Pizza was just okay, nothing that I would crave. Service was the same. Dry wait staff.

Food was ok. Service was slow and not friendly. Sat waiting on refil of drink for 10-15 minutes. Other customers were having to ask for basic service items: refill of drinks, ready to order, box, etc. read more

Ordered on line so I wouldn't be stuck waiting. So much for that. Apparently their printer isn't working so they aren't receiving on line orders. Here's a suggestion, turn off on line ordering so as not to waste peoples time. read more

Slow service and mediocre pizza. Would not go back. Ordered delivery so no idea what the atmosphere is like.

food cold and not good. poor service. owner yells obscenities at the staff. wont be back.

This was the best pizza ever. Great food, great atmosphere and great prices. Staff was super friendl...

The best pizza place in Waynesboro! Great service, even better pizza. My personal favorite is the sicilian.

The worst restaurant in the US we have visited in five months. The food was terrible. And they have the most unfriendly waitress. Zero stars. read more

The food is meh and service is terrible. Probably won't order again unless we're desperate. read more

New York Flying Pizza - Do you see $4 worth of EXTRA mushrooms? Me neither. I know times are hard, but these are canned mushrooms, not porcinis!! - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Virginia

My husband, mother-in-law, and I all got the spaghetti and Cesar Salad. I really enjoyed both my dishes, however, they did like the spaghetti at all. I also thought that the homemade bread was very yummy with sprinkle parm and perhaps basil. The service was quick and the ambiance there is casual and inviting. The location is in downtown Waynesboro and they seem to pretty busy during lunch and dinner hours. I really loved my dishes and would get them again!! I will say parking could be tricky during those peak hours, so just keep that in mind. read more

I decided to try this place for a takeout sub. I got the large NY Deluxe sub. A friend and I took it up to Sunset Park. We both really liked the sandwich. It was big, loaded with meat, peppers, black olives, red onions. The bread was nice and soft. I would absolutely try another sandwich from NYFP. read more

Food is average. Pizza is a little to greasy for my likings. The prices were a little high for what you get. I've ordered online twice and waited way longer than the expected time it will take to be done, and it was not ready either time. Mind you the restaurant was empty, it's not a big deal just worth noting. I don't like writing bad reviews! read more

Do not. Under any circumstance. Order a pizza online from this restaurant. It makes you download he Slice App. You will spend 4 hours being lied to by someone that says your pizza is on the way. If their pizza tastes like their customer service, you are better off serving your kids a few steaming piles of hot garbage. read more

I ordered cheese fries and this is what I got. A hot mess. The service is horrible also. read more

New York Flying Pizza - I ordered some mozzarella cheese fries and this what came. They were horrible - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Virginia

Went there on Friday for lunch with grandkids and family, needless to say the service from the waitress was awful, she couldn't care less about our presence at the restaurant. Now let's get on with the food to which was beyond awful, the food was cold and completely tasteless , we order a buffalo spiced pizza, tasteless, to which I still believe was a frozen boxed pizza. Order some subs too, awful Fellas you got to try and get your act together, we gave you the second chance and we will never come here again, promise you that. For anybody thinking about going here, dont, the service and food was beyond terrible. read more

CHECK YOUR SUBS! I normally order from them. TONIGHT though, there was ONE solitary VERY THIN slice of turkey on the WHOLE 8 inch sub for $15.71. read more

I have never been so repulsed by a place of business as much as I am right now nor have I ever shared anything on social media like I am about to or rated a restaurant. For 5 close to six years my daughter could not eat anything without getting sick. Finally having surgery to remove her gallbladder, the organ which caused her such discomfort after eating, she is able to eat most things without feeling or getting sick. This is such a celebration. She was hungry and we went to NY Flying Pizza in Waynesboro. We ordered garlic breadsticks and a pizza half cheese half pepperoni. Breadsticks were ready they were sitting at the window, the ever so unfriendly waitress went to the window with three... 3 plates, mind you it was myself and my daughter. The unfriendly waitress walked over to the window took a breadstick off the tray placed it on a plate, pushed the plate back on the ledge, then brought the breadsticks to the table. She then walked back toward the window, rinsed her fingers off grabbed the plate with the one singular breadstick from our order, walked over to a table sat down and ate it. Leaving zero tip and shared the breadstick from our order was tip enough. Never again!! Too bad I can rate with a zero star option! Absolutely disgusting!! read more

The short, Hispanic waitress with black hair with some gray was unfriendly and rude. She didn't welcome us and had a scowl on her face. This is customer service? The food is OK, but we won't be back until this business learns how to treat customers. Why would you have a waitperson who is so unpleasant and nasty? read more

The pizza and the nachos were cold and the nachos were soggy and soppy it was horrible.. No utensil or napkins read more

Good food at a good price. The only issue I had for making it a five star review was that their delivery service charges four dollars and that's even if you live within 1/2 mile area. read more

Only Pepsi products and a glass of water comes with lemon without asking so just get the wine! Grated Parmesan is The Real Thing and as such clumps in the jar. So Worth taking the lid off and loosening it with an unused utensil-I used my knife. The flavor totally exceeds anything else I've had. Pizza slice is terrific: crust is thin and crisp and the sauce is tangy without being overbearing. The cheese knocks it out of the park. Just look out for the special pricing however. A slice is currently $2.25 ad toppings are $.50. They have a "special": 2 slices with 1 topping for $6.99. read more

New York Flying Pizza - pizza by the slice topped with parm - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Virginia

See all

0 stars. I ordered a gluten free baked Ziti. they told me 8 bites in that it wasn't. The whole experience wasn't good but I wasn't really expecting much. But getting an order so wrong... read more

Pretty disappointed! Ordered take out and order was projected to take about an hour, which is fine but when I arrived at the hour mark the order was not ready. Not a big deal except parts of the order were ready and given to me in parts as I sat and waited. So I had 2 pizza's, an order of ravioli and 2 salads handed to me while waiting on an order of garlic cheese bread. Roughly 10 min went by and I received the garlic bread and headed home. I only live about a quarter of a mile from the restaurant so not a long journey. All the hot food was cold. One of the pizzas was missing the topping I ordered. I've worked in restaurants for many years and try to give people grace but they were not busy, 2 tables in the restaurant and a couple of to go orders. read more

Ordered carry out. Was told to be there in 20 minutes. Showed up at 25 minutes and still had to wait another 20 minutes for food to be completed. Ordered a Philly cheese steak Stromboli with extra cheese and mushrooms. Didn't check the order until I got home. Received what looks like a small Philly cheese pizza with very little cheese and no mushrooms. If I could give a negative or lower rating I would. Seems like every time we order from there, something is inevitably incorrect. I should have checked the order before leaving restaurant, but really shouldn't have to. We will not be ordering from here again as there is always something incorrect. read more

Will not be returning here again the owners are stuck up and rude our server returned to our table all of three times 1. To take our order 2. Deliver our food 3. To give us the check which we had to ask for At one point we had to get up and refill our own drink because she was too busy yammering with friends or family that came to the store And I hope they see this and I'll let you know I am fluent in your language and you can tell all your little friends you were talking crap about my family calling us assorts of labels we did nothing to deserve that I wrote a review explaining exactly how we were treated maybe you'll learn not to talk shit on the people that place food on your plate at the end of the day. The point in our experience that really triggered this review to come about is when I had to get up and ask her for the check when she didn't want to print one I had to ask for the check printed she told us we could get up and pay it whenever which isn't a problem but we just wanted a printed copy and I also asked her for a box which she snobbly said yes and when she brought us our check with no box I kindly asked for a box again because human error is completely acceptable and I just assumed it slipped her mind and she snarkly rolled her eyes and said she heard me already. I understood you fully and loved the comment you made to what I assume to be your husband my only response is don't come to another country and capitalize on the service industry and throw a fit when you have to do your job half assed The food was decent but the service experience was completely unacceptable! read more

This is a newish place in Waynesboro across from the high school. Several other Italian or Mediterranean places have come and gone from here. I had linguine and clams in white sauce. I think this is really a pizza and sub joint, so it was a stretch my going after the pasta. Anyway the food was well plated, clams were good, only complaint was they'd used something to thicken the sauce that took away from the bite of the sauce i'd hoped to be in place. She had a calzone or something similar and loved the sauce. So i'd go back for a pizza or sub, etc... Help was very anxious to be helpful and cheerful, it was easy to get in, casual and comfortable. I'd recommend for Italian comfort food and a beer... read more

New York Flying Pizza - Clams linguini in white sauce - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Virginia

Ordered dinner last night for pickup. We ordered 2 small Sicilian pizzas and a sausage hot sub with peppers and onions. When I got home I was surprised to learn that what I had gotten was two tiny deep dish pizzas that had huge crusts and almost no toppings. The pizza wasn't cut all the way through and by the time we were done cutting it was a mess with what toppings were there. The sausage sub was the next surprise, it was bread and sausage no peppers no onions and not a drop of sauce. We felt like we were ripped off. Won't ever eat here again! If I could give them lower than one star I would. read more

Terrible experience. From out of town and staying in a local hotel and was recommended this location by the front desk. I ordered a pizza for delivery and gave them my Hotel name and location. They called back to confirm location and address. Delivery should have been 30-40 mins. After 1:15 min the owner/manager called and said they don't deliver to this location after driver went to wrong hotel in neighboring town and for an extra 5$ he would come here (this after delivery fee and a tip for the driver). I declined. Terrible service and attitude, like it was my fault they made a mistake. Can't tell you how the pizza is. read more

The one and only time my husband and I went here the food and the service was HORRIBLE. We waited for almost an hour (we were one of two occupied tables in this facility) and upon questioning our waiter they apparently failed to turn in our food order. I ordered the eggplant which was absolutely disgusting. We just left without eating. They did offer us a free meal upon return; however, we have not been back. read more

New York Flying Pizza - Disgusting slivers eggplant parmesan? swimming in a froth of grease, cheese and swollen, overcooked spaghetti. - Pizza Near Me - Waynesboro, Virginia

See all

in town tonight so I ordered a Philly Stromboli and medium cheese pizza and a 2 liter of Dr Pepper. the pizza was average, nothing special. the Stromboli was good, the only complaint I have is I ordered extra ricotta cheese, it was all piled up in the middle, but still good. Now the funny part, I paid $2.90 for a 2 liter of Dr Pepper, when I pulled it out of the bag, it was dr wham, I never even heard of this and after tasting it I know why. Next time in town would I order from here, no. read more

Decided to give NY Flying Pizza another try after 2 years of previous bad experiences. 2 takeouts and 1 dine in, excellent young male server although on 1 of the takeouts...the pizza had incorrect toppings. As recent as yesterday, order was taken by a rude woman. Observed her rudeness to a senior lady picking up takeout, and a young lad picking up an order for his grandmother. Every minute of this person was rude!! I've even heard through the grapevine....just don't go to NY Flying Pizza when the short lady is there, she runs everyone off, especially the servers. Anyway, she has run us off for good this time. Good Luck NY Flying Pizza! We will drive out of our way for pizza from now on!! read more

Best cheesesteak in town! Service has always been great and our go to place for pizza and subs.

The chicken pesto was nothing to write home about. I am not haunted by any memory OF the chicken so much as I am reminded that the chicken didn't have a choice to be made into such a forgettable meal. The service was sad, but the staff couldn't want to be there anymore than I wanted to keep eating the chicken. I give it a 2.4/5. read more

The staff what really nice but the pizza was trash. I waited over 30 mins for two slices of soggy pizza. It was over priced for the slices and I threw it up afterwards. I had to head to the place down the road to get real pizza. Being from Long Island, NY. This was a major disappointment, I mean nothing compares but this place can't even come close. Maybe give it a try for anything but the pizza:) read more

Food was so-so. Calamari and salad were very good. Chicken park was nothing special and needed a lot of help with salt and pepper. The Alfredo sauce was like thin Elmers glue and was inedible. The menu was very confusing. We thought it was a New York Italian food but the have gyro and chicken Marsala......ok. Service was pretty fast( I think chef Mic was helping out). Over all a strong Meh from me. read more

From out of town staying over for the night. So glad we chose this. We ordered a Sicilian pepperoni pizza and spinach turnover which were both delicious! The service was wonderful, the staff was so friendly. read more

Ordered 2 hoagies, Italian. The rolls were fresh, but the quantity of meat, cheese and the true taste of a hoagie made with knowledge, tradition and good ol' TLC simply wasn't there. read more

Placed an order and received the estimated time the order would be ready. I waited an extra 15 minutes since they have always been late in the past. Once I arrived- long after the estimated order time- I still waited more than 20 minutes- only to then find out they had never even started cooking the pizza. I requested a refund and wasted an hour due to their disorganization and incompetence. Get it together. read more

Literally the best pizza I have had in VA. Anytime we head up to wintergreen this is our favorite spot to hit! We get a pizza with ricotta and salami read more

Ordered meatball sandwich. Excellent, homemade meatballs. Great texture. Moist and delicate. I would like to eat the meatballs, sauce, and cheese without bread. Extra sauce would make the meatballs even better. Friendly, attentive service. Fair prices. read more