We finally ordered something other than the Special pizza! Amazing Eggplant Parmesan that was so good. It came with a side salad, garlic bread, pasta with sauce and vegetables. My husband and I split it and I highly recommend it. Btw the employees that work there are always so nice and friendly and make me feel valued. read more

Cicero's Pizzeria - Love the Cicero's Special Pizza and side salad! - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

Honestly, this is a painful review to write. We live practically around the corner, and Cicero's has been our go-to pizza place for years. Their pizza is pretty good, taste-wise. But sadly... They seem to be terrible at actually providing what was ordered. Tonight we ordered three pizzas and two were completely wrong. This seems to have been getting worse over time. One of our common pizzas we prefer to have jalapeno on half of the pizza due to differing heat tolerance in the family. We explicitly called this out while ordering and got jalapeno across the entire pizza multiple times. Ok, I guess we can deal--those with lesser heat tolerance can just pick it off. We've called in the past and the customer service has been apologetic and in one case offered a credit for a future order. Tonight, we had two completely wrong pizzas: 1. Pepperoni, mushroom, red onion, artichoke. Well, we got sausage, red onion, and artichoke. Two of four toppings were correct, one was swapped, and one completely missing. 2. Sausage and mushroom. Well, we got a mushroom pizza. No sausage to be found. When calling, the person answering the phone was completely dismissive. He read off the order [showing that what Grubhub transmitted to them was correct] and didn't care that what they delivered was flat out wrong. And then said that if we wanted anything done, to take it up with Grubhub. A combination of incompetence and poor customer service is not great. It has us thinking that we need to find a new local pizza joint. Which is terrible because the pizza is pretty good. But if they can't deliver what we order, then we never know what's coming. And in a house with some food allergies, we want to know that what we order will be correct. This has been our local trusted pizza joint for almost a decade. But it seems that it's going downhill, and that is truly sad. read more

See all

We tried Cicero's for the first time by ordering take out, so I can speak to the service and decor. FOOD: The pizza was good! We got the Margherita pizza, mushroom appetizer, and garlic cheese bread. Everything was good! read more

See all

Our go to spot for take out pizza and salads! Especially when the kids come home from college, it's ALWAYS a place from home they want to order food from. The family size salad easily feeds 4 and they have the best ranch dressing in town. We always order extra ranch. We love the ample toppings and the red sauce on the pizza. It is also a great quality pizza when eating leftovers cold or slightly warmed up. The crust is not over cooked and has a nice chew to it that makes for a delicious bite. They have great specials and family deals so if you've never had Cicero's, you have to order it for your next gathering! read more

Cicero's Pizzeria - Our standard mushroom and onion pizza and then had to add pineapple on half for a guest. - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

See all

We love the food here is GREAT. And since my last review the phone service has been much more pleasant. A BIG THANK YOU :) The pizza is the best around and always comes cooked the way we like it. We especially like the baked ziti as well super good, cheesy garlic bread yum yum. From dessert to sandwiches to pasta and pizza it's ALL GOOD read more

Solid American pizza joint. Bbq chicken was pretty good - could use a little extra spice. Toppings were very generous- our custom pie came out perfect. Will try some of their other dishes next time. read more

First time we tried pizza from this spot. It's a small take out restaurant, I am not sure, but I think it's a family run business. The staff were very friendly and nice. We ordered a vegetarian and a chicken pizza. It was really good. Very good quality pizza. Definitely will order again. read more

Pizza was good! Ordered on line for pick up, ready on time & hot. Lots of tasty toppings, I liked the crust, not too thick or too thin! 16 inch pizza with 3 toppings was less than $25. Definitely will return when I've got the urge for pizza. read more

I asked for a chicken Parmesan pizza, clearly said Pizza the guy didn't hear me and started arguing with me I didn't want to argue back so I just left with the chicken parm sandwich that I clearly did not order. read more

We ordered a custom pizza and meatball sandwich today, and the food was excellent and delivered hot & tasty. Their food is fresh and made just the way grandma used to make it. The Uber eats delivery service was timely and precise. The ambiance of our house was comfy. Highly recommended read more

Friendly services. Fresh dough daily. Pretty reasonable price The place is on the smaller side with no public restroom. There were 2 TVs, but they were not on during our carryout waiting. Pizza and pasta were really good. Will come again. read more

Cicero's Pizzeria - Menu 7.22.24 - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

Have not been here for a while and thought since I was in the area, I'd stop by. The interior has not changed. I ordered a pepperoni, green bell pepper, sausage and onion pizza. The service was prompted and welcoming. The pizza was good and will be back to try the sandwiches. read more

Cicero's Pizzeria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

My go to place for lasagne! Dinner includes fresh and ample salad. I usually split it to eat the rest later. Garlic bread ok, pieces however are too thin and dry. read more

Our favorite little Italian place for takeout! The individuals taking the orders over the phone, are friendly and efficient, especially Hope. You can see the cooks working hard to expedite the orders This is a place we keep coming back to Try the meatball sandwich and the pizza is fantastic too! read more

Family loves this food!!!! A definite constant reorder!!!! From pizza to potato wedges... YUMMY read more

Wow, the simple pepperoni pizza I picked up yesterday was really good, the pepperoni has a unique flavor that was better than most

I've tried their sandwiches and their pizza and enjoyed them both. It's a small place. Mainly takeout that has a few tables. Always smell so wonderful when you walk in the door. read more

First time eating at Cicero's, and it was very good. Had a Large Submarine Sub. It came with extra olives and pepperoncini on the side, a nice touch. The meats, veggies, were very fresh. There is close ample parking available, and the inside is well kept and pleasant. The help is very friendly and helpful. The large sub is enough for me for 2 meals. I will definitely come back again. read more

Been going here for over 15 years now. Consistently good pizza & salad. Never had any issues with order quality and the customer service is on par. Highly recommend. read more

Great pizza. Extremely busy. A little pricey but maybe they run specials. The pizza was a good size though. We got pepperoni and cheese and lots of sides. read more

I know today being a holiday but I called and the automated VM said they were busy on the other line taking orders, I was #1 in the queue, after 15 min hold I hung up called back went to #3, decided to drive down there and lo and behold. They were closed instead of changing their voicemail saying that we were closed for the holiday it just put you on hold and kept you there until you eventually hung up. Their phone. System is horrible. Try to catch up to the 21st-century. read more

The pizza is delicious. I would recommend you pick up the pizza instead of having it delivered because of the fees.

Great pizza. This 85 characters to post a review is dumb. Lol ..... been going here for years always reliable! Check them out

Very very yummy!!! This place is must! You want traditional Italian very yummy food then look no further. It's in a small shopping center not a lot of people which made it very nice for us to order. Sometimes the best places are the ones ruined by family business and that's something I truly enjoy. If your in the area I highly recommend the lasagna! Great service and friendly staff. Supporting local Mom and pops shops. read more

See all

Very good pizza and wings. The pizza has really fresh ingredients. Employees are always friendly.

Customer service sucks and they are the ones that made the mistake . I use to go once a week now never gain the salad I'd terrible made wrong and made me very ill and the pizza was worse disgusting I'll never go again to the grease pot read more

Their pizza is so delicious! My family has always gotten it & it never fails. The salads are good too.

Amazing pizza hidden in a non-descript strip mall. It is what I consider, New York style with very thin crust. This is not really a dine-in restaurant (they do have a couple tables) but its really more for take-out. I drive all the way from RSM and pass numerous pizza restaurants to get my favorites here. read more

Ciceros' Pizza is delicious. Something about the Sauce,'and the crust. Great service, quick food, and the salad are amazing too! Would definitely recommend you try it!! read more

Very good food here Btw. The pasta was a tad bit overcooked However pink sauce wign Dooo your noodles r read more

We ordered a combo pizza, two orders of chicken Alfredo and salads for a quick dinner before heading to a graduation ceremony. The family enjoyed everything. They were surprised at how delicious the pizza was that they asked where we got it. They said next time, get the same pizza at the same place because the quality was better than other neighborhood establishments. The gentleman who took my order was pleasant and made recommendations that we enjoyed. Since this was take out, I have no comment on the ambiance. I'm glad I gave Cicero's a try. We'll be regulars from now on. read more

The pizzas are fresh and delicious, but for me, nothing beats the meatballs at Cicero's. More often than not my go-to take-out is a meatball sub. And the staff is always friendly. read more

Great food. The I recently tried the pizza at Ciseros, and it was an absolute delight! The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh, and the sauce had a delicious balance of flavors. The cozy ambiance added to the overall enjoyable dining experience. Highly recommended! read more

Cicero's Pizzeria - Awesome owner!! - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

See all

Tried out Cicero's for the first time as we explore restaurants in our new neighborhood. I had the lasagna and it was very well done, nice portion and even had some left over for lunch the next day. The wife had the fettuccine Alfredo and liked it as well. Also had some lunch the next day. I was hoping to drink a beer while I waited for my food but no beers here. Also no TV as an NFL game was on at the time. They do a great pickup business and next time we'll pickup as well. read more

Worked here throughout High School and still crave Cicero's 15 years later! Was treated extremely well by not only the staff, but the community that rallied around Cicero's. I'd often see someone I knew ordering take-out or delivery every time I worked. I still go here weekly when visiting family. No other pizza compares! Tim, the owner, has been here forever! And they stick to the same principles they were founded on. A true staple in Mission Viejo that values the community. Incredible pizza, pasta, subs, and more. With Big-O going out after over 40 years in business, Cicero's needs to be protected at all costs! El hefe for life! read more

I've been trying to give these chumps chance after chance because I'm Italian and live very close but seriously these idiots are a circus. Always got ripped off there. Get home no salad or sometimes bread or wrong order all together. Last week we ordered take out. I ordered penne with meatballs guess what No FreAkiN meatballs and the pasta was so overcooked it's fell apart. Talking about ruining a dinner !!! My daughter had ravioli and it was overcooked too. Tried again last Friday and guess what. No bread. What the hell is wrong with these idiots ? No quality control what so ever. They have some good recipes but the service and continuous mistakes is a damn ripoff. Owners should pull their head out of wherever it is. read more

Cicero's Pizzeria - Penne with meatballs but No meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Mission Viejo, California

Large Cicero's Special, Large House Salad, and Tiramisu, priceless evening feast (but for a reasonable price)

Ciceros Pizza. Better than the best.!!! I'm salivating. Just thinking about it.. I get the tomato and Basil Pizza with extra garlic..

I used to eat here all the time but last time I was there the health department guy was saying to the owner you have ignored my violations and if this happens again I will be forced to shut you down then I look on here . He has a load of violations. It sounds like a waste dump. I'm not eating here again read more

We take out from this place all the time. Food quality has always been good and love the small business in our neighborhood.