This is my favorite pizza in Batavia. After living here for a few years, this was my go-to spot. We were back in town for the day hanging out and decided we needed to get some pizza before we went home. We ended up getting a few things which were all delicious. We got a large cheese and pep pizza, some wings, fried mozzarella, and some fried dough bites for dessert. The pizza here has been great and the service is always pretty quick. They have two sides of the restaurant with takeout on one, and dining on the other. The dining room is gorgeous and has such a great vibe to it. It feels upscale, yet cozy. If you're in Batavia and need a pizza, Main Street is the place to go. read more

See all

They have daily deals and this was half a sheet plus wings. The wings were all good but our favorite was the bourbon and berry hot. The other flavors we got was also good. The pizza dough was my favorite since it is soft and fluffy. Flavor wise really nice and portion are huge. Service was great and definitely would come back! read more

See all

It was average. A little more sauce needed, overall 6/10 the wings were on the small side, flavor was decent!

Once again, I'm back in Batavia and MUST stop in here as I " eat my way " through western New York! Lucky for me it was a Tuesday so I could take advantage of the Pasta Special, 2 pasta dinners and a bottle of wine for $30. As always a delicious meal read more

Main St Pizza Company - Shrimp Diablo - Pizza Near Me - Batavia, New York

See all

This place has really lost ground over the past few years. The male bathroom has been very poorly cleaned. We did keep going back because we enjoyed the staff and food, but it's not going well. Our most recent waitress was great, nobody will live up to Zack, but that's a very high bar. The most recent change was not doing separate checks for us (couples) like they have done for years. We have a large group (6-10) there a couple times a month, but there are better chooses close by that check all the boxes so much better. We'll miss the old MSPizza service and go elsewhere. read more

Ordered a deep dish pizza, which is the best, and they had put in a regular pizza. Without any hesitation they apologized and told me to keep the pizza and they would make the deep dish. Not all places have this level of customer service. Thank Main St. read more

Excellent food. Excellent service!! Shout out to Jenny!! She was a STELLAR server! Thank you, Jenny! We've ordered medium hot wings since arriving in NY, and found them to be pretty mild, so we ordered the hot wings, and they had a nice spice level. Tiny bit spicy on lips, but is you love spicy, you'll need to go extra hot for your wings. Hot was a mild medium spice level IMHO. Love the crispy skin! Pizza sauce was great as was the crust! 5 star experience! read more

Main St Pizza Company - Hot wings - went for hot over medium. Excellent choice spicy but not too spicy. - Pizza Near Me - Batavia, New York

See all

Hubby found this place for us to stop and have dinner. Great place, kid friendly as well! We tried the Main Street Chicago style pizza - it was really good! But the hot peppers are extremely spicy - we eat spicy and was glad we asked for it to be only on half of the pizza - the spice lingers! The kids make your own pizza was so cute! They bring out the dough, sauce and cheese (plus one topping of your choice). The kids assemble it and they then take it to bake. The lasagna was huge!! Needed a bit more sauce but otherwise really good!! All the portions were huge and we wind up packing up more than half of our food! read more

See all

For me this place got 5 stars ,the staff is helpful and friendly,we went there for my son's birthday the pizza was good and they had HONEY BBQ chicken wings which was very delicious,plus it have nice scenery on a good sunny day,one of the premier restaurants in Batavia!! read more

This is one of my favorite restaurants. The food is always so good. While we were sitting waiting for our friends we overheard the waitresses conversation which was inappropriate. There was 4 servers standing by kitchen entrance having this conversation. It was rude and unnecessary. Our waitress was a little slow and not the friendliest that we usually have. read more

See all

Stopped by for lunch for my friends birthday. Service was good and food is always delicious and fresh. read more

See all

The food was delicious. The waiter was amicable, and the ambience is above and beyond. Serve me a glass of wine with my pizza in that top it off. read more

Meh....Looked on yelp for pizza Batavia to try and find a good pizza. Got a pepperoni mushroom and black olives.. Sweet sauce but just bland beyond that. Spent 50 on a pizza and two drinks lunch for two.. read more

Main St Pizza Company - Pretty looking pie but very bland flavor. Not impressive - Pizza Near Me - Batavia, New York

Good selection of food. I tried the Fettuccine Alfredo and my brother had the ravioli. Both were very good. The waitress was good. There was a bit of a wait to be seated, but I guess that's a good sign. Also a bit of a wait to order. Location was good but the parking was a bit rough, ambiance was fair but it was somewhat loud. All-in-all an okay dining experience. read more

(4) ~ very good overall food & service MENU: ** Arancini = (4.25) Very good & Shareable ** Italian Lemon Cream Cake = (4.25) Very good ** Water (tap) = very good, must be filtered;) ** Spicy Pork & Vegetable Soup (cup) = (4) very tasty * Caprese Grilled Pizza = (3.75) Good read more

Great food! Wonderful service. Excellent portions. The dry rub wings are fantastic! A wonderful place to end a long workweek.

Ahhh my favorite pizza. The crust - doughy, bubbly, and delicious. The toppings - sweet sauce, banana peppers, sausage, bbq drizzle, you name it! YUM. But for real, their sweet sauce base is heavenly. Sign me up forever. I usually go straight for the BBQ chicken pizza. The slices are huge, no matter what pizza you end up getting. Besides pizza, Main St Pizza has subs, pasta, wings, subzonis (just try one, trust me) and more! There is a takeout side to the restaurant and a sit down side. What pizza places still let you do a full sit down? There's something nostalgic and comforting about a cozy, sit down pizza place. Especially when that pizza place also serves amazing entrees. It is always slammed here, and for good reason! The staff is always friendly. I have never ever had a bad experience here, and I always look forward to my next visit. read more

Logan barry is good the floor is very clean the wings are very good i recamed the chicken fingers are awesome read more

See all

Came here for a slice, when a competitor down the street decided not to have slices available for dinner. The girl at the register is a keeper. She was super friendly. This place would have been 5 stars if they had their own blue cheese, and not handing out the commercial premade Ken's ones. The slices were lukewarm, and yet still very delicious. At $4 each, it was reasonable for the sizes of the slices. There was a fairly perfect sauce/cheese/roni ratio going on here. Not one of the best, but pretty darn good. Just get a homemade blue cheese going on, you are a pizza place! read more

See all

Amazing service. Amazing food. Such great quality. I asked for vodka sauce on my manicotti and it was no problem. The garlic bread was incredible. Chicken parm was huge and tasty. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Ordered a buffalo chicken calzone came loaded with olives and had no buffalo taste at all and the chicken was slimy and gross. Service was extremely slow also read more

Main St Pizza Company - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Batavia, New York

Originally first visited with a friend who lived in Batavia. Have since gone back twice when just going for a ride in that direction. Their meatball is huge and delicious, same with the ravioli. Love the flavor of the sauce. Side salad is quite large. Lunch special has many options and a nice value. Definitely will be returning again. Popular with families as they offer a make your own pizza for the kids. One of these days, we will try the pizza. read more

We visited on June 17. Not a pleasant experience. Panini was dry and pretty sure they didn't bring the sauce for it. Broccoli was not cooked. Fruit punch tasted watered down. Waitress was alright. Old lady in the black and white shirt was rude. Snapped at my daughter because she wanted to bring them the bill/money. We had to wait another 10 minutes for the waitress to come and get it. Only thing that was really good was the Garlic Parmesan fries. read more

Last night we met friends for dinner. There six of us dining. The server took our order, it was a while before dinner arrived. Everyone got their meal ,except one diner. The server had misheard the order, so everyone else ate while the lone diner waited for her meal. The other diners had issues with their meals. Panini sandwiches that were missing half of the ingredients and french fries that were cold. When the last meal was delivered, we just put it in a box to go. Everyone else was done with their dinner. The server did remove that one meal from the check. She knew there was a problem. We've dined there before and the food and service were good. Last night was a disaster. read more

Was in Batavia for a training class at my employer's main office today. Went to Main St Pizza for lunch. Simply order half a meatball sub to go. It took half an hour which is far to long. Especially since none of it was freshly made. I appreciate that they use slices of larger meatballs but the edges were dry and hard. The roll was also stale. read more

This place was amazing! Really good food. A must try! Be sure to try the ravioli! Be sure to give everything a try because all of the food was really good! read more

See all

Menu is extensive but everything looks awesome. I highly recommend it. They don't take reservations. Sometimes if you dine in a small party like 2 or 4 they will seat you before a larger party due to table sizes or styles. There are 2 dining rooms. The main dining room and another dining area near the take out pizza area. read more

I live in Rochester, but work in Batavia... so when the boss says, hey! Want to join us for lunch at Main Street Pizza, there is NO hesitation!! They recently (a year or more??) remodeled and the place is great! Located right on Main Street Batavia. When the weather is nice they open up the big huge windows to the outside. Very nicely decorated inside. The staff is friendly and attentive. Food - O. M. G. I have some favorites and some not so favorites. -The pizza is ok. The sauce is more of a sweet sauce and I'm not a fan. But I could also get a white pizza, right?! -Wings are delicious! My favorite is garlic parm! -Raviolis. My friend ordered these once and I swear the raviolis were literally the size of her head! Tasty! -This last time around I ordered the 2 for $12 at lunch. Caesar salad and Chicken Pesto w/pasta. I could have eaten just the salad for lunch. The portions were huge! Managed to eat part of the chicken and pasta but took it home. Ate it for lunch and dinner the next day! -Chicken Alfredo... again! Huge portions! My coworker and I split this one night at dinner and we still took some home! Definitely worth the trip if you like good food :) read more

Main St Pizza Company - Chicken Pesto - Pizza Near Me - Batavia, New York

Stopped in for pizza but this place is so much more than a pizza place! We went for lunch and there was a lunch special for $12 you got a choice of soup or salad and then choice is pasta or sandwich. You can pick off from any item on the menu so the salad was not limited to just the house salad which is unheard of. The portions are huge for lunch so you'll have leftovers to take home. We started with the stuffed peppers and the flavors were outstanding , the peppers were hotter than I like but you can never tell how hot a pepper is going to be. We decided to all try different items so we could share but the favorite was the Alfredo with homemade pasta. The pizza was ok but nothing to rave about. The only thing I wish they included was some bread and butter. read more

See all

Stopped here for dinner on a busy Friday evening. Had not made a reservation but was seated in the main dining room promptly. Ordered a glass of wine and them dinner, service was not fast but not slow either, which considering how busy they were was understandable. I had a Caprese salad which was served in a reasonable timeframe and was very tasty. For an entrée I had a deep dish pizza with pepperoni, sausage and hot peppers. The sauce here is sweet which I enjoyed. My date had Manicotti which she thought was a bit bland. The space is quite attractive, unfortunately the restrooms are single occupancy (one for men, one for women) which made for extended lines and waits on a busy evening. All in all I would not hesitate to return. read more

Main St Pizza Company - Dining - Pizza Near Me - Batavia, New York

See all

Great food! Wings were a must, and went for the flight with 4 different sauces + blue cheese. As wild as it sounds, try the raspberry! It was recommended to me by a local, and it ended up being over one of my favorites! The sweet & sour was also very nice! Server was a sweetheart and was on it with refills or checking in. It isn't a HUGE place, but it seems that tables turned fast enough that it wasn't a problem. read more

Huge portions, fresh food with great flavors, quick service. What else could you ask for? read more

Main St Pizza Company - Eggplant Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Batavia, New York

The pizza and wine was immaculate! Took my granddaughter there and she got a huge meatball it would barely fit in her mouth!

Itching to get out and about on a Friday afternoon and to do a little celebrating for big events that happened in the last couple weeks, we enjoyed a few beers around WNY. We ended our tour in Batavia and were seeking out a spot for dinner. Thankfully, coming out of Eli Fish, we saw Main Street Pizza Company and immediately knew where we were going! We walked in a little before 7pm and were greeted by a masked host who let us pick if we wanted to dine inside or outside. We chose inside, just to cool down as it was still warm out. As we were sitting down, he came over with the menus, silverware, and place-mats and noticed that the table was a little dirty and insisted we choose another instead, which was very astute of him! As soon as we were seated, we saw him go right over to that table and clean it more thoroughly so kudos to him! Now, if there was one complaint about our dinner, it was with the service provided by our server. It took him almost 15 minutes after we were seated to finally come to our table and take our drink order. Once our drinks were brought out, he took our dinner order and we didn't see him again for a long while (around 25 minutes or so). I'm sure that our order took that long to prepare and cook but he could've checked in on us once or twice to make sure we were set and to give any updates on our order. When we were ready to get a box to take home and pay for our meal, our server was nowhere to be found until we were up and walking out of the restaurant. We actually ended up talking to masked host who greeted us as we came in and he took care of everything, right away! Now, onto the food! We ordered a half-sheet Sicilian (16 slices) pizza with cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, and Ricotta cheese. The pizza was fantastic, everything about it was perfect! The crust edges were crunchy with the under-crust having a great chew and doughy-ness to it that makes up a Sicilian-style pizza. The sauce coverage was perfect and was more savory than sweet, which I didn't mind at all. The mushrooms were fresh-sliced and plentiful along with the pepperoni, which was not the cup-n-char variety you see from Buffalo. The real star on this pie was the Ricotta cheese, in my opinion, as it added an herbal flavor and provided a cool creaminess. This pizza was soo good, I ate almost half of it, by myself, in one sitting (don't worry, I paid for it later haha)! I ended up bringing the rest home and eating it the next day for dinner. I reheated in the oven at 400 degrees for about 15 minutes and was so happy it tasted just as good the second time! I heard a lot of great things about Main Street Pizza Company in Batavia and I firmly believe them now! I definitely want to come back and try one of their grilled pizzas (control my portions... haha) and hopefully the dine-in service is a little more attentive. read more

See all

I've heard so many good things about this place and it definitely was true. When I walked in, it smelled like my Italian grandma's house when she was making sauce. I kept hearing about this giant meatball, so we tried it and it was delicious. Not everyone can make good meatballs and the size of this thing was like a mini meatloaf. We split it between the 4 of us. We got the stuffed jalapeño peppers. It was pretty good. They should warn you , the closer you get to the small part of the pepper is west the seeds are. Woa that was spicy and I love spicy but too much for me. We got the deep dish pizza, cheese and pepperoni , half with meatballs and banana peppers. This pizza was really good. The sauce was homemade and the dough had a touch of sweetness to it which I loved. If you know anything about pizza, the dough is very important. If the dough isn't good the rest isn't. I seriously can't wait to go back . read more

Main St Pizza Company - Meatball (1/4 of it) and a Stuffed Banana Pepper - Pizza Near Me - Batavia, New York

See all

Though I went 5 years ago, if the food is still the same (I had a pepperoni pizza) I didn't like it.

Excellent food. Service is good. Prices are good. Portions are huge!!!! We got the cheesy breadsticks for app and the large meatball. Lasanga. Stuff shells and pizza. read more

See all

Wow!!!!!!!! Definite 5 Star place. Very trendy, bustling place. We were told a 15-20 wait. Seated in 17 minutes. This place was slammed so the servers were running. The portions are huge and food was delicious. The wife and I split an order of veal parmigiana. Rich taste with great breading covered with gobs of delicious melted mozzarella. There was plenty to share. We got our son a pizza that didn't disappoint either. Flakey crust, wonderfully sweet sauce and again, really good cheese. (Stretches really far instead of pulling of the slice like a solid scab) Lastly, that damn meatball! This monster was 10 ounces big and spiced perfectly. All 3 of us ate off of that thing! Check my pics!!!! read more

Had an early dinner last Saturday. Great food and excellent service. We were seated had drinks, salad and entrees within 1/2 hour! Food was awesome, as usual! I had Rigatoni Bolognese. A huge Portion! I took more than 1/2 home. The Bolognese was really tasty and just a tad spicy. My dining companion ordered the dish with 3 entrees that included chicken Parmesan with rigatoni, stuffed shells and the huge meatball. She said that the chicken Parmesan was one of the best she's ever had, liked the rigatoni and loved the meatball. We ordered cannoli's to go because we were so stuffed. They were really good too. Super creamy and yummy! I can't sing enough praise for this establishment. One of my favorites. read more

See all

The service was bonkers, we waited and tried to make eye contact and finally a waitress came over explaining that they had fired staff n didn't know the table was hers. However, she did seem like the only wait staff there. They were out of all the specials, it took more than one trip to the kitchen to report what the chef's choices were, the chicken alfredo came without chicken, the water glass was taken to be refilled and didn't come back without being asked for. But....the sauce is good, the homemade pasta is good, and if you like a meatball they are huge. We visited on a Tuesday and there was wonderful live music being played. read more

See all