We visited on a warm and humid August evening. The sign read "Island's longest salad bar" and while…read morewe could not independently verify that assertion, we can confirm it was one of the longest we have seen. The food was great and service was very friendly. We had a wonderful time cracking the lobster and enjoying it hot with butter. Lots to choose from for an after dinner treat -. The strawberry shortcake was particularly delicious while the kids enjoyed the ice cream. A great experience and wonderful time!

I have been going here for years and I grew up in Sherwood PEI. Tonight I had the worst lobster I…read morehave ever had in my life. I explained to the server it was horrible and they apologized and offered another one, but I explained I was full and could not do it. She was kind and apologetic but said it's not your fault. The lobster was soo cooked there was very little meat in the claws and what was there was stuck to the side of the shell and had to be somewhat scraped from the shell which really was not enough meat to make it worth it. I complained Ed in the way out and one of the managers said if it was over cooked they all would have been. I have been eating and cooking lobster since I was in my teens. He looked at me and said so what do you want me to do. Lots of people try this to get a meal. I said obviously you are not going to do anything and I left saying we would not be back. As a Veteran, I will pass this on to other Veterans and let them know they are probably better off to go to New Glasgow lobster suppers.

Excellent service! We ordered ahead of time and they cooked our lobster the day of our departure…read moreand packed it on ice in our cooler! Impressed with how they accommodated our needs! Happy customer from Ontario!

Same price as restaurant n not friendly service idk why the reviews have high rates…read more I just went to a restaurant and groceries in Charlotte Town also steams lobster for u

This place was delicious! Fish and chips the fish was so tender my friend described it as fluffy…read moreheaven in his mouth! My sister and I both got hamburgers that were handmade patties and absolutely delicious!!!

Nice place right on the water with seating either outside, outside with wind protection and inside…read more Very friendly and attentive wait staff. Beer was cold and oysters were yummy but small and a bit pricey, 12 dz for $36 CA. No happy hour specials.

Tremendous fish cakes with an excellent salad-- a perfect lunch. The Caesar lacked much flavor…read morethough. Service was polite and prompt.

Tasty food! EXCELLENT SERVICE, thanks Victoria!…read moreVery lively ambiance and beautiful setting. Recommend highly.

Have been at their other location a couple of times and was always impressed, even though we…read moreusually waited to be seated the food was always exceptional. This time we were sadly disappointed. The new place is beautiful for sure but the service and food left a lot to be desired. We waited 50 min for our appetizer which was just baked brie which we make at home all the time and doesn't take that long, and yes we realize they were busy but when you watch others seated 10 min after you get not only their appetizers but their main meal it gets very frustrating. After finishing the appetizer we waited another 40 min for our meal. I had the pork loin which was very dry but mostly good. My husband had the scallop and shrimp dish and found it just ok, definitely had better at other places on the island. We skipped dessert because we just didn't want to sit any longer, it was very hot and very loud. From other reviews I guess your experience can either be very good or just ok depending on the time and day you go. For us this time around was a disappointment.

Stay away if you can. I had a less then average lobster…read moreroll. My wife had a chowder that looked like a blended potatoes with flour. Service was very low class. No wonder the restaurant was empty while other restaurants were full.

The food and service is excellent. We had the stuffed Haddock special and blue mussels in garlic…read moreand butter. EVERYTHING WAS GREAT! Roll, potato salad and coleslaw were the best we have had also.

The weather was overcast and the day arrived with light drizzle. We continued our PEI adventure…read morewith a stop to see what was advertised as "world famous" chowder. The chowder was creamy and full of flavour and served piping hot. We arrived ahead of a tour bus and were promptly seated. The French fries were some of the best we have had. The fish and chips and salmon burgers were also great. I've had better calamari. Efficient and friendly service. Good family spot.

This restaurant offers seating both indoors and outdoors. Interior is warmly decorated and lightly…read morefollows the lobster theme - very cute. We came here as part of a tour. It cost extra (~$60 IIRC) for a lobster lunch. We were each served a lobster and in the centre of the restaurant, they had trays of side dishes (self-serve). I don't remember all the side dishes but there were salads, soup, mussels. One con was that these didn't seem to get refilled as much as they should've throughout our lunch here (though we were told it would be constantly refilled). If you are part of a tour, my tip would be to fill your plate on the first round with whatever you think you'll eat. I usually take small portions and just get more after, but there was no more in this case. :') For the most part, the service was great. Our food was served almost immediately after being seated. The servers were very friendly. Food wasn't bad. I found my lobster to be just a teensy bit overcooked but the food is rarely ever perfect when you're part of a tour, because they have to prepare so much all at once.

I went right on their start time and there was a bit of a line up because you have to order and pay…read morewith like a voucher before eating. We had 4 people in our party and we were afraid of the portion sizes so we ordered 3 at the front. But the waitress told us later on that they made a mistake and said everyone needed a ticket. So we only got appetizers/dessert coupon for one person so we kind of wasted our money.... The course included full or half mussels (choice), tomato andor seafood chowder, salad then lobster either cold or hot and a non- alcoholic beverage. Variety of dessert choices at the end. Everything was good I like how they weren't seasoned but pure taste. Service was nice. Big place, good scenery, might get a little hot when it's crowded. But good place to experience seafood in PEI

This place is a true PEI institution. It started back in 1958 as a fundraiser by the New Glasgow…read moreJunior Farmers, serving lobster and pies in a canteen hauled onto the site for $210. Today, it's grown into a huge dining hall with a polished system--but the sense of tradition is still very much alive. The setup is simple but memorable: everything is all-you-can-eat except the main course. You'll get bowls of seafood chowder, steamed mussels, salads, rolls, and dessert included with your meal. The lobster is the star, of course--I had the 1.5 lb, and it was perfectly cooked, sweet, and tender. The sides are plentiful and satisfying, but they exist to set the stage for that big plate of lobster. Expect a line before the doors open--it's part of the experience. Service is efficient and friendly, clearly well-practiced at managing the volume. This isn't fine dining, and it doesn't pretend to be. It's about tradition, community, and sharing in a piece of PEI history. Bottom line: if you're on the island, a lobster supper here is non-negotiable. It's as much a cultural event as it is a meal.

Fish with fried to death and it was hardly any fish in it and the scallops were fried to death too…read morethe fries were fine. server was nice. The man at the door didn't make us feel very welcome.

The low reviews are kinda ridiculous. First and foremost, the drinks are good, and strong. On the…read moremenu it says "every drink is poured as a double." I'm in right there. The food is typical pub food, but the view is lovely. It's small inside and a little beat up, but you know I kind of like that.

Oh my goodness! Such delicious ice cream!! We went there everyday of our PEI vacation. I have tried…read more8 of their fun named ice cream delights!!! See pics! All staff is pleasant and efficient. I wasn't in a store where there wasn't a line. They also have merch in the store, shirts, stuffies, all sorts of trinkets. No doubt in my mind if I see a Cows I am stopping!!

This place is far busier than their location on Milky Way, as it's located in the very touristy…read morearea of the Cavendish boardwalk. Cons? Be prepared for long lines cramped in a small area. Pros? Lots more flavours to choose from!! Among the four of us, we shared three cups of double scoops. Since you pay only $1 more for an extra scoop, it's very much worth it to share (instead of ordering another single scoop)! We decided to experiment and try new flavours. My sister got the Cookie Moonster again, as she really enjoyed it the last time. She also got the Moo York Cheesecake, but I felt that this flavour wasn't as good. There wasn't a prominent cheesecake flavour, and the taste really just blended with the cookie moonster. My parents shared the Cowconut (my mom's favourite; I found it a bit too overwhelming) and the Maple Walnut (it had quite a strong maple taste, but there were impressive chunks of walnut pieces in the ice cream). I opted for the vanilla - plain and simple, but the best! I also got the PEI Blueberry. We had sampled both the Apple Crisp and the Blueberry... I preferred the Apple Crisp more, but my dad found the caramel bits to be too sweet, so we got the Blueberry. Between the strawberry and blueberry, however, I do prefer the strawberry, so I'm glad I listened to the server the last time at Milky Way!