Excellent ice cream, if a little pricey. We visited on July 9th and the music was so loud that we…read morecouldn't hold a conversation, and could barely hear the server and the cashier.

Solid three stars for delicious Prince Edward Island ice cream. There is a gift shop as well. The…read morekiddie cone was enough ice cream.

These big blobs of fried dough covered in Nutella or frosting are a delicious indulgence! That said…read morethe service was so slow they were cold by the time we got them and the ambiance was simple, gaudy Boardwalk at this location.

I have mixed feelings on beavertails. They are pretty tasty and of good quality. They are a bit on…read morethe pricy side but that is to be expected in a tourist trap area. I got the skor flavor and it was pretty good but the standard cinnamon is probably the best flavor. This particular location was very busy on a saturday on the busiest weekend of the year so i am going to cut some slack to the cashier... She was likely tired, cranky, and had a long day, and it showed. they should get someone with more energy and patience to deal with the clients.

Such a gift in the hot summer! Kiwi flavor was my favourite and it was cheaper than Ontarioread more

Stopped for lunch here at the Cavendish Boardwalk after seeing the AoGG Heritage site. This place…read morewas *hopping* for lunch, which is always a good sign. Our family has to navigate life with a severe nut allergy, so we were impressed when the staff took the time to discuss with us exactly which menu items were made in-house and safe. It's a mom and pop operation, they talked about how hard it was to find consistency and quality from the suppliers during -and after- the pandemic. We were able to find several food options for my son, and for him we ordered fried fish with a side of poutine. He was in heaven. Well, we all were, actually, because the seafood was delish. We even returned later for soft serve ice cream because they guaranteed it was nut-free. My kid has only had ice cream from a commercial restaurant maybe 2 or 3 times in his life, so it was a very rare and welcome treat. We definitely recommend Captain Scott's - both for their food and also for their family's friendliness and service. We love this place. Thank you!

The food was terrible and most likely frozen beforehand. The staff were unfriendly and the prices…read morewere high for such small portions/servings. The place was kind of depressing it was empty and staff were on their phones the whole time. Multiple people came in and left because of the ridiculous prices. The staff weren't doing their jobs as they were sit around and not doing anything while on their phones. Overall do NOT come to this restaurant it was my worst part of my trip to Canada.

It was a pleasant summer evening against a stunning sunset. I had the PEI Apple Crisp with a…read morechocolate peanut cone. Almost too much toffee relative to a faint apple flavour. The cone, while fresh, resulted in an overwhelming cone to ice cream ratio towards the end. Cows always has rich ice cream although often heavy on the caramel. The rest of the family appreciated the selection and had difficulty deciding. We will be back!

Burnt sugar ice cream? I've never heard of such a flavor, but hell if it ain't excellent. We're…read moreusually pretty skeptical of ice cream joints in a tourist town, but after seeing the lines back at the location in Halifax we figured they had to be pretty good. We were there pre busy season so it was quick in, quick out, helpful servers scooping. There's a neat little shop with all manner of kitsch attached to it if that's your way. I mean, all in all a solid showing, it's top shelf and you get a hefty scoop for the price. Pro tip: if you get a 2 scooper, get two flavors. The burnt sugar went really well with chocolate peanut butter cup.

Service was excellent and quick. However, the food is…read morepretty expensive for what it is. For 2 meals it was just about $50. The food was mediocre and really not worth the cost. It was good but not $50 for 2 meals good.

Affordable chip stand fare. Had a fish sandwich, scallop burger and club sandwich. Club and fish…read morewere very good the scallop burger not so much - dry and chewy. Served with huge amounts of the sides - onion rings and sweet potato fries. All the food seems to be pre-made, frozen food that is fried/cooked on site. The staff are very young - so please be patient.

It was a warm and overcast Wednesday afternoon, and we entered the newly renovated and expanded…read morelocation. This place has a wonderful selection of soft serve with unique flavours that are made with fresh ingredients. A worthwhile stop and worth the wait - we will be back before we leave!

Great ice cream joint in a wonderful town on PEI! Definitely stop by if you want some good ice…read morecream.

Perfect spot to pick up a scoop of ice ream or enjoy a shot of espresso on the north shore of PEI!…read moreA modern take on an old fashioned ice cream parlour. Deck on the front and picnic tables/lawn games. Right next door to Village Pottery so you can shop as well from the longest running pottery shop on Prince Edward Island while you're there!

Im not kidding when I say that I would go back to P.E.I. just to go to Potters. Yes Cow's is so…read moredelicious, but this place exceeds beyond expectations. First off Prince Edward Island probably has got to have the best dairy products in North America even New England. Yes I have lived in New England for 27.66 years. I had a caramel swirl small sized ice cream. The portion for a small was suprisingly Texas size. I did not eat the ice cream till 30 min later after I purchased and it was still so firm and creamy. I think there is this best kept and top secret in which no one in this province will ever disclose in making quintessential ice cream. Apart from the Ice Cream I also purchased a donut. Donut like the ice cream was beyond outstanding. I had the cake battered donut with vanilla frosting with fruit loops sprinkled on top of it. It tasted so different than any donuts I ever had. I prefer store bought donuts as oppose to Dunkin Donuts found all over greater Boston. However, now after I tried a PEI donut from Potters I will never go to Dunkin Donuts. The texture was so firm and fresh even one day after the purchase. I believe it has some potato starch from the red soils. I hope to come back and see you next time Potters.

We visited on a warm and humid August evening. The sign read "Island's longest salad bar" and while…read morewe could not independently verify that assertion, we can confirm it was one of the longest we have seen. The food was great and service was very friendly. We had a wonderful time cracking the lobster and enjoying it hot with butter. Lots to choose from for an after dinner treat -. The strawberry shortcake was particularly delicious while the kids enjoyed the ice cream. A great experience and wonderful time!

I have been going here for years and I grew up in Sherwood PEI. Tonight I had the worst lobster I…read morehave ever had in my life. I explained to the server it was horrible and they apologized and offered another one, but I explained I was full and could not do it. She was kind and apologetic but said it's not your fault. The lobster was soo cooked there was very little meat in the claws and what was there was stuck to the side of the shell and had to be somewhat scraped from the shell which really was not enough meat to make it worth it. I complained Ed in the way out and one of the managers said if it was over cooked they all would have been. I have been eating and cooking lobster since I was in my teens. He looked at me and said so what do you want me to do. Lots of people try this to get a meal. I said obviously you are not going to do anything and I left saying we would not be back. As a Veteran, I will pass this on to other Veterans and let them know they are probably better off to go to New Glasgow lobster suppers.

The food is amazing! You will never be disappointed. Not…read morereally a restaurant for small children as the location is small. My favorite restaurant on PEI- it's a must when on the island!

We arrived half hour prior to our reservation time, and the very sweet hostess sat us immediately…read more The servers were friendly and made sure we had what we needed to make our meal enjoyable! We sat by the front windows, and when I walked through the intimate dining room it looked inviting as well. There isn't a lot of seating, and Pedro does all the cooking, so reservations are a must, as they fill up fast and stayed busy the entire time we were there. Pedro came over introduced himself and asked how were our meals. Everything was delicious. My husband was a wonderful chef, and the seafood linguine was bathed in a sauce that replicated my hubby's! He died 8 years ago, so this was a pleasant surprise that brought back some sweet memories. Definitely a yes!