I've given this place multiple chances, and the result has been the same every time:…read moredisappointment. I've ordered both pizza and subs, and the quality has been consistently poor. The pizza lacked flavor and freshness. On my most recent sub order, I paid extra for additional meat and received what amounted to roughly two pieces of bacon per half. That is not "extra" by any reasonable standard. The sub itself tasted stale and did not seem freshly made. This location was formerly Paparoni's and is now operating as Timmermans, and the decline in quality since the ownership change is obvious. What's more concerning is how criticism is handled. Customer opinions and negative feedback appear to be removed or hidden on their Facebook page, which suggests an attempt to control the narrative rather than address legitimate issues. If a business truly stands behind its product, it shouldn't feel the need to silence dissatisfied customers. I'm posting this here because honest reviews should remain visible to the public. Based on repeated experiences and how feedback is handled, I will not be returning. Others deserve to know before spending their money.

Ordered a family deal large pizza (half cheese, half pepperoni) and sweet sauce country boneless…read morechicken wings and it came with 2 liter bottle of soda. Service was prompt and friendly. Everything was ready within the promised time frame of 20-25 mins. That was great! As far as the pizza, I'd rate it a 3. Average overall. Nothing super special about it. The boneless chicken wings I'd rate a 3 as well. This is a pizza shop in my hometown, so it has some memories attached. However, I did not let them influence my rating. I keep it real and honest!

I stopped by Daryls today and had a couple slices. Not the best ever, but solid enough that I'd get…read morethem again. For $11, I got two slices, a cookie, and a drink. The homemade blue cheese is good, the staff are friendly, and though the seating area is small, it's clean and gets the job done.

GOLLY! that cheeseburger pizza is sure the best i've ever had! i've traveled to many pizza places…read morein my days and this- boy it's the best!get the cheeseburger pizza!!! service is quick. and it's a cute area.

Great breakfast sandwiches and fish fries! They are a hidden gem! We love getting food from here…read more You can't go wrong with fish fries, breakfast pizza, sandwich's, pizza, and wings!

Their Pizzas and Subs our fantastic, they have great staff,ready to please!! I recommend them…read moreevery place I go. And family has changed their mind and now go to Vincenzos

We ordered chicken fingers shaken in sauce. Twice on the phone I repeated "shaken in sauce."…read moreDo you think we actually got fingers shaken in sauce? No! This was your last chance. Will be calling Pizza Paul's from now on. They know what fingers shaken in sauce really are.

We got some pepperoncini pizza and 12 each of BBQ and medium wings to take out. All the food was…read moregood, but their buffalo wing sauce was a little thin. The BBQ wings were fine. The round pizza was cut into squares, so be aware if you don't like that. The crust is also quite thick around the edges, but it was properly baked and not burned. There was a special which included a 2 liter of pop. The service at the counter was prompt and friendly. In addition they opened at 11am on Sunday, which is not always the case.

Picked up pizza and wings for my son-in-law's birthday...the pizza and wings were very good;…read morehowever, I would give 4 stars but am giving 3 because the round pizza was cut in squares which I don't understand. Basically, 4 of the slices are almost completely crust and the last to be taken. Perhaps one can request that the pizza be cut in 8 slices...will try that special request next time!!!

First time sitting on the pizzeria side. They seem to be sitting a lot over here tonight…read more Service was good. Ravioli were delicious. It's a lot quieter on this side lol

This is my favorite pizza in Batavia. After living here for a few years, this was my go-to spot. We…read morewere back in town for the day hanging out and decided we needed to get some pizza before we went home. We ended up getting a few things which were all delicious. We got a large cheese and pep pizza, some wings, fried mozzarella, and some fried dough bites for dessert. The pizza here has been great and the service is always pretty quick. They have two sides of the restaurant with takeout on one, and dining on the other. The dining room is gorgeous and has such a great vibe to it. It feels upscale, yet cozy. If you're in Batavia and need a pizza, Main Street is the place to go.

We were driving from Buffalo to Newark and had to make a quick food stop. We spotted Mama Mia's and…read morepulled right in. We got a slice of their pepperoni pizza, and it was so good we ended up ordering two more! It's thin, a little greasy, and light - just yummy. We did the lunch special with a drink for just under $10, totally worth it. Service was good, fast, and friendly, and the ambiance was cozy and clean.

The pizza is really good. It is thin crust. I also thought the service was pretty well. He actually…read moreput extra dough in it to make it a little extra wider for me and the place is clean when I went to pick up the pizza and it was really quiet there was no one there.

Local pizzeria in town. Ordered 1/2 white garlic ricotta pizza and 1/2 cheese. It was the best of…read moreboth worlds. The wings were tasty and cooked perfectly. My only complaint is the bleu cheese is not the best. The brand they use is low end and nothing like Ken's brand which ruined the taste of the wings. The celery was also not crunchy. Very nice customer service.

Everything about our order was wrong. We got a very dry chicken parm wrap, potato wedges with no…read moresour cream, a soggy sub, and no blue cheese which we paid extra for. Called immediately after the food was delivered to notify them of our dissatisfaction and we were told nothing can be done and to call back tomorrow. We got our food 45 minutes before they closed; plenty of time to fix the mistakes.

The subs at the shop are no longer a good value. The large hot sub is $15 but it's made on a very…read morenarrow roll and even then many bites were only bread due to the small amount of chicken on it. The cold sub we got was also very minimally filled. We ordered online and the system is not set up very well- lettuce isn't listed as an add on, so I thought it came on the sub by default. There's no options for condiments and everything else is listed as "add extra" But what that really means is do you want ANY of this on your sub-not extra. I paid $15 for a very dry roll with three very small chicken fingers and a few pieces of onion.

Retsof's best pizza!! The wings were also so so delish!…read more I didn't get to sit down because my date just wanted to take it home. He doesn't like to bring me into public. Which is why I can't speak to the ambiance. But he said that the service was good and it was really quick! He will definitely be returning!

We were driving through Warsaw tonight around 8:30 hadn't ate yet ordered a pizza and wings to go…read more they told me 35 minutes took us 40 to get there the pizza was done but had to wait another 15 minutes for the wings. I was disappointed with the wait but then the food disappointed also. The crust was tough and I asked for medium buffalo wings and there was no heat at all. Spending almost $50 on pizza and wings and being disappointed. Disappointed customers

I love ordering their pizza just about every other week. They have the best thin crust pizza that…read morethey deliver hot and fresh right to my work. I love that they deliver and I don't have to leave the office. Staff is always very friendly.