Exceptional Pizza. Service was kind and welcoming, as Dean Martin and Frank Sinatra tunes filled…read morethe air! If you speak Italian, engage Giuseppina in conversazione, ask her About the Uncle Miltie Discount ! JK This is a lovely family run pizzeria that is simply home style Italian Food.

My fiancé loves pizza and we wanted to try somewhere new. We looked at the reviews and decided to…read moregive this place a try. As we walked in we were immediately greeted and sat. I love the atmosphere of this restaurant, nice cozy spot with great old Italian music. We ordered the garlic bread bites and picante pizza. When the garlic bread bites came out we didn't expect there to be a lot. But it had an amazing amount of garlic butter and the marinara sauce has so much flavor I asked for a second bowl of it because I loved it. The picante flavor was the right amount of spice and the Italian sausage was homemade. The owner said everything is homemade and their marinara sauce is passed down through many generations. Everyone was so sweet, will definitely come back!

We had such a great experience at Martin's Pizzeria. The New York style pizza was absolutely…read moredelicious. We tried the pepperoni with hot honey and wow... total flavor explosion. Sweet, spicy, savory, everything just worked perfectly together. We also ordered their Cuban style pizza which was packed with flavor, and the crust was cooked to absolute perfection. Crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, just how it should be. One of my favorite touches was seeing the little Gospel of John books at each table. Such a beautiful and meaningful detail that made the space feel even more welcoming and intentional. The service was amazing from start to finish. Everyone was kind, attentive, and genuinely cared about making sure we had a great experience. You can really feel that this is a family owned and operated business, and that love shows in both the food and the atmosphere. We will absolutely be back the next time we are in Fort Myers. Highly recommend this place to anyone who loves great pizza, great people, and a warm, inviting atmosphere.

BEST NY PIZZA I EVER HAD , will truly recommend not only is their pizza amazing but they have the…read morebest customer service and will make you feel like family as soon as you walk in ! If you are ever craving some good pizza this is the place to go will 1000% be coming back !

Visited fat Tony's for the first time spoke with Tony and Marie very nice people feels like a…read morefamily get-together. Excellent food outstanding pizza and let's not forget the meatballs out of the world. Fat Tony's is a hidden jewel in Fort Myers. Highly recommend for sure I will be back

What a pleasant surprise! Walked in Fat Tony, the lady at the counter is friendly and a delighted…read morepersonality! I looked at the Meat Lover with Pepperoni; the slices are huge. So beautiful, waiting to be folded and devoured. Friend got her white pizza and loves her thin NY style crust slice. Plies of garlic knots send an attractive signal that I ordered six to go. They were crispy on the outside and soft inside but loaded with Garlic! The San Marzano sauce is a perfect fit as a dip! Next time, we will try their strombolis, calzones, meatballs and paninis! The service is quick, food delicious and reasonable price. If you are in the area, stop by Fat Tony, you'll be very happy!

We are always looking for new restaurants to try, especially highly rated pizza places. So here we…read moreare at Vincenzo's. This is a small, family-type of restaurant. It has a comfortable and casual ambiance. They were playing some light rock, not too loud. We were immediately greeted and directed to sit anywhere. Our server was friendly and efficient. We first ordered drinks, a Peroni and unsweetened iced tea. Then we ordered an 18" pepperoni, meatball and extra cheese pizza. It took a bit longer than we thought it should for the pizza to arrive, but when it did, it was hot and flavorful. We love the tomato forward sauce and the amount was just right. The cheese, meatballs and pepperoni were spot on. The crust is crispy outside, but soft inside, a great combination. Very easy to eat. The restaurant was doing a good bit of take out business and I can see why. We will be back.

Huge pizza, easy carry-out service - pizza was ready to go when we arrived. Loved our NY Style…read morepizza. Will definitely be back.

Researched, found Papa Joe's on Yelp. What a nice find! You could feel/smell the Italian heritage…read more Our first impression was great when we were seated within a minute of entering Papa Joe's. Our waitress (Jackie) was attentive, professional, down-to-earth with a sweet personality. Likewise, when we met the owner. Here's the best part, the food/service! Our meal started with Joe's salad and garlic bread! OMG, we were doing the happy dance before we even received our entrees. My wife loved her chicken parm (& sangria) and I loved my 16 inch White pizza and sweet tea (made by someone who knows how to sweeten tea)! I was only able to eat 3 slices, taking a bunch home. I'm looking forward to indulging again on the leftovers tomorrow.

After hearing raves about how good Papa Joes is as a family restaurant, we came for an early dinner…read moreat 5:15. Delighted to see table cloths n settings on the out door seating. But we ate inside to get a better impression of its ambiance and hospitality. 5 stars here. With candles it would have been romantic. There's a nice level of music and the traffic picked up around 6p. In evaluating every Italian restaurant, the three best indicators to try (my 1st time) is 1) veal parmigiana 2) an eggplant dish and 3) a pasta with homemade sauce. The recommended drink was their homemade sangria. It was ok. Not exciting, not overly fruity (1orange slice on the cup lip) and not sweet (that was a plus). Only Budweiser product on draft. What no IPA? Only in the bottle. For our dinner entre I had the 'cut with a fork' veal. It required a knife. Not the best. The tomato sauce was average but overly salted. It was served delightfully hot. The fettuccine side was excellent and enjoyed. My serving was appropriate and good sized. My wife ordered an egg drop soup, strattoria, that we shared. Ok but not memorable. Her mussels were served in a recommended red sauce. This was too salty. Our excellent waitress Theresa wanted to please her and brought a new order. WOW . . .This tomato sauce was 5-star. The absolute BEST. Initially after placing our order Theresa brought a gratis appetizer of garlic bread which was tasty and hot. We finished it. In summary- ambiance & service were tops. The drink soso. The original tomato sauce was marginal, but improved greatly on the reorder. For this night out our billing was over $60 + tip. That's on the high side of our eating out budget. Although a very popular neighborhood eatery, I voice concerns to them about OVER salting. That is a poison and a common solution to mask flavors. Mix of 5s and 3s. We will return for a 2nd opinion.

Stop in for early dinner before hitting a show at Barbara B Mann. No reservation need if early 5pm…read moreon a Fri even with 4 people of-course this was in late April after most snow birds are gone. Had Italian wedding soup very good homemade mini meatballs tri mix meat delicious. I opted for the veal house special with a cream sauce spinach & mushrooms hubby had veal parm nice size portions our friends did chicken parm & piccata everyone had a bit left over for take home lunch the garlic knots are amazing. Eye spying other tables pizza looked pretty good coming from NJ girl. Will be back!

They have a great thin crust pizza and it is delicious every time is a good peace of pie!read more

One of my favorite pizza places in Fort Myers! The crust is the perfect New York style--thin,…read morecrisp, and just the right amount of chewy. They use just the right amount of cheese, so every bite is balanced instead of overloaded, and all of the ingredients taste fresh and flavorful. If you're in the Fort Myers area and craving authentic New York-style pizza, I definitely recommend giving this place a try. It's consistently delicious, and I'll definitely be back!

I'm a local and I didn't even know DHOP had a Philly cheesesteak…read more. Oh boy, I'll be back for another!!! Amazing

Capones always hits the spot with anything you order off their menu! I have been here and had…read moredelivery several times and everything is fresh and fresh exceptional!! This is alway my favorite place. The atmosphere and the staff are above and beyond every time!!

Worst meal management service ever. ordered Mussels, served unopened, Soup served Luke warm, sent…read moreback, salad smothered in shredded mozzarell, warm lettuce. worthless manager, no bill adjustmen. Never going back, ever. don't waste your money here- A Big Zero