Waited an hour while people that arrived after got their food before us including a party of 12…read morethat's got their food before us as well. Waited an hour for them to tell us our pizza hadn't even been put into the oven on top of that they didn't give a full refund for the food absolutely poor customer service

Pizza taste very good The breadstick is like a sequel whats…read moreactually good The interior was inviting.

We are lucky in Salem to have 3 pretty good Italian/Pizza places. I'd say Joe's has the nicest and…read morelargest dining room of the three. Today instead of ordering the daily lunch special like we normally do my wife got the soup and salad (I think soups are a new item here) and I ordered chicken Parmesan. The side salads you get are pretty large. We don't like tomatoes peppers and olives so ours are pretty plain. She had Caesar and I had regular. Both came with lots of cheese and mine had bacon. They do give you a pretty small container of dressing, but I guess that is kind of a good thing. Soup choices were tomato or potato and she chose potato. She thought it was a bit underdone. My chicken parm came with a half sized serving of pasta, which was pretty large. I was so full from just eating the salad and chicken parm I took the pasta home. I've had the baked meatballs too and both dishes are pretty similar. Lots of cheese. The meatballs could use more sauce, but are limited by the baking dish. I like them both well enough to have had them multiple times.

Food is mostly microwaved, soggy, and not at a proper portion ratio…read more Servers and staff are very polite though. 10/10 If I go again, it's because I know I won't be waiting for service.

The guy that works during the day by himself does an amazing job!! Kudos!! He needs a raise!read more

Awful! The last 2 times we've visited the staff has been in the back LOUDLY talking poorly about…read morecustomers and cussing, even with small children in the restaurant, let alone customers at all. We will not be visiting until this place is cleaned up considerably!

Their donut holes are disgusting. They taste like Plato. Not recommended unless you like Play-Doh…read more they are disgusting

For pizza from a gas station, Casey's is actually really good! I love their taco pizza and their…read morepizza crusts are so good. You can order pizza to pick up or by the slice. They usually don't have very much to get by the slice unless it is during meal time. Their prices are also very reasonable. This is a quick meal for a busy night.

So lucky to have this family owned restaurant! Nice varied…read moremenu, a longtime favorite for over 50 years! Fresh made pizza dough with delicious toppings.

Always and forever, a Carmi standard! We love everything about Dimaggio's! Don't hesitate-- just…read moreorder and enjoy!!

The best, I've had since I was 12, the only pizza I'd eat in Illinois. Wish they would deliver to…read moreother states

Writing this review even though it's been over a decade since I've sinned here. It was a favorite…read moreof mine when I attended college. The food & staff was always superb. I have lots of great memories with old friends.

Poor service. Over charging and hard to get servers to the table I evidently do not believe in a…read morelot of training for their servers, and I asked for napkins for a spill, and she went and waited on two other tables stood of the counter and talked before she ever brought me in napkins

We were passing through. Great stop! People were nice, food was awesome!! The whole family loved…read moreit.