Looking for a decent pizza in Amherst, OH? We stumbled up on this place after the district track meet this evening. Looked it up and had the highest rating in the area. It looks like a large house from the outside, and there is porch seating as well as indoor seating. We were greeted promptly by our server who took our order. I was immediately impressed with the cleanliness of the establishment and was surprised that there were not very many customers in the restaurant on a Friday night. We had a pizza supreme and an Italian salad with breadsticks and drinks for dinner. It came out quickly and well prepared. I was suprised that the salad dressing came out in a packet. Not judging.... The menu was full of variety and had something to offer (even gluten free crust!) for all. Our pizza was tasty, the lettuce was crispy, and the bread sticks with marinara were hot and very good. It was a very good experience and there was good ambience . Would be good for families with young ones all the way up to adults only. I didn't recall if there were alcohol beverages offered. But they do offer BOTH coke and Pepsi . read more

See all

It is a great little place. It's not cheap but the pizza dough is sooo good. I just had a macaroni and cheese pizza, and a T-Rex. Delicious little pizza place. Busy in a good way- the staff hustles! read more

D'Tutanelli's Pizza - Mac n Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

See all

Best pizza in the area! Kind workers and generous as they gave a discount for it being our first time. Chicken bacon ranch pizza is perfection read more

Ordered some bread sticks for carry out. This place is downtown Amherst at 5 points. The order was ready on time and service was great. The inside it tastefully decorated. Get the twist. read more

D'Tutanelli's Pizza - Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

My mom and I (together we are 148 years old hahaha) ordered an extra large with all the veggies, add pepperoni, and requested that all the toppings be diced up small because of mama's teeth and swallowing issues - THEY DID IT PERFECTLY. We were in no hurry to get it and we ordered early enough I think to avoid the dinner rush. The pizza was delicious, we shared with our neighbor and she liked the smaller toppings, too. I also tried 5 garlic parm tenders and OMG too much food and they were so DELICIOUS and huuuge. We'll for sure be back. Be sure and tip your delivery GOOD when they go above and beyond like that! Thank you, D'Tutanelli's! read more

Have always enjoyed D'Tutanelli's but something has changed. Stopped in last week for a pizza and we also split a large salad. The food was good but we both noticed the toppings were smaller than usual and very sparse. Nothing like the last few times we've eaten here. Ordered a Sausage & Mushroom and told the gal who took our order that we love their sausage and we'd really like to see more sausage than mushroom. She took that to mean "extra" sausage and charged us for an extra item on the final bill "after" we gave her our credit card. I also had asked for a refill on my glass of Coke during dinner, and she charged for another glass of pop. I've never seen that before, and did not see it until we looked at the final bill, again, AFTER we gave her the credit card. * I can understand it if we had asked for a can of pop. And . . . my first glass of pop was more than half filled with ice, so didn't really have a full glass of pop the first time. Okay, so filling up glass with ice, is normal anymore and we didn't say a word about it, but charging for a refill??? C'mon man, we just ordered over 30 dollars worth of food and gave you a nice tip . . . and you need to add for a pop refill? That's just wrong. Looks like we'll have to stick with TAKE OUT. read more

This pizza is so terrible. The sauce is sweet and tastes like spaghetti sauce. The pie is small for the price and the crust is soft. The side salad had a good mix of greens, but I stand by my one star rating. The pizza was that bad. read more

We ordered pizza for delivery to our home. The pizza arrived within 30 minutes and it was still hot. We had a large, thin crust with onions and pepperoni. The sauce, cheese and toppings were great! In fact I liked the pizza as much or better than Yala's, which has a great reputation in the area read more

Delicious pizza, lots of topping and pizza came out hot and fresh. They were able to accommodate a large party and the service was excellent. Servers and kitchen staff were great with our kids. read more

Don't know why we have never ordered here, because it is close to home and they also have delivery. The menu is fairly extensive so everyone should be able to find something to satisfy their hunger. We always go for thin crust, pepperoni and onion. The crust and sauce were good and there was plenty of cheese and pepperoni. The onion was lacking and I had thought maybe we forgot to order it, but did find a few pieces. Delivery was prompt and I would certainly order again. read more

We ordered 3 pizzas and breadsticks for a family dinner and the pizza was great! The service was great, it was ready on time. They offered me the special of the day, and although I'm not a huge fan of breadsticks they were good. They have just enough of everything- except the pepperoncini- you pay extra for those toppings and there were like 6 pieces- that gage them a 4 instead of 5. Overall great job!! read more

It's pizza so that's good? It was entirely flavorless pizza. The sauce was missing spice and the cheese had zero taste. We won't be getting it again read more

I ate here one afternoon with my friend for the first time and the service was fast and friendly. They even gave us a fairly large and great tasting pizza-like appetizer which was awesome. Prices are a bit on the higher end only because it is a small business, but I would (and will) visit again. -Ariana read more

D'Tutanelli's Pizza - D'Tuts - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

Good pizza and wings. Pizza dough is always fresh and their pizzas are always consistently good. A little pricy but good.

Such a great experience! Brought my family here for something a bit different (we usually get takeout). The server was awesome and the food was amazing! I highly recommend the stuffed crust! read more

D'Tutanelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

I thought the pizza was just ok. I was not liking the price. $18.99 was a little steep in my book. I just don't see myself being a regular read more

D'Tutanelli's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

Did take out from the Avon store. Thought the pizza a very good. A tad pricy but well worth the price. Called ahead, ready when requested. My go to pizza place in the future read more

I've heard a LOT if good things about this pizza parlor... ugh, I beg to differ. The staff was rude and har absolutely NO hospitality! I don't often write bad reviews, but the treatment & crummy pizza that we received prompts me to write a review, as a consumer advocate. I don't mind paying $20 for a quality pizza, but this pizza was a far cry from "quality". When I opened up the pizza box, as I usually do before I leave, the pizza had scarcely any toppings...... and I ordered several toppings. So I asked the girl that I paid if she could explain why my pizza barely had any toppings.... she shrugged her shoulders and went to get a woman that was the "manager", and of course, the "manager" was rude, also. When I asked her about my poor quality of pizza, she merely said, "well, that's how we make our pizzas"! No apologies or any kind of consumer interaction. Ugh!! I will never go to this establishment again! #UnsatisfiedCustomer read more

Even though they took it off their menu, they have the best veggie sub I have found after moving down to this area 3 years ago.

Lousy pizza, outstanding breadsticks, grumpy proprietor. I do not recommend this pizza or this restaurant. They are only a block from the best two pizza places in town, don't know why they would try offering lousy pizza at the same price with no concept of making the customer feel welcome or at ease. The high school kid waiting on us was the exception. He was not a good waiter, but he did his best to make our dining experience less miserable. read more

I stumbled in late, an hour before closing. Atmosphere A+ Quaint, Clean & Charming Food A+ Pizza...what one should be like; plenty of toppings. The only thing better than the food; Service A++ Personable, attentive, helpful, and just what you'd want to sit down and encounter at the end of a long day. I'll be coming back read more

I've only been here once and I definitely plan on coming back in the future. D'Tutanelli's has one of the best pizzas i've had in this area. I only wish it was a little closer to my home (i live about 15 minutes away, which isn't terribly bad). The service was good and the food was great. I really like D'Tutanelli's Pizza. read more

Better than Yalas, better than Giovanni, better than Papa John's. Better than any pizza in Avon, Lorain, Elyria, Oberlin, N. Ridgeville, Amherst. I could eat their pizza daily! Love the dine-in atmosphere (Love it sooo much we had our son's 1st birthday party there about a year ago). But please don't take my word (or someone else's) for it, order & find out for yourself. You won't regret it! read more

D'Tutanelli's Pizza - a sign on the sidewalk - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

We wanted a really casual laid back rehearsal dinner the night before our wedding so we made reservations here. We loved it! The service was great, the pizza was absolutely fantastic, and the staff was so friendly and accommodating of our large party. They even had a dessert pizza to finish everything off. Highly recommend read more

They gave no notice that their dining room is completely closed (not on their website nor their Facebook page). Quality of pizza and service has declined despite the what appeared to be more than ample staffing. Pizza was not cut through and it was doughy (not completely cooked). Price of pizza was too expensive for the quality. read more

This was a cute little pizza place. The waitress was awesome and very helpful, as we told her this was our first time there. They gave us a free appetizer... A pepperoni bread with marinara to dip and it was yummy. The menu had a lot of items to choose from, at reasonable prices and the pizza was really good... We ordered the T-Rex, which was their all meat pizza. The only reason I'm not giving it a five star rating is because, to me, it tasted a lot like Pizza Hut and I can get that anytime. We are not from the area and drove here hoping for a pizza unlike what we have available to us on a daily basis. read more

Veggie pizza was delightful, artichokes were not artijoking. Also got the 'choke dip-no complaints here! One thing I feel very strongly about is how we're charged 2.50 for being "out of the area". We're 3 miles out. A friend who is of respectable moral aptitude is a mile away and is also charged this "out of area" charge. What a racket! Call it delivery charge and call it a day. PS great teriyaki wings. PPS all the delivery drivers know me by name. PPPS we like to call it dtutes. Hope it catches on. Take care. read more

As a follow up to my previous review, an owner called us a few days later and apologized. She offered us a free pizza for our trouble and it was very, very good. The crust was really quite spectacular and the pizza was composed of high quality ingredients. We will definitely order again. read more

Great pizza. A little pricey but worth the money. It's perfect for that evening when you want something other than boring Marcos pizza. We were very impressed with what we got and we will be visiting there again. Another plus is that they also deliver. When you have kids at home, that is a huge plus for us! Thank you for giving Amherst something to look forward to. Keep up the good work. read more

Food is delicious but the customer service is bad. Got a specialty pizza & I asked to replace the green peppers with banana peppers. When I picked it up she charged my 2.25 for the banana peppers. I told her that wasn't right- she should have told me that on the phone! But no she could of cared less & didn't apologize. I can get pizza elsewhere if u can't make the customer happy read more

Love this place.. so happy my boyfriend took me there. We love free topping Tuesday. Heck we just love this restaurant. We have never been inside always get it to go. Maybe one day we will eat inside. The leftovers make a great lunch for my boyfriend the next day. Like I said so glad my boyfriend introduced me. read more

Pizza, wings and apps have all been great. I'll explain why it's 2 stars and why they've lost my business. This review is for the Avon store. I've ordered 4 times. 2 times I've picked up, 2 times I've had it delivered. Both times delivered its been 20 min late and the latest time was 45 min late. Still new, yes, great food yes but I just can't continue to support a shop when it takes 90 plus minutes ordering food at 430pm . read more

The food is very good. The pizzas are much better than chains. Sauce is fantastic. Slightly pricy. Location is very convenient at the main intersection in downtown Amherst. Staff is friendly, place is spotless. The major complaint of mine is that everything is an upcharge. Proprietors may have preferred buying an airline instead (charge for pillow, charge for seatbelt, charge for life vest, etc...). A little heavy on the red sauce, extra... Few sprinkles of cheese, extra. ..A little ranch dressing drizzle, extra... Surprised there is not an upcharge for the cardboard box and also for the oven time. I am used to good restaurants taking care of their regulars. Another great place is a block away. read more

For all of my almost 40 years I have had a love affair with all things pizza. This pizza reminded me of a pizza from my childhood in Akron, Ohio. It's more expensive than the chain pizza shops but well worth it. Not going to be everyone's most loved pizza but everyone should give it a try. read more

Phenomenal pizza. First experience was getting their GIANT pizza to have at home, and we were hooked. We even posted pictures of our kids with the monster-sized pizza. Their dining room is extremely family friendly, and the complementary pepperoni bread is delicious. read more

Amazing pizza !!!! I have never tried their pizza before tonight and am very pleased with the results :) the pizza was awesome the cheese bread was awesome as well !!!! Will definitely order again :) read more

Meh, is about it. I have had better food at the mall food court. Really disappointing! Was hoping to find a new family owned pizza place but found a step above what I can buy in the grocery store (barley). Ordered the supreme pizza, sausage was almost undetectable along with the onions and peppers. I was able to see a few peperoni but certainly not worth the $$$ paid. If you looking for good authentic family owned pizza place this is not it. read more

Best pizza around hands down. Staff at the Avon location super friendly. Ordered three times so far and every time is excellent!!

the pizza,and cheese bread was amazing and the service is phenomenal would recommend this pizza place

Relocated to Five Points in Amherst. Fast service, decent pizza, but honestly pretty greasy. I liked the sauce. But...it's still Olde Town for me read more