First time I saw $35 for a large and I almost said to my wife, "let's leave" but then I saw it. The…read morebiggest pizza on planet earth. Definitely worth getting especially if you love pizza and eat a lot. Ambiance was unique. Service was decent.

Huge pizza slices, I only need 1 to fill me up, every slice I have tried is good, as I am in…read moreWaynesboro every couple months visit my daughter. My go to is Pepperoni or their Garlic Mushroom

Excellent Nee York style pizza. Plenty of toppings, perfect crust and was ready earlier than…read morepromised.. Much prefer it to chain restaurant pizza.

The food is as amazing as the family that runs the restaurant! The Stromboli and pizza were…read moreamazing! The staff were all working and the place was so clean. As others would come in the owner knew most by name. Would love to eat here again if/when we come back!

Pizza was just okay, nothing that I would crave. Service was the same. Dry wait staff.read more

Food was ok. Service was slow and not friendly. Sat waiting on refil of drink for 10-15 minutes…read more Other customers were having to ask for basic service items: refill of drinks, ready to order, box, etc.

Our food always arrives hot & fresh when it's delivered. Definitely our go-to for Italian.read more

I ordered the Chicken Marsala at Scotto's Italian Restaurant in Waynesboro, Virginia without seeing…read morethe previous reviews first. After trying it, I wish I had read them beforehand because I would not have ordered it. I only ate two pieces before giving the meal back because it was that disappointing. The dish was very bland and lacked the rich flavor you'd expect from a proper Marsala sauce. The mushrooms tasted like canned mushrooms, which gave the dish a bitter taste and poor texture that really hurt the meal. I understand they are a small business, and I always try to support local restaurants. However, if you are serving food to the public, it still needs to be edible and meet a basic standard of quality. When I expressed my disappointment, they would not remove the item from my bill. Instead, they only offered a 10% discount, and I still had to pay for a meal I barely touched. Overall, a very disappointing experience.

When you say Tony's Pizza and Italian Restaurant, you had best pronounce it as Eye-talian, like the…read morelocals do. Because in here you can get burgers and jalapeno poppers and bacon cheese fries and wing dings and Hawaiian pizza and sweet tea and every other sort of dive-bar food. And your kids can have grilled cheese with fries, or mac and cheese, or cheese pizza. Because we shouldn't, not even for a culinary moment, subject your kids to any cultural experiences beyond what Fishersville, VA can provide. Now there is an obscure law in Virginia, that says that "al dente" is some sort of Communist plot and not a way to cook pasta. As a result, just like every other Italian restaurant within 500 miles, the pasta is overcooked into a flabby, submissive state. You show that pasta who's boss, Virginia. The tomato sauce, as well, said nothing besides just tomato sauce; and the meatballs were more balls than meat. The wines come in Cabernet and a couple other colors, clearly decanted from boxes just minutes ago. I am not a picky fellow, but I just couldn't eat it. It was all just calories. I give two stars gladly for the help, who were just as polite as pizzeria pie, and talked all sorts of kindnesses to us from beginning to end. Understand: these are very sweet people running this place. But authentic Italians: please just don't eat here. You will be really sad and angry if you ignore this advice.

As a current employee I will say we have some of the best food in fishersville!! Even when dining…read morebefore I became an employee the service was perfection and still is!! The ambiance is a very cozy vibe, always has great music and it's an overall great place to be!

My wife and I ordered two cheesesteaks yesterday for supper. She had the supreme with onions and…read moregreen peppers as well as last tomato and mayonnaise, and I had a basic cheese steak with lettuce tomato and mayonnaise. They were both delicious and quite full of meat. They also tasted great. The delivery was very prompt, even quicker than I expected.

Ordered delivery from these good people and will definitely do so again. Food arrived hot and the…read moredriver was very friendly. Even though I was told they were busy, the delivery time was totally reasonable and I have no complaints. I ordered the chicken parm with pasta and a house salad. Food was well prepared, tasty, and portions were quite generous all around. Pasta was well cooked, sauce was good and well seasoned, and the chicken cutlets well prepared. I think my only real quibble would be the amount of cheese blanketing the chicken, but I might also be that rare bird that doesn't like a lot of cheese? Salad was good, but I think it would be improved by using mixed greens instead of iceberg and fresh olives instead of canned. That said, my meal was a welcome treat after a long day of driving and I will happily order from NBP again soon. I look forward to picking my way around their menu in the future and will definitely be trying some pies!

Why is it so difficult to make a pizza well done! I have ordered from here many times and you…read moreNEVER get it correct. I asked for well done and it's practically raw. Is this a joke for you?????

Good location. Staff is always friendly and helpful. Pizza is on par with other Papa John locations.read more

I enjoyed pizza from the West Broad Street restaurant, delivering hot and tasty pizza in about 40…read moreminutes. The delivery service was fast enough and dropped off courteously. I got the Pacific Veggie specialty pizza. This oven delight comes with diced, tomatoes, onions, mushrooms and spinach for vegetables and pizza cheese with provolone and feta cheeses, too. I enjoyed this combination of ingredients - the provolone stood out well, while the rest of the ingredients blended in nicely.

Great pizza, my favorite is the Italian sausage topping! The pizza is perfectly savory and a little…read moresweet. Service is nice with the staff being very welcoming. Ambiance is not bad either.

We had a large party and it was on their prime rib night…read more Drink orders were first, and it took an exceptionally long time to get our orders. It wasn't very crowded, maybe 6 or 7 other tables with 2-4 people each. You had to pre-order your prime rib to ensure they had one for you. Not wanting the prime rib, I ordered the pork chop dinner along with the two sides. They were out of pork chops. They asked what else I would like, I asked if they would do the prime rib at the pork chop price, about a $15 difference. They (the server) said no. The only other choice was sandwiches or a shrimp scampi. I didn't want either, so I just asked if I could get the sides instead (a baked potato and asparagus). She said she would put the order in. When the food came out, all I ended up with was my appetizer (6 oysters Rockefeller). I asked about the side and was told by yet another waitress that they don't do that. Three different waiters/waitresses. No manager ever came over. Way over priced (1 shrimp scampi -$32, one half Caesar salad - $6, one half order (6 anorexic) oysters Rockefeller-$19, 2 good old fashions - $30 plus a mandatory 20% gratuity. I still had to stop on the way home to get something to eat. Poor management and exorbitant pricing makes for a poor business model. But I guess the members get a pretty steep discount so they gouge the non-members to keep the doors open. Not likely to go back and would definitely NOT put my name on any kind of recommendation for this place. Spend your money elsewhere, anywhere, just not here.

Servers were friendly. Food is very good. Great big television to watch sports in the bar.read more