Our staycation at Barnacle Resort was everything we expected. A little escape for rest and…read morerelaxation, which was much needed. Quiet and tranquil, with the perks of having Key West just 45 minutes away for dinner and a great time! Will definitely be coming back!

We've stayed at the Barnacle six times over the years and loved it. It was full of various colors…read moreand interesting knick-knacks that helped create a wonderful "Keys funky" atmosphere. It sits on its own beach and is very quiet and serene. Breakfasts were an "event" with hot egg and meat breakfast dishes, fresh fruit and a variety of breads along with juice and bottomless coffee served in an atrium that was open to the skies and full of rocks and plants. The Barnacle is now under new ownership and the atmosphere has changed dramatically. We recently stayed there for six nights, from a Tuesday to the next Monday. Gone are the varied colors, rocks and plants. The atrium is now roofed over and has all the charm of a high-school cafeteria. The color is primarily beige as is the experience. Breakfast is now serve-yourself cold continental. Saturday and Sunday were "special" because, without any warning, explanation, apology or compensation, there was no breakfast at all. Not a scrap to be found nor anyone from management or staff to provide it. We were left completely alone to our own devices. Good luck. There are some other changes to the Barnacle as well, specifically the posted warnings "This property is under 24-hour surveillance" with cameras to boot. There's even one on the rooftop sundeck which seems not only intrusive but not a little bit creepy as well. All this was ours for the premium price of $450 per night. They get two stars because it was clean, the AC in the room worked and the bed was comfortable. But that's where the "good news" ends. Over the years, we've recommended to many people that they should stay at the Barnacle. Now, and it pains us to say this, we have to recommend you don't.

The Mermaid & The Alligator is what you hope a bed-and-breakfast will be…read more Set in a historic Victorian in Old Town, it's shaded, peaceful and just far enough from the noise to let you breathe. The rooms are comfortable and full of personality, with small details that make them feel lived-in rather than staged. Outside, the gardens are the star -- leafy, quiet and perfect for lingering. Our room had a wraparound porch and a hammock. Breakfast isn't an afterthought. It's fresh fruit, homemade dishes and good coffee served outdoors, slow and unrushed. And because it's independently owned, the hospitality feels real -- warm, attentive and low-key in the best way. You come to Key West for the energy. You stay here for the calm. And you leave wishing you'd planned to stay longer.

If you've ever dreamed of running away to a storybook Key West hideaway, stop scrolling -- this is…read moreit. The Mermaid & The Alligator is hands-down the best bed-and-breakfast in Key West, and honestly, you'll wish you never had to leave. Housed in a 1904 Victorian mansion right in the heart of Old Town, this independently owned gem has the kind of charm chain hotels only pretend to have. Think wraparound porches, lush tropical gardens, orchids dangling from banyan trees, and a vibe so tranquil you half expect Hemingway to stroll through with a daiquiri. The rooms? Gorgeous. Each one feels personal, with Caribbean-inspired decor, canopy beds, and soft linens that make it way too easy to "accidentally" sleep through your Duval Street plans. Outside, the gardens are pure Key West magic: fountains trickle, palms sway, and yes -- the occasional rooster might strut by like it owns the place. Breakfast here is its own event: fresh tropical fruit, homemade pastries, quiches, and strong coffee served in the garden. It's the kind of peaceful start that makes you consider selling everything, moving here, and writing your memoirs. And because it's independently owned, the hospitality feels personal -- warm, genuine, and full of little touches that make you feel less like a guest and more like a friend who lucked into paradise. The Mermaid & The Alligator isn't just a stay; it's a love letter to Key West itself. Come for the charm, stay for the breakfast, and leave plotting how to "accidentally" extend your trip.

We came here as this place had really good reviews on "booking" and it has these well deserved. The…read moreplace is from 1905 and is well maintained by the owners. The rooms (we had the blue and yellow) are of a good size with balcony, air conditioning and fan above the bed. Everything is working well and very clean. The pool and garden next to this house can be used as well. The breakfast has everything you need for a start into your day (the location is great to discover Key West, the main attractions are in walking distance). The owners and staff are very kind and helpful. We really enjoyed our stay and if we are back in town will definitely come back.

This B & B is unique and was a great experience. It was also the best "customer service" ever…read more Charles and Bella are the extra star, both are warm and welcoming, the bit of the extra that makes a place special. The B & B is in old town, but close to Duvall St. And walkable to all the tourist attractions. The beautiful old house keeps its history, but is clean and cared for with interesting art and color. There is access to a garden area and a small pool as well. The light breakfast is lovely and filling. I wish we could have stayed longer!

This place was awesome. I'm almost afraid to even give it five stars because I wanna keep it all to…read moremyself! Truly a gem. The entire property was renovated with high-end materials, furnishings and decor. We got The Beach front cottages next to each others, some good friends of ours traveled with my husband and myself. It was perfect. Very low-key. They recommended Midway café, and oh my gosh, such a great find! Maybe a 3 to five minute walk from the cottages! They also gave us recommendations and I don't remember the name. We walked across the street for dinner the first night the second night we Uber to another place down the road. We'll be back!

Pines and Palms retirement community!…read more We've stayed here for a few years and always had a great experience... last year (2024) we were told that the resort would undergo a renovation and would be featured on HGTV's Restoration Island. We were excited about the new changes and rebooked for 2025. Fast forward to 2025, we arrived and were pleasantly surprised by the new look! the property looks great! Now to the bad.... the pool/bar. The property doesn't have a liquor license. therefore, if you like anything other than beer, you're out of luck. If you do happen to have a preloaded yeti with your favorite mixed drink, watch out! The pool boy will promptly call you out and ask you to stow it. Additionally, at 8pm the pool closes !!!!! No evening dips. I was told that was due to no attendant present. However, the beach is still open and "swim at your own risk" as if that's safer at night.... seems as if the unavailability to charge you $10 for a drink has out weighed your ability to use the pool. Additionally, pines and palms charter is no longer here, I was told the boat was sold, I was given a number to a captain that provides services to the resort, snorkeling/fishing and such. That person doesn't answer... You're better off going elsewhere. In the end, I'm sitting here writing a review while at the resort at 9pm, disappointed. It's a bummer, this place was a hidden gem.

Quaint, cool, clean, awesome owners! Don't pass it up!! Great rooms, breakfast, hot tub and pool…read moreare spotless clean! Our go to in Key West

Our second time staying here and just as good as the first time. Less than a block of Duval street…read morebut you'd never know it. Quiet with a good pool. They have a continental breakfast every morning and a happy hour in the evening. The staff is attentive and helpful. The rooms are well appointed with great linens, stocked Keurig coffee makers and large refrigerators. Bicycles are avail for rent. We rented them and went to the Fort Zachary Taylor beach. It's a great beach and only $2.50 a price. We love it there.

We spent two nights at this BNB and could not have loved it more! Our kids loved the animals -…read moregoats, pigs, bunnies, chickens and two playgrounds, and we all loved the pool and comfortable guest house! The animals are clearly a labor of love for Isa, who spent time answering the hundreds of questions our kids peppered her with. The pool was warm and gorgeous. And the guest house was stocked for breakfast each morning. a PERFECT place to stay near the Everglades (only 10 mins away!). Highly recommend.

From the owner: Enjoy our bed and breakfast and host your next pool party, birthday party or any small gathering…read more Our farm has a beautiful heated pool and tropical landscaping around the tiki and pool area. All of the amenities you’d find in a resort but with more privacy and for a fraction of the price. Call us today for more information!

My husband and I stayed at Pines and Palms for 5 nights...to escape the PA chill. This quaint…read moreresort was all we needed. The location is great, we walked to many restaurants, breweries and coffee shops. Everyone (staff and guests) was wonderful and friendly. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and do plan to return. Here are some tips for anyone planning to stay here and some suggestions to the resort: CHECK IN - Easy Peasy. Nice women greeted us and told us a little about the resort. Sadly, no champagne was offered to us, as we read in other reviews. ROOM - We were in a "partial ocean view one bedroom king suite", in the 'highrise' building - number 20. The room was a little dated as we expected. The bathroom is very tiny, but functional. Nice kitchen area. Bed was comfortable and lots of pillows. Table and chairs on the deck overlooking the resort. Overall, great room and had a decent ocean view. The only thing about the Highrise rooms is you can't use the grills, but that was not an issue for us, as we hadn't planned to do that. You really don't need to spend much time in the room. HOUSEKEEPING - Rooms were clean; plenty of towels - beach towels replaced daily. Wet mopped daily and had a nice smell. POOL - Clean and warm. Nothing fancy, but its perfect for the P&P vibe. Pool bar was great, Anderson was our man. Happy hour is 3-5 every day. Everyone talks to one another and we watched some fun sporting events. Saturday there was live music. I wish it was more than one day. The musician was good. BEACH/OCEAN - Cute little beach, with lounge chairs and a hammock. We used a kayak one day which was really fun, there is also paddle boards for use. 2 nice piers to walk out for sunrise or to look at fish. One pier has 2 Adirondack chairs. Beach area could use some firepits, cornhole and/or horseshoes. OTHER - Yoga on the beach Sat and Thurs. I wish it was offered more frequently, I didn't get to partake. Bikes on the resort to use, we rode around town one day and stumbled upon a farmers market. Adorable boutique on site. Truly ADORABLE. Check out the orchids in the trees!! Offsite, check out (all walkable): Midway Cafe, Islamorada Brewing Company, Florida Keys Brewing Company, Bob's Bunz, Square Grouper, Lazy Days, Amara Cay (resort bar open later than PP bar) And don't miss the Tarpon Feeding at Robbies!!

I love Pines & Palms on Islamorada. The property is quaint & has a nice relaxing vibe.read more

I have not stayed at the resort, but downstairs at the bar Konstantine is the best. Great drinks to…read morelet time pass.

Honestly, not terribly impressed. As an offshoot of the Southernmost Resort, I expected some…read moreupdates to the room. The AC is absolutely terrible. It's hot and humid currently and I have it set to 59°. It is still 79°. I contacted the front desk to either look at it or change my room. Never heard a word back from them almost 24 hours later. I will say the chick getting tailed down the hall seemed to have a good time. Could hear her through two doos and about 50 feet of distance.

Jane & her husband were fantastic. When we arrived she had lots of information pamphlets for us to…read morelook at, tourist suggestions, restaurants etc told us where to see a beautiful sunset just a short walk down the street. She showed us all around the apartment downstairs and how the lights, fans, air con works etc. Although there's no kitchen, there a coffee machine, toaster oven, microwave with a bagel toaster in the side, plenty of tea and coffee and heaps of snacks. There were some beers in the fridge that we were welcome to have too! There were plenty of beach towels to use and a drying rack put out so we would hang them up after using them. There's a little jetty out the back that you can sit and have a coffee in the morning or a drink at night. There was also a fire place out the back & wood. She warned us that sometimes great big iguana's hang out in the garden. She made us feel very welcome. Her husband even gave us a great trip for lunch (Chad's) that was close by and fantastic. The bathroom is small but complete with toiletries and a good size for two people to share. The rest of the apartment is quite large. Lots of toys and things to use as well. Although it downstars from someone's house, it was very private and comfortable. We left our iPhone charger behind and forgot to get our souvenir hat which she happily posted to us as well. All round a great experience.

Loved this resort! Best part is you have access to 2. Both…read morehave pools with bar and ocean views. Music never stops and neither does the relaxing fun. Check in was easy (they even got us in early). Rooms were nice, sheets were clean, room was stocked and cool. Fridge in every room and all toiletries available. We jumped from pool to pool and when needed relaxation went over to the private beach area. The weather was sunny and windy. It was the perfect combination of a nap on there numerous provided hammocks. There's always some festivity going on to choose from but we went our own route. Happy hour is available even on the weekends and make sure to grab some bites. There are a couple of fast food places around just in case and local restaurants but all you really need is here at the resort. Our days were filled with ocean breezes, cold cocktails, naps by the sea, and the perfect sunsets. Also available were spa services and gym. Take advantage of it all!

General - We came here for our 2026 winter vacation. We were looking for sun and sand and found it…read morein Marathon, Florida! Location - This hotel is located right in the middle of Marathon in the Florida Keys. Marathon is a fairly large city when looking at the keys and this hotel is right in the middle of everything this island has to offer. You are close to many different restaurants, a Publix, famous 7-Mile Bridge and the one of the best beaches in the Keys, Sombrero Beach. Rooms & Building - Rooms are all suites and spacious. They reminded me of what you would find normally at an Embassy Suites. The style and theme was modern, nautical which fit the surrounding area. The room had a fridge and microwave and a small living area. The bathroom had a spacious rainfall shower and large vanity with plenty of room to spare. Amenities - The hotel has two outdoor pools onsite. The pools are heated and stayed comfortable throughout our stay. The site also offers a small butterfly garden, green space with firepits and hammocks, and beautiful marina views (and sunsets). The property grounds are well maintained and beautiful. Food - Breakfast is not included in your stay but there is a restaurant and coffee shop onsite. The coffee shop serves Cuban-style coffee which was unique and very good. The breakfast sandwiches at the coffee shop were also pretty good. We didn't eat at the restaurant but the food menu looked interesting. Vibe - Easy going staff and customers. No complaints. Reality vs. Online - Pictures that I saw on their website and online matched the quality and condition of the hotel and rooms in-person. No surprises. Price & Final Verdict - If you are looking for a luxurious stay while in the Florida Keys, Faro Blanco offers a good mix of luxury and hotel-styled amenities. One neat perk - if you are a Diamond member, you can use the amenities at their sister resort next door (infinity pool, hot tub, and man-made beach). Prices tend to fall into the $300's+ for a night, so this place might not be in everyone's price range or interest.