a long time and the last time I had was in Grove City, it was nice…read moreto have Flyers Pizza again but in Groveport. It tasted like I remember. I enjoyed the Pepperoni. I thank Knox County Special Olympics for buying the pizzas for them and Franklin County Special Olympics. I will have to check out Flyers in Groveport soon.

Ordered a pizza and salad for take out today and we were very satisfied. The food was good and…read moreworth the cost. The pepperoni pizza was cooked well and had good flavor. The crust was a little chewy, sauce sweet with a little tang at the end and the cheese and pepperoni were very good. The salad was a basic salad, but was very fresh and crunchy. I ordered online and everything was ready with about 20 minutes. The young lady at the pickup window was very pleasant and personable. All in all it was a good experience and we will keep the place in mind for future.

I don't usually love a cracker crust pizza but the sauce and topping really made this pizza…read moredelicious! Loved the veggie pizza especially! Placed an order for pickup and the service was timely and accurate!

We went out to eat on a Saturday night and decided to try Little Sicily's for the first time since…read moreit had been recommended to us. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza with mushrooms. It's hard to pinpoint what I loved most about their pizza. It was loaded with toppings, and the pepperonis were perfectly crisp. There were plenty of mushrooms, and the pizza had just the right balance of spice and sweetness. I really appreciated how they baked it; there was no undercooked dough at all. The cheese melted perfectly with just a slight char, and the sauce had a wonderful sweetness that reminded me of Columbus-style pizza. The crust was thin but not overly crispy; it had a nice bite and chew without being too thick. For a Saturday night, the dining area wasn't crowded, and our server was quick and friendly.

This place could have killed me! Ordered some subs and the only thing I asked for was no peppers…read morebecause Im allergic to them. Drove 25 mins to get them get home and they had poppers all over them so I called them to have them replaced and was told "pick them off" they refused to replace them or give a refund. The audacity of this place. If I wouldn't have checked i would be in the hospital. Beware if u have any good allergies. Or if they mess up ur order chulk it up to a loss because they refuse to actually have costumer service. I recorded the man on the phone telling me to pick them off and refusing a refund or to replace. If I wasn't deathly allergic them it wouldn't be a big deal but the way they treated me on top of it!!! Yeah unexceptable!

The worst customer service I've ever experienced. I belittled , mocked and felt attacked by someone…read morewho claimed to be the owner. Placed an online order that was made incorrectly. Instead of correcting he insisted I placed the order wrong and told me to never order from there again. I explained how I was a loyal customer and advocated for them, he mocked me by saying they will have to close because I've decided not to do business there any longer. I have never felt so disrespected. I will no longer be doing business with them

We ordered a meatball sub, a gondola sub and a cardos special. Everything was delicious. I…read moreappreciate the time they take to wrap the subs in foil. Staff is nice too.

If you're a meat lover, their meat lovers pizza is packed with meat. Especially sausage. It's a…read moredecent pizza but the sauce has absolutely no flavor or just doesn't have enough sauce at all. It's an Ohio style pizza that is thin. Little to no flavor. I wouldn't recommend.

Got pizza delivered via Uber Eats...it was fantastic…read more Great sweet and tangy tomato sauce An absolute avalanche of toppings on the pizza, never seen so much crispy pepperoni and giant pieces of bacon Really tasty garlic butter sauce The breadsticks were great as well Would definitely order again

I got a supreme pizza and it was very light on toppings and this is the third time in a row little…read moredisappointed

This pizza shop is inside of a gas station so don't miss it. Do you remember the Godfather's Pizza…read morein Columbus about 40 years ago? This is it! The pizza is delicious and consistent every time. I love the ground beef and pork topping. Perfect right out of the oven and perfect right out of the refrigerator the next morning. Mini pizzas are ready to grab off of the shelf but large pizzas need to be ordered. Service is pretty quick.

Probably the best personal pizza I've had in ages. I got the meat pizza which was really flavorful…read moreand filling. I would not suggest anything from Chester's which is located in the same gas station, the wedges were terrible! Meat pizza 1-5=5!

I have to give this location massive props. I miss my local…read morelocation on Sullivant Ave. and we were in town watching a local musical play at Sweet Harmony and they're partnered with them. I've been to a different location and it was extremely depressing because it was Massey's, but didn't taste like it. This location hit that good ol time taste from the early days. I had it delivered to the Harmony place and the delivery driver was so friendly. Excellent pizza!

'Loved' their deep dish pizza... What happened? It came out with the sides tall, but thin and…read morecrispy... deep dish pizza should be just that, a deep dish. The entire pizza was flimsy and not deep. Very disappointed. We asked the server and was told that that is the way they are made.

Oh dear lord, this tastes nothing like an east coast pizza. Where is the bot when you need it?…read more I like the dining room atmosphere and all the tables. The decor on the walls looks like this would be a fun place to bring friends. The pizza was mediocre at best. Edible, but nothing jumping out to make it stand out. The sauce was bland, but at least they used a cup and crisp like pepperoni. Because it was carry out, can't rate too high or low on the service, except to say it was a very unpleasant experience just to walk in there. No smiles. No small talk. Barely an acknowledgment. More grunting than conversation. So matter-of-fact, I doubt either one of the two fellows remembers I was there! Part of me felt like an intruder. Not very cozy or comfy. Future pizza will be coming from nearby Pickerington. 05/24

The pizza was hot and fresh. The service was great. We ordered takeout but the inside is really…read morecute especially the bar. We will be back for sure

Friendly, attentive staff in a casual atmosphere. They have great pizzas, salad options, and…read morebar-style appetizers. The FRESH smash burgers are delicious. There is a good variety of draft and bottled beers. The manager is very knowledgeable about wine and they carry a nice selection. There are live-music days and I have had the pleasure of hearing some great performers here. There's a game room available and pool table for those wanting to hangout for a while with friends. Definitely worth stopping in. The Vibe: Relaxed. The manager, Brian, did a great job breathing life into this place.

Tried to give them another chance after a long hiatus. Tried to order two different appetizers, out…read moreof both. Tried to skip appetizers and order dinner out of that too. Should have known it wasn't worth it when we walked in at 5:30pm on a Saturday evening and there were two people in here... It's too bad, their food is generally very good but they do not run this business well.