Late-night cravings = satisfied! I stopped by Buddhaberry…read morefor a late night treat and wow this place did not disappoint at all. The frozen yogurt was insanely delicious...probably the best I've had in a long time. Super creamy, rich flavors, and all the toppings your heart could want. The staff was so friendly and welcoming, even that late in the evening, and the shop itself was nice and spotless which says a lot. I'm was just visiting the area, and I so wish we had one of these in Jersey. I'd be a regular for sure. Can't wait for my next trip back just for this place. Highly recommend if you're anywhere nearby. Total gem!

I wouldn't typically bother with writing a review for a self service frozen yogurt place. I mean, I…read morecould definitely applaud my own ability to make a delicious cup filled to exactly the right level... but that would just be silly. However, the flavors at Buddhaberry are surprising and delicious and the variety of toppings can't be beat. I recommend the Mexican Hot Chocolate yogurt which is precisely the right amount of spicy, and adding the s'mores cluster topping gave just a bit of sweetness and crunch to make for a great combo.

Yummylicious is a awesome ice cream store in Downtown sag Harbor. They offer speciality ice cream,…read moresorbet or yogurt. Try out a few samples. The mango and the cotton candy flavors are amazing.

Walking through this beautiful neighborhood, admiring the boats, the atmosphere, the shops, we…read moreneeded to get the kids ice cream to bribe them into cooperating. This shop has no seating but on a beautiful day, you just take it to go or sit outside on a bench. No bathroom either so bring hand sanitizer before you let the kids eat. On this day, they had usual flavors one of which was cotton candy ice cream. It tasted exactly how you'd imagine cotton candy ice cream to taste. Very expensive but what do you expect.

After dinner, we decided that we had a hankering for a little bit of ice cream so we went to Big…read moreOlaf. The line was out the door, and we ended up waiting 20-30 minutes or so which wasn't too bad. The people behind the counter got through the line quite quickly while also being generous about letting people try different flavors. I went with one of the seasonal flavors, peanut butter chip ice cream, which was tasty. There are so many different flavors to choose from which is is a great problem to have. Big Olaf is an old school place which is cash only.

CA$H ONLY!!! This is so important. While there is an ATM inside, so many people I saw got turned…read moreaway bc they did not have cash or a debit card. If you are lucky/smart enough to bring cash, the place is delightful. The scoops are huge, there are a ton of flavors (including vegan), and the waffle cones and ice cream are tasty. There's a reason why Big Olaf is in its 49th season and its because the ice cream is so good. Friendly staff, free samples, and free parking out front. Just remember to bring your ca$h monies!!!

Bougie candy store with some great gummy candy sold for way too much money. But they did have a…read moreblack licorice option in addition to the rainbow colored gummies my kiddos gravitate to. The pretty pink bags they have you dump your candy into are also pretty cute too. Gah, this place is a money pit.

From the owner: The magical world of BonBon was founded in 2017 by friends Bobby, Leo and Selim to sweeten and…read morerevolutionize the US candy world; through a love for their homeland and its sweet and savory treats. On our journey since launching our Lower East Side retail location, community events and online efforts; we have become the bona fide destination for anyone with a sweet or savory tooth for Scandinavian treats. We import all products ourselves from Sweden, this way we can always ensure quality and the highest standards as set by real-life Oompa Loompas on site in Sweden and New York. We believe that everyone should be able to enjoy BonBon candy and we therefore strive to have as many of our products as possible be vegan, gluten free and made with natural colorants. In the fall of 2020 our first very own produced candy - Sour Wild Strawberry Fish were made to be made as such and were followed by our Sweet Wild Strawberry Fish, Sour Blackberry Fish, Sour Elderflower Fish and Sour Peach Fish. Hope to see you in the shop soon! Love, BonBon

I was shocked to walk up to this location and find a line out the door. While we had a decent wait,…read morethe food and service made up for it! The location itself is also very cute (I was in love with the VHS tv they had in the back playing old movies!) My iced coffee was wonderful and the donut was delicious. The barista staff were quick and very helpful. Definitely a pricey location (about $5 for a donut) but I would go again!

First barista was extremely pleasant and the coffee is good. However, as the first barista made my…read morecoffee the second girl with balayage changed snd overcharged me for donuts. I chose three mini donuts and one regular which was accurately charged by the barista. The second girl came and changed the order to two and two. I was confused and assumed the other barista must have given me a larger donut which would have been alright. Upon actually opening the box I learned I only have one large donut. Very strange behavior and I am visiting for a conference, perhaps that's just the treatment for tourists at this establishment. Unless you're a local I would not recommend as the experience with the second barista (who was in the back throughout a majority of the interaction and ordering) is a frustrating and confusing one.

Local American restaurant located in Sag Harbor. We came as a large group on a Wednesday evening a…read morethe ambiance was bustling. I ordered the flounder which lasted a bit lacking in flavor, but maybe that more on me for trying to be healthy. The cod bites were good, calamari not bad. I personally didn't order it but the fish and chips portion looked massive and yummy. Food also took a while to come out but again we were a large group.

Decent place, nice local crowd & the bar tender was friendly. Best thing about this place is the…read moreinside/location. Old school east end feel with a great view. The wings are much like Elbow II in Laurel. The breaded food service delivery brand, just add your own sauce. I didn't have a chance to try a burger or any of their other specials, I'll feel that might bump them up to four stars.

Quick and easy order and turn around time…read more I got an island blue smoothie , a double smash burger and fries very delightful all around. Cashier was kind NOTE : Not accepting cash at the moment... I'm not sure that's legal in NY... Also, I believe no "doubles" are sold here, only at the Amaganset location... bold to have that name without them as your staple.

Not what I was expecting from a place that features jerk seasoning…read more Overall, not the worst food on the planet. The jerk bowl was average at best..A lot for rice and beans however I was expecting black eye-peas not red bean..A lot of cabbage while lacking the true flavor of jerk seasoning. Also had the fish sandwich which was mid at best...As a local, wouldn't recommend unless in a deep pinch.

Such a cute coffee shop. Came here with my mom and brother on our recent trip out east, and decided…read moreto grab some coffee after having lunch over at Lulu's. The place was busy but not packed -- we were able to grab a cute table over by the windows which had comfy cushions and pillows. I ordered a cappuccino which came out quickly and was nice and hot and strong. There was a lot of great people watching here -- folks getting work done as well as some cute dogs. Taking a look at their Apres menu made me wish I was in town longer or later -- it looks like they have a great food and drink menu at night! There's also a souvenir shop attached to this location if you're in the mood to do a little shopping while you're here. The service was fast and friendly. I'd come back.

December 2025. If you enjoy a good cup of Joe....I recommend…read morethis place. It's what Starbucks USED to be. Service is friendly and it's a welcoming and casual atmosphere.

While enjoying a good day in Sag Harbor, we just stopped by this place for lunch. Le Frenchie…read moreburger was good and delicious. It was big enough for one person, nicely flavored and cooked. Grilled chicken sandwich with Brie, apple and mustard was okayish. I kind of expected more of it, but overall good big portion. Crispy chicken bao was good and was served with a nice sauce.

Z‍ The service was amazing, they helped me choose the LT…read morebackyard burger which I think is a very solid burger. there's nothing absolutely but I enjoyed every bite. Didn't try their fries but they look good. I could see 'em at a couple of tables, taking a peek, peeping like a Tom, and they look good. I want to come back and try all their burgers though. I'm so happy they're back. I never even once understood why they changed it to a taco joint when K Pasa is right down the street. And they own K Pasa. Truly bizarre. Did they think the tequila demand was that high? Anyhoops, I recommend this place and it's solid as a rock. A burger rock. Since my, T.J. Miller - the original yelp gangster

Best Burger. Don't try to modify it, order it as the chef recommends. This is the best burger…read more You're welcome.

I would have given 5 stars but the hostess was awkward and rude. We booked a table inside and upon…read morearriving were told that we were wrong and sat outside. She gaslit us and told us we were lying and that she "can promise we arent on the books for inside". We spoke to people around us and it seems that the same thing happened to everyone. She was extremely unclear and rude and demanded proof that we booked inside. Other than that, we had a lovely lunch. Our waitress was amazing and made up for the incompetence of the hostess who absolutely shouldn't be working in customer service.