Our room looked like it had been converted from a storage room or something. It was really loud,…read morecould hear people running up and down hallways until midnight. Room was also next to where they served breakfast, so at around 6 am you could hear them preparing for the morning meal. Lots of clunking and slamming things. Shower head leaked like a sieve, so it made for an interesting shower. Place was neat and clean, just REALLY LOUD. Things might have been different if it wasn't for that weird room we had? After stopping at the Holiday Inn Express in Mitchell, I looked to see what that room was here....sure enough, it was storage and restrooms. If they try and give you room 125, RUN.

All though the price is on the high end, I have to say I am more than happy to pay it!…read more The front desk woman is amazing, I wish I knew her name. She has a rose tattoo on her right forearm and she has a GREAT attitude. Our boxer dog even took two treats from her. && Kenya doesn't even like treats! The rooms are clean, beds are comfy and I am sure breakfast will be awesome. I would recommend this place.

Tucked away (and I mean "tucked" away) in Newcastle, you'll find your stay for the evening. Don't…read moreget discouraged if you can't find it right away. It's there. I eventually found it. Of course, I wasn't using GPS like you are, so it took me a bit longer. Tucked away means quiet and quiet it was. Birds chirping were the only sounds I heard when I opened the car door. That's a good sign if you're looking for quiet. I checked in and was given room #13. Yes, it ran through my mind, uh oh, unlucky number 13. But doom and gloom weren't in the cards for me. Quite the contrary. Number 13 was exceptionally clean and comfortable. My host was friendly and helpful when it came to suggesting a place for dinner. Though trying to follow his directions found me at an oil refinery. LoL! Again, no GPS. I eventually backtracked and ended up where I started to. Quick Tip: At your next stop at a store, pick up some cheap double AA batteries and shove them into your suitcase. You'll be glad you did when your remote for the TV doesn't work. No having to go through the hassle of getting dressed and making your way to the front desk or waiting for maintenance to get to your room. Just pop them in, and you're set. As I had to do at The Pines. It didn't take but a minute before I could watch the mindless dribble which spewed forth. Oh, don't forget to pull your batteries before you leave. You'll undoubtedly need them down the road.

What a nice hidden little gem. Found this while just searching on Google for places to stay…read moreovernight. I didn't want to spend a lot because this was just going to be used for sleep during a nice little road trip. The owner actually was outside when we pulled up late(930pm) and he was very helpful and gave us the room key. The room was small and quaint very clean very vintage feeling. The bed was very comfortable it was soft but firm and did not feel old. Very quiet environment no loud noises even early in the morning. Also, a very cute area outside for lounging around. I would highly recommend staying here!

Great historic building, formerly the Benevolent Hall built in 1886, now a unique hotel. Modern…read morerustic with lofts in all rooms, queen beds on the first floor, king or twins in loft area. Balconies on some of the second floor rooms. Coffee shop downstairs and 24 hour water and coffee available. Lovely two story seating area and back deck on 2nd floor. Excellent location on Main Street within walking distance of many restaurants. Leigh was super helpful and patient with our indecision on whether to stay one nights or two. we opted for two. Would happily stay here again. Not a lot open in mid April but we did visit New To You, Loud American Bar & Grill and Rossini Gypsy Tattoo Parlor, Uncle Louie's and Red's Bar & Grill. These rooms are unique, clean and comfy. Original (?) tin ceilings. Motorized shades for windows.

We booked our stay direct at the hotel during a road trip, after checking online for pricing first…read more They were the same. We booked two of the standard/cheapest rooms for $159. For some reason the receptionist booked us at a more expensive rooms. We didn't realize until the next day seeing the receipt email. It was all very strange, but the manager did make it right the next day thankfully. I would recommend booking online to avoid any confusion. The location is right on the main drag- in walking distance of everything you need and next to the rallies. The hotel is historic and completely renovated in a mix of original and modern. Original detailed ceilings and exposed brick was really special. The rooms were great! All the rooms have two beds in a loft. (You might need to bring luggage up stairs for one of the beds.) Two very large beds- I thought they were supposed to be queen but I think they were kings. The sheets are buttery soft and the mattress was perfection. I travel full time and this is one of the most comfortable hotel beds I've been in. We stayed in 210 & 208 both window rooms- 210 had a window that was low enough to open the blinds to get natural light and peep out, but 208 was much higher- both cool rooms. The balconies rooms would be well worth the price if you were staying for a rally. Cool cafe downstairs. House coffee is included with the stay- 3 blends available. There was no basic black coffee- I am a basic black coffee girl- so I was scared- but the blends were very subtle flavoring and delicious. They have a full cafe with lots of great sounding drinks.

The finest, friendliest, cleanest place to stay. Tremendous value for the money. The breakfast is…read morephenomenal and beats the hell out of any hotel breakfast that I have ever had. Great selection and service. Nice pool and jacuzzi. Great, friendly, and knowledgeable staff. Most hotel staff at other high-end hotels I have stayed at are incapable of giving directions out of a paper bag. The staff at the Americinn know their way around and are super helpful.

From the moment you walk through the doors, you are welcomed by all staff with a smile or hello…read more The lobby has literally a library with books for adults and children, board games, and an ongoing puzzle waiting for another piece to be found. Also has an indoor pool and a jacuzzi. Breakfast included and lots to choose from. Clean Hotel.

We arrived and were greeted by Kamran at the front desk who was so incredibly nice and helpful…read more Kamran let us know that the hotel had just been remodeled and that the rooms were very nice and he was right. Our room was so clean and fresh and we were very pleased with everything.

Deb is a so-called go to person with tour bus guest. she is quite rude, unprofessional and…read moreevidently doesn't know the ADA laws. We were to have handicapped accessible room, didn't at 1st had to request it AGAIN when it was on the original reservation. BORING BREAKFAST. same junk everyday. No Raisin Bran. got sick of waffles for 3 days. No originality where's the eggs sausage gravy and biscuits Rooms are ok. outdated terribly. She just ruined my stay from then on out. she needs replaced. Will never stay here again.

Very clean, great bedding and spacious bathroom. The a/c was super loud and wifi didnt work…read more We were not informed about breakfast which according to my reservation, was included

I give Sage motel a lot of credit for being the only place in Newcastle that was able to provide…read morelast minute availability. Without the Sage motel, I would have been forced to sleep in my car for the evening in an area that I'm completely unfamiliar with. And the price couldn't be beat! The cons: No pets allowed. No breakfast offered. I did not see an ice machine. Overall, it's not a bad place to stay for a night.

Check-in staff was so friendly and nice and the rooms were clean and comfortable! The morning…read morebreakfast was above and beyond and the hospitality lady Diane made the best omelets! A gem in a small town.

This hotel is amazing, the breakfast is an actual meal and not some old stale bagels and danishes…read morewith week old coffee, the service is legit, you don't have to beg for towels or toilet paper, I checked in to my room and there was a stack of full sized towels! They also turn over the room every day, not just once a week, so your room is always clean and stocked up, there is a pool and hot tub that is available until Midnight and they have beach towels available so don't have to take two of your room towels, they also have a laundry that I should've taken advantage of - this place is really great

My hunting partners and I have stopped several times over the last few years. We've had our deer…read moreand antelope processed here. They do a great job at a more than reasonable price. They also have a taxidermist. Rocky Top Taxidermy. I've gotten a European mount done, and my friends have had shoulder mounts. They do an awesome job.

I'll start my review by giving 5 's!!! From the very moment…read morewe arrived for our stay at the lodge during our 5 day hunt trip, we were treated like family. More like kings! Hospitality was over the top. Twyla and Larry the owners of this historical landmark are two of the most amazing people. Didn't think it could get better than the first day until the next day arrived and was amazed to see it would get even better. Breakfast, lunch and dinner was top notch! Amazing!! They truly work very hard to make sure your stay is memorable. You could spend the day just fooling around looking at the amazing sites or stay in the lodge and look at amazement at the fish and wildlife their family have taken over the years in their own backyard. What a paradise. I have made two new life friends and will definitely be returning very soon. Thank you Twyla and Larry for an amazing time Chris B

Didn't stay here. Nasty owner. GPS took me to the wrong motel. I was registered with the Sage…read moreMotel 300 feet away. I called a phone number on the door of the Hilltop Inn. The owner of Hilltop said, "You should learn to read." Then laughed and hung up on me. Luckily the owner of the Sage Motel was very kind. The Sage Motel is beautiful on the outside! The Sage Motel has great WIFI and many charging ports. Beautiful king sized bed. I highly recommend driving past the Hilltop Motel to the Sage Motel. Locally owned. Refreshing attitude and service.

This is our third time staying at the Hilltop and this time our stay was perfect. The rooms are…read morenewly remodeled, bright, airy and clean. The price is amazing, about 30%-50% less than what other hotels in Newcastle are charging. And if you want a hotel room right in the Black Hills, say in Custer (37 mi away), expect to pay 4X as much. Newcastle is right between Devil's Tower (WY) and Mount Rushmore (SD), so it is the perfect location for all your Black Hills site seeing. Yes, this is an older hotel, built in the 40's or 50's and the rooms are small. But they are spotlessly clean. The tub has an 11-jet Jacuzzi, the perfect thing after day of hiking the trails and seeing the sites in the Black Hills. There's a small kitchen area with a table, 2 chairs, a bench, a small fridge (that actually freezes ice!) and a microwave. No phone, but there's TV, WiFi and plenty of plug outlets to charge all your electronics. The only thing this room lacks is hangers, so bring a few with you. If you've read negative reviews about the Hilltop, check the date. It is true that under the former owners the rooms were often not clean and with worn carpet and dark paneling, the room seem closed and dingy. But now, under new ownership, this is an ideal place to stay.

The front desk people were very nice. I had finished my box of Kleenex went to the front desk and…read morehe gave me a brand new one.. The breakfast was scrambled eggs, waffles, yogurt, fresh fruit, we had biscuits and gravy that morning and the coffee was just right. They also had apple juice and orange juice. But the thing that I want you to be aware of is that they've done a retrofit on some of their locks and so our room 109 needed repair. We would not have been aware of it if somebody hadn't tried to get into our room, he was at the wrong room, but he was able to open the door and thank gosh I had the safety lock on , I told the front desk and they will work on it, but I just wanted you to be aware of this particular room. You can check it to make sure your room is not in the retrofit selection without your key. See if you can open the door. even if the deadbolt is thrown. Ya'll have a blessed vacation.

Sticky carpets need cleaned. Pop or coke slopped on wall by…read morelight switch 6:05 am. Coffee machine in maintenance mode or flush system mode. No coffee at 6:05 am. No waffle batter. Went to front desk and no one there. Looked down hall no one there. Check your security footage to verify. Picked up phone dialed zero to talk to front desk, rang 8 times and I left it ringing. Check your security footage to verify. No one on duty at 6:05 am??? Was anyone on duty thru the night?? Don't feel very safe there. 9-7-2024 update The manager of super 8 Sturgis SD emailed me today and said that since I "used electricity", slept in bed, used bathroom that there will be no refund. He said I used "some" amenities and should not expect all amenities to be available.... Such as s staff member on site on duty, or breakfast. Stephen Holmes, CEO of Wyndham, perhaps dirty motels and rude managers with zero integrity are the reason Choice Hotels is fighting your hostile takeover..: Choice has quality control standards and customer service standards. Also President Geoff Ballotti. Finally found Geoff's contact info and left a message with his assistant.