Best pizza on island. NY,style always fresh and great service. Order early as they do get busy.read more

Fentoni's is the perfect pit stop when you're in full beach-and-boardwalk mode. This is their slice…read moreshop right in the heart of the action, serving up a variety of pizzas by the slice. No waiting forever, no breaking the bank. You order at the counter, they pop your slice in the oven, and a few minutes later you've got that crispy NY-style crust in hand. The pizza is solid all around.Classic flavors done right, nothing overly fancy, just dependable, tasty slices that hit the spot. Perfect for a quick lunch break before heading back to the sand or catching the next boardwalk event. Not a life-changing pie, but for speed, price, and location, it's a winner.

We visited Wildfire Pizza on Jun 21, 2026 for a takeout order. Although it was a 4-minute walking…read moredistance from where we were staying, we drove there anyway. The pizzas come only in 12" sizes. We ordered a plain cheese pizza, a margherita pizza and a spinach feta bread. We were told that the pizzas would be ready in 20 minutes; it was packed to go in 15. The spinach feta bread was ordered later and took almost as long as the pizzas to be ready. I realized why after I saw it. It looked like a pizza pie: round, same 12" size but cut into many smaller pieces - the pizzas were cut into 8 slices each. The margherita pizza is plain cheese pizza with tomatoes and sprinkles of crushed vegetables. The taste left much to be desired. The important thing is that it fed us. The feta bread is plain cheese pizza with way too much cheese, and the spinach not evenly spread across the pie. Why even called it "bread" when it was made like pizza? There was plenty left for tomorrow's dinner, meaning that we liked it enough to not throw them away. The staff are college-aged young except for one guy who appeared to be in his 70s. There are a limited number of tables for dine-in, but the limited space don't make it dine-in friendly. While Wildfire Pizza is one place we will not be returning to.

This is based off of two separate take out orders, the first was back in April when we moved to the…read moreneighborhood and we ordered delivery- they had initially forgotten one of our items and the delivery driver was extremely apologetic and brought the missing order in record time. On both the April order and our most recent order we had gotten pizzas and cheesy bread. The first time both the pizza and cheesy bread tasted amazing. On the second order one of the pizzas had a very large hair in the crust, and the order arrived extremely cold. In all fairness the coldness was in part to us using a third party delivery system as opposed to from the restaurant itself. The hair in our second order definitely was off puting and I don't know if we will risk it again.

Great food and good service. Continually and consistently good.Would recommend. Wish the atmosphere…read morewas cleaner. Cigarettes and cigars put out, outside by door.

Isaac and his team took great care of us and our crew from "A Caring Heart" from Wilmington NC. We…read morewent to Wallace mid May and the folks of the park let us use a picnic shelter (shout out to Jason!) Isaac delivered plenty of pizza for us all! He was amazing and the world is so small because through conversation we realized he knew a boss of mine from Fairmont NC that I worked for in 2009! Food was superb! And it's always great to connect with good people! Thank you Isaac! April Richardson and Crew A caring Heart

This Italian joint is authentic! The staff and delivery service is great. The food is always well…read moreprepared, delivered hot & most of all homemade.

Change your hours if you are going to close early. Bad business to say you'll be open and then…read morereject calls.

When our favorite non-fancy Italian restaurant (Italian Bistro in Porters Neck) opened another…read morelocation in Hampstead (Surf City area), we didn't have high expectations. We've been patrons at the Porters Neck location for about 19 years, and love their basic Italian dishes, salads, pizza, and always friendly service. Well, I just have to say that if you like NY/NJ/CT-style thin crust pizza, you won't find better pie south of the Mason-Dixon Line than you will at their new location. And if you haven't had a slice of their Greek-style pizza, you are missing out on something really special. Not sure what else is on the Hampstead location's menu, but am looking forward to finding out. (Tip: I always order the Greek pie with extra tomato sauce and ask them to make it a little crispy...Perfecto!)

Great pizzas and they deliver to Surf City! Perfect dinner after a long day on the beach.read more

Food very yummy. The subs and pizza are really good. Service is somewhat speedy. And the decor is…read moreyou know like decent.

I am beyond angry. We came here straight from the beach because a local gluten free group would not…read morestop raving about this place. As the mother of a gluten free toddler, and gluten free myself, I trusted that recommendation completely. I will never make that mistake again. Walking in, the place was flat out disgusting. A trash can shoved directly under the soda machine, jammed against a booth, flies swarming around it like nobody had cleaned in days. FLIES. Next to the soda machine. The only open table and booths were dirty. Like, more than crumbs. We should have walked straight back out the door but we didn't, because we were exhausted and had a 3 hour drive home, and we thought, "How bad could it be?" Incredibly bad, it turns out. The "gluten free" crust was thin, flimsy, and burnt around the edges. And the aftermath has been brutal. My toddler and I have both been glutened so badly we are sick, in pain, and completely wiped out the day after what was supposed to be a fun family trip. Instead of beach memories, I'm nursing my kid through cramps and misery because this place could not be bothered to handle allergen prep or basic cleanliness properly. If you have celiac disease or a real gluten allergy, stay far away from this place. Whatever cross contamination is happening in that kitchen is dangerous, not just inconvenient. I don't care how many people recommend it, the risk is not worth it. We will never go back, and I will be telling everyone I know to avoid it too.

The whole package! Greek Pasta is my favorite but you really…read morecan't go wrong. The wait staff is very friendly and Dan the bartender is the man!!! They have Meomi by the glass too. Hurry.... go now!

Everything was good until the pasta came out. Our appetizers were great, our waiter was attentive…read moreand I loved the flavor of everything we ordered. It was clean, loud, good loud filled with conversation and laughter. Unfortunately, my pasta was extremely overcooked. It was so soft that I couldn't even pick it up with a fork without it falling apart. The photo shown shows just how shredded the pasta was when I picked it up. The sauce itself was delicious, which made it even more disappointing because the pasta was basically mush. I brought it to their attention, and they apologized, but then told me the kitchen was closed. I believe they stop serving at 9:00 p.m., and it was only 9:03 p.m. when I mentioned the issue. Whether the kitchen was technically closed or not, fixing the dish would have only required boiling a small portion of pasta and adding some of the sauce that I assumed was already prepared. I mean it was literally 3mins past 9pm there's no way they cleaned the kitchen and packed up that quick. There were still multiple tables here. Instead, I was told there was nothing they could do, though they would remove the item from the bill. While I appreciate not being charged, I don't think that was the most appropriate solution because it essentially meant I didn't get to eat a main course. My husband still had his meal, so at that point it didn't seem worth leaving or trying to find food elsewhere after already spending around $70 on dinner (the pasta not included). If it had been much later in the evening, or I wanted to add something to my bill, I would have understood, but being only a few minutes past closing made the response feel disappointing. The flavors were excellent, and up until that point the experience had been very good. I really wanted that pasta too haha. The sauce was so good. I hope they handle situations like this differently in the future.