I have eaten at most of the restaurants in this area except this one because of the lack of…read morepictures of the food, no website and no menu to look at. Two things will happen today which is restaurant of the week and a Steve stop by. The place is nice looking with a tropical colorful theme. The have a steam table at the counter with some pre made goodness as a visual come on and get something. I ordered the rellenos de papa and the pork jibarito with PR rice. I will admit like the other reviews service was slow for me being the only person in the place and a good 10 minutes before I heard my sandwich sizzling on the grill. The rellenos de papa is basically a ball of mashed potatoes with a ground meat filling fried to a golden brown. This was bland and needed seasoning but still good with a thin crispy shell. The Puerto Rican rice was also bland with pigeon peas but cooked perfect Al Dente and not mushy. The pork jibartio was very good with a nice garlicky flavor. It's this crispy plantain fried nicely, hearty roast pork, cheese, lettuce, tomato and a very garlicky mayo and I mean fresh garlic flavor. This version was the tastiest, meatiest and biggest pork jibartio I have had in town. I enjoyed the food and like other reviewers I'm not going to take stars away for the slow service because I have never been to Puerto Rico and for all I know this is how service is in Puerto Rico. I have a known good place specific foods like pizza, burger etc etc and I think this will be my pork jibartio place because of the garlic Mayo.

During the worst of COVID this place took a downturn but they are back up on top. Typical Puerto…read moreRican service, so it's friendly and slow. Unlike other Boricuan restaurants, no one here speaks American English, but that doesn't even slow me down a little. When I've got a taste for chuletas, I'll figure out a way to get them on my plate. Besides, I wouldn't want to eat in a Puerto Rican restaurant where they could only speak English. So because my Spanish isn't very good, I end up ordering more of the different fried dumplinas, pastilillos, and empanadillos than I can eat because I'm never completely sure what's in them. You'd think I'd remember, but it doesn't matter, almost as good reheated the next day. Be careful, it's a dangerous intersection for pedestrians.

Great food, bakery items on point and owners friendly and love the smalll cafe ambiance. Food takes…read morea little longer because they cook it to order which I love. Be patient.

We came to Milwaukee for a baseball game. My husband and I loved our meal here! It was absolutely…read moredelicious! We had the roasted pork and rice as well as jibarito - steak! Food was amazing and the staff was so friendly and helpful! Thank you - love from Ohio!

I did a carry out order and was greeted right away. Very laid back atmosphere. Not very crowded…read more Nice place to to sit and have a drink. Parking around the place is street only.

I love this restaurant. 100% one of my favorite Caribbean restaurants in the city! The food is so…read moregood and the vibes of the restaurant remind me so much of the islands. Also, if you are able to try any of their fresh juices, please do so you don't miss out! The passion fruit juice is to die for.

I ordered takeout online for the Benito Bowl. The order process was easy, and my food was hot and…read moreready when I arrived. Parking was a little tricky (it was a busy time of day). The inside of the restaurant was super warm and welcoming. I would love to come back and dine in sometime! My car smelled so good all the way home - it was hard not to sneak a bite! I tried the pernil with mofongo al caldero and it was fantastic. So good! The mofongo was super flavorful, and the pork was delicious. I also tried some of the Pechuga al Ajill (chicken in garlic sauce) - really, really good. I ordered some tostones and an alcapurria de masa. They were generously sized and piping hot.

I was a really big fan of the inside of this place! Plenty of seating, choice of bar seating too,…read moreand overall beautiful rican vibe here. Amazing service, she was very nice and helpful. Food was just okay! I loved how crunchy the pollo frito was, rice fell a bit short flavor wise. The sandwich too was okay. The meat was very oversalted but the potential was there.

The food was very good. I definitely recommend anyone who wants to try different cultural food…read more...to go here! The food they cook is Puerto Rican Barbecue. I got the Piggy Mixto with crazy fries (pictured). I also tried their Nutella frappe, which was both refreshing and delicious.

Very disappointed. Not worth the trip. Just left there. The tostones were awful. Not worth the…read moreprice. Half pound of lechon and side of tostones with parcha was $30. It was over priced. Definitely not going back!

I don't go into mke too often but wanted to visit and see if I could find a good Puerto…read moreRican/Caribbean restaurant since I was in the area. McCoco's stood out to me so I decided to give it a try. The service was great- it's a small establishment and once we walked in someone immediately greeting us and sat us down. The ambiance was very pleasant. They had pictures of the Caribbean on all the tvs and it felt very tropical Once we were sitting we got a complimentary bowl of soup. It was so warm and perfect for the cold day. I forgot what it was called but it was very delicious. Food I would say overall was good. I was hoping the tostones to be a bit more crispier and a little more garlicky tho /: My mofongo was good too - again missing just a tad more garlic. The meat was well seasoned and very tasty. My boyfriend got the Jibarito and he basically said the same thing about the garlic and crispiness of the tostones and his jibarito sandwich. I would still recommend this place tho! And I would for sure come again to explore the rest of the menu (: 3 1/2 - 4 stars overall

Wow - so glad we ordered this!…read more Ordered via Grubhub and got the arroz con gandeles 2x1 with the bander pepper steak. Both were large portions and absolutely delicious! Tried the Yuca sticks and tostones appetizers and really enjoyed both of them. I'm a big empanada fan so we got some chicken empanadas and they did not disappoint! All told everything we had was fantastic. We will absolutely be back and will have to visit in person one day.

A I really love getting into the off beat neighborhoods and trying the little neighborhood places…read morelike today. I stumbled on this Puerto Rican place and I wanted to try it because I don't really see true Puerto Rican places at all come to think of it. I have not had Puerto Rican food since I was a boy eating at my friends house and I can only remember that rice was always on the dish. The place is across from the El Ray food store on 13th St with plenty of street parking. The neighborhood looks a little worse for wear but that is where you can find some of the best ethnic/real food. If there is such a thing as Puerto Rican dive than this place is it with all the artificial trees and roosters all over the place. There is plenty of old green booths and tables on old linoleum floors. Up front is a hot table with empanadas, blood sausage, pork, plantains etc. The older man and woman were very helpful in assisting me with picking out a dish that would be a good representation of Puerto Rican food. The menu has so much that I really don't know what it all was but I probably would have liked all of it no matter what I chose. I chose the Bistec enpanado which is thin breaded steak, Puerto Rican rice and fried plantains with a side of ground beef and cheese empanada. When the plate hit the table it smelled amazing and was plentiful so there would be left overs to relive my lunch again. For the first time I liked the plantains because they were not hard but fried with the texture of a thick slice of cheese. The rice had great texture/flavor and was fluffy with individual grains, no sticky mushy rice here. The breaded steak was very tasty but I can't nail down the flavor profile which bugged me. The empanadas was crispy/golden tasty but they were skimpy on the ground beef and cheese filling because 3/4 of the inside was air, see my pictures. I really liked all the flavors from the dish but I think the nicely seasoned ground beef and cheese empanada was my favorite with the crispy golden she'll. Overall for my first real adult experience with authentic Puerto Rican food I liked it even though the style is not super flavorful with bold tastes or flavors/spices. I would definitely like to get back and try some more of the menu, maybe the roast pork or the cubano sandwich.

Love this place.. Never a bad meal or experience! The hot case is a great go to for a snackread more

This location was the previous home of La Morovena, which was also a Puerto Rican carry-out only…read morerestaurant. La Morovena moved to 8th & Greenfield, and El Rincon Criollo now serves here. I ordered an alcapurria, which is a mix of plantain and root vegetables pureed and filled with meat, potatoes, and seasoning, then deep fried. It was pretty good and larger than I expected. My entree was mofongo, a large ball of mashed green plantain which is deep fried and filled with seasoning and bits of chicharron, with bistek encebollado (steak cooked in oil and onions). The mofongo had decent flavor and a substantial amount of chicharron, which helped counter the otherwise disappointingly soft texture of the mofongo. The steak was tender and the flavor was solid. I would definitely go back to try other menu items, or one of the daily specials.

What I like about this place is that it satisfied every Puerto Rican desire to feel at home in this…read morecold ass winter. Great service!